People v Carmen

People v Carmen G.R. No. 137268, March 26, 2001

 TOPIC: Culpa | Elee!"# Elee!"# Pla$!"$%&'ppellee: Pla$!"$%&'ppellee: People o( "he Ph$l$pp$!e# 'ccu#e)&'ppella!"#: Eu"$*u$a Care! + Mo"her Perpe"uala, Cele)o!$a a-$e + I#a-el a-$e, el$a /$-o!a + e)$! /$-o!a, 'lea!)er /$-o!a + No!o /$-o!a, '!) Re!ar$o Nue4 + Re Nue4 Po!e!"e: Me!)o4a 'CT/: RTC Ce-u co!5$c"e) )e(e!)a!"# o( ur)er a!) #e!"e!ce) "he "o #u%er "he pe!al" o( reclu#$o! perpe"ua a!) "o pa "he he$r# o( "he 5$c"$ "he aou!" o( P0,000.00 a# $!)e!$" a# ell a# "he co#"#. arou!) 2 ocloc9 $! "he a("er!oo! o( a!uar 27, 1;;7, 2 $rl# pla$! hear) a -o #hou" (or help, arou!) "he 5$c$!$" o( "he hou#e o( Care! 9!o! a# Mo"her perpe"uala. /he a!) "o "her oe! Cle)o!$a a!) el$a ere $er#$! Ra!) u" cae "ha" "$e, Care! a#9e) Nu!e4 "o "o call "he (u!eral parlor a!) -r$! a co?! a# "he ch$l) a# alrea) )ea). I" a# arra!e) "ha" "he -o) oul) -e "ra!#(erre) "ra!#(erre) "o "he hou#e o( accu#e)&appella!" accu#e)&appella!" Nue4. "he o-o Ra)o #"a"$o! $! >acolo) C$" h$ch re(erre) h$ "o "he N>I. O! e-ruar 3, 1;;7, E))$e Ale) a copla$!" (or ur)er, a!) a#9e) "ha" h$# #o!=# rea$!# -e ehue) a!) au"op#$e). Care! a!) "he o"her# a)$""e) "ha" #he a!) "he o"her accu#e)&appella!"# co!)uc"e) a Bpra&o5er heal$!B #e##$o! o! "he 5$c"$ o! a!uar 27, 1;;7, accu#e)&appella!" accu#e)&appella!" Care! re(u#e) "o $5e a! (ur"her #"a"ee!". O! e- 20, 1;;7, "he -o) a# ehue) a!) au"op#$e): "raua"$c hea) a!) che#" $!ur$e#. e(e!#e $"!e##e# a""e#"e) "o "he heal$! o( Care! - pra o5er a!) $"hou" a! (or o( 5$ole!ce. I//DE: he"her "he accu#e) are u$l" o( ur)er @E<: No, -ecau#e "he )ea"h re#ul"e) (ro rec9le## $pru)e!ce a!) "here a# !o al$ce or $!"e!" "o 9$ll. @EREORE, "he )ec$#$o! o( "he Re$o!al Tr$al Cour", >ra!ch 1F, Ce-u C$", $# 'IRME $"h "he MOIIC'TION "ha" accu#e)&appella!"# are here- )eclare) u$l" o( rec9le## $pru)e!ce re#ul"$! $! ho$c$)e a!) are each #e!"e!ce) "o #u%er a! $!)e"er$!a"e pr$#o! "er o( (our FH o!"h# o( arre#"o aor, a# $!$u, "o (our FH ear# a!) "o 2H o!"h# o( pr$#$o! correcc$o!al, a# a$u. I! a))$"$o!, accu#e)&appella!"# are ORERE o$!"l a!) #e5erall "o pa "he he$r# o( Ra!)
ur)er. accu#e)&appella!"#, !o!e o( ho $# a e)$cal prac"$"$o!er, -elo! "o a rel$$ou# roup, 9!o! a# "he M$##$o!ar$e# o( Our