G.R. No. 181531
July 31, 2009
NATIONAL UNION OF WORKERS IN HOTELS, RESTAURANTS AND ALLIED INDUSTRIES !ANILA "A#ILION HOTEL $HA"TER vs. SE$RETAR% OF LA&OR AND E!"LO%!ENT, &UREAU OF LA&OR RELATIONS, HOLIDA% INN !ANILA "A#ILION HOTEL LA&OR UNION AND A$ESITE "HILI""INES HOTEL $OR"ORATION FACTS: A certification election was conducted on June 16, 2006 among te ran!"and"file em#lo$ees of res#ondent %olida$ &nn 'anila (avi lion %otel )te %otel* wit te following results: +'(-++S &/ -T+S &ST 3 T-TA -T+S CAST 3 /78%A&/"'(%C 3 %&'(%7 3 /- 7/&-/ 3 S(-&+ 3 S+;+;AT+ 3
454 46 151 169 1 4 22
&n view of te significant num
argaining Agreement )C>A*, suc em#lo$ees cannot vote. &t
ISSUES' )1* weter em#lo$ees on #ro
Fo 6u6o/+/ o )*-/ /+)-o( , (y +6loy++, *+)*+ +6loy+7 o 7+-(-)+ 6+-o7 o (o), /*ll 4+-((-( o( )*+ -/) 7y o *-/?*+ /+-+, 4+ +l--4l+ o +4+/*-6 -( (y l4o o(-@)-o(. All oter wor!ers, including am
T*+ 6o-/-o( -( )*+ $&A 7-/ul-y-( 6o4)-o(y +6loy++/ o o)-( ((o) o+-7+ )*+ $o(/)-)u)-o(lly6o)+)+7 -*) o o+/ )o /+lo(-@)-o(, / +ll / )*+ 6o-/-o(/ o )*+ L4o $o7+ (7 -)/ I6l++()-( Rul+/ o( +)--)-o( +l+)-o(/ (7 Bu-/6u7+(+ )*++o(. A law is read into, and forms #art of, a contract. (rovisions in a contract are valid onl$ if te$ are not contrar$ to law, morals, good customs, #u
II. A/ )o *+)*+ HI!"HLU /*oul7 4+ +)--+7 / )*+ +Clu/-+ 4-(-( +(), )*+ $ou) ul+/ -( )*+ (+)-+. I) -/ +ll/+))l+7 )*) u(7+ )*+ /oll+7 :7ou4l+ Bo-)y ul+,; o )*++ )o 4+ l-7 +)--)-o( +l+)-o(, Bo-)y o )*+ 4-(-( u(-) u/) *+ o)+7 AND )*+ -((-( u(-o( u/) *+ (++7 Bo-)y o )*+ l-7 o)+/ /). (rescinding from te Courts ruling tat all te #ro
H-( 7+l+7 )*) (o *o-+ -( )*+ +)--)-o( +l+)-o( o(7u)+7 o4)-(+7 )*+ +u-+7 Bo-)y, -) ollo/ )*) u(o +l+)-o( u/) 4+ *+l7 )o 7+)+-(+ *-* 4+)++( HI!"HLU (7 6+)-)-o(+ /*oul7 +6+/+() )*+ ((7-l+ +6loy++/. "ETITION GRANTED. NOTES' A run"off election refers to an election
