Re publ i coft hePhi l i ppi ne s Fi r s tJudi c i alRe gi on REGI ONALTRI ALCOU OURT Ci t yofBat ac Br anc hXVI I I
I SABELDAWA WANG yRI ZAL, Compl ai nant ,
v sus- er
Cr i m.CaseNo._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
t hHomi mi ci de FO OR R:Rapewi
JOELYATAR yQUI AOI T, Res pondent . xx
MOTI ON TO QUASH I NFORMATI ON JOEL YATAR y QUI AOI T by t COM OMES NOW ac cus ed he under si gned counsel sandunt ot hi sHonorabl eCour tr espect f ul l ysubmi t s: 1.Thatf r om t hef act spr ese nt ed by t hepr i vat ecomp mpl ai nanti ncl udi ng t he r es ol ut i on pr epar ed and r el eas ed by t he Honor abl e Ci t y Pr osecut orofBat ac,I l ocos Nort e,t he accused her ei n movef ort he quashaloft hei nf orma mat i onont hegr oundt hat : “ That t he f act s char ge d do not c ons t i t ut e an offense be causet hei nf or mat i ondoesnotc har get hepr ope roffense” 2.T .That ac cuse d submi mi t st hat a comp mpl ai ntor i nf or mat i on mus ts t at e everysi ngl ef actnecessaryt oconst i t ut et heoffensecharged.Fr om t he l egaland f act ualasses sme mentoft he f act s pr ese nt ed t he ess ent i al e l e me nt s oft he offense as al l ege d and as defined by l aw was not s uffici ent l yshown; 3. .T Thatt hei nf or mat i on i mput esupon t heaccuse dt hecr i meofRape wi t h Homi ci de,t heel ement sofwhi c h ar easf ol l ows:( 1)t heaccuse d had car nalknowl edgeofawo woma man;( 2)car nalknowl edgeofawo woma man was ac hi e v ed by means off or ce,t hr eatori nt i mi dat i on;and ( 3)by r eason oron occ asi on ofsuch car nalknowl edgebyme meansoff or ce , t hr eatori nt i mi dat i on,t heaccusedki l l edawoma man;
4.Thatt hei nf ormat i onsubmi t t edbyt hepr osecut i onal l egest hat : x “
x
xt he acc used,i n or dert o have car nal
knowl edgeo facer t ai nKATHYLYN D.UBA,sev ent een ye aro l d,di dt he nandt he r ewi l f ul l y,unl awf ul l y,and f el oni ousl y,and wi t h use ofa bl aded weapon s t ab t i ng t hel at t e ri nfli c t i ngupo n he rf at ali nj ur i e sresul i nt hedeat h oft he vi ct i m,and on t heoccasi on orby r eason t her eof ,ac c us ed,wi l f ul l y,unl awf ul l y and f el oni ousl y,and by meansoff or ceand vi ol ence had car nalknowl edge ofsai d Kat hl yn D.Uba agai ns therwi l l ; ”
5.Thatupon car ef ulscr ut i ny oft hei nf or mat i on,t heel ement sf ort he cr i me of Rape wi t h Homi c i de we r e not me t . As al l e ge d i n t he i nf ormat i on,t heaccusedhad car nalknowl edgeoft hevi ct i m on t he o cc as i o no ft heki l l i ngo ronl yaf t e rt hevi c t i m’ sde at h,t hi sbe i ngt he caset hecr i meofRapewi t hHomi ci dei snotpr oper l yest abl i shed; 6.Thatgi vent hoseci r cumst ance,i ti sbutonl ypr opert hatatt hi sst age t hatt he pr ose cut i on shoul d be shutoff as l eadi ng t he Honor abl e Cour twi l lonl ybebur dened by basel essaccusat i on notwort hyofa f ul l e re xami nat i o n; 7.Al lt ol d,t heaccused her ei nr espect f ul l ysubmi t st hatsi ncet hef act s asal l egedi nt hei nf ormat i ondonotadmi tt hatt hecr i meofRapewi t h Homi ci de was commi t t ed, i ti st her ef or e but i mper at i ve t hat t he i nf ormat i onbequashedast hef act sasshowni nt hei nf ormat i ondoes notconst i t ut et heoffensecharged.
PRAYER WHEREFORE,i ti smostr espect f ul l ybeseechedoft hi sHonorabl eCourt t hatt heabovear gument sbeconsi der ed and t hei nf ormat i on f ort hecr i meof Rapewi t hHomi ci deagai nstt heaccused,JoelYat aryQui aoi t ,bequashed. Ot he rj us tande qui t abl er e l i e f sar el i ke wi s epr a y e df o r . Bat acCi t y ,I l o c osNo r t e ,Phi l i ppi ne s ,Mar c h24,2017.
DELARA& ALVI ARNELAW OFFI CE Counself ort heAccused 2nd floor ,ABC Bui l di ng Abl an,Bat acCi t y ,I l oc osNor t e
By:
At t y.CLAUDETTE ABI GAI LB.DE LARA
At t y.APRI LLE S.ALVI ARNE
ROLLNo.24680,15May2012
ROLLNo.56789,15May2012
I BPNo.09903456/1. 05. 2012
I BPNo.12098/1202012
PTRNo.2468123/1. 06. 2017I . N.
PTR No.7898505132017I . N.
MCLE Compl i anceNo.V0003456
MCLECompl i anceNo.
3. 26. 2015
X00967,162017
Bat acCi t y ,I l ocosNort e( 077) 6543425
Bat acCi t y ,I l ocosNort e( 077) 6543425
NOTI CE OF HEARI NG
THE BRANCH CLERK OFCOURT Regi onalTri alCour t ,Br anch18 Bat acCi t y
Gr eet i ngs! Pl eases ubmi tt hef or egoi ngmot i on t ot heHonor abl eCour ton Mar ch24,
2017at8: 30i nt hemorni ngf ori t sf avorabl econsi der at i onandappr oval .
At t y .Cl aude t t eAbi gai ldeLar a Counself ort heAccused
At t y .Apr i l l eS.Al vi ar ne Counself ort heAccused
Copyf ur ni shedbyper sonalser vi ce:
HON.MARVI NA.DI EGO Ci t yPr osecut or Officeoft heCi t yPr osecut or ,Bat acCi t y
HON.JOESHUA AGCAOI LI Pr i v at ePr o se c ut o r Taf tSt . ,Bat acCi t y ,I l oc osNor t e
