@LFWZ KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3 @LFWZ MGILDF
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH
@g~~of 4 Lf~}d`d~l @lfwz Mgildf 7&3 ‐Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg‛
Kgkidjd~ Lf~}d`d~l @lfwz Mgildf7&3 Kw`dl Mdyl Lf~}d`d~l ^gy}d Sgfag`d~dff|d Kgkiwd} Nofblhwyd~l Mgildf Mgfhdf ^dfhd} Kwmdj Lf~}d`d~l FLNMF^KDL@ ^GYRGYXGIB]SSYOZ\MJNS^DKID Mdf awhd YOW]GY
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
4
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Ilohydbl Sgfw`l~ Ml jd`dkdf lfl ~d|d dedf kgkidxd dfmd wf}we
kgfhgfd`
~d|d
kgfmd`dk VV Oydfh
~gndyd
`gilj
Admw` *Adkdf Mw`w,
il`dfh mdj&& }de egfd` kded }de ~d|dfh& \gdj xd`dwswf ~gndyd mgbdw`} ~d|d }lmde }gy`d`w igyjdyds dfmd (kgf|d|dfhl( ~d|d *xgegegegeg&&&, V_V
fdkwf fhhde dmd
~d`djf|d mofh ed`o ~d|d kgksgyegfd`edf mlyl egsdmd dfmd& Fdkd `gfheds ~d|d dmd`dj Obdfl Mdyl|df @djly
ml
^gkdydfh
47 Oe}oigy 4<<=
Kgfdkd}l sgfmlmledf boykd`f|d ml ^KE Fghgyl 4 Kdhg`dfh awyw~df ]gefle Eoksw}gy Mdf Adylfhdf& ^dd} lfl D`dkd} ywkdj ~g`d`w slfmdj+slfmdj }gyhdf}wfh kw~lk nwdnd egwdfhdf mdf ~wd~dfd jd}l& ^}d}w~ wf}we ~dd} lfl kd~lj igyawdfh igyw~djd kgksgy}djdfedf hg`dy AOKI@O mgfhdf d`d~df e`d~le sdyd Aoki`ogy~ ^dxdfhdf1 )ildy il~d ~g~wed jd}l mgeg}+mgeg} ~dkd idf|de ngxge) jgjgjg&&& sdydhydsj lfl
~gidlef|d
*fo}g1 ed`lkd} }gydejly sdmd
}lmde dfmd sgynd|d$,
&
Joii| ~d|d ~gmgyjdfd ~dad1 kdedf mlkd~delf idaw mlnwnllf ad`df+ad`df mliofngfhlf fof}of mlid|dylf }lmwy idygfh&& gj }lmwy mdj ~gfmlyl dadj$
Nof}dn} Sgy~of Gkdl`1 obdfl>3Chkdl`&nok Bdngiooe1 j}}s1//xxx&bdngiooe&nok/kdhg`dfhmgbdngy \K1 Ydl`dj Lksldfkw Xgi~l}g1 j}}s1//xxx&obdfl&no&nn
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
9
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
LF^]D@D^L @LFWZ MGILDF 7&3
O`gj1 Obdfl Mdyl|df @l~gf~l Moewkgf1
^gkwd l~l |dfh dmd mlmd`dk iwew lfl igid~ mlhwfdedf mdf ml~gidyedf ~gndyd igid~ wf}we }wawdf iwedf eokgy~ld`& Mgfhdf ~|dyd} }lmde kgfhjdsw~ d}dw kgfhwidj d}}yliw}g sgfw`l~ mdf nos|ylhj} Obdfl Mdyl|df }dfsd ~gsgfhg}djwdf mdyl sgfw`l~
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
>
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
MDB]DY L^L
Jd`dkdf Awmw` &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&> &&&&&&&&&&&> Mdb}dy L~l &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&= &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&= ^gadydj @lfwz &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&7 &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&7 Lf~}d`d~l @lfwz @lfw z Mgildf 7&3 &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& & &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&44 &&&&&&&&&&&&&44 ^g}}lfh FLN *Fg}xoye Lf}gybdng Ndym, &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&>4 &&&&&&>4 MF^ ^gyrgy &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&>> &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&>> Xgi ^gyrgy &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&>2 &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&>2 B]S ^gyrgy &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&=3 &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&=3 MJNS ^gyrgy &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&=> &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&=> Kdl` ^gyrgy &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&=7 &&&&&&&&&&&&&&=7 Syoz| ^gyrgy &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&7= &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&7= Yow}gy &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&28 &&&&&&&&28 ^dkid ^gyrgy &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&83 &&&&&&&&&&&&83 ^^J ^gyrgy &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&87 &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&87 Nokkdfm @lfwz &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&82 &&&&&&&&&&82 ^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
=
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
^GADYDJ @LFWZ
^gsgy}l |dfh }g`dj el}d eg}djwl igy~dkd @lfwz dmd`dj ~d`dj ~d}w e`of mdyl ~|~}gk osgyd~l WFLZ& Mled}dedf e`of edygfd @lfwz kgfhlew}l ~}dfmdy SO^LZ |dfh }gymdsd} md`dk ~|~}gk osgyd~l }gy~giw}& Kwfnw`f|d @lfwz }lmde mgfhdf }lid+}lid ighl}w ~dad ~dad }g}dsl kg`d`wl kg`d`wl ~giwdj syo~g~ |dfh sdfadfh mgfhdf eg}gy`lid}df idf|de ~wedyg`dxdf mdyl ~g`wywj mwfld |dfh sgmw`l }gyjdmds @lfwz ~gjlfhhd ~|~}gk osgyd~l }gy~giw} mdsd} kgfadml sosw`gy ~gsgy}l ~gedydfh lfl& Idjedf mgfhdf dmdf|d rdyldf ~gsgy}l Mgildf YgmJd} Kdfmydeg ^w~g Nd`mgyd ]wyio@lfwz ]yw~}lz mdf kd~lj idf|de `dhl @lfwz kdelf kgkdf}dsedf mlyl kgfadml ~|~}gk osgyd~l d`}gyfd}lb Klnyo~ob} Xlfmox~ |dfh sosw`gy&
@lfwz sgy}dkd ed`l mliwd} o`gj @lfw~ Igfgmln} ]oyrd`m ~goydfh kdjd~l~xd }lfhed} mwd |dfh ew`ldj ml syohydk ~}wml L`kw Eoksw}gy Wflrgy~l}d~ Jg`~lfel Blf`dfmld sdmd }djwf 4<<4& Sdmd kd~d }gy~giw} ~|~}gk osgyd~l |dfh dmd jdf|d igigydsd ~gsgy}l MO^ |dfh ~gmdfh sosw`gy Wflz mdf Dss`g KdnO^& MO^ |dfh igydad`df ml noksw}gy sgy~ofd` mliwd} o`gj Il`` Hd}g~ kg`d`wl sgyw~djddff|d Klnyo~ob} Noys& ]g}dsl jdyhd wf}we kgksgyo`gj MO^ mldfhhds nwews kdjd`& Wflz kgywsdedf ~|~}gk osgyd~l |dfh idh w~ }g}dsl o`gj sgkiwd}f|d awhd mlawd` mgfhdf jdyhd |dfh nwews nwews }lfhhl mdf jdf|d igydad`df sdmd kg~lf kg~lf kdlfbydkg ~gjlfhhd sgfhhwfd noksw}gy sgy~ofd` }lmde mdsd} kgkdedlf|d& ^gmdfhedf Dss`g KdnO^ ~dkd mgfhdf MO^ mdf Wflz jdyhdf|d }lmde }gyadfhedw& Kd~d`dj w}dkd dmd`dj eomg syohydk mdyl eg}lhd ~|~}gk osgyd~l }gy~giw} }lmde`dj mlswi`led~ledf& Lfl kgkiwd} kdjd~l~xd |dfh ~gmdfh ig`dady kgfhgfdl ~|~}gk osgyd~l }lmde mdsd} kgksgyo`gj nof}oj |dfh f|d}d kgfhgfdl ~|~}gk osgyd~l&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
7
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Egdmddf }gy~giw} dhde }gy}o`ofh mgfhdf jdmlyf|d KLFLZ |dfh mliwd} o`gj Dfmygx ^& ]dfgkidwf ~goydfh syobg~~oy mdyl Ig`dfmd |dfh kgkdfh kgfhlfhlfedf kdjd~l~xdf|d ig`dady ~gndyd kgfmd`dk kgfhgfdl dsd ~g~wfhhwjf|d |dfh }gyadml sdmd ~|~}gk osgyd~l l}w& KLFLZ ml}w`l~ md`dk idjd~d N mdf idjd~d d~~gki`| mgfhdf sdfadfh 49&333 idyl~ eomg syohydk |dfh igyad`df sdmd kg~lf Lf}g` :3:2& Kg~lf }gy~giw} nwews idf|de mlawd` mdf ~gmdfh kgkidfalyl sd~dy noksw}gy ~dd} l}w& ^|~}gk osgyd~l KLFLZ mdsd} mled}dedf ~gidhdl WFLZ klfl mgfhdf igyidhdl eg}gyid}d~df& Mdyl eg}gyid}d~df l}w`dj }lkiw` eglfhlfdf @lfw~ ]oyrd`m wf}we kgfhgkidfhedf ~|~}gk osgyd~l ~gagfl~&
Sgkiwd}df @lfwz ~gkw`d igydxd` mdyl joil @lfw~ |dfh ~gfdfh kgfhhwfdedf noksw}gy mdf kgkdfbdd}edf egkdkswdf noksw}gy ~dksdl id}d~ kde~lkd`& @lfw~ kgfgkwedf jd`dfhdf edygfd }lmde dmdf|d ~|~}gk osgyd~l |dfh mdsd} kgkwd~edf joilf|d& Ld kgkswf|dl eg~lksw`df mdyl eg}lhd ~|~}gk osgyd~l }gy~giw} }gymdsd} egewydfhdf f|d}d |dh }lmde mdsd} kgkgfwjl egiw}wjdf mdyl sdyd syobg~~lofd`& KLFLZ kgywsdedf ~|~}gk osgyd~l |dfh idhw~ }g}dsl kd~lj }gy`d`w ~gmgyjdfd mdf jdf|d mlhwfdedf ~gidhdl ~d`dj ~d}w d`d} kgfhdady mlmwfld sgfmlmledf& Aled mlhwfdedf wf}we mwfld lfmw~}y| KLFLZ kd~lj kgkl`lel idf|de egewydfhdf&
^g}g`dj igigydsd xde}w kgfhgkidfhedf ~|~}gk osgyd~l idyw }gy~giw} @lfw~ kw`dl kgkswi`led~ledf @lfwz wf}we sgy}dkd ed`lf|d sdmd iw`df Dhw~}w~ 4<<4 ml fgx~hyows~ noks&o~&klflz& @lfwz ml~dkiw} mgfhdf df}w~ld~ ~ged`l o`gj oydfh+oydfh |dfh kgfhlew}l fgx~hyows }gy~giw}& Kgyged mdyl |dfh ~wmdj dj`l jlfhhd sg`dady lew} kgkigyledf lmg mdf sgyidledf }gyjdmds @lfwz& Mdyl ~lfl`dj nled` ided` @lfwz kgfadml ~giwdj ~|~}gk osgyd~l |dfh igyegkidfh sg~d} ~dksdl ~gedydfh lfl&
Sgyegkidfhdf lfl mdsd} ml`ljd} mdyl idf|def|d ml~}yliw~l |dfh kgfhdkil` @lfwz ~gidhdl id~l~ ~|~}gk osgyd~lf|d& Nof}ojf|d Mgildf YgmJd} Kdfmydeg ^w~g Nd`mgyd ]wyio@lfwz ]yw~}lz mdf `dlff|d& Fdkwf |dfh sgy`w mllfhd} dmd`dj @lfwz kgywsdedf egyfg` mdyl ~|~}gk osgyd~l iwedf ~giwdj sdeg} ml~}yliw~l `gfheds *ml~}yo,& Sdeg} ml~}yliw~l |dfh dedf el}d hwfdedf md`dk iwew lfl dmd`dj Mgildf 7&3 |dfh }g`dj kgfhd`dkl kg}dkoy bo~d md`dk jd` egdkdfdf& ^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
2
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
D& Egwf}wfhdf Kgkdedl @lfwz
^gig`wk kgkw}w~edf kgfhhwfdedf @lfwz }gf}wf|d dmd sgy}lkidfhdf egwf}wfhdf |dfh mdsd} mlsgyo`gj mdf egywhldf |dfh kwfhelf }lkiw` md`dk sgkdfbdd}dff|d& Igylew} lfl dmd`dj igigydsd egwf}wfhdf |dfh mdsd} mldkil` d}dw d`d~df mdyl sgkdedldf @lfwz ~gidhdl ~|~}gk osgyd~l d`}gyfd}lb Klnyo~ob} Xlfmox~ 1
Kwydj
Jdyhd awd` sgydfhed} `wfde @lfwz jdksly <3' }lmde mlswfhw} ild|d& Ild~df|d ~l~d 4' kgywsdedf jdyhd ml`wdy sgkiwd}df sgydfhed} `wfde @lfwz ~gsgy}l ild|d sgfhdmddf NM ild|d sgfhlylkdf mdf `dlff|d& @ghd`
@ghd`l}d~ sgydfhed} `wfde @lfwz }gyadklf edygfd @lfwz kgfhhwfdedf HFW Swi`ln @lngf~g *HS@, ~gjlfhhd nomg syohydk |dfh }wyw} dmd mllew}~gy}dedf mdf ~g}lds oydfh igyjde wf}we
kgkdedlf|d ~gndyd igid~ ~g~wdl mgfhdf egiw}wjdf& Jd` lfl awhd kgywsdedf ~giwdj egwf}wfhdf }gy~gfmlyl |dl}w ~g~goydfh mdsd} kgfhgkidfhedf ds`led~l d}dw kgfdkid` egewydfhdf |dfh dmd sdmd ds`led~l }gy~giw} }dfsd jdyw~ kgfwfhhw ml~gmldedf o`gj rgfmoy sgydfhed} `wfde&
]lmde
kgkgy`wedf sgydfhed} egyd~ |dfh ~dkd ~ged`l i dyw
@lfwz il~d ~dad mlsdedl wf}we eoksw}gy+eoksw}gy eoksw}gy+eoksw}gy |dfh `dkd mdf }lmde }lmde kdksw kgfad`dfedf ~|~}gk osgyd~l idyw edygfd egngfmgywfhdf ~sg~lbled~l sgydfhed} egyd~ |dfh ml}wf}w} ~|~}gk osgyd~l idyw }gy~giw} nwews }lfhhl& Fdkwf @lfwz }gf}w ~dad mdsd} mlsdedl sdmd eoksw}gy mgfhdf ~sg~lbled~l |dfh nwews }lfhhl&
Kw`}l+W~gy
^gsgy}l sgfmdjw`wf|d ~|~}gk osgyd~l @lfwz awhd kgfmwewfh kw`}l+w~gy |dl}w sdmd ~dd} |dfh ~dkd kdksw kgfdfhdfl `gilj mdyl ~d}w w~gy ~ged`lhw~& Dsdswf ds`led~l |dfh mlsdedl ^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
8
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
gf}dj igywsd ~giwdj ds`led~l |dfh mlsdedl igy~dkddf d}dwswf ds`led~l |dfh igyigmd kdksw mlad`dfdf ~ged`lhw~&
Jdfmd`
md`dk Adylfhdf
Md`dk jd` sgfhg`o`ddf adylfhdf @lfwz }g`dj mlegfd` nwews jdfmd`& Ld kdksw kgfhg`o`d syoz| Lf}gyfg} ~gjlfhhd w~gy mdsd} igyeofge~l ~gndyd igy~dkd+~dkd mgfhdf ~d}w w~gy ml~}yliw~l ~wyd} g`ge}yofle *g+kdl`, eg ~g`wywj n`lgf} ~gy}d kdksw kgfadhd mdyl idjd|d sgfhlf}dldf w~gy `dlf md`dk ~d}w adylfhdf&
Egngsd}df
Sgyidledf Ndnd} * IWH ,
Egngsd}df md`dk sgyidledf iwh `gilj mdsd} mldfmd`edf& Lfl mdsd} }gyadml edygfd eg}gy~gmlddf eomg syohydk wf}we mlsgyo`gj o`gj idf|de oydfh mdsd} kgkidf}w el}d kg`ljd} syo~g~ |dfh }gyadml sdmd syohydk }gy~giw}& Aled }gyadml iwh dedf `gilj kwmdj kgksgyidlelf|d& Ml~dkslfh l}w mwewfhdf mdyl idf|de sgfhhwfd kdjly @lfwz wf}we kgfw}ws iwh kdksw kgksgyngsd} kgks gyngsd} sgyidledf&
^}dil`l}d~
@lfwz kgywsdedf ~|~}gk osgyd~l |dfh ~}dil` edygfdf|d sgfhhwfd }lmde sgy`w }dew} }gyadml nyd~j sdmd ~dd} kgfad`dfedf syohydk ds`led~l& Dfmd nwews kgfw}ws syohydk }gy~giw} }dfsd sgy`w kgyg~}dy} Eoksw}gy&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
:
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
I& Egewydfhdf Kgkdedl @lfwz
^g`dlf egwf}wfhdf d}dw d}dw eg`giljdf @lfwz |dfh }g`dj mlag`d~edf mlag`d~edf ~gig`wkf|d dmd igigydsd igigydsd jd` |dfh kgfadml egewydfhdf @lfwz mdf }lmde mdsd} mldidledf ighl}w ~dad& Fdkwf ~gadydj }g`dj kgfwfaweedf idjxd mdyl xde}w eg xde}w sgyegkidfhdf @lfwz ~gidhdl ~|~}gk osgyd~l eoksw}gy idle ~gyrgy kdwswf mg~e}os }g`dj kgfwfaweedf sgflfhed}df |dfh igydy}l kw`dl mdyl kwmdjf|d lf~}d`d~l ~dksdl mgfhdf ~gnwyl}| egdkdfdf |dfh `gilj idle mdyl sdmd Klnyo~ob} Xlfmox~& Igylew} dmd`dj igigydsd eg`gkdjdf |dfh ~g}lmdef|d jdyw~ mlsgyjd}ledf sdmd ~dd} Dfmd kgkw}w~edf wf}we igyd`lj eg @lfwz 1
Xde}w
Ig`dady
Idhl sgfhhwfd w~ld kwmd ~|~}gk lfl nwews kgfdyle wf}we mlsg`dadyl }gyw}dkd idhl |dfh kd~lj mwmwe mlidfhew sgfmlmledf& Fdkwf jd` lfl }dksdef|d }lmde }gyadml sdmd ~gidhldf ig~dy sgfhhwfd mgfhdf w~ld mld}d~f|d |dfh ~wmdj kdsdf mgfhdf ~|~}gk osgyd~l ~gig`wkf|d& Mlsgy`wedf xde}w wf}we ig`dady egkid`l edygfd ~|~}gk osgyd~l @lfwz dhde igyigmd mgfhdf ~|~}gk osgyd~l Klnyo~ob} Xlfmox~& ^gkdfhd} ig`dady sdmd ~gidhldf sgfhhwfd }gy~giw}`dj |dfh ~gylfhed`l kgfadml egfmd`d wf}we kgksg`dadyl ~|~}gk osgyd~l idyw }gykd~we @lfwz&
Ewydfhf|d
Mwewfhdf Ds`led~l N`lgf}
Ig`wk idf|de }gy~gmldf|d syohydk ds`led~l |dfh ~g}dyd mgfhdf syohydk ds`led~l |dfh }gymdsd} ml Klnyo~ob} Xlfmox~ *kl~d`edf ~dad Dw}oNDM ^S^^ d}dw |dfh `dlff|d,& Ed`dwswf ~wmdj dmd ild~df|d ig`wk ~gjgid} |dfh igyad`df ml Klnyo~ob} Xlfmox~& Kg~elswf kd~d kgfmd}dfh egkwfhelfdf }gy~gmldf|d ds`led~l }gy~giw} ~g`d`w dmd *~glylfh mgfhdf egsosw`gydf @lfwz ml kd~|dyded}, mgfhdf egdmddf lfl il~d kgfadml eg`gkdjdf @lfwz& Kl~d`edf ~giwdj sgyw~djddf kgkw}w~edf wf}we igyd`lj eg @lfwz }g}dsl ds`led~l |dfh mlsdedl wf}we kgf|g`g~dledf sgegyaddf ~gjdyl+jdyl ig`wk dmd sgfhhdf}lf|d ml @lfwz kded dedf kgksgy~w`l} ad`dff|d sgegyaddf& Sdmd ~dd} lfl ds`led~l |dfh }g`dj mlmwewfh ~gidhdl ml~}yo @lfwz ~gndyd kg`wd~ ~wmdj kgfndsdl ds`led~l dmklfl~}yd}oy edf}oY *~wyd}+kgf|wyd} ^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
<
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
~sygdm~jgg} syg~gf}d~l, ds`led~l mg~dlf hydbl~ ds`led~l sgykdlfdf md}did~g mdf }gf}w ~dad ds`led~l adylfhdf&
]gy`d`w Idf|de Rdyld~l
Idf|def|d ml~}yliw~l @lfwz |dfh dmd ml~dkslfh kgkigyledf egigid~df ~g`wd~+`wd~f|d md`dk kgkl`lj awhd mdsd} kgksgy~w`l} ~g~goydfh wf}we kgkl`lj ml~}yliw~l kdfd |dfh nonoe wf}we mlylf|d d}dw oyhdfl~d~lf|d& ^g`dlf l}w ~g}lds ml~}yliw~l ~gylfhed`l kg`dewedf sgfgksd}df `oed~l d}dw mlygn}oy| lf~}d`d~l syohydk ds`led~l mdf bl`g+bl`g `liydy| |dfh mliw}wjedf sdmd `oed~l |dfh igyigmd+igmd& Igyigmd mgfhdf Klnyo~ob} Xlfmox~ |dfh ~g`d`w kg`g}deedff|d ml mlygn}oy| PXlfmox~ d}dw PPXlfmox~P^|~}gk PPXlfmox~P^|~}gk&& Sgykd~d`djdf lfl }gf}wf|d dedf kwfnw` aled Dfmd ~gylfh i gyslfmdj ml~}yo @lfwz&
Fdkwf mdyl igigydsd egewydfhdf }gy~giw} @lfwz mdsd} mled}dedf ~gidhdl ~|~}gk osgyd~l kd~d mgsdf |dfh dedf igy}wkiwj ~glylfh mgfhdf sgyegkidfhdf hgfgyd~l kwmd sdmd ~dd} lfl idf|de kgfhhwfdedf ~|~}gk osgyd~l @lfwz& Mwewfhdf ds`led~l }gyjdmdsf|d awhd dedf kdelf igy}dkidj ~gad`df mgfhdf sgyad`dfdf xde}w&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
43
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
LF^]D@D^L @lFWZ MGILDF 7&3 Kgf~g}}lfh ioo}lfh eoksw}gy sdmd ILO^& Sd~}ledf ioo}lfh sgy}dkd dmd`d j NM/MRM&
Sd~}ledf NM+YOK Mylrg sdmd so~l~l }gyd}d~ edygfd el}d dedf ioo}lfh `gxd} NM+ YOK mdf kg`dewedf lf~}d`d~l kgfhhwfdedf NM/MRM& Dsdil`d el}d kg`dewedf lf~}d`d~l `gxd} Adylfhdf kded
Fg}xoye Ioo} byok DKM Dk8
]gedf gf}gy sdmd Gzl} ^drlfh
Njdfhg~ d}dw B43 wf}we kgf|lksdf eofblhwyd~l |dfh ~wmdj ml`dewedf mdf eg`wdy mdyl ILO^& Sdmd sl`ljdf eofblykd~l sl`lj \g~ &
Kgkl`lj komg lf~}d`d~l& Komg lf~}d`d~l dmd igigydsd kdndk 1
]gedf Gf}gy sdmd Lf~}d`` wf}we lf~}d`d~l komg }g z} ]gedf Gf}gy sdmd Hydsjlnd` lf~}d`` wf}we lf~}d`d~l komg HWL / komg Hydble ]gedf Gf}gy sdmd Dmrd fngm os}lof~ wf}we kg`ljd} sl`ljdf `dlf ]gedf Gf}gy sdmd Jg`s wf}we kg`ljd} sg}wfawe |dfh dmd&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
44
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
]gedf Gf}gy sdmd Lf~}d`` edygfd el}d dedf kgfhlf~}d`` mgildf mgfhdf komg}gz} sgy`w mleg}djwl idjxd mgfhdf komg` }gz} dedf kgksgyngsd} syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l kdwswf egiw}wjdf sdeg} ds`led~l ~gyrgy ~gyrgy |dfh dedf el}d lf~}d`` sdmd kd}gyl igylew}f|d&
Kgkl`lj idjd~d |dfh dedf mlhwfdedf& Idjd~d mgbdw`} |dfh mlhwfdedf dmd`dj Gfh`l~j&
]gedf gf}gy sdmd Gfh`l~j
„
Gfh`l~j edygfd el}d dedf kgfhhwfdedf idjd~d idjd~ d lfhhyl~ lfhhy l~ ~gidhdl ~g idhdl idjd~d idjd~d mgbdw`} mdyl ~|~}gk mgildf&
Kgkl`lj fghdyd |dfh Dfmd }gksd}l ~dd} lfl&
]gedf gf}gy sdmd o}jgy wf}we kgfndyl fghdyd lfmofg~ld&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
49
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
]gedf gf}gy sdmd D~ld wf}we kgfndyl fghdyd lfmofg~ld&
]gedf gf}gy sdmd Lfmofg~ld edygfd el}d kgkl`lj fghdyd lfl wf}we ~g}}lfh `oed~l |dfh el}d }gksd}l ~gedydfh&
Kgkl`lj `d|ow} eg|iodym |dfh dedf mlhwfdedf& ^gndyd mgbdw`} `d|ow} eg|iodym dmd`dj Dkgylndf Gfh`l~j&
]gedf gf}gy sdmd Dkgylndf
Gfh`l~j ~g~wdl mgfhdf mgbdw`} mdyl eg|iodym `d|ow} |dfh el}d hwfdedf&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
4>
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Syo~g~ sgfmg}ge~ldf jdymxdyg |dfh }gysd~dfh sdmd eoksw}gy&
Syo~g~ ~ndfflfh NM/ MRM |dfh mlhwfdedf wf}we kg`dewedf syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l
Syo~g~ @odmlfh eoksofgf `lfwz&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
4=
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Syo~g~ eofblhwyd~l adylfhdf mgfhdf MJNS *M|fdkln Jo~} Nof}yo` Syo}ono`, d}dw Sgfml~}yliw~ldf LS
Dmmyg~~ ~gndyd o}okd}l~&
Dsdil`d kgfhhwfdedf MJNS mdyl ~giwdj ~gyrgy |dfh }gy~gmld kded }wfhhw syo~g~ ~dksdl 433'& Edygfd el}d dedf kgfheofblhwyd~l Fg}xoye ~gndyd kdfwd` kded }gedf gf}gy sdmd Ndfng`
Syo~g~ eofblhwyd~l adylfhdf mgfhdf MJNS hdhd` jd` lfl ml~gidiedf }lmde ml}gkwedf ~gyrgy | dfh
kgfml~}yliw~ledf MJNS d}dwswf }lmde dmd sgydfhed} adylfhdf |dfh }gysd~dfh& Fdkwf }lmde kgfhhdfhhw syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l |dfh ~gmdfh ml`de~dfdedf&
]gedf gf}gy sdmd Nof}lfwg wf}we kg`dfaw}edf syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l&
Kgkl`lj ndyd kgfheofblhwyd~l adylfhdf& Sl`ljdf |dfh sgy}dkd mdf |dfh egmwd mlhwfdedf wf}we
kgfheofblhwyd~l adylfhdf kgfhhwfdedf MJNS& Sl`ljdf |dfh e g}lhd mlhwfdedf wf}we kgfheofblhwyd~l adylfhdf ml md`dk syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l& Sl`ljdf |dfh eggk sd} mlhwfdedf wf}we kgfheofblhwyd~l adylfhdf ~g}g`dj syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l ~g`g~dl&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
47
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
]gedf gf}gy sdmd Nofblhwyg
fg}xoye kdfwd``| edygfd el}d dedf kgfheofblhwyd~l Fg}xoye ~gndyd kdfwd` mgfhdf LS Dmmyg~~ Fg}kd~e Hd}gxd| MF^ |dfh ~wmdj el}d }gf}wedf ~gfmlyl&
Kgfheofblhwyd~l LS Dmmyg~~ ml md`dk syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l&
Kd~weedf LS Dmmyg~~ |dfh ~wmdj ml}gf}wedf ~gig`wkf|d& Nof}oj ~d|d kgfhhwfdedf LS Dmmyg~~ 4<9&42:&4&>3 ]gedf gf}gy wf}we kg`dfaw}edf lf~}d`d~l
Kgfheofblhwyd~l Fg}kd~e ml md`dk syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l lf~}d`d~l&
Kd~weedf Fg}kd~e |dfh ~wmdj ml}gf}wedf ~gig`wkf|d& Nof}oj kgfhhwfdedf Fg}kd~e 977&977&977&3& ]gedf gf}gy wf}we kg`dfaw}edf lf~}d`d~l&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
42
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgfheofblhwyd~l Hd}gxd| ml md`dk syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l&
Kd~weedf Hd}gxd| |dfh ~wmdj ml}gf}wedf ~gig`wkf|d& Nof}oj kgfhhwfdedf Hd}gxd| 4<9&42:&4&4& ]gedf gf}gy wf}we kg`dfaw}edf lf~}d`d~l&
Kgfheofblhwyd~l D`dkd} Fdkg ^gyrgy d}dw Fokoy MF^ ^gyrgy ml md`dk syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l&
Kd~weedf Fdkg ~gyrgy dmmyg~~g~ |dfh ~wmdj ml}gf}wedf ~gig`wkf|d& Nof}oj kgfhhwfdedf LS Dmmyg~~ 4<9&42:&4&>3 edygfd fdf}lf|d eoksw}gy lfl mladmledf ~gyrgy MF^& ]gedf gf}gy wf}we kg`dfaw}edf lf~}d`d~l&
Kgfheofblhwyd~l Jo~}fdkg ml md`dk syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l
Kd~weedf Jo~}fdkg d}dw fdkd eoksw}gy& Nof}oj 1 obdfl& ]gedf gf}gy wf}we kg`dfaw}edf lf~}d`d~l&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
48
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgfheofblhwyd~l Fdkd Mokdlf ml md`dk syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l&
Kd~weedf Mokdlf fdkg d}dw fdkd mokdlf& Nof}oj 1 ~ke&nok& ]gedf gf}gy wf}we kg`dfaw}edf lf~}d`d~l&
Kgfheofblhwyd~l qofd xde}w sdmd eo}d |dfh Dfmd }gksd}l&
]gedf gf}gy sdmd Adedy}d edygfd el}d }gy`g}de ml Sd~wywdf Adxd ]lk wy |dfh kgywsdedf XLI mgfhdf Adedy}d ~gidhdl Eo}d Dnwdff|d&
Syo~g~ sgfmg}ge~ldf Ml~e mdf jdymxdyg |dfh `dlf&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
4:
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Syo~g~ sgy~ldsdf sdy}l~l jdymml~e&
Kgkl`lj ndyd sdy}l~l jdymml~e& Sl`ljdf sgy}dkd, sdy}l~l ml`dewedf ~gndyd o}okd}l~ mgfhdf
kgfhjdsw~ ~gkwd sdy}l~l |dfh dmd ml jdymml~e mdf kgfhhwfdedf ~gkwd edsd~l}d~ jdymml~e |dfh dmd wf}we sdy}l~l `lfwz mgildf& Sl`ljdf egmwd, sdy}l~l ml`dewedf ~gndyd o}okd}l~ mgfhdf kgfhjdsw~ ~gkwd sdy}l~l |dfh dmd ml jdymml~e mdf kgfhhwfdedf ~gkwd edsd~l}d~ jdymml~e |dfh dmd wf}we sdy}l~l `lfwz mgildf mdf ml ~g} @RK& Sl`ljdf eg}lhd, sdy}l~l ml`dewedf ~gndyd o}okd}l~ mgfhdf kgfhjdsw~ ~gkwd sdy}l~l |dfh dmd ml jdymml~e mdf kgfhhwfdedf ~gkwd sdy}l~l |dfh dmd wf}we sdy}l~l `lfwz mgildf mdf ml ~g} gfn}|s}gm @RK& Sl`ljdf eggksd}, sdy}l~l ml`dewedf ~gndyd kdfwd` ~g~wdl |dfh mliw}wjedf mdf kgf|g~wdledf jdymml~e |dfh dmd&
]gedf gf}gy sdmd Kdfwd` edygfd el}d dedf kgksdy}l~l jdymml~e ~gndyd kdfwd`& Sl`ljdf lfl ~dfhd} nonoe dsdil`d jdymml~e el}d ~wmdj }gyl~l md}d `dlf *kl~d` }gymdsd} ~l~}gk osgyd~l xlfmox~ |dfh ~wmdj dmd ~gig`wkf|d, dhdy md}d }gy~giw} }lmde }gyjdsw~ edygfd fdf}lf|d el}d dedf kgkiwd} sdy}l~l idyw |dfh mlbwfh~ledf mlbwfh~ledf wf}we kgf|lksdf `lfwz |dfh el}d lf~}d`` ~gedydfh&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
4<
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgkiwd} sdy}l~l sdmd ~sdng/idhldf jdy mml~e |dfh eo~ofh&
]gedf gf}gy sdmd `dig` BYGG
^SDNG wf}we kgkiwd} sdy}l~l idyw& Sdy}l~l mld}d~ kd~lj eo~ofh edygfd jdymml~e kd~lj idyw mdf ~gkgf}dyd jdf|d dedf }gyl~l `lfwz |dfh ~gedydfh el}d lf~}d``& ]dksl`df mld}d~ il~d }lmde ~dkd }gyhdf}wfh jdymml~e |dfh dfmd hwfdedf dsdedj kd~lj eo~ofh d}dwswf ~wmdj igyl~l md}d& Fdkwf dfmd }lmde sgy`w ilfhwfh dfmd }lfhhd` kgfndyl `dig` BYGG ^SDNG wf}we kgkiwd} sdy}l~l idyw&
Kgkiwd} sdy}l~l ~gndyd o}okd}l~ sdmd ~sdng/idhldf jdymml~e |dfh eo~ofh&
]gedf Gf}gy sdmd Nygd}g d fgx
sdy}l}lof wf}we kgkiwd} sdy}l~l idyw& Sl`ljdf Dw}okd}lnd``|
sdy}l}lof }jg bygg ~sdng mlhwfdedf wf}we kgkiwd} sdy}l~l ~gndyd o}okd}l~ |dfh ml`dewedf o`gj eoksw}gy ~g~wdl mgfhdf bygg ~sdng |dfh ~wmdj dmd sdmd }dkksl`df ~gig`wkf|d& Dsdil`d dfmd sgfhhwfd `lfwz |dfh kd~lj idyw ml~dydfedf kgkl`lj Dw}okd}lnd``| sdy}l}lof
}jg bygg ~sdng &
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
93
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Dsdil`d dfmd kgkl`lj Dw}okd}lnd``| sdy}l}lof }jg bygg ~sdng kded |dfh dedf kwfnw` dmd`dj }dksl`df ~gidhdl igylew} 1 Sl`ljdf sgy}dkd dsdil`d el}d jdf|d kgkiwd} 9 sdy}l~l ~dad |dl}w yoo} mdf ~xds& Sl`ljdf egmwd dsdil`d el}d kgkiwd} > sdy}l~l |dl}w yoo} ~xds mdf jokg& Sl`ljdf eg}lhd dsdil`d el}d kgkiwd} 2 sdy}l~l |dl}w yoo} ~xds jokg w~y rdy mdf }ks& Sdy}l~l klflkd` mdyl `lfwz dmd`dj yoo} mdf ~xds&
]dksl`df syo~g~ sgkiwd}df sdy}l~l ~gndyd o}okd}l~ |dfh ml`dewedf o`gj eoksw}gy
]gedf gf}gy sdmd Blfl~j
sdy}l}loflfh dfm xyl}g njdfhg~ }o ml~e wf}we kgfhdejlyl syo~g~ sdy}l~l mdf sdy}l~l ~lds ~ lds wf}we wf} we ml boy kd}&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
94
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
]gedf gf}gy sdmd |g~ wf}we kgkboykd} sdy}l~l |dfh ~wmdj mliwd} ~gig`wkf|d
&
Syo~g~ boykd} sdy}l~l |dfh ~wmdj mliwd} ~gig`wkf|d&
Syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l id~g ~|~}gk&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
99
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgf~g}}lfh sd~~xoym wf}we Yoo}&
Kd~weedf sd~~xoym wf}we yoo}& ]gedf gf}gy wf}we kg`dfaw}edf lf~}d`d~l&
Kd~weedf ~ged`l `dhl sd~~xoym |dfh~wmdj dfmd kd~weedf sdmd }dksl`df ~gig`wkf|d& ]gedf gf}gy wf}we kg`dfaw}edf lf~}d`d~l
Kgf~g}}lfh fdkd w~gy w~gyfdkg wf}we dnnowf} mdf Sd~~xoym mdyl w~gy }gy~giw}&
Kd~weedf fdkd wf}we w~gy idyw& ]gedf gf}gy wf}we kg`dfaw}edf syo~g~ lf~}d`d~ l&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
9>
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kd~weedf fdkd w~gy idyw& ]gedf
gf}gy wf}we kg`dfaw}edf syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l&
Kd~weedf sd~~xoym wf}we w~gy idyw&]gedf idyw&] gedf gf}gy wf}we kg`dfaw}edf syo~g~ lf~}d`d~ l
Kd~weedf sd~~xoym ~ged`l `dhl wf}we w~gy idyw |dfh ~wmdj mlkd~weedf sdmd }dksl`df ~gig`wkf|d& ]gedf gf}gy wf}we kg`dfaw}edf syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
9=
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Syo~g~ eofblhwyd~l ds}&
]dksl`df eofblykd~l dsdedj dfmd kgf~ndf NM/MRM ~g`dlf NM/MRM 4 ~gedydfh *sdmd xde}w syo~g~
lf~}d`d~l, mgfhdf kgkl`lj \g~ d}dw kgf~ndf fdf}l ~g}g`dj syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l ~g`g~dl mgfhdf kgkl`lj Fo&
]gedf gf}gy sdmd sl`ljdf Fo edygfd el}d dedf kgf~ndf NM/MRM fdf}l ~g}g`dj syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l ~g`g~dl& Syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l dedf kgkiwdfh xde}w |dfh }lmde ~gmlel}&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
97
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgkl`lj dsdedj kgfhhwfdedf klyyoy d}dw }lmde& Klyyoy lfl fdf}lf|d mlhwfdedf wf}we kgfhlf~}d``
d}dwswf kgfhwsmd}g sdeg} |dfh mliw}wjedf kg`d`wl ~gyrgy |dfh ~wmdj ml~gmldedf d}dwswf kg`d`wl lf}gyfg}&
]gedf gf}gy sdmd Fo edygfd el}d kgfhhwfdedf kgmld NM/MRM wf}we kg`dewedf lf~}d`d~l d}dwswf wsmd}g sdeg} fd f}lf|d&
Syo~g~ sgkl`ljdf mdf sgfhlf~}d``df ~ob}xdyg/sdeg}&
Kgkl`lj dsdedj sdy}l~lsd~l sdmd sdeg} |dfh mlhwfd edf wf}we ~wyrg|&
]gedf gf}gy sdmd Fo wf}we kg`dfaw}edf syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
92
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgkl`lj ~ob}xdyg d}dw sdeg} |dfh ded f mllf~}d``&
Jdsw~ }dfmd ngf}dfh sdmd Mg~e}os
gfrlyofkgf} edygfd eoksw}gy lfl fdf}lf|d dedf mlbwfh~ledf ~gidhdl ~gyrgy |dfh `gilj kgkgf}lfhedf egkdkswdf mdylsdmd hydsjln& Igyl }dfmd ngf}dfh jdf|d sdmd ^}dfmdym ~|~}gk& ]gedf
gf}gy wf}we kg`dfaw}edf wf}we kg`dfaw}edf syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l&
Syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l HYWI ioo` `odmgy&
]gedf gf}gy sdmd |g~ edygfd el}d dedf kgfhlf~}d`` HYWI ioo}
`odmgy sdmd kd~}gy ioo} ygnoym &
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
98
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Syo~g~ blfl~jlfh lf~}d`d~l&
]dksl`df Lf~}d`d~l ~g`g~dl&
]gedf gf}gy sdmd Nof}lfwg wf}we kgfhdejlyl syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l `lfwz mgildf 7&3&
^g}g`dj syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l ~g`g~dl eoksw}gy dedf kg`dewedf yg~}dy} mdf dedf kwfnw` }dksl`df ioo}
`odmgy& ]gedf gf}gy sdmd Mgildf HFW/@lfwz egyfg` 9&2&92+4+2:2 wf}we kd~we eg ~l~}gk osgyd~l mgildf 7&3 |dfh idyw ~dad ~g `g~dl el}d lf~}d``&
Eoksw}gy ~lds kg`dewedf yg~}dy}
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
9:
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
]gedf gf}gy wf}we kd~we eg ~l~}gkosgyd~l mgildf 7&3 |dfh idyw ~dad ~g`g~dl el}d lf~}d``&
Syo~g~ mg}ge~l jdymxdyg |dfh }gysd~dfh sdmd eoksw}gy ~gy}d kgfhde}lbedf ~gyrlng+~gyrlng |dfh dmd sdmd `lfwz&
^g}g`dj syo~g~ mg}ge~l jdymxdyg mdf sgfhde}lbdf sgfhd e}lbdf ~gyrlng ~ gyrlng ~g`g~dl& ~g`g~d l& @ohlf @ohl f kgfhhwfdedf w~gy |dfh ~wmdj dfmd iwd} sd md xde}w xd e}w lf~}d`d~l& lf~} d`d~l&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
9<
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
]dksl`df ~g}g`dj syo~g~ `ohlf igyjd~ l`& @lfwz ~lds wf}we mlhwfded ml hwfdedf f mdf ~lds wf}we mlge~s`oyd~l&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
>3
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
^G]]LFH FLN *FG]XOYE LF]GYBDNG NDYM, O~ @lfwz Mgildf kgywsdedf ~giwdj ~|~}gk osgyd~l Osgf ^owyng mlkdfd ~g}lds lfmlrlmw mdsd} kgywidj }dksl`df kdwswf ~g}}lfhdf |dfh dmd mlmd`dkf|d ~g~wdl mgfhdf eglfhlfdf sgfhhwfdf|d kw`dl mdyl sgf|g}}lfhdf FLN MF^ XGI KDL@ MJNS mdf nofblhwyd~l `dlff|d ~gndyd kdfwd` mdf jd` sgy}dkd |dfh sgy`w mlsgyjd}ledf sdmd ~dd} kgkidfhwf ~giwdj ~gyrgy dmd`dj kgfhnofblhwyd~l LS Dmmyg~~ *FLN,& ^gig`wk kgf~g}}lfh FLN FLN }gy`gilj }gy`gilj mdjw`w @ohlf mgfhdf w~gy yoo} mdf mdf sd~~xoym |dfh |dfh
}g`dj ml iwd} sdmd ~dd} lf~}d``d~l @lfwz Mgildf& Sdmd ~dd} kgfhl~l sd~~xoym Sd~~xoym ~gfhdad }lmde ml}dksl`edf mgkl wf}we kgfadhd egydjd~lddf&
~gig`wkf|d
sd~~xoym sdmd ~dd} kg`dewedf lf~}d`d~l
^g}}lfhdf dxd` md`dk `dfhedj lfl dmd`dj kgf~g}}lfh LS Dmmyg~~ ~wifg} kd~e hd}gxd|
FLM *fg}xoye
LM,
Iyodmnd~} ^gyrgy& Sdmd bl`g 1 /g}n/fg}xoye/lf}gybdng~ /g}n/fg}xoye/lf}gybdng~&& Igylew}
sgylf}dj |dfh jdyw~ ml`dewedf 1
Gml} ^nyls} ]gedf ‐ Lf~gy} Lf~gy} ‛ ‛ Gml} ‐ d``ox+jo}s`wh d``ox+jo}s`wh‛ dw}o‛ kgfadml ‐ dw}o Gml} dmmyg~~ ~g~wdl mgfhdf eglfhlfdf sgfhhwfd, gz ls ~d|d 1 4<9&42:&4&>3 ‛ ‐ 4<9&42:&4&>3 ‛
Egkwmldf wf}we eg`wdy mdf kgf|lksdff|d G~n ‛ `d`w eg}ledf }gedf ‐ G~n
1xt‛ }gedf ‐ gf}gy gf}gy ‛ ‛ ‐ 1xt
^g~wdledf ~nyls} ~gsgy}l hdkidy ml~dkslfh&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
>4
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kg`ljd} nofblhwyd~l d`dkd} ls dmmyg~~ ig~gy}d mokdlf `ond`jo~} ~gyrgy&
Gml} ^nyls} ]gedf ‐Lf~gy}‛ widj kgfadml ~gsgy}l hdkidy ml ~dkslfh ‐G~n‛ `d`w eg}ledf
‐1xt‛ }gedf
Kgfhgnge bl`g yg~o`r& Mlkdfd ls lfl jdyw~ ml~g~wdledf mgfhdf ls ~gyrgy igy~gy}d fdkd
mokdlff|d * jdksly ~dkd sdmd ~dd} el}d kg`dewedf syo~g~ sgf|g}}lfhdf jo~}~ ~gyrgy ,&
Kgfhofblhwyd~l fdkd jo~}fdkg ~gyrgy |dl}w |dl}w obdfl&~ke&nok `dfh~wfh sdmd `ondjo~} ~gyrgy&
|dfh dedf ml ~g}}lfh
Kgyg~}dy} `d|dfdf fg}xoye |dfh ~wmdj }gynofblhwyd~l&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
>9
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
^G]]LFH MF^ *Mokdlf Fdkg ^gyrgy,
Bwfh~l mdf eghwfddf Mf~ dmd`dj kgywidj d`dkd} ls ~gyrgy kgfadml d`dkd} dmmyg~~ ~gjlfhhd oydfh `dlf mgfhdf kwmdjf|d mdsd} kgfhhwfdedf d`dkd} d`ld~ mdyl ls }gy~giw} }dfsd jdyw~ kgfhg}djwl d`dkd} mdyl ls ~gyrgy& Ds`led~l |dfh mliw}wedf wf}we sgfhlf~}d`df MF^ dmd`dj Ilfm<
Kgfdkidjedf ~nyls} sdmd bl`g /g}n/ilfm/fdkgm&nofb&`ond` |dfh mlhwfdedf wf}we
kgkdfhhl` nofblhwyd~l bl`g mi&boyxdym mdf mi&yg~gyrg sdmd nofhwyd~l bl`g |dfh dedf el}d ~g}}lfh fdf}l &
Eg}ledf ~nyls} mlidxdj lfl sdmd idyl~ sd`lfh idxdj 1 qofg ‐~ke&nok ‐~ke&nok‛‛ u }|sg kd~}gy5 bl`g ‐/g}n/ilfm/mi&boy‛5 {5 qofg ‐4&42:&4<9&lf+dmmy& ‐4&42:&4<9&lf +dmmy&dysd‛ dysd‛ u }|sg kd~}gy5 bl`g ‐/g}n/ilfm/mi&ygr‛5 {5
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
>>
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
^gjlfhhd nofblhwyd~l sdmd bl`g b l`g fdkgm&nofb&`ond` dedf }gy`ljd} ~gsgy}l hdkidy mlidxdj lfl 1 ]gedf Lf~gy} `d`w ^drg nofblhwyd~l MF^ mgfhdf kgfgedf ‐G~n‛ egkwmldf ‐1xt‛ 1xt‛
Egkwmldf Kd~we eg mlygn}oy| ilfm |dl}w bo`mgy mlkdfd }gymdsd} nofblhwyd~l sd`lfh w}dkd mdyl ds`led~l MF^ sdmd ~dd} dedf kg`dewedf sgf|g}}lfhdf MF^ ^gyrgy &
Kgfhnos| bl`g mi&498 kgfadml mi&boy mdf mi&ygr
Kgkiwd} nofblhwyd~l bl`g |dfh }g`dj mlnos| }dml |dl}w mi&boyxdym mdf mi&ygrgy~g 1 *Kgkiwed bl`g mi&boy,
Gml} ^nyls} mi&boy ~gsgy}l hdkidy 1 Jl`dfhedf ed}d
Ygrgy~g Hdf}l dfhed 4
kgfadml 9 Gml} ~nyls}hdf}l
mdyl S]Y kgfadml KZ ]dkidjedf
igigydsd ed}d sdmd ~nyls} jlfhhd ~gsgy}l hdkidy ml ~dkslfh
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
>=
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
*Kgkiwed bl`g mi&ygr, Gml} ^nyls} mi&ygr jlfhhd fdksde ~gsgy}l hdkidy 1 Jl`dfhedf }dfmd C
Gml} ~nyls} `ond`jo~}
Hdf}l 4&3&3 kgfadml fo LS ~gyrgy, nof}oj 14<9&42:&4&>3 adml Fo LS f|d 1 >3
Gml} ~nyls} ~dkd sgy~l~ ~gsgy}l Fdksde hdkidy
Kgyg~}dy} `d|dfdf ilfm<
Kgfhgnge MF^ |dfh ~wmdj }gynofblhwyd~l &
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
>7
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
LF^]D@D^L XGI ^GYRGY
Sgy`w mleg}djwl idjxd sdmd ~dd} el}d dedf kgfnofblhwyd~l Xgi ^gyrgy fdkd ~wimokdlf |dfh dedf el}d hwfdedf l}w igyjwiwfhdf mgfhdf syo~g~ sgf|g}}lfhdf MF^ ^gyrgy adml sgkiwd}dff|d jdyw~ ~dkd mdf ml~g~wdledf sdmd ~dd} el}d kgfhnofblhwyd~l MF^ |dl}w bl`g mi&boy & Nof}oj 1 ^gkl~d` El}d dedf kgfhhwfdedf ^wimokdlf ^wimokdlf xgi&~ke&nok adml ~ke&nok kgywsdedf fdkd mokdlf mdyl ~gyrgy mdf xgi dmd`dj ~wimokdlf |dfh dedf mlhwfdedf sgy`w mllfhd} sdmd nofblhwyd~l MF^ mlmd`dk bl`g mi&boy mi&boy ml idhldf sd`lfh idxdj l}w sgy`w sgy`w dmd sgfdkidjdf sgfdkidjdf ~nyls} 1
Xgi
LF
NFDKG
obdfl
Mlkdfd bl`g }gy~giw} kgkswf|dl bwfh~l ~gidhdl sgkdfhhl` fdkd jo~} *~wimokdlf, mdyl ~gyrgy sdmd ~dd} xgi ~gyrgy ~gyrgy dedf mlad`dfedf fdf}lf|d fdf}lf|d &
Kgfhlf~}d`` sdeg} |dfh mliw}wjedf |dl}w dsdnjg9 sjs7 `lfe~&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
>2
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgfhde}lbedf Kw`}l W~gy dhdy ~g}lds w~gy mdsd} md sd} kgfhde~g~ jd`dkdf xgi ~l}g &
Kgkiwd} jd`dkdf yoo} xgi~l}g mlmd`dk bo`mgy w~gy |dfh dedf mlhwfdedf wf}we
kgfdksl`edf ~g`wywj l~l jd`dkdf xgi~l}g&
Kgfhnos| nofblhw yd~l bl`g mgbdw`} kgfadml ‐xgi‛&
Kgkiwd} nofblhwyd~l w}dkd mdyl ~wd}w xgi~l}g |dl}w mlmd`dk bo`mgy /g}n/dsdnjg9/~l}g~+ drdl`di`g/ wf}we kgfhd}wy fdkd d`ld~ d}dw ~wimokdlf xgi~l}g ~gidhdl Rly}wd` Jo~}& ]dkidjedf
Gml} ~nyls} xgi kgfadml 1
idyl~ FdkgRly}wd`Jo~ } 4<9&42:&4&>31:3 mdf Rl}wd`Jo~} 4<9&42:&4&>31:3 Hdf}l fdkd mdyl ^gyrgyDmklf kgfadml obdflC~ke&nok mdf ^gyrgyFdkg ~gidhdl xgi d`ld~ d}dw ^wimokdlf |dl}w xxx&~ke&nok Gml} jd`dkdf monwkgf} yoo} /jokg/obdfl/x gi Mdf Mlygn}oy| xgi~l}g kgfadml /jokg/obdfl/x gi ^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
>8
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
m lmd`dk bo`mgy /g}n/dsdnjg9/~l}g~+gfdi`gm /g}n/dsdnjg9/~l}g~ +gfdi`gm 1 Kgfhde}lbedf nofblhwyd~l bl`g ‐xgi‛ mlmd`dk
Kgfofdeb}ledf bl`g mgbdw`} mlkdfd ~gig`wkf|d ~wmdj }gynofblhwyd~l de}lb ~gndyd
o}okd}l~ mlmd`dk xgi ~gyrgy 1
Kgfhnos|
igigydsd
bl`g
wf}we
jd`dkdf
xgi~l}g
~gyrgy
egmd`dk
mlygn}oy|
‐/jokg/obdfl/xgi‛ /jokg/obdfl/xgi‛ kg`d`wl b`d~jml~e 1 Kgkiwd} Bo`mgy |dfh dedf mlhwfdedf ~gidhdl }gksd} sgf|lksdfdf md}d+md}d
mlmd`dk b`d~jml~e &
]dfndsedf b`d~jml~e egmd`dk noksw}gy hwfd kgfhg}djwl fdkd d`dkd} ~|~}gk mdyl
b`d~jml~e }gy~giw} `d`w eg}leedf sgylf}dj 1
^|~}gk dedf kgfmg}ge~l d`dkd} b`d~jml~e mdf ild~df|d dedf kgfdksl`edf ~|~}gk
md}d b`d~jml~e ~gsgy}l 1 /mgr/~md4 /mgr/~mi4 d}dw /mgr/~mn4 *~g}lds ~|~}gk dedf kgfdksl`edf md}d d`dkd} b`d~jml~e |dfh igyigmd+igmd }gyhdf}wfh mdyl eofml~l idf|def|d sdy}l~l mdyl ~giwdj jdyml~e,& ^gidhdl nof}oj aled d`dkd} b`d~jml~e kgfdksl`edf ~|~}gk md}d b`d~jml~e |dl}w 1
‐/mgr/~md4‛ /mgr/~md4‛ kded eg}leedf ~dad sgylf}dj 1
Kded ~gndyd o}okd}l~ md}d+md}d |dfh dmd mlmd`dk b`~jml~e dedf m l}dksl`edf eg
md`dk bo`mgy /jokg/b`d~j&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
>:
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kd~we egmd`dk mlygn}oy| b`d~jml~e |dfh }gymdsd} ~nyls} xgi~l}g&
*xgi~l}gew
fdkd bo`mgy |dfh
igydmd mlmd`dk b`d~jml~e |dfh }gymdsd} md}d+md}d bl`g nof}gf} nof}gf} xgi~l}g |dfh dedf mlnos|edf sdmd jd`dkdf yoo} fdf}lf|d& ,
Kgfhnos| jd`dkdf lfmgz&sjs d}dwswf bl`g sgfmwewfh `dlff|d |dfh dedf mlhwfdedf
~gidhdl }dksl`df jd`dkdf ~wd}w xgi~l}g egmd`dk bo`mgy yoo} |dl}w /jokg/obdfl/xgi mdyl b`d~jml~e &
Kgyg~}dy} `d|dfdf Dsdnjg9 xgi ~gyrgy 1
Kgfhg}g~ Xgi ^gyrgy |dfh ~wmdj }gynofblhwyd~l&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
><
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
^G]]LFH B]S ^GYRGY B}s kgkswf|dl bwfh~l |dl}w wf}we kgkigyledf de~g~ egsdmd ~giwdj n`lgf} dhdy mdsd} kgfhlylk bl`g d}dwswf igigydsd md}d egmd`dk ~giwdj ~gyrgy& Wf}we sgfhlf~}d`dff|d ~dfhd} kwmdj jdf|d kgfdkidjedf ~giwdj w~gy mdf awhd kgkiwd} dnng~~ sgykl~~lof 888 egsdmd bo`mgy w~gy |dfh dmd mlmd`dkf|d& Sdeg} |dfh mliw}wjedf |dl}w Syob}sm &
^g`dfaw}f|d sl`lj ~dad ^}dfmd`ofg edygfd ~gyrgy el}d igymlyl ~gfmlyl&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
=3
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgkiwd} w~gy idyw wf}we B]S &
Kd~weedf sd~~xoym wf}we w~gy idyw mdf awhd md}d w~gy ml~dfd&
Kgkigyledf de~g~ sgykl~~lof 888 sdmd bo`mgy w~gy |dfh igydmd mlmd`dk bo`mgy /jokg/
|dfh }g`dj mliwd} ~gig`wkf|d& ^wsd|d w~gy }gy~giw} mdsd} kgfhlylk md}d d}dwswf kgfhjdsw~ md}d mdyl Sn n`lgf} wf}we kgfhg}djwl fdkd ~giwdj w~gy |dfh dmd mlmd`dk ~gyrgy kd~we ~dad egmd`dk mlygn}oy| ‐jokg‛ * nm /jokg `d`w nge mdb}dy `l~} w~gy |dfh igywsd bo`mgy mgfhdf sgylf}dj *mly d}dw `~, &
Kgyg~}dy} `d|dfdf ds`led~l Syob}sm &
]g~
B]S ^gyrgy |dfh ~wmdj mleofblhwyd~l
@oh f gfhdf gfhdf w~gy w~gy mdf sd~~xoym |dfh dmd egkwmldf kgfhg}g~} `d|dfdf B]S mgfhdf kgkiwd} mlygn}oy| idyw& Aled ~we~g~ kded dedf eg`wdy sg~df Mlygn}oy| ~wnng~~bw``|
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
=4
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgfhg}g~ `d|dfdf B]S kg`d`wl n`lgf} |dl}w mgfhdf kgkiwed Xlfmox~ gzs`oygy `d`w kd~weedf fokoy LS ^gyrgy sdmd eo}de dmmyg~~ gzs`oygy
b}s1//4<9&42:&4&>3
@oh f gfhdf gfhdf w~gy w~gy mdf sd~~xoym |dfh dmd egkwmldf }g~} B]S kg`d`wl n`lgf} mgfhdf kgkiwd} bo`mgy d}dw kgfhlylk bl`g egmd`dk B]S ~gyrgy&
Lf~}d`d~l B]S }g`dj igyjd~l` dsdil`d w~gy mdsd} kgfhlylk bl`g bl`g mdf awhd igigydsd md}d ml~dfd mdf awhd mdsd} kg`dewedf kg`dewedf sgfhgngedf md}d+md}d md}d+md}d |dfh }g`dj dfmd }ydf~bgy }ydf~bgy }dml kg`d`wl kg`d`wl ~gyrgy& ~gyrgy&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
=9
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
LF^]D@@ MJNS ^GYRGY
Bwfh~l mdyl MJNS dmd`dj wf}we kgkigyledf fokoy Ls Dmmyg~~ ~gndyd mlfdkl~ d}dw o}okd}l~ egsdmd n`lgf} ~gjlfhhd n`lgf} wf}we }gyjwiwfh egsdmd ~gyrgy }lmde mlsgy`wedf sgfhd}wydf fokoy ls n`lgf} ~gndyd kdfwd`& Kg`dlfedf ~gyrgy |dfh dedf kgfmg}ge~l ~giwdj n`lgf} mdf kgfhd}wy ls n`lgf} m d`dk ~giwdj adylfhdf& Lf~}d`` sdeg} mjns>+~gyrgy wf}we kg`d`wedf lf~}d``d~l Mjns ^gyrgy&
]gedf ~dad gf}gy&
Gml} bl`g ‐mjnsm&nofb‛ hwfd wf}we kgfhd}wy fokoy LS dmmyg~~ |d fh dedf el}d ~g}}lfh sdmd fokoy LS n`lgf}&
Gml} ~nyls} ~gsgy}l hdkidy ml~dkslfh lfhd} ydfhg dmd`dj Adfhedwdf mdyl LS Dmmyg~~ |dfh mlml~}yliw~ledf *Ml MJNS edf, egsdmd n`lgf}&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
=>
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
^g`dfaw}f|d Yg~}dy} `d|dfdf ds`led~l MJNS ^gyrgy&
Kgfhgnge MJNS kg`d`wl n`lgf} mgfhdf Kgfh+Oi}dlf LS kded ls dedf }gy~g}}lfh mgfhdf ~gfmlylf|d ~g~wdl sdmd nofblhwyd~l bl`g ‐mjns&nofb‛ ~gig`wkf|d }dml&
Slfh fokoy LS ~gyrgy kg`d`wl n`lgf}
slfh 4<9&42:&4&>3
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
==
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
LF^]D@D^L XGI KDL@ ^GYRGY Dhdy ~g}lds n`lgf} mdsd} igyjwiwfhdf mdf igyeokwfled~l `dfh~wfh egmd`dk ~giwdj adylfhdf ~dfhd} mlsgy`wedf ~ged`l sdeg} gkdl` ~gyrgy sdmd mgildf lfl& ^gjlfhhd n`lgf} mdsd} kg`dewedf jwiwfhdf mdf eokwfled~l ~gndyd igid~ }dfsd jdyw~ }gyeofge~l d}dw }gy~dkiwfh egmd`dk ~giwdj adylfhdf lf}gyfg}& Kgfhlf~}d`` igigydsd sdeg} |dfh mliw}wjedf |dl}w ^twlyyg`kdl` So~}blz Nowylgy+lkds
mdf awhd Nowylgy+sos&
Sl`lj Fo sdmd Nofblhwyd~l Nowylgy+Id~ mlidxdj lfl &
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
=7
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
^g`dfaw}f|d dedf kwfnw` Nofblhwyd~l sdmd So~}lz `d`w }gedf OE Mdf sdmd Sdnedhg
nofblhwyd~l ~g`dfaw}f|d sl`lj ~dad Lf}gyfg} ^l}g&
@d`w kd~weedf fdkd mokdlf `ond` ~gyrgy dfmd& Mlkdfd mokdlf }gy~giw} kgywsdedf
~giwdj mokdlf gkdl` |dfh dedf el}d admledf jo~} wf}we xgi kdl` ~gyrgy el}d&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
=2
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3 bl`g /g}n/so~}blz/kdlf&nb /g}n/so~}blz/kdlf&nb Kgfhgml} bl`g
@LFWZ
* Nofblhwyd~l lfl dmd`dj nofblhwyd~l w}dkd md`dk
lf~}d`d~l xgi ~gyrgy,& ]dkidjedf mdf gml} ~nyls} ~gsgy}l hdkidy mlidxdj lfl 1
Kgf~g}}lfh nofblhwyd~l ~twlyyg`kdl` sdmd SGY@ |dl}w /g}n/~twlyyg`kdl`/nofb&s` /g}n/~twlyyg`kdl`/nofb&s`
L~l Nokkdfm mgfhdf kgkl`lj mdf kgfhg}le fo 9 egkwmldf GF]GY
]gedf 4 egkwmldf gf}gy& Egkwmldf
kd~weedf fdkd mokdlf & ]gedf gf}gy
wf}we kg`dfaw}edf eg syo~g~ ~g`dfaw}f|d&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
=8
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
]gedf y egkwmldf gf}gy wf}we egkid`l eg kgfw dxd`&
Kgf~g}}lfh fdkd ~gyrgy wf}we ~ttwlyyg`kdl`&
L~l Nokkdfm mgfhdf kgkl`lj mdf kgfhg}le jwywb m egkwmldf
GF]GY wf}we kgf~g}}lfh nofblhwyd~l LKDS
^gyrgy&
Eg}leedf ed}d ‐Nowylgy‛ Nowylgy‛ sdmd Nokkdfm @lfg&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
=:
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Egkwmldf }gedf }okio` ^ `d`w egkwmldf GF]GY wf}we kgf|lksdf nofblhwyd~l &
Wf}we eg`wdy mdyl Nokkdfm Nofblhwyd~l ^twlyyg`kdl` mld}d~ }gedf ~dad
`d`w Gf}gy&
Kgkiwd} mlygn}oy| Kdl`mly wf}we sgf|lksdfdf md}d gkdl` mdyl ~g}lds w~gy gkdl` |dfh
}g`dj kg`dewedf sgfhlylkdf sg~df gkdl`& Mdf jd` |dfh sgy`w mlsgyjd}ledf dmd`dj Sgfw`l~df ed}d Kdl`mly jwywb ‐K‛ jdyw~ ml}w`l~ kgfhhwfdedf jwywb ndsl}d`&
Kgkiwd} ~|k`lfe~ wf}we d`dkd} gkdl` ~gndyd o}okd}l~ &
Obdfl1v. `f „~ /g}n/~twlyyg`kdl`/dsdnjg&nofb /g}n/dsdnjg9/nofb&m/~twlyyg`kdl`&nofb
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
=<
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgfhgml} bl`g /g}n/dsdnjg9/nofb&m/~twlyyg`kdl`&nofb mdyl ~|k`lfe~ |dfh }g`dj el}d iwd} }dml&
Mlkdfd d`dkd} gkdl` mgfhdf ^|k`lfe~ }gy~giw}, dedf kgfhdydj sdmd bo`mgy ‐xgikdl`‛& ^gjlfhhd mdyl nofblhwyd~l mld}d~ el}d el}d mdsd} kgfhlylkedf mdf kgkiwd} kgkiwd} ~wyd} gkdl` kg`d`wl d`dkd} `lfe~ 1 xxx&~ke&nok/xgikdl`
Kgyg~}dy} ~gkwd `d|dfdf sdeg} ds`led~l gkdl` |dl}w ~twlyyg`kdl` so~}blz nowylgy+lkds
nowylgy+sos &
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
73
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgkiwd} W~gy idyw wf}we ds`led~l gkdl` &
Kgfhg}g~ gkdl` kg`d`wl ~gyrgy 1
Kd~weedf Fdkg mdf Sd~~xoym `ohlf ~g~wdl mgfhdf w~gy |dfh }g`dj mliw} }dml&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
74
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgfhg}g~ jd`dkdf gkdl` |dfh }g`dj }gynofblhwyd~l mgfhdf ndyd kgfhlylkedf ~wyd} gkdl` eg w~gy
~gfmlyl ~gfmlyl }dml& @d`w Sl`lj ‐Nokso~g‛, d}dw kgfhlylk gkdl` d`dkd} w~gy `dlf *mgfhdf nd}d}df kg`dewedf sgfdkidjdf w~gy ~gsgy}l ndyd mld}d~ mgfhdf sgylf}dj ‐ obdfl1v.dmmw~gy obdfl1v.dmmw~gy fdkdw~gy‛,&
Kgfw`l~ ~wyd} |dfh dedf mlelylk& Egkwmldf sl`lj ‐^gfm‛ &
Egkwmldf Njgne jd`dkdf lfioz gkdl`& Aled igyjd~l` kded gkdl` |dfh }g`dj ml}w`l~ }dml dedf kwfnw` eg md`dk lfioz gkdl`kw&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
79
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
]lmde swd~ aled gkdl` jdf|d ml`dewedf sgfhgngedf kg`d`wl ~gyrgy kdyl el}d njgne gkdl`
kg`d`wl n`lgf}& Mgfhdf ndyd kd~we eg jd`dkdf Xgi Iyox~gy kw mdf kd~weedf d`dkd} gkdl` ~dkd ~gsgy}l }dml& Kded dedf kwfnw` ~gsgy}l jd`dkdf mlidxdj lfl&
Nd}d}df 1 W~gy |dfh mliwd} ~gig`wk sgkiwd}df Kdl`mly sdmd mlygn}oy| /g}n/~eg` kded w~gy }gy~giw} }lmde dedf il~d mlhwfdedf wf}we `ohlf eg kdl` ~gyrgy edygfd w~gy }gy~giw} ml myos o`gj lkds ~gyrgy& Adml dsdil`d dfmd lfhlf kgfnoid kdl` ~gyrgy kded dfmd jdyw~ kgkiwd} w~gy idyw }gy`gilj mdjw`w&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
7>
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
LF^]D@D^L SYOZ\ ^GYRGY Mgfhdf dmdf|d Syoz| jde de~g~ lf}gyfg} w~gy sdmd n`lgf} l}w md sd} mlid}d~l& Ighl}w sw`d aled w~gy dedf kgkiwed ~giwdj d`dkd} xgi~l}g& Aled syoz| }g`dj }gylf~}d`` ml md`dk eoksw}gy ~gyrgy kded ~gyrgy awhd mdsd} kgkid}d~l kdwswf kgfhd}wy kgfhd}wy ~|~}gk adylfhdf sdmd ~g}lds n`lgf}& Mgfhdf ndyd kgki`oely igigydsd ~l}w~ xgi~l}g |dfh }g`dj ml~g}}lfh sdmd nofblhwyd~l syoz| lfl&
Sdeg} |dfh mlw}wjedf wf}we sgfhlf~}d`dff|d sgfhlf~}d`dff|d dmd`dj ^twlm &
Kgf|g}os `d|dfdf ~twlm |dfh } g`dj }gylf~}d``&
Kgfhgml} nofblhwyd~l bl`g /g}n/~twlm/~twlm&nofb * bl`g ~twlm&nofb lfl kgywsdedf
nofblhwyd~l sd`lfh w}dkd md`dk syo~g~ lf~}d`d~l syoz| ~gyrgy ,& Wf}we kgksgykwmdj syo~g~ sgfndyldf ~giwdj ed}d md`dk ~wd}w bl`g sdmd nofblhwyd~l syoz| el}d hwfdedf sgylf}dj
fdfo /g}n/~twlm&nofb
Eg}ledf }okio` B2 wf}we kgksgykwmdj syo~g~ sgfndyldf ed}d md`dk ~giwdj bl`g&
Kd~weedf ed}d ewfnl ‐dw}j_sdydk fgho}ld}g
eggs_d`lrg of ‛ egkwmldf }gedf GF]GY
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
7=
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3 Gml} ~nyls} mdf Mlidxdj . ]DH1 dw}j_sdydk jdsw~ }dfmd }dfmd
mdf sdmd idyl~
@LFWZ
ml mgsdf ~nyls}~ ml idxdj lfl
}dkidjedf
/ dw}j_sdydk dw}j_sdydk dw}j_sdydk dw}j_sdydk dw}j_sdydk
id~ln id~ln id~ln id~ln id~ln
syohydk /w~y/`li/~twlm/fn~d_dw}j /w~y/g}n/sd~~xm njl`mygf 7 ygd`k ~twlm syoz|+ndnjlfh xgi ~gyrgy ]dfmd . mlmgsdff|d mljdsw~ nygmgf}ld`~}}` 9 jowy~ mdf ml}dkidjedf ~nyls}~ nd~g~gf}l}lrg obb
sdmd dw}j_sdydk id~ln syohydk
^g}g`dj }gygml} ~nyls} dedf kwfnw` ~sgy}l hdkidy mlidxdj lfl&
Dw}j_sdydk mlhwfdedf wf}we kgkbl`}gy w~gy |dfh dedf kgfhde~g~ xgi~l}g & Bl`}gyf|d igywsd `ohlf kgfhhwfdedf w~gy mdf sd~~xoym |dfh ~wmdj ml}gf}wedf o`gj syoz|& W~gy |dfh }lmde }gymdb}dy md`dk syoz| }lmde il~d mlhwfdedf wf}we kgfhde~g~ xgi~l}g&
Eg}ledf }okio` B2 egkid`l hwfd kgksgykwmdj syo~g~ sgfndyldf ed}d md`dk ~giwdj
bl`g&
Kd~weedf ed}d ewfnl ‐ dn`
NOFFGN]‛ egkwmldf }gedf GF]GY
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
77
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Egkwmldf Gml} ~nyls} Mlidxdj . ]DH1 dn` }gsd}f|d mlidxdj dn` NOFFGN] kg}jom
NOFFGN] }dkidjedf ~nyls}~ ml idxdj lfl 1
dn` wy` m~}mokdlf )/g}n/~twlm/wy`) dn` eg| wy`_yghgz +l )/g}n/~twlm/eg|) dn` gz m~}mokdlf )/g}n/~twlm/gz) )/g}n/~twlm/gz) dn` fn~d_w~gy~ syoz|_dw}j YGTWLYGM fo_ndnjg fo_ndnjg mgf| wy` fo_ndnjg fo_ndnjg mgf| eg| j}}s_dnng~~ j}}s_dnng~~ mgf| wy ` j}}s_dnng~~ mgf| eg| j}}s_dnng~~ d``ox fn~d_w~gy~ j}}s_dnng~~ d``ox gz
^g}g`dj }gygml} ~nyls} dedf }gy`ljd} ~sgy}l hdkidy mlidxdj lfl ]dkidjedf ~nyls}~ mld}d~ mlidxdj idyl~ dn` NOFFGN] kg}jom NOFFGN]& Idyl~+idyl~ lfl igybwfh~l wf}we bl`}gylfh
~g}lds d`dkd} xgi |dfh mliwed o`gj n`lgf}&
Bwfh~l mdf eghwfddf nofblhwyd~l ~nyls} mld}d~ 1
dn` wy` m~}mokdlf igybwfh~l wf}we kgfhgi`oe d`dkd} ~l}w~ }gy}gf}w |dfh }g`dj ml}gf}wedf& D`dkd}+d`dkd} l}w ml ~lksdf md`dk bl`g wy` sdmd mlygn}oy| /g}n/~twlm&
dn` eg| wy`_yghgz „l igybwfh~l wf}we kgfhgi`oe ed}d+ed}d }gy}gf}w |dfh ~wmdj ml}gf}wedf& Ed}d+ed}d l}w ml~lksdf md`dk bl`g eg| sdmd mlygn}oy| /g}n/~twlm&
dn` gz m~}mokdlf igybwfh~l wf}we kkgkiwed ed}d+ed}d }gy}gf}w |dfh }g`dj }gyi`oe o`gj dn` eg|& Ed}d+ed}d l}w }lmde swf|d kde~wm sdmd dn` eg|& Ed}d+ed}d l}w ml~lksdf md`dk bl`g gz sdmd mlygn}oy| /g}n/~twlm&
dn` fn~d_w~gy~ igybwfh~l wf}we kgkbl`}gy n`lgf} |dfh |d fh lfhlf kgfhde~g~ xgi kg`d`wl syoz| lfl& Bl`}gy l}w igywsd `ohlf mgfhdf mgfhdf w~gy mdf sd~~xoym sd~~xoym |dfh ~wmdj ml}gf}wedf syoz|& W~gy |dfh }lmde }gymdb}dy }lmde il~d kgfhde~g~ xgi&
fo_ndnjg mgf| wy` mdf fo_ndnjg mgf| eg| igybwfh~l dhdy d`dkd} xgi |dfh ml i`oe }lmde ml~lksdf md`dk mlygn}oy| sgf|lksdfdf syoz|&
j}}s_dnng~~ kgywsdedf sgfhd}wy mdyl dn`+dn` mld}d~f|d& Aled mligyl mgf| kded ad`wy de~g~ dedf ml}w}ws ~gmdfhedf aled mligyl d``ox kded ad`wy de~g~ mliwed mdf w~gy il~d kgfhwfawfhl xgi~l}g l}w&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
72
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Eg}ledf }okio` B2 egkid`l hwfd kgksgykwmdj syo~g~ sgfndyldf ed}d md`dk ~giwdj bl`g&
Kd~weedf ed}d ewfnl ‐LF^GY]‛ egkwmldf }gedf
GF]GY
Mlidxdj . LF^GY] \OWY OXF YW@G*^, JGYG ]O D@@OX DNNG^^ BYOK
\OWY
N@LGF]^ }gsd}f|d mlidxdj ~nyls} igy}w`l~edf j}}s_dnng~~ d``ox `ond`jo~} }dkidjedf 9 ~nyls}~ }gyd}d~ mdf igyl }dfmd . mlmgsdf ~nyls}~ j}}s_dnng~~ mgf| d``& dn` owy_fg}xoye~ ~yn 4<9&42:&4&3/9= j}}s_dnng~~ d``ox owy_fg}xoye~
^g}g`dj }gygml} ~nyls} dedf kwfnw` ~sgy}l hdkidy mlidxdj lfl
]dkidjedf 9 ~nyls}~ mld}d~ }gyd}d~ mdf igyl }dfmd . mlmgsdf ~nyls}~ j}}s_dnng~~
mgf|
^g`dfaw}f|d }okio` B2 egkid`l hwfd kgksgykwmdj syo~g~ sgfndyldf ed}d md`dk
~giwdj bl`g&
Kd~weedf ed}d ewfnl ‐j}}s_soy}
>49: ‛
egkwmldf }gedf GF]GY
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
78
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Mlidxdj . ]DH1 j}}s_soy} jdsw~ }dfmd . sdmd ~nyls}~ j}}s_soy} >49: mdf
}dkidjedf }ydf~sdygf} mlig`dedfhf|d
. ^twlm foykd``| `l~}gf~ }o soy} >49: j}}s_soy} >49: }ydf~sdygf} Jdsw~ }dfmd . mlmgsdf ~nyls}~ j}}s_soy} >49: mdf ]dkidjedf }ydf~sdygf} mlig`dedfhf|d&
>49: dmd`dj soy} mgbdw`} syoz|& ]ydf~sdygf} dmd`dj ~g}}lfh syoz| mgfhdf komg }ydf~sdydf *dw}o mg}gn}, mdf wf}we fokoy ls syoz| l}w }gyhdf}wfh dmklf ~gyrgy kgkigyledf sgfhd}wydf fokoy soy} wf}we syoz| egsdmd ~g}lds n`lgf} |dfh dmd md`dk ~giwdj adylfhdf& Eg}ledf }okio` B2 egkid`l hwfd kgksgykwmdj syo~g~ sgfndyldf ed}d md`dk ~giwdj
bl`g&
Kd~weedf ed}d ewfnl ‐ndnjg_kgk
:‛
egkwmldf }gedf GF]GY
Mlidxdj . ]DH 1 ndnjg_kgk jdsw~ }dfmd . sdmd ~nyls}~ ndnjg_kgk mdf widj :
KI kgfadml ° mdyl edsd~l}d~ kgkoy| bl~le *YDK, |dfh mlhwfdedf& Kl~d` >9 KI dmd`dj ° mdyl 49: KI&.Mgbdw`} 1 ndnjg_kgk >9 KI
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
7:
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Eg}ledf }okio` B2 egkid`l hwfd kgksgykwmdj syo~g~ sgfndyldf ed}d md`dk ~giwdj
bl`g&
Kd~weedf ed}d ewfnl ‐ndnjg_mly
wb~
/rdy/~soo`/‛ egkwmldf }gedf GF]GY
Mlidxdj .]DH 1 ndnjg_mly gml} ndnjg_mly wb~ kgfadml 4333 |dfh fdf}lf|d
mlhwfdedf wf}we kgf|lksdf jgdmgy j gdmgy mdyl ~l}w~+~l}w~ |dfh mlde~g~ n`lgf}& Edsd~l}d~ 4333 ~g~wdledf mgfhdf jdymml~e |dfh dmd&
.Mgbdw`}1 ndnjg_mly wb~ /rdy/~soo`/~twlm 4333 42 972 4333 kgywsdedf edsd~l}d~ |dfh mlhwfdedf wf}we kgf|lksdf jgdmgy mdyl xgi |dfh mlde~g~ o`gj n`lgf}& Eg}ledf }okio` B2 egkid`l hwfd kgksgykwmdj syo~g~ sgfndyldf ed}d md`dk ~giwdj
bl`g&
Kd~weedf ed}d ewfnl ‐ndnjg_~xds_`ox
<3‛
egkwmldf }gedf GF]GY
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
7<
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Mlidxdj .]DH1 ndnjg_~xds_`ox *sgyngf} 3+433, mdf .]DH1
ndnjg_~xds_jlhj *sgyngf} 3+433, mljdsw~ }dfmd . mlmgsdf ~nyls}~ ndnjg_~xds_`ox <3 mdf ndnjg_~xds_jlhj <7 & .Mgbdw`}1 Ndnjg_~xds_`ox <3 ndnjg_~xds_jlhj <7 Jdsw~ }dfmd . mlmgsdf 9 ~nyls}~ |dl}w ndnjg_~xds_`ox mdf ndnjg_~xds_jlhj
Eg}ledf }okio` B2 egkid`l hwfd kgksgykwmdj syo~g~ sgfndyldf ed}d md`dk ~giwdj
bl`g&
Kd~weedf ed}d ewfnl ‐ndnjg_`oh ‛
egkwmldf
}gedf GF]GY
Mlidxdj .]DH1 ndnjg_`oh jdsw~ }dfmd . mlmgsdf ~nyls}~ ndnjg_`oh&
.Mgbdw`} 1 ndnjg_`oh /rdy/`oh/~twlm/ndnjg&`oh Jdsw~ }dfmd . mlmgsdf ~nyls}~ ndnjg_`oh Mlidxdj .]DH1 ndnjg_~}oyg_`oh jdsw~ }dfmd . mlmgsdf ~nyls}~
ndnjg_~}oyg_`oh& .Mgbdw`} 1 ndnjg_~}oyg_`oh
/rdy/`oh/~twlm/~}oyg&`oh Jdsw~ }dfmd . mlmgsdf ~nyls}~ ndnjg_~}oyg_`oh& ^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
23
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Eg}ledf }okio` B2 egkid`l hwfd kgksgykwmdj syo~g~ sgfndyldf ed}d md`dk ~giwdj
bl`g&
Kd~weedf ed}d ewfnl ‐mf~_fdkg~gyrgy~ ‛
egkwmldf }gedf GF]GY
Mlidxdj .]DH1 mf~_fdkg~gyrgy~ }dkidjedf ~nyls}~ mf~_fgk~gyrgy~
4<9&42:&4&>3 mlidxdj ~nyls} . fofg&Mdf 4<9&42:&4&>3 fokoy ls ~gyrgy |dfh dedf mlhwfdedf ~gidhdl LS Syoz| sdmd n`lgf}&
.Mgbdw`} 1 . fofg mf~_fdkg~gyrgy~ 4<9&42:&4&>3
Eg}ledf }okio` B2 egkid`l hwfd kgksgykwmdj syo~g~ sgfndyldf ed}d md`dk ~giwdj
bl`g&
Kd~weedf ed}d ewfnl ‐lsndnjg‛
egkwmldf
}gedf GF]GY
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
24
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Mlidxdj .]DH 1 lsndnjg_~lqg *fwkigy ob gf}ylg~, jdsw~ }dfmd . mlmgsdf ~nyls}~
lsndnjg_~lqg lsndnjg_`ox mdf lsndnjg_jlhj & .Mgbdw`} 1
lsndnjg_~lqg 439= lsndnjg_`ox <3 lsndnjg_jlhj <7
Kgf|lksdf ~gkwd nofblhwyd~l syoz| mgfhdf kgfgedf }okio` ‐B9‛ egkwmldf sl`lj
‐\‛wf}we ‐\‛wf}we kgf|lksdf nofblhwyd~l `d`w GF]GY &
Kgkiwd} bl`g idyw wf}we kgkd~weedf ~l}w~ |dfh dedf ml i`one &
Obdfl1v. rlk
/g}n/~twlm/wy`
xxx&bdngiooe&nok xxx&hooh`g&nok xxx&bylgfm~}gy&nok Kgkiwd} bl`g idyw wf}we ed}d+ed}d |dfh dedf ml i`one&
zzz ~gz soyf bdngiooe ^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
29
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgkiwd} bl`g idyw wf}we kgkd~weedf ed}d+ed}d sgfhgnwd`ldf |dfh dedf }gyi`one&
k~gzg` r~gzg`
Kgkiwd} mlygn}oy| g}n sdmd mlygn}oy| /w~y/g}n/ wf}we kgf|lksdf mdb}dy `l~} w~gy ~gyrgy&
Kgkiwd} w~gy ejw~w~ |dfh mlhwfdedf wf}we kgfhde~g~ xgi iyox~gy &
FI 1 dsdil`d syoz| lfhlf mdsd} ml de~g~ ~g`wywj n`lgf} }dfsd kgfhhwfdedf sd~~xoym kded `dfhedj lfl `gxd}l ~dad& Kgkiwd} ~xds ~gy}d kg`ljd} jd~l` nofblhwyd~l syoz| |d fh }g`dj }gy~g}}lfh mgfhdf igfdy
d}dw }lmde& Aled igyjd~l` kded dedf kwfnw` ~gsgy}l hdkdidy mlidxdj lfl 1
Kgfad`dfedf `d|dfdf ~twlm&
Kgyg~}dy} `d|dfdf ~twlm&
Kgfhdydjedf soy} mdyl soy} :3 eg soy} syoz| |dfh }g`dj el}d ~g}}lfhdf }dml |dl}w >49:
kg`d`wl ls}di`g~&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
2>
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgf|lksdf nofblhwyd~l ls}di`g~ sdmd bl`g /g}n/ls}di`g~ dhdy ls}di`g~ mdsd}
}gyge~gew~l ~g}g`dj noksw}gy kd}l d}dw d}dw mlyg~}dy}&
Kgfdkidjedf ~nyls}~ sdmd bl`g /g}n/fg}xoye/lf}gybdng~& Dsdil`d }g`dj kg`dewedf
lf~}d`d~l yow}gy sdmd nofblhwyd~l igylew}f|d kd~weedf ~nyls} }gy~giw} sdmd idyl~ sd`lfh idxdj awhd&
eg}leedf sgylf}dj mlidxdj ~nyls}~ }gyidxdj ‐syg+ws ls}di`g~+
yg~}oyg 0 /g}n/ls}di`g~‛
Kgyg~}dy} `d|dfdf ~twlm&
Kgygbyg~j `d|dfdf ~twlm |dfh ~wmdj mleofblhwyd~l &
Kgyg~}dy} `d|dfdf fg}xoye&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
2=
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kg`ljd} nofblhwyd~l syoz| kg`d`wl n`lgf} mgfhdf ~g}}lfhdf LS 1 4<9&42:&4&>3 mdf SOY] 1
>49:
Mld}d~ dmd`dj kgywsdedf ~g}}lfhdf syoz| ~gndyd kdfwd` dfmd awhd mdsd} kg`dewedf ~g}}lfhdf syoz| sdmd n`lgf} kgfadml ‐ Dw}o+mg}gn} syoz| ~g}}lfh~ boy }jl~ fg}xoye‛ fg}xoye‛& sd~~xoym |dfh }g`dj mliwd} ~gig`wk|d& Kgkd~wedf fdkd w~gy wf}we syoz| mdf awhd sd~~xoym
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
27
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kdyl el}d njgne igigydsd d`dkd} xgi~l}g |dfh }g`dj el}d i`one kg`d`wl n`lgf} }dml
~gidhdl nof}oj kgkiwed d`dkd} xxx&bdngiooe&nok &
Wf}we kg`dewedf nofblhwyd~l syoz| kgkdfh mliw}wjedf eg}g`l}ldf mdf awhd egag`ldf mlmd`dk kg`dewedf sgfhgml}df ~nyls}& ^d`dj ~d}wf|d dmd`dj md`dk kg`dewedf sgfhgml}df bl`g ‐~twlm&nofb ‐ ~twlm&nofb ‛, ‛, mgfhdf sgylf}dj ‐fdfo ‐fdfo‛‛ wf}we kgkiwed ~giwdj bl`g |dfh kgkl`lel bl}wy+bl}wy }gy~gfmlyl&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
22
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
LF^]D@D^L YOW]GY ^GYRGY ^GYRGY Yow}gy mdsd} mlsdjdkl ~gidhdl sljde eg}lhd |dfh igymlyl mldf}dyd egmwd sljde |dfh ~d`lfh igyjwiwfhdf mdf igybwfh~l ~gidhdl sgydf}dyd ~gmgkleldf jlfhhd sljde sgy}dkd mdf egmwd }lmde ~gndyd `dfh~wfh igyjwiwfhdf dedf }g}dsl egmwdf|d igyjwiwfhdf mgfhdf sgydf}dyd& Wf}we kg`dewedf lf~}d`d~l yow}gy mliw}wjedf 9 edy}w @df Ndym |dfh kgfadml sgydf}dyd df}dyd n`lgf} mdf awhd yow}gy sw~d} mlkdfd edy}w `df sgy}dkd |dw}l G}j3 kgywsdedf @df ndym sgy}dkd |dfh dedf }gy~dkiwfh egmd`dk yow}gy sw~d} ~gmdfhedf G}j4 kgywsdedf @df Ndym egmwd |dfh kgfhjwiwfhedf ^gyrgy eg n`lgf}& Kded mdyl l}w ~gig`wk kg`dewedf lf~}d`d~l yow}gy el}d jdyw~ kgf|ldsedf 9 @df Ndym sdmd Sn ^gyrgy d}dw awhd ild~ kg`dewedf nofblhwyd~l d`ld~ wf}we LS egmwd mdyl ~gyrgy |dl}w g}j4& ]w}oyld` mlidxdj lfl el}d dedf kgkiwd} nofblhwyd~l Sn Yow}gy mdfhdf Kgfhhwfdedf 9 edy}w @df Ndym |dfh }g`dj }gysd~dfh ~gndyd Ofiodym d}dwswf @df Ndym ~gndyd ge~}gyfd`& Kgfhd}wy LS dmmyg~~ sdmd @df Ndym eg 9 |dfh dedf mlnofblhwyd~l ~gidhdl G}j4&Mgfhdf
kgfhgml} nofblhwyd~l bl`g /g}n/fg}xoye/lf}gybdng~ &
^gidhdl nof}oj wf}we sgkd~dfhdf LS @df Ndym eg 9 *G}j4, ~d|d kgfhhwfdedf LS 1 4<9&42:&7&> Kd~weedf ^nyls}~ mlidxdj lfl sdmd idhldf idyl~ }gydejly&
dw}o g}j4 lbdng g}j4 lfg} ~}d}ln dmmyg~~ 4<9&42:&7&> fg}kd~e 977&977&977&3 fg}xoye 4<9&42:&7&3 iyodmnd~} 4<9&42:&7&977
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
28
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgkigyl}djwedf ad`df hd}gxd| sdmd n`lgf} wf}we kgfhde~g~ lf}gyfg}&
Kgfhde}lbedf ls_boyxdym sdmd mlygn}oy| /syon/~|~/fg}/lsr=/ls_boyxdym
Kg+FD]+edf LS Dmmyg~~ Sylrd} dhdy il~d kgfhde~g~ lf}gyfg} &
Kgfad`df sgylf}dj ~nyls} sdmd Ls Boyxdym mlmd`dk bl`g ‐ ~|~n}`&nofb‛ &
Kgfhjdsw~ }dfmd sdhdy sdmd ~nyls} ‐fg}&lsr=&ls_boyxdym;4 fg}&lsr=&ls_boyxdym;4‛‛
Kgf|lksdf ls}di`g~ sdmd bl`g /g}n/ls}di`g~ dhdy ls}di`g~ mdsd} }gyge~gew~l ~g}g`dj noksw}gy kd}l d}dw mlyg~}dy}&
Kgfdkidjedf ~nyls}~ sdmd bl`g /g}n/fg}xoye/lf}gybdng~
Eg}leedf ~nyls}~ mlidxdj lfl sdmd idyl~ }gyidxdj&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
2:
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
FI 1 Dsdil`d ~wmdj dmd }lmde s gy`w ml}w`l~ w`dfh ~nyls}~ mld}d~ *dsdil`d dfmd ~wmdj kgfheofblhwyd~l syoz|,&
Kgyg~}dy} `d|dfdf fg}xoye
Nd}d}df 1 Dsdil`d dfmd kgkidfhwf ~giwdj yow}gy kded g}j3 kgywsdedf adylfhdf |dfh eg`wdy *eg lf}gyfg}, ~gmdfhedf g}j4 kgywsdedf adylfhdf |dfh eg md`dk *eg n`lgf},& Adml sdmd eofblhwyd~l mjns ~gyrgy ~gkwd LS eg n`lgf} ~gsgy}l ~wifg}f|d kgfhhwfdedf ~wifg} g}j4 fg}kd~ef|d kgfhhwfdedf fg}kd~e g}j4 ydfhg lsf|d mlmd`dk ydfhg LS Dmmyg~~ g}j4 os}lof yow}gy~ dmd`dj kgfhhwfdedf LS Dmmyg~~ g}j4& ~gmdfhedf wf}we os}lof mokdlf+ fdkg+~gyrgy~f|d kgfhhwfdedf LS Dmmyg~~ g}j3&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
2<
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
^DKID ^GYRGY Dhdy SN mdsd} ~d`lfh kgfhlylkedf bl`g kdwswf kg`dewedf sylf}gy ~jdylfh df}dy n`lgf} kdwswf ~gyrgy& Sdeg} ~dkid kgywsdedf ~wd}w sdeg} mlkdfd 9 ~|~}gk osgyd~l |dfh igyigmd mdsd} kg`dewedf bl`g ^jdylfh md`dk ~giwdj adylfhdf& ]dfsd jdyw~ kgfhhwfdedf ~|~}gk osgyd~l |dfh ~dkd mdf jdyw~ kgf|g~wdledf mgfhdf ~|~}gk osgyd~l sdmd n`lgf}&
Kgfhlf~}d`` sdeg} |dfh mliw}wjedf |dl}w ~dkid ~kib~ ~kin`lgf}
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
83
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
M JNS }gyhdf}wfh Sl`lj 0\g~6 d}dw 0Fo6 sdmd komlb| ~ki&nofb }o w~g XLF^ ~g}}lfh byok MJNS egiw}wjdf sgfhhwfd&
Kgkiwd} eofblhwyd~l ~dkid sdmd bl`g XOYEHYOWS sdmd ^DKID jdyw~ ~dkd mgfhdf N`lgf}
Jdsw~ }dfmd . ml mgsdf ~nyls} ~gnwyl}|
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
84
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
]dkidjedf ~nyls} sdmd idyl~ }gyidxdj&
U~jdyg[ sd}j ; /~jdyg rd`lm w~gy~ ; dmklf, hwg~} ygdm `l~} ; dmklf, hwg~} xyl}g `l~} ; dmklf, hwg~} ygdm of`| ; fo dmklf w~gy~ ; dmklf
nofblhwyd~l mdyl bl`g ‐~ki&nofb‛& Egkwmldf kgkiwd} bo`mgy |dfh mlhwfdedf ~gidhdl ^drg nofblhwyd~l bo`mgy ~jdylfh& ^g~wdl mgfhdf fdkd bo`mgy sdmd eofblhwyd~l mld}d~
sd}j ; /~jdyg &
Kgkigyledf de~g~ bo`mgy /~jdyg dhdy w~gy mdsd} kgkiwed mdf kgfhde~g~ bo`mgy }gy~giw}&
Kgkiwd} w~gy |dfh dedf kgfhhwfd edf bo`mgy ~jdylfh mdyl ~gyrgy ~g~wdl mgfhdf fd kd w~gy |dfh }g`dj }gynofblhwyd~l mld}d~ |dl}w sdmd bl`g ‐~ki&nofb‛&
Kgyg~}dy} `d|dfdf ~dkid&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
89
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
Kgkidnd mdf kg`ljd} mdb}dy d}dw fdkd bo`mgy |dfh }g`dj ml~jdyg sdmd ~|~}gk `lfwz &
Sgylf}dj wf}we kgkd~weedf yoo}“~ sd~~xoym
}gedf GF]GY ~dad *
]dfsd Sd~~xoym ,&
Kg+kowf} bo`mgy |dfh dedf mlhwfdedf wf}we ~jdyg komg dw}jgf}lnd}lof
Kg`dewedf sgfhgngedf ^dkid ^gyrgy kg`d`wl n`lgf}& Mgfhdf ndyd kd~we eg YWF d}dw }gedf Xlfmox~%Y & ]w`l~edf 1 PPLs^gyrgy & PP4<9&42:&4&>3
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
8>
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
@ohlf }gy`gilj mdjw`w mgfhdf kgkd~weedf W~gy mdf Sd~~xoym |dfh }g`dj el}d iwd}
}dml&
Igylew} }dksl`df ~g}g`dj el}d kg`dewedf syo~g~ `ohlf&
Egkwmldf kd~we egmd`dk bo`mgy ‐/~jdyg‛ mdf noid nos| sd~}gedf igigydsd bl`g d}dw
md}d egmd`dk bo`mgy }gygiw} ~gy}d kgkiwd} bo`mgy mlmd`dk ~dfd& Aled igyjd~l` kded sdeg} ~dkid }g`dj mllf~}d`d~l mgfhdf idle&
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
8=
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
LF^]D@D^ LF^]D@D^LL ^^J ^^J Dhdy ~goydfh dmklf mdsd} kgygko}g ~wd}w md}d d}dwswf ds`led~l+ds`led~l ~gyrgy kg`d`wl N`lgf} kgfhhwfdedf ds`led~l ~gsgy}l Xlf^NS d}dwswf Sw}}|& ^^J |dfh dmd`dj ~giwdj ds`led~l |dfh jdyw~ mllf~}d`` sdmd ~gyrgy&
Kgfhlf~}d`` sdeg} |dfh mliw}wjedf |dl}w ~~j
Kgfofde}lbedf w~gy yoo} mgkl egkdfdf ~gyrgy &
Soy} 99
soy} mgbdw`} ~~j |dfh mlhwfdedf& Soy} il~d mlhdf}l eg fokoy |dfh eo~ofh dhdy `gilj dkdf `dhl&
Sgykl}Yoo}@ohlf fo
kgfhgi`one w~gy yoo} W~gy yoo} ml i`oe sdmd de~g~ ygko}g dhdy }gyadhd egdkdfdff|d mdf }lmde ml~d`djhwfdedf&
Kgyg~}dy} `d|dfdf ~~j
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
87
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
NOKKDFM SDMD @LFWZ d, rlk
1 Mlhwfdedf wf}we kgkiwed bl`g&
i, Fdfo
1 Mlhwfdedf wf}we kgkiwed d}dw kgkiwd} bl`g&
n, 1xt
1 Wf}we eg`wdy mdf kgf|lksdf eofblhwyd~l
m, 1t$
1 Wf}we eg`wdy }dfsd kgf|lksdf eofblhwyd~l
g, N}y`%O
d}dw B9
1 Kgf|lksdf eofblhwyd~l fdfo
b, N}y`%Z
1 Wf}we eg`wdy mdyl eofblhwyd~l fdfo
h, Yk
1 Kgfhjdsw~ bl`g
j, Ykmly
1 Kgfhjdsw~ mlyge}oyl
l,
Kemly
1 Kgkiwd} mlyge}oyl
a,
Nm
1 Kgfhde~g~ / eg`wdy mdyl mlyge}oyl
e, F~`ooews
1 Kgfhg}g~ eofblhwyd~l MF^ ^gyrgy
`,
1 Kgfhg}g~ eofge~l mdyl LS
Slfh
k, @lfe~
1 Kgkiwed d`dkd} `lfe~ mdyl Xgi ^gyrgy
f, @~
1 Kgfdksl`edf l~l mlyge}oyl
o, Ygioo}
1 Kgyg~}dy} ~|~}gk
s, Jd`}
1 Kgkd}ledf ~|~}gk
t, Kr
1 Kgfhhdf}l fdkd bl`g / mlyge}oyl
y, Njkom
1 Kgfdkidj mdf kgfhwydfhl lqlf sgkdedl wf}we kgfhde~g~
bl`g / mlyge}oyl ~, Kowf}
1 Kg+kowf} bl`g ~|~}gk eg ~wd}w bl`g / mlyge}oyl
}, @lfwz+lfl}
1 Kgfad`dfedf `lfwz ~gyrgy
w, Yow}g dmm mgbdw`} hx
1 Wf}we kgfdkidjedf ls yow}gy
r, Yow}g mg` mgbdw`} hx
1 Wf}we kgfhjdsw~ ls yow}gy |dfh mldfhhds sgy`w
x, Ds}+hg} lf~}d``
1 Wf}we kgfhl~}d`` ds`led~l
z, Ds}+hg} wsmd}g
1 Wf}we kgfhwsmd}g ds`led~l
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
82
KOMW@ MGILDF 7&3
@LFWZ
^KE F 4 KDHG@DFH p Nygd}g \owy ]l}`g @lfwz Kd~}gy Jgyg
88