© COMPILED BY KC
II-MANRESA 2016 TC) E'cl%)i+e $%ri)7ictio# ,Sec- 2 ,2* of PD 125* $;ISDICTION O?E T
SC A7.i#i)tr"ti+e Circ%l"r 6&5@&A No. 1F+ 1F 1* a%astal o lan% egistation cases 3le% &e,oe t$e eectiity o, t$is A.. s$all &e tans,ee% &y t$e E5ecutie ?u%ge o, t$e R# $aing uis%iction oe t$e cases to E.?. o, t$e a((o(iate outs o, li4ite% uis%iction ,o t$e e8uie% aXe a4ong t$e &anc$es o, t$e cout un%e $is a%4inistatie su(eision 2* But t$ose alea%y co44ence% as o, t$e %ate o, eectiity s$all e4ain '9 sai% couts+ e5ce(t '$en t$e (aties agee ot$e'ise ;DOL LIET
. >ENDE
ISS;E May t$e tial cout motu proprio %is4iss a co4(laint on t$e goun% o, i4(o(e enueQ N<. ;LIN3 : $ile t$e goun% inoke% &y t$e tial cout in %is4issing t$e (etition &elo' 'as clealy t$at o, i4(o(e enue+ t$e Solicito Heneal con,uses enue 'it$ uis%iction. A %istinction &et'een t$e t'o 4ust &e %a'n.
?EN;E O AN ACTI as 35e% &y statute 4ay &e c consent o, t$e (aties+ an% a i4(o(e enue 4ay &e 'aie o, t$e %e,en%ant to aise it at t$ In suc$ an eent+ t$e cout 4a ali% u%g4ent Poce%ual *4ay &e 'aie% conenience to t$e (aties at$ t$ei access to t$e couts as it (lace o, tial.
%le of t9e e+i)e7 %le) a. laying o, enue i s (ro t$an su&stantie. &. It elates to t$e uis%icti oe t$e (er)o# at$e t 4atte. c. Poisions elating to e elation :etee# t9e (l 7efe#7"#t an% not &et an% t$e su&ect 4atte. %. >enu e elates t o tri"l not touc$es 4oe o, t$e co#+ (aties at$e t$an t$e s case. In 3acoycoy v! 0AC+ t$is out ule%7 proprio %is4issal o, (etitioneCs co4(laint &y #$e motu es(on%ent tial cout on t$e goun% o, i4(o(e enue is (lain eo+ o&iously atti&uta&le to its ina&ility to %istinguis$ &et'een uis%iction an% enue.
?EN;E IN INEIO CO;TS AS =ELL AS IN TPESSLY O IMPLIEDLY )is4issing t$e co4(laint on t$e goun% o, i4(o(e enue is cetainly not t$e a((o(iate couse o, action at t$is stage o, t$e (ocee%ings+ (aticulaly as enue+ in in,eio couts as 'ell as in t$e couts o, 3st instance *no' R#+ 4ay &e 'aie% e5(essly o i4(lie%ly. J$ee t$e %e,en%ant ,ails to c$allenge ti4ely t$e enue in a 4otion to %is4iss as (oi%e% &y Section o, Rule o, t$e Rules o, out+ an% allo's t$e tial to &e $el% an% a %ecision to &e en%ee%+ $e cannot on a((eal o in a s(ecial action &e (e4itte% to &elate%ly c$allenge t$e 'ong enue+ '$ic$ is %ee4e% 'aie%. T
PETITIONE COECTLY IN?OKED T
10