Gonzales v Climax Mining DIGEST

G.R. No. 161957

January 22, 2007

 JORGE GONZALES and PANEL PANEL OF ARBIRA ARBIRAORS !". #LI$A% $INING L&., #LI$A%'ARI$#O $INING #ORP., and A(SRALASIAN P)ILIPPINES $INING IN#. *''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' * G.R. No. 16799+

January 22, 2007

 JORGE GONZALES !". )ON. OS#AR B. PI$ENEL, n -" a/ay a" PRESI&ING J(&GE o BR. 1+ o -3 REGIONAL RIAL #O(R o $A4AI #I, and #LI$A%'ARI$#O $INING #ORPORAION

FA#S  -3 a"3 " a on"odaon on"odaon o o /3on" roo3d n -3 "a83 d"/u3d Add3ndu8 Add3ndu8 #onra 3n3r3d no y -3 /ar3". In GR No. 161957, -3 #our -ad -3d -a -3 &ENR Pan3 o Arraor" -ad no :ur"don o!3r -3 o8/an or -3 annu83n o -3 Add3ndu8 #onra on ;round" o raud and !oaon o -3 #on"uon and -a -3 aon "-oud -a!3 33n rou;- 3or3 -3 r3;uar our" a"  n!o!3d :uda ""u3". Bo- /ar3" <3d "3/ara3 8oon" or r3on"d3raon. Gon=a3" a!3rr3d -a -3 &ENR Pan3 o Arraor" -a" :ur"don 3au"3 -3 a"3 n!o!3" a 8nn; d"/u3 -a /ro/3ry a" -n -3 a8 o -3 Pan3>" au-ory. On -3 o-3r -and, -and, #8a* #8a* $nn; $nn; Ld., 3 a., n; n; A83ran A83ran :ur"/rud3 :ur"/rud3n3 n3 and -3 (N#IR (N#IRAL AL $od3 La, ar;u3d -a -3 arraon au"3 n -3 Add3ndu8 #onra "-oud 3 r3a3d a" an a;r3383n nd3/3nd3n o -3 o-3r 3r8" o -3 onra, and -a a a83d r3"""on r3"""on o -3 8an onra do3" no a!od -3 duy o arra3. In GR No. 16799+, Gon=a3" -a3n;3d -3 ord3r o -3 R# r3?urn; -8 o /ro33d - -3 arraon /ro33dn;" -- a" "ou;- y #8a*'Ar8o -3 -3 o8/an or -3 nu<aon o -3 Add3ndu8 #onra a" /3ndn; 3or3 -3 &ENR Pan3 o Arraor". Gon=a3" ar;u3d -a -3 Add3ndu8 #onra a" !od, -u" -u" -3 ar arra raon on au"3 au"3 ona onan3 n3d d -3r -3r3n 3n a" @3 @3"3 "3 !od !od a n no. o. )3 on3n on3nd3d d3d -a -a any "" ""u3 u3 a" o -3 nu nuy, y, no/3 no/3ra ra!3 !3n3" n3"", ", or na/ na/a a y y o  /3ror8an3 o -3 arraon au"3a;r3383n ra"3d y on3 o -3 /ar3" o -3 a3;3d arraon a;r3383n 8u" 3 d33r8n3d y -3 our /ror o r33rrn; -38 o arraon. arraon. )o3!3r, #8a*'Ar8o oun3r3d -a Gon=a3">" aa@ on or r3/udaon o -3 Add3ndu8 #onra " no a ;round o d3ny 33 o -3 arraon au"3 au"3 n -3 #onra. S3on 2, /ar. 1 o RA 76 "3 on"d3r" -3 arraon "/uaon an nd3/3nd3n onra n " on r;- -o"3 3nor383n 8ay 3 /r3!3n3d ony on ;round" -- 3;ay 8a@3 -3 arraon a;r3383n "3 r3!oa3. L@3"3, #8a*'Ar8o 38/-a"=3d -a n S3. 2+ o RA 925, -3 our, n"3ad o ryn; -3 a"3, 8ay, on r3?u3" o 3-3r or o- /ar3", r33r -3 /ar3" o arraon, un3"" 
"a83 "u rou;- u/on a 8a3r o!3r3d y an arraon a;r3383n 3!3n -ou an; or -3 ouo83 o -3 ""u3 o -3 !ady o -3 arraon a;r3383n. Ar.  o -3 (N#IRAL $od3 La "a3" -a -3r3 a our 3or3 -- an aon " rou;- n a 8a3r -- " "u:3 o an arraon a;r3383n r33r" -3 /ar3" o arraon, -3 arra /ro33dn;" 8ay /ro33d 3!3n -3 -3 aon " /3ndn;. ISS(E C-3-3r -3 ?u3"on o !ady o -3 Add3ndu8 #onra a3" -3 a//ay or 3nor3ay o -3 arraon au"3 onan3d -3r3n )EL& NO. -3 dorn3 o "3/aray, or "3!3ray a" o-3r r3r" a , 3nuna3" -a an arraon a;r3383n " nd3/3nd3n o -3 8an onra. -3 arraon a;r3383n " o 3 r3a3d a" a "3/ara3 a;r3383n and -3 arraon a;r3383n do3" no auo8aay 3r8na3 -3n -3 onra o --  " /ar o83" o an 3nd.  -3 "3/aray o -3 arraon a;r3383n " 3"/3ay ";n<an o -3 d33r8naon o -3-3r -3 n!ady o -3 8an onra a"o nu<3" -3 arraon au"3. Ind33d, -3 dorn3 d3no3" -a -3 n!ady o -3 8an onra, a"o r33rr3d o a" -3 onan3r onra, do3" no a3 -3 !ady o  -3 arraon a;r3383n. Irr3"/3!3 o -3 a -a -3 8an onra " n!ad, -3 arraon au"3a;r3383n " r38an" !ad and 3nor3a3.  -3 "3/aray o -3 arraon au"3 " on