Fair Trade Vs

c
  c 

 



           !   " 
  "# 
$   
 
% " & "
' 

"$ "& & "
(   &"
)* 
!%%+
 
 $
 *" %% $ 
  $%"'$%"
%%*" 
&    ( )&"
 $%"'$%"*"  ( *"   
  &
 * ( $" ( *   
"  
,*  
&$%-  !
*"&"$     "!%% 
$   **  ( &
.
 $%"'$%" 
*  "
&  $"""& "

   "

"&$   ** ,free trade-
  $ &
& 
$%"'$%" 
 & !    $  "& !%  
"*
 "")+ 

&"$   "" 

(  $ 
   %" "

/
"  "" (    $   ** +"  $ &
  /
    & " 
 0$%  &" 

&$%""&! $
"$"$      &"$   
 ( "
""& " $   ** (  
&""    " "     
(  $ 
 ( &""    " 
   
" + )  ( 
"" *
 (  (   '  ( &&


"   %%&
 + )    '  *&*  "
$"
 $ *
 %&%
  0$%( && "
  '  *"  
*  
%#
     & +"   *&* 
  &$   **  (  $ 
&"
   *&* )&"!" 
"$    
,fair trade- c
  *"+" ""$*
 $
"$ $%"& "
"*"   ( + + ) &&$%&%
 $" "   &$  * 
$%"&   "& +
 

 &
     %"&& "
 &$ (#
 )&&$%&%
 &% &
   &$   (  
)& &$ ( $"*    &$    %/
% ( 
  
)&
"
  . 
& "
)$

 %"&  & "  /% 
* 
!
$ ( %

( *
*
)""( ( *$
 $   $%"!

 &  $ *$ 

$ 

$   1 2  
   *  *")&  
&$"
&!%* ""&   $&    *" &"  (   &&    +""3455 4 67c444  c448   
#
 
   

     *  ( " 
"
 
 )&  $"
&!%* "" &

#
 
&   ( &+ 
%$
$&*     &$"
 %%&
$%


 
% )(
"7

$ ( 
& " %$ 
$   ** ,free trade-9 $ ( 
& " %$ 
$    
,fair trade-9 :  
&  % 
   $   ** ,free trade- $    
,fair trade-
  &$   
 
% 9 ; %%       
 
% 

*  
%** 
$ +   )*
(  &*  (  
 $ $  *  $%
&$%) +" " 
% 
#$  *  
&$%  !   %
)&"  &*  ' &*  

 ( 
% %$   **   &"  & (  ( )$+ +
'$+ +
$   ( 
""%$ "$    ** 

+""* ( &!
$   &*  * "$  !
$ ( $  **   + +
'$+ +
*"



  &
"
$
 $"  ' $"  *      
 
% *
   &"" < 
"&( (
"$    **   

&&"
 ( 
& "
" "$   
" "   +  
* 
(  $ "
' " !
$ ( $"   
#!  %*  
= > &$
>  ""   
?% " "  ( 
*  
$   ** $"&*"  %%&
(   &
*

>$ ")&  * 
  '  &

( &
"
 $   ** $"&*" %%&
(  ( &! $
 > 
 &$
  '   *") + (    +" % 
"
& 

"$
* <  
&

  
*   
$+ +
   ( 
  


1 2 

 * ( ( $*  &
free trade" &      & +"* 
 $
 ( 
  $&"
   *&*  $  
*
 $%%&
 ( &(       
$*  
" 
( " "+    " $
  &    
  
" "$   
 
% & "
fair trade   @64  #


    
%      
%    $   ( 
 " %$""" "    $""  
    $   * & "" ( 
& " $  *"$   $%  ,

/
" 

/
"-)   

/
" $&
 " "     "$&
 " "   $&
   
 1:2 ""&
) % $ & %%&
)*
 
* 
  $    $    
%    "&
 %&$ A"&
 *"   



* *     ( *  '*  $%

   (  $ & &*  $   
 
% )&
 (    ( $* *" ( )*   )&  " )  
  
&*  ) ""&$    1=2 #


c
 ,   
-    **    *" %$%%&
( & !"$   &%
. ;%&&%
(!
$
% ;%
 (&, - "  
?%;"%& 6 
. 
%( *$" 
")
"& $+"  $%"     $ $ +  $%'
&$%  " &*  $   
( 12    **  $ +" 
#


 * 

   (  &*  *"  , &*   ( 
 $ $&
 -  &$     

/
" '

/
"  $"  ' $"  ( *  
  ( ** 1B2 #


c ,   * - c
    $   ( *   $  
%)*"   
 &%& 
)( *"+" &!
$   
 ) $&* " *
 &*"    "
$!
$ %

$   ( *
#
 &&
 $   ' %&$% $%"( $

 )" & 
  '  &

 
* $ *
+   $   
 
%  1C2    4554 67c444  c44  c ,   ** -


    **    *" %$%%&
( & !"$   &%
. ;%&&%
(!
$
% ;%
 (&, - "  
?%;"%& 6 
. 
%( *$" 
")
"& +"  $%"     $ $ +  $%'
&$%  " &*  $   
(     **  $ +" 
#


 * 

   (  &*  *"  , &*   ( 
 $ $&
 -  &$     

/
" '

/
"  $"  ' $"  ( *  
  ( **     
 
% 

*  
%** 
$ +   )*
(  &*  (  
 $ $  *  $%
&$%) +" " 
% 
#$  *  
&$%  !   %
)&"  &*  ' &*  

 ( 
% %$   **   &"  & (  ( )$+ +
'$+ +
$   ( 
""%$ "$   

** 

+""* ( &!
$   &*  * "$  !
$ ( $  **   + +
'$+ +
*"



  &
"
$
 $"  ' $"  *    +   +   
$   ** 
 
%    +  $   
 
%  &&#%"   &$&*   
$  *" 
 "
* < *& ! &*" (  ( & &"$ + +  ( *  
  &$        

) !  %

 
% 
 
* 
*
+   
$   **   &+ 
 &""   *&* $ + < " %


*&*   &   &%(  
*" ( %&


) *
"  
%$ )$ + 
&  *  (  "  *"&&"!" $   ** ) * +"  *" 


) *
+   
& 

& *&* 
%$ 
 " 

%%& < (  &% & 

&    /
4
! %  & &
    $
%(  & )$  $%"% 
+" &  &
$"&*" (  *
     *  '*  % 
  *#
 

*"* 
#
     %%&( & +" $   ** $! (   "
"&"$      $  ** $ *" ( !  %%&
& &"  & &
)!%%( )&"+" $   $
  $   * 
   *&* ( ""
  ( 

 
 $

)D" 
) 4%& ) $
+"   
%% A& &" *  
    &+ " 
   $ (%) &  
 $   **   **  *$

)&&*" $  & 

E$   ** &+ 
$ (  $ 
$
  &%%&
""** $  *  A*
+  $   **   *+
* " & 

&)$%
%
&)
% 
%
&)%&"
& *
+   
( $ +  *    c
 ,   
-


 c
    $   ( *   $  
%)*"   
 &%& 
)( *"+" &!
$   
 ) $&* " *
 &*"    "
$!
$ %

$   ( *
#
 &&
 $   ' %&$% $%"( $

 )" & 
  '  &

 
* $ *
+   $   
 
%   c
 *"+" ""$*
 $
"$ $%"& "
"*"   (  + + )&&$%&%
 $" "   &$  * 
$%"&   "& +
 

 &
     %"&& "
 &$ (#
 )&&$%&%
 &% &
   &$   (  
)& &$ ( $"*    &$    %/
% ( 
  
)&
"
)$

 %"& & "  /% 


* 
!
$ ( %

( *
*
)""( ( *$
 $  $%"!
 
 &  $ *$ 

$ 

$     +   
*
'*
*
  #
  

"
*   
 "F= '  5  
  
&   %
 
 "
*    $  "

 

(    %&$%  &      ""+  ( )fair trade   *"   %
( &"!" 
*   (  
  
    $%" %"&  
 
+ 
)%"&&  * <  $%" "&"  *
( ( *


  $" "$%" 
(   "(  &  
") (  & $"+" 
   %$%")" & $%" (   "  ( & 
!
 


 &"
&"!"%$fair trade( *"   ""&"$ (  *" &
 $   ( 
   $  
%) $  
  $ 
" * $
   

 *+  ( $"  < ")%$fair trade

$"& 
*&* $" ,&"+"$  #


 $

$'$

$(    
  
% c
 %!

%Gc-  %" 
   44 
%    "  ( &&"
$&*    
$   #
 
  *&*  %"( H ( &   +" H
+"  
+   "* . 
&
  
")  


$  * 
% 
"
*  * 
 $""&

  *&*   


#

"*&* )*  %$  ( &  &
$    (  * 
% 
)
 * 
!
& (   "
*  &

 + 
$%
 
     &$        &    "

 )& 

 &&$*

(  &&*
  *
 
  
  "FC ' )+"& $ 
%$
   !


%(   * "$  $
 
,$"&$")$  )  $% -  & 
$   %$
&&*   *E
#
 
fair trade""%$
 &  & ( 
*
     0 /    &$!%*  < 

)
*"  "*"  "   $% %$
 $!
   %$ 
$ 
%$
 

% A


* 
*"   )fair trade$%$"* 
 *E
#
 (  
&  $  $%"( 
+"  
&+ 
& ! &+ &
   $  
*
* 
 %"&* < $%"  !
& $    (  
  


$%") 
#
 
&&$*  &   $$  $%  + $  IJ ' )  fair trade *&* !  

#
 
"
*   ( &+ 
$  " & (  "

)$+"  $%"#
 

 %*  &! $
 ) &
( "% 
&"+" $"&*" * : $*
 &  "

=  

)$%"'$%"* *fair trade  ( 
+" 
%%"" $
&"
 +" 
$ + 
 "$&  @
$%"( $"& 
*  & 
$&
 "" $%"'$%"* *fair trade*
* ( "&*"
"
*  ) 


 *
 &
  * < $  $  % 
"""
" &"
  "$ ( &!
$  $   (  *
 
* 
$%" 

  $
%(  & )$  $%"% 
+" &  &
$"&*" (  *
     *  '*  % 
  *fair trade

*"* 
fair and green trade  : 

$'

$c
  Fair trade* 
*"   
#& <  %

$   ( *
*
* 
 $%"!
 &
"
 & (  & 

$

  Fair trade&&* " $%"!
""&&$%
"$ (  ( & "
$
  $ $  ) &
"
 $%"!
   $  )&( "  $
 
K$ $ & ) 
 

&
 
#  $$&$" (  & 

&+ 
<   "  %*   "  $   ( 
  
)+" &
"

"  
"     &

&( $" *  '*  
&
<
  & 
&fair trade)%"&*
& 
+
$ ( $%"(  & 


 $ 
$
" ,&
 7$&
    & )&"
*"")&+&"$ 
) *-* 
%&$%*
( $%"
  &
&$   %/
%   * 
    "*" $

%"&  +
$ ( $%")& 
 *  "" &&*
  $&
"&,( &
$"
*
( $%"

 &* *
( ""
/ 
-(  
 <  %$%"  
$" *" &
 $   ( 
   $  
%) $  
  $( *"+" ""&! $
  ( 
&* ,* 
"
A
 -
  & $   
 
%  Fair trade&&*
 "&*  * 
$&* " (  * +"  & <  %

$   ( *
*
 &
"
  
 $%" *""( $

 )" & 
     * 
  )fair trade<"+"  &*"% 
 
 
% c 
%%#  
/ ,c- 6 
 
$ ("  #
 "


*&

 /% 
 *
+  
 
%    $&"  " ?% 6 
 
%,?6-)c " &"!"  + 
; !")0
!%
 
%% " "&  
* 
"    
#""&<"+" $   ( *
 
    &  & 
" 
% c
 %!

%)%

 
%     ( 
&(*"&*
 (    *" $    $ 
*" 
 

&*" $" * 
$%" 
   %%&
&   $    $ 
$ "+ < *  : 
   
$%" = %%*"( $   (  
 &    &* (     ( $  & "

% $

$$ 

$ 
"
  $&*  $  

B %& 
   C &*"
" 
 %


" + (  &   * 
$+   & (    J 
 &
*  $+     
 &" 
" 
"$ &&*
  &$ * 
$&* " % ) !  *  &" 

  " 
&$% &&*"
 (  $%" %   ; c
 c  Fair Trade&"!"* 
  
# 
*"$   ** ,free trade-( &"" * ( %   
  
 A(  * < & &"  ( 

& 
% %&$%!
<  *"&
&  &

  "( & 
#

 %* 
 * <  
(    *"
 
* 
  
 # ( $ 
(  
  
""
  $&    (  $   " ' " # ( $  $ 
(    
  
 " ' " doubel standard  "    ( 
$    '    (   &"*" $   (    '  *&*  &"*  "*" $   *"( !  #
%%#
   "*" partnership(  &"" " * $
 &+ 
"*" $%
 
#    
"*"  $         (    *&*  ( &+ 
   $   $%
 
* " !  '!  %%

 

  

$  !""$*  *       free trade&&    '  *&* ""&
* 
 
$   & )   $  

( 
  '  & +"& 
& $ *
+  $%
* 
 $%"(   & "  &$  %&
 A%"
$ $      *"$

!  %
 
% &(* *   *&* &  &
 "

$ "( * 

+" %   

"
&$       & +"    *&* & 
* 
&   

 (  >$%$" 
"
&
& 

!%&( +"& ( B  
*
*  

!%&% '% &

 1J2 
 %

$   ( & 
 & & 

  
*"   &(* * 
&$  ( & 
*       (    *&* )Fair Trade&"!"* 
*"   $     
#( *$
 $  $%" &

& "
$ $ $

$ 
 ) $  
)%&"
 
  
    & $ ( )$

$ 

*"
<"+"   &*" 


*"
( *
 $)$"  % 
 
$%")$
  
*   $  $&$"   & $   )  $&
"&* 
$%"( 
 
  12 + &+ 
*"   $   "  #
  &(* ** 
  
  <  %$ )&
 ) 
 #
 
%


  #
 &"!" $  $   " J '    &$&*  ( #
 
%
 !""$ &&* "$%"'$%"&


** 
<
 ( $
D%(   )  )   &)  
) "   &*  fair trade( !""$$%

#*"&"+" * 
(  $"
*
* ( & (     $% '% 


& (  & 



*+  &(
 $" &  &"
 & $   "
$%$%
 (  "( & 
& 1

2  & 
&fair trade)%"&*
& 
+
$ ( $%"(  & 


 $ 
$
" ,&
 7$&
    & )&"
*"")&+&" $ 
) * 
( -* 
%&$%*
( $%"
  &
&$    %/
%   * 
   "*" $

%"&  +
$ ( $%")&  
 *  ""&&*
  $&
"&,( &
$"
*
( $%"

 &* *
(  ""
/ 
-( 
 <  %$%" 1

2 * 
( )$%"+" & 
$"
 $! ( ( 
*
 % %"&  "&&*
 
#%& 
* ( &
$%"& ,%

) < "$ )/ 
 - &+  " 
 E" 
 $%"( %"+" & "  $&" "
""&&*   &! 
+  "  &   ( &   $
) ""( ( *
  $% $   (  
 1 2 
$" *" &
 $   ( 
   $  
%) $  
  $( *"+" ""&! $
  ( 
&* ,* 
"
A
 -
  & $   
 
%  Fair trade&&*
 "&*  * 
$&* " (  * +"  & <  %

$   ( *
*
 &
"
  
 $%" *""( $

 )" & 
    1 :2   * (  +

 "*
* ( &&*
!    free trade
&* fair trade. A" 

 *"&&


$ & (
"&( " 
/
 +" '*
  "trading  * (     


  !  + (   "Mode of Production Free trade  " $  ** 
"&""&&*"" *   "$%#
)*
 $"&     !  )
  $"
  ' ( ** "+  % * (  Free trade  &$  &+&   &*"%$% 
'%$% 
     "
/% 
  '   ( E& +"  A 
 (  $&   &  $&* " 
 & $ " 
$&
 ) & "$"%%'%%& (    &
$%#
)  $"  ' 
+"
* 
    &$ free trade *
 

 
** $   (  (  "&* (   &)$
  $" )!) 
) & 
* (   
( 
  
 + 
( $"   
"  $&

  ( E$""%     
* ( *

& 
(
" &"!"(   $  
&&
  

 
A4)* 
" $ !<  (   "&* (   &( 
* *  *
%%$% 
( * &   $&
  1 =2  
""*%$ 
( )$
 $  %$% 
" +   &*
+  (  
"  & "
% 
 
"$   $
7c,International Monetary Fund-)?6 ,World Trade Organization-) ?,World Bank- @
   
"& 
#
 

"* 
 < +
*""&( ""&
"
 " &
(  
 $   +  $  %$% 
 +" &&$"(
  &  &&&*
 
 
 % ""&+ 
$&
&$
 
%  
" "  A  ( +
 + 
%#
  "$%    *
+  ( 
"   %% 
 
*")$&
  
% &+ 

 *"
)  " &+ 
 $$ +     %$% 
4 ( 
$ )&"
&*  ( *
 &$  
    "&$&$" ( 1 2

 

$%"( 
$+" *
 )+
&free trade
  "' """ &+ 
 " "
+ 
 %&%

 & (    ( 

 * 
%"&  A%"
( &" %$"*

 
 %"  %$% 

* 
*
 

  + $ free trade  &
 
"
$ 
<
  $
*
%$+   ) $% 
) $"+")$& "<
  % " 
)%)% , 
*  &  )$   )  !#'( -)&" % " 
1 B2 (
 $
*  +
&$  ** )+"&     & &*




#  &&*" < !    
#( 
  fair trade,$   (  
- Fair trade &+ 

 $(   &$ *

  "$%#
(   &&$
&*  

'

 
& (     
"#


fair trade( 
"
$ 
<*
c7fair trade   &%$   ( *   $  
%)*"   
&%& 
) ( *"+" ""&!
$   
 )$&* " 
 &*" & "
$!
$  %

$   ( *
fair &&
  ' %&$%$%" $+ (  $

 " & 
  '     ( 

*  %$  *
+   $   
 
%  1 C2  
$

  ) $ "  ( *
 

 )( 
7free trade* 
    fair trade * 
&%E
 *

 Fair trade * 
  *
* ( &( " % % 
 
 Fair trade     
 
% ( *  
* < % 
 
 $ ("( ""
*"c,International Fair Trade Association-)(   * 
  & &+ 
7World Fair Trade Organization,?c6- ?c6*" &"&"  "  &
 

(  "
$"
 % & "$"%   "% 
 
( 

 * *"  &  fair trade A
 % 
 
*
* ( 
#%" $  
  /% 
*
+  )" & *
+ $    
% EWorld Trade Organization ,?6-) /% 
%"&& "
 &$ ( $&*"  $  "" %   &&%
%

  %   &$ $ $

$'$

$fair trade ?c6 % (   
:

% 
 


 J   1 J2 Fair trade* 
&%*

)&( "$%   % &<"+" (   $

$' $

$fair trade$
( 
%  %c)** $ *"
 
$

$
"(  $
""
+ 
 $%&   &$ fair trade)   
7  &
 *

  "  "" 
#&& 
&

 )$&* (   (  ! )
  &&$+    +   )&%& 

" )  $&$"   ") "*" *

( *
 &*"    ""partnership 
&&*   @ 
 ( &+ 
$ 
$  $ "fair trade    & 
 *

  ""  )*
 & !"$  %& '%& & "
   &&&$%"
*  )  
"$ (   &
 
+ 
( $%
 
*
  $"&* ( & "
& "$""&* (   & %#
( 
$%*" &""""&&"
    "&&


&
 

/ 
  
  &$% &( &+   $%" & (      fair trade  && %
*

  &   $ 
#
 )
  $%""" %"&) * +
   &*$%"
D + )  #
 
 * $   % +
  + Fair trade* 
&%*

*
 
 $ 
  *
 "   
&   +   $  + Fair trade
  ( $%#
 &"+" happiness and welfare oriented 1 2

 A   Fair Trade   $   ( *   $  
%)*"   
 &%& 
)( *"+" &!
$   
 ) $&* " *
 &*"    "
$!
$ %

$   ( *
#
 &&
 $   ' %&$% $%"( $

 )" & 
  '  &

 
* $ *
+   $   
 
%   Fair trade* 
*"   
#& <  %

$   ( *
*
* 
 $%"!
 &
"
 & (  & 

$

  c
 &&* " $%"!
""&&$%
"$ (  ( & "
$
  $ $  ) &
"
 $%"!
   $  )&( "  $
 
 $ $ & ) 
 

&
 
#  $$&$" (  & 

&+ 
<   "  %*   "  $   ( 
  
)+" &
"

"  
"     &

&( $" *  '*  
&
<
   &fair trade)$%" %"&&&


$%

( + +   

")" *  $
 +" &$     $  
 


 " & "

#%& 
  %&"
 
 * 
!%%     &&"   +"  %"&
""" %&$%*
( $%"
)& " $%/ 
)" 
 %
 c %'# % $&*"  +" *"&"


#%& 
 !  *" $  %"&) *
"+" &
$%$%"
(  +
 %&"
 



 "  * ) &  %"&$"  *
&&* (   +" ( 
 <  * 
   " $

&   & 
&fair trade)%"&*
& 
+
$ ( $%"(  & 


 $ 
$
" ,$&
    & )&"
*"")&+&"$ 
) 
  &"  $ 
$ 
-* 
%&$%*
( $%"
  &
&$    %/
%   * 
   "*" $

%"&  +
$ ( $%")&  
 *  ""&&*
  $&
"&,( &
$"
*
( $%"

 &* *
(  ""
/ 
-( 
 <  %$%"  * 
( )$%"+" & 
$"
 $! ( ( 
*
 % %"&  "&&*
 
#%& 
* ( &
$%"& ,%

) < "$ )/ 
 - &+  " 
 E" 
 $%"( %"+" & "  $&" "
""&&*   &! 
+  "  &   ( &   $
) ""( ( *
  $% $   (  
 ?6
  $  $  &&*"" "&
 $   ( 
   $  
%) $  
  $  ( *"+" ""&! $
  ( 
&* ,* 
"
A
 - 
  &$   
 
%   c4 A

$7EE< *!%& & *%$% !%&E

CE E%$'""&'#
'  & $7EE*&'"&! %E%* L<E#"L 
! !#&9 
!
M J  $7EE! #'%%&
*%$% !%&E

E E&   ' &$ '%* 
 
'  $ & $7EE 
 (" J <%$ !%&E

E :E: E $  '&& '  '$   '** E $7EE#
0 
## <%$ !%&E E%%&
'$%

'
 
% E 

    
  
     

 
      
  
            
           
      !""     
 #"$              %!""&#"$            %
 
 
 
 
   '     
 
%  !""&#"$%
 
  (       
  

  
 
 
 )* +   
   
 ,-  

 
    
      



    

      
   

 
   
        

  

      

  
.

 %
 % %       
 / 
/ 
    
       
   )0 1  
   
  
!"" #"$     

       !"" 
 
 
  
         %
     !"" !""    
    

 
                
1 
   
   !""  
 ( 

(  (    (      
2%!""  
*3   %
  ( )*4  )550

   +           
      
 
  
   (    

 
  



            
   
  (
!"" +"    !"" 

  
  
 
 
 
 

 
+" 

  
    36  !""
  
 #"$ 
  
 

   
     


 


 7)  

  

        *  

         

 8 3            
   #  #"$  %

   

 


    (    (  !"" 39           #"$       
 
  
 
   
 
 
   
 

 


  %

   
  
   % 

 
  
  
  
   

   
   

       %   
* 
          
  
    
   %
     (
 

   

   
  / (: 

 
 
    
%
  
  
    
  
 / (
:
 
    
   %  
 
 
 
 
      1   
  


  %
 
 
 

          
     ( 
   
  
(  %

 
    


      
  
      
  4; 1 
   
 

   
 
   
      
2   %
%
 %

%    %   
  "  
  
 
+!$  
  )5;6 +!$ 


    
   $<,!  % +!$
 $-  = % 
                  

   #  
(   
   
> %  
    (

     
   
   
 
(    -       ( >      
  
  
> 
 
   

  
      
   %
    
    

 &&  
  1    %
  
  
   -    
     
 ( 
 
    

$-!       (   
  
         
 06 
 
     
  (
%


 
      
  
  
 ((
   
     


 
 
         




  %
     (  (    %    

 



 
 
  
  %
((   
  

 
   



  

        
 
      


    
     
  
   
>   %
 
     

% %      

Kopiitudashat's Blog

@"( =)

 Kebijakan Luar Negeri dalam Kaitannya dengan Pengambilan Keputusan Suatu Negara     7 ( 2 ?


 @A7);

 A*
+  " 
,#%
$%
!(-   &(   $
  &"$ (  $! $
$
  
% " "  ;%"%&*
 ?%#&&  *
+  "  
)  "(  $ 
*"* 
$%

" 
)* 


 
$
   
% ( &   $%<  $ *

 " "   A  
" *
+  

 *
$
 
$  *
+  
  & "$
  
% ( &"$   "+" " & (  "
! $
" "  '*  ( * "  "*"    *
+   " 
)$%< $
  
%  $ 
+  * 
*
"7  
*  
   $ 

 * < "*"    $
  
% )*
+  "  
 $%< $ 

   & %

A%

$ & ( &&$  $%< * 
"+" )* 
*
+  " 

"  * 

"& A*
+  " 
 
*"   $
  
% ""& $  $%<( *


 A%

" &&$  $%<* 
  ( 
"  * &  *
+  "  
""&! $
$
  
%  " $%<* 

"&

) ""( $%<* 
 
%
$)
$"   *
+  " 
 
    "  ""&&$ "
 $
( 
+    &!%&$  
/"(%##%
$%
!() * < *
+  " 
   $" $ "  &"*" 
 
% )(
" 
$ ( &&$"(
 $ ""
$  * 
&      &$"&" *
+  " 
)  "
  

(  $ 

 * 
""' ""( &&$ "
$"&" *
+  " 
" "  )( &"
 &
&*" " "
"" ""&  ( $ 
$
$"&" *
+  "  

  



&""4% "&
$"


/
")%&$%)*
% 
)
&  
% ) 
&%*     

/
"  &$%$&*"  $""    *   $   !(    

&
  $ 
 

/
"  &&&*" " "$""   &
&$& 
 ( ""$
 
 * 
""" &   &$&*"   *
+  " "    &&"&" " "*
+  ) %

/
"
   $   
$ "
%

 $&

  
% , 
% !%
!-  "
%



 & "
  &( 
%%
)$! ( )*" ( )"+"  
* 
( &"&( 

  ( *
+  ( 
" %$"" 

/
"     %%
)  " %

   &

&&% 

 ( A
& " A
&@%(  &+ 
   

/
"( * 
& 
# 
   
% A%   )   " "( &( "&         
$"" $    ( 
  $  
 ""     %&$%&
 * < $"" #
 " "*
+  *"  ( 
"  %$
  

 

/
") $
*
&"$  & 
# 
$
  %&$% A%&$%( 
& "


*
 &"$  %&$%$
 )%&$% $ )  "$"%&$%
( &&$"(
$%

 
 $
 "
 $&
  )&
 ( *  

+,  -)$(    )
  
 * 
( 
 ( &
! ;%&
#%    "&%% "" &"  
+  ( &""    A%&$%$
 )(   &"  ( 
* "%&
)&( &$
 %$

$"*
 ""
$+"    &*"*
+   A
 $
 ( 
 
%&% 
% $&
 )%&$%$
 

*
 & #%&

( &+ 
%&$%$     *
% 
$ &  

$%$" %
%*   "
(  

 A"*   &

A"* )$""    %/
""&&$  " *"  *   $"" 4    "$"

 A"!/) &"*
&"$  $%" *
% 
!  ""    &$  *
% 
)$"" 
 

 * 
 $%" 
% 
 

/
" $
*
&"$  $%" 
** 
$("
  %&$%&
 @ 
)*
+  " 
&"$  $%$%

( &
$"
* 

) %&$%&
  +"&  A*
+  " 
* 

"&""&<"+" $
  
% +"    
$ "
%""'""
   )$
$%<)

  
% )
%%
)  $
 ( "" 
&

  *
 
&&*"
&%%&
)
& $%

) 
&%
'*" ( 
&'
&

 ( !  %&$
#! "$  & 
& 
%  
 ( )
%%
+"!'  "#
!'( 
"A%      &&*"$
 "" 
(  *
+  &""$

 
$  %*     
&
%* &  $
( $  
"       $$ &*
 $"" *
+  " 
(  
"  (  
& "   """*"     '  * )$% '$%  

( *"  # %
" 
% $

" 

 D *"&
 &*  


   $
(  $ .
&
 
%   &*
+  " 
" "  
 ( %
(   *"  &.
&$     "&"&" *
+  " 
""&  
 $&    $  ( *   $

$ %& ( 
+"+"%c%%  
!"" 6 
. 
%,c6-  @ 
) $ 

&$" * <   &$&*"  $"" ""& 
 *
+  "  
" "  )$ 

/
")%&$%)*
% 
)
& 
%  
&%* 
   $ *
 
 &$
   4#
 %
& !%74$%
*!

%'&  <
 ) (" 

   &""*"  
%   "74% A (    '  %$ $% C &""*"  
% 7
&) 
 $
 " 4 + 5 #
%   

'>B `eterrence dan Compellence sebagai Strategic of Military `efence     7 ( 2 ?


 @A7)0

  
(  "
&&"!" $
% 

( 
< 
%/
"  <  $%0(<  %0(? &+ 
   " 
 


&  " *  $
 &"  $
 
 * 
<
 ( $&$"    
( 
"    &  
 &  A% 


  !""$&  !  %%&

 &"
 
$"  

( !""$#

   



 "  &&*  "
 ( 
  *
#

)  
*
&&*
 #%)* 
!
"
+"  *
#

 
$  +"& * +  %/
%  #%

&&
!""    "$$%<G   %/
G"" & ' & &&*  "
   !%#%<(  
!
$  % 

*&+ 
  !%#%( 
""% $%&* +   %&* +  

 ( &"$   
!( 
"  "     *"  &
  +  ( 
&


  $! (  

 $ &
   

  & &$"  < ""&(  ""0 5%  4
!  &%)! $ 

 * 
 
$" 
( 
 " % $
 $ & $  $
 " ""  $
 $ & & " 

 $
 "   #





 "&%5 ( *
+  
! ! %(  & 

 
$  % 
 (  "&! $
 ( 
& " " " 
& "
 ! & *

&$

& "$"$

) $&*
 
$%

#*"$  
+
  $
 " & 
   $
 $ &  $&*
 
 
#*"$ ""& +
  $
 " * "* 
( ! (  $ 
 "   &   &
 <  "$" &
( 
& "     &
( &" A   &



$"    %( 
 !   $ &! $
     &
%%
I!F$ &  

&"  % %
!( &  

 % 

 
% $ ! $*%&    
'
%
&  A !" ( 
 &
 @$ &&*" &  $    < * < 
 +  $&" &  
!
$  !   * '*     '  &"
*%&* '%&* ""&&


+  

)&  $  % ,% < - "

     
* "
#( 
 
    & $   ( )!

* 
  &** $ $
%7

 =' = 
%


< 
%$*%&    
'
%
& ) !" ( 

&*" * " * ! )%  
"*"&   
%
!( 
& 
 %



 ""
 %*
+  !%
&( &"$   
 
$ 
 %/
  * 
$&   

 
"  ( $ &  
&"  "
&"   & &$" &

( ""&&    
&
"
$
  & "
 $(*  %  <    



 
%$&
  
%<$    ( &+ 
 & 
/  

%* 
$%  
" &  
""&&*"   %/
 

) "
+" 
"  ""&&*"$ " %/
   

 


+"  
 * 
!%"/ " 
 (* *$% 

&!%* &   +  '

+   $  %*('%*(( 
 $/
 % %/
   

(     !%"#%! 
 (
&  +  '+   
  $  $   &

  $" '$" "  &

 %/
  "+"  < !   * 
 
$   , (%##-"" &
 
$
 "  "
  ( 
 

  
  
 
# ( $/
#  
 &
 % !( $ 


&"
    $&*
$"
& """  ( &&* " $
 "( 
 


 
","
 * * /
%-   
 &*  
  ) $ 

&$" * <   ( &&"
 + 
(  !     
&    
%%
( &&"
  $&*  +  ( #
#""& "
' "
 <    


&&


** $  "+" 
  ( ""&&$%
  G*
( 
 "  +  "
 & "$"+  %/
% ' A  


 $  
 
&

 (#!(  &"  $   & "
 
! !%&$!( &"   &&

& "$"%&

  ;%&$!)$ &  

"  % !
""&(*"!( 
"   ""&&
!",
"!- %
""& " " " 
,* /
%- @
 ! 
"  ""& * /
%&  !%&$ !*"+" ""&&
!"* /
% <  "$"" ( *
 ( 
"  !  * &   
  %

&
 
   "&  
  &&   %
& " " """&
 
 "
 ** /
%
" "   
*
+  
! ! %<  "$" "(  *
* ( 
"      
 
#)*
 ( &"   
%%&
A    $ 
"  !  * & )&  + 
" " &*
"
     &    &&  $
 " &
&  
$%

#( 
*
 $
 $ & A &*
"
  

& 
  
   & " " $ 
$  * 
! !%&$!  
" "$$
#( &&    A
  &&   &
 $%($%
# 
"
( )   && #     $ &
"
""&'!   
 ) 

&"$  " " !%&$!   
$    

 $ 
+   
%
 
&

 
G " ."'( &

*  $! $
&   $ $   %(  

&*" %"
)  $ &+ &
&  (  $  "& ""   &

( !  %  " @
  *
 
! $
)&  &  

 $ 
! $
  & !" "  &

 < & "$"&  $ 
*""  & !" %   ( 
$

  &( ?  "$"*
 
*
 * < "  &  


  $ 

  
 &"
 $" "
"" & !" "   <   4#
7 %"()@ &  .

%.)4%*);%
%
%# 
% 4 
%7 ;%&$
/ "(,=

%-) B)<D%7%&  6

 %#! $#  &$7EE<<<  $"*
! 
% !%& ?
%)? )(%#"! ! $# '>B

Maria EM Ȃ 070710023 THI 4 Power dan Pengembangannya dalam Teori Perimbangan Kekuatan dan Stabilitas Hegemoni     7 ( 2 ?


 @A7)3

 %<&+ 
%$" &  "& 
  &&(
 $
"*" 
 
%  
$     "&"  $%<( 
&


""&
  $%<( 
&


"  &! $
$
 ( @ 
 $ 
   * < $%< $ 
"  * 
   & "$"* 
"+"  
 ( 
 $&
 
 $" &  &  &
"   +"& $""( 
 < 
  $ &&$* ! !  
""&( 
 $" )&  
 $"  $ &&$"  $%<
*
 %%&
""&
&"" $"&*" $""( )(
" !  &&*


#$  "  ( *
 &&


*
 
    %<%%&



*#"
* 
   $%<&% #
 * 
"+" ( "" "+" ( ""&
$%

  
% 
%*   %<




 &&$"(
#


(  
 ""4%* )$%<    * 
&  &&$ "
$
 
""& "  $ ( 
 

  
$"
 
 

& " (  %<

 $ 
$%

 * 
%"!& "$"* 
  
%
$   $%<* 
%"!&  $$%<* 
&

   , !" $%<-)
 +
 " "  &&$"(
"&* ( ( * $
 <
 ( 
%
)+"& $"" *   &* ( * &"

   * <    

 $ 
%% * 
   $%<( *     


   
 / &
 %
( &&


 ( %"!
 &*    %$%

(  
(  
  $ &&* < %
&+ 
"$$%<"
    
&"
&&$%

 $%<* 
 
%
$
&  $%<*


  * 
"*" $%
(  $ &
  $%<
&  (     ,$%
 $%<-    

*
/   &$
&*  
 
      
    &&"" ""&   "*"    
)&    *"    
&

$%<& 
'& 
   &%

)$%<   * 
&   % $  &&$ "
$
 " %  
&  !  "   *" 
&&$ "
    && #  *"'*"$%<$
%#$%<( &%
 
 $&

 & "
*" ( )
%%
 " $%<( &&$"  "  %%&
  $%

 * 
(  %<*" %$(  $ 
"" &" G*
# 
 
*G  $%< *
# &"

&

&
$ &    !%$( &

#
 
 $( 
*    &  
"  " "    $ "
" $ **  
"
 
 (  $%<@$   $%
  &*
 %%&
*
   
$  $%<@$  %
  &*
 &

 
&
"    %&
( & &*  * $  *  %( 
$ "
 " "  &"
&&


$%<( * 
 "
%  $

  $ &" 

%( 
 
&

 
*"<
( &"$    " 
* $ * &"
  $ 
$ "
%  $  ;
 (  $   &" &&$ "
*
+  
 &( % *&&


 & 
%%
 
&
&$    !%) * $ * *
( ""&" 
 * $  * *
( ""& " $
   & 
!
*
(  & 
* *
(  &  $%<& 
*  
&
 
   & * 
  ""&+    $%<
"


 *"$ 
&*%
$
$%$   & < $*"    "$"$%< ( *
&" 
 $
"  %%&
)&

 
$%& 
 

A
 
$    *"  &+ $%<,"%#$%<-$
$&

  

  )&  
 
$%<  &&*"   "  "
 ""*'""*(  A
 "  "
* 
  & ""*( *
&* )+ 
 ( 
*"  ! %#%<,%-  &  

"  %"!(
""& &*    %$%
 
&*
$% 

&""? .( % 
*
 *
   (  &+ &
$ &
  &  ( *
*

* 
 
&&"
$%   
&*  "  "   "$$%<  &&
  
&(       &&
  
&&  $ &&
  



 &


 $  
+  & "
** $      & )+"& %#
  '  *"  *  *


  
"&" 
&"
 $   '  *"  *   A" )*
&" &+   $     +"&   *"  * (  
* *
!
 A
 )&

& 

&
 " 
""& "  
  &"
 
&$
&*  "  


 &&


#


& "$"

 %( +   &*
"
 ( &"!"*
$   
   (    "&! 
$%<"" &+ 
$"  "  *" ""
&*  
& A
 +  

%  
 &*    &J 
**  %(
"

*"
"  )$% $(
&*  )&%
 "$ ( &! 
&%
) *

   &
)$%<$%

! !  "&"&)+  ""&"
/  
&( &   $&*" *
+    A

( &"!"&"
&( "+" %

( &""%
*%)5.  ;  ""&(   &%
"
)&(
$ 
& $"" 
&
"

)&+ &
 *

   &  * & ) &+ &
$ &
 * 
 "+" 

&"

& 
# 
   &!  '!  ( & $ %%    &+   $%


 
$
 "%&* )* " "" 
$ ! $ ) $&* "   $(  ) 

)  $ ")
/
)
$%& 
)$(
 %#
!   )$"!" +  )$%&* +   $  A  $
   
% " "*   $ &+ 
 ! & * 
  
&  %( !  %
 &
 
$ (  &  &(* * $ 
"

 @
 %& &*  ""$%<( *
$% )&  
&"
$%  $ 
+    %
A *
 &%
,&%
! *

(- A
 """

& 
 * 
"""
$% )&  $%<  % 
$   """* &&"!"  %%&
 ( &" 
"
 "  %%&
 &

 &%

   &&* < "

 
% &"+" *
  @
  
&
 $%<* 
$ 
 " & (   
$+"  %
$  &   "&  
% 
&
 $%<    "
*   &$"*   
$%<&+ 
*
$" 
# 
   (  *
*"   ( $
* 
+" &
 
 +  %$%) * $  
&*  
&*  ( 
& ")  "  $
 $  (  $ 
    
&*   %
&%
! *

(*  $  $&

 & 

 $%

( &&
&$
 %%&
<  "$"
 $"( & "

'

& 

  

'


*   $&+ 
$%
$
 A"  %&
 
  ( && 
$" 
"*" %%&

 
%  $
+" &!
$  " "$%%&
"
( *" *    $   ** 
&  & # ( 
  (   
   * 
  &% $
 +" &"   ( *$ 

$ 
 &%
  "( 
$  &
* 
%&
 
"  &

   "$%

)
$"    &$%%&
$  "
( 
*    $ &%
 " 
* 
  $  
      

* 
+
 %%&
"
   
* &    &%%&
"
 "

 "  &%   &&%
$"   ( "  ( *
& &*
 
 & "% $%%&
"
""&+   *

 $%%&

"

   &&+   &%
)
$" "  '"  " & (  $ 
"   * 
  * 

""&
"  
   &%


)
$"   (  " % ( &"!" "  %&
 ""&+ &
  ( * " !   A"  


<"+"   &*"

"
( &+ 
#%"%
* 
  %
&%
!  *

(&+  

#
 
&% "*
  
#  *  '*  ( 

 (   &%%&

* )*  '*  ( 
$"     * ** 
&  " "* 
"  &&*
 & # * 
&" %   *" ""% ")&
 ( /  )  & * 
( A"" $"*


  ( &"
 $ &&"!" #
( 

&
& 
""  $  " *%
*"
$  
&
"

#

 ( *"  

  %&%  A
   &%( &&* "%?%% (&)&  
* 

"    $
  ""& &  $  " 
(   
&
"&(
  ** 


"
( $    (  $ 
""
 *""   4#
7    <
)

)%<  
% 4 
%) *%%%# 
%  4 
%)$$ CC' J %"()@  # . ##)4  ) C )%
! $$% !% 
%  4 
%);%
%
%# 
% 4 
%)$$ : ':J %)? ;%/ () J);%#
! ;%%$ 
% "%# !"()!5 <' 
;%&$ 
)!  %)5% @ !%)4%*   %"!
%% 
% 4 
% <D%7 60#%
/
( '>B Strukturalisme dalam Kerangka Marxisme     7 ( 2 ?


 @A7))

 4/%"
 !
 4/%"
"
( + 

%$  &"* 
&#% 
& %%&
)( ""( "  
$ %$&

  )&+ 
 $
 
&%%&
 
&  "+" $(  
 %%&
    "&" 
&% * ( '* ( (    & $
 
&+ 
 $ ( 
 &   
  +  %
,%!

N" 

-)(
"  
&   "$
   
""  $
 

"
 % "  '"  "" "&" 
&%  A  

&&*"  "&*""( 
 &&


  '  $%"
&+ 
 "  "&$&

&%   A%



&
&*" $
 
 A  0   
*( 
 &
%$  *""  &%%( """"&"
A $
  ;%&&"
 
#%$  $   *     &"
 ( ) 0&

 $
 
&* 
*" 
&
&   "& *%+"
( &&


# %'# %$%"
   "&$%
 
 "&$% (  &&*""  "&*%+"
""*  
"$   & " $% % "& *%+"
)"$ ( 
 $  *""+ "*
!
 
 $ (  "( 
 $  ( ) 

   "$ *""(  "(  ( 
 $ 

 ( &"$  ""  

 &* ( 
&*
% "&*%+"
 

 0
&& "&
 & "
* 
& "& 
)  
"$ & "
+  ""
< 
 *  $&

 $
* 
( &(* * & "
" *%#
&&$*" & 
( &"$  # %" & $%%
$%

 ,& 

&
%
- 

$  ( )*"    ( &"   ) $
   ( &"     


* "

 & 

&)*
 * 
    %%&
 "$ ""   $%

)#
 # )%
)  & )   &  * 
 &" "$ ""    " "(  " $ 


 & 
)%   
"&  $%"
 "
! $
* ( '* ( (   " &  
 +   0      "
* " $   %&
 
 $%
 
   $   (      "
* "


( 

 $ 
! $
 +  /%"
 ( $   < (   
< 
%%#
   )  
" %" &   &     4/%"
%
&""* (   0     
&    '  $%"
  *  
* < %%$%     $   J=  0 &"
* < %* 
 
 $
 
  
" &

  
&
 
%  A%#
 %&$

    * ( &"$   %#
    )*%+"
 
% ( & "$&
   $% 
%&%$%
     &&&  "" $
 
&%* )& 0
&
 * <   
 %%%&  $

  %$
  *%+"
)%  
"%#
    * (  &"$  %#
$
    *%+"
     

")
& $
 
& ( * "  *
# $ 
#
 
  *"  &&$" 

& "
 %%

&)
&$

&) %* 
 
%%&
 A $
 
&( &%* 

&"
&%%$  % 0
$
 "  ) 4 " * !)5"c  && "? 
""& &*  "" "
%*   &  %%&
(   ( *"&* 
$&

  0
& %


&"

*"* 
%
"" 
&%* (   " & (    /%"
 %* (  (  $ 
! $
 !   
   *
 $  
""%* (  $%
 
#   %
&$

&
 
&" %
 
 0 &   * < A $
 
& && "
 * "  *"( I%%$%
A $
 
&F  ""( 
 &*  
&$

&    (  * < $"  &"
 
%   &  $ $&

&% $  %#
  " *""%*    %

&"
? 
    
 $%"
( )
&"
 $ 
%% &+ 
:
 )(
"&

' (&)<%&$
 <%!%%&( 
&$ 
     &

'(&
&   
 $%"
 ( *   $*""   
"" 

%  
&" )<% &$
)$%" 
""
"  * 
%&%
 " & ""$(  *
% 
  &

 
& 
)<%!%%&()   
&%%&
"
(  $
 
 
&  $%"
( 
 " *"+" ""&!
$  ""  
&"
%%&


&"
&&"!" *""*"     &
&"
 ( * 
  &  !%)&
'$
$( $
$(   !%(   (  && %&
 
$%"
   ( $ 
* ( & $ ""  
 $
 
&) **    $
$((  $ 
   &+ 
%*+$%
 
$     !% A%



&"
&&"!" &
'$
$(* 
 *

 %,*"##.%-     !%   &
$
$(  ; %
A " 

&* 
"
&+ 
"
& +"   "
A
 
&    "
A
     " "$    & +")  " ( 
"
& #  %  & +" ""&$%
 
&   
&  $"$&*  "
&%)"*"        "
< 
  
  +  %
)   "  I( &%&
 
F I( 
%&
 
F) $
( 
" $ %
   0
& A
 &  

*" 
 &"
  &
&*" ""'""* "
 "*&* ( $ 
 $%
 
) 
( ""(   *""'$&

&% ) "*&* &+ 
"*"   %%
'$+ + (   +" 

"
%%%

& ( * "( &"
 %? 

+&    &  %
$%
 
!%'$
$(  *   $$
#*"&( ) 
& 
* 
&)( &
 * 

 
$%

)&  & 0
& "" 
&

*
&
 "
  &
& %%&
?  "$"$&

  0



 $%* 
*  ""% ""(  %/
) $
(      ( $%
 
    


   $  
 <  "$"
&$
 0 "
 $  &"" ( 
 " "%$
(   
"%$
$ &
 * 
  
* 
&  0
&+" * <   %$  
   
) 
 $ $  +  &   
* 
)&
 * < % 
 "

   $  
%#
     @
 &""
    & 0
& "" 
&&  " &
   $ 
 
  

" A" (  & ' & **
!   ""(     &" "
 ) *
 & 0
&**
!   ""  &  )&  "" 
&*
&
    
&"
 $ +" 
   * < $&

  0
 ( &&* " $&

 ""  ?  "$"**
!     ) &" ( 
  0
   $
  $

  )" &     
 &  
$%
 
  $
 
&)+" (  * <  "&$% ( 
 &" 
# %'# %$%"
) ( &

+" 
 &" 
%%&
'$%

) & +
  %"      4#
 
%"!
%%$%

! % $( $# %*) $ 4
! ?(@%  0
%
%# 
% 4 
%
  (
)@% 5%* 
. 
%%#?%%

! $$

'  
 )<  0
&
%%)A  
% %(7%

/
& (%3   "!"%#%?% (&8 $$ JC'

C %)5% @ !%)4%*   %"!
%% 
% 4 
% <D%7 60#%
/
( B) `ari Liberalisme Menuju Neoliberalisme     7 ( 2 ?


 @A769




* 
&A 
 A !" ( 

*  % "
,-&&* < 

 & "
"" &
 
$   

 ( &"$  

 < * 
  "&
* 
( 


 
%*

( 
   '  
* 
&( &"$   

 
  
&*   
 "&
   $   $%

# & "
)( 
  * < "*" 
 
%  $ *
# %%$ 
# 
$  %#
"  $! (    $& +" ( 
* < %&%
   "
   $    ( *
   
 !" "" 
* " *+  &  & "
(  
 "&


 ( &&$  

/
" %
/
 

/
"* 
 +
" &   
  
* 
& 
G""&&*  (  
* 
&(    
+  &"
G   *  
   

/
" 

 '$

 $  !%  ( & ""
 
 

   @%%! $&  &    %
"
% )  &  +
""&
 
%  
&* * 
 $&

 && "A   $ &
 * 
 & +"  

'

  ( 
""
* 
&    $%$&"+" &
)&  $   )
$
 

"
)   
& "
)  +    %
* 
& *  $ +     
 
* 
 "&  "&"

&$"    &%
&
  &  $  * /
% 
  

 
 

 &"

*"* 
%
* 
&  

  "&&$&    "&  "  $
*
&
 & "
 
 
$*"  ( )%
* 
&+" **   
* 
&  &  I'"%$
( F  %
* 
&
 '
 

* 
&  
)

" +
%
* 
&*
    + 
'+ 
  

   = %
* 
&& %$


'

  
* 
& 
 ** 
 $(&$"   &  * /
% 
& A%"

&
( 
  % "& * /
% 
& 
*   
 

" *
F 
F &
& * < 
 &"  & "

"*
  $
$ " 
 

 $*  $ * <  &
 $ $  <"+"*
 $   %*
 
 $ &<"+" +  & ( 

+  & 
" 
+&  % "&
* 
* 
$   **  $     
 & "
 
( &&*  %
* 
& 
* 
& 
   

*  %" &   &"*" 
 
% ) $  

"
)<    )  "$"& (        #%" %
"  
 

&"

* 
&+ 
= 
 " & (
" 
* 
&%
%%
)
* 
&

"
% )
* 
&$"*
  
* 
&
$
 
* 
&%
%%
( 
< 

%4
! 4%! !&
 "*" 
 
%  *"  ( * 
"*"       $
*
&"$  "*"   
%  (
""*"   & (    % 
 
 
  ( **  "*"    & (   

 ( &&$ " $  $
   *   
* 
&
$
( &&  "*"   
%     * 
  
 " ( $ 
" &   & "
* 
& "%
   & $$
#

)"  &

( ""&%&
 
$    "
G 

 

" *
"*" )$%

( 


%
"'
"$" %%&
 
"&

"
%  $


&"
 $ 
*"* 
&%
 
   &%
 
&
   +  " 
"$
$
     %
* 
&
    
* 
&

"
% ( & %$
$&

   $
( 

"

 
%   ?%%%<?
% 
   '  ( 
 

&"!"* 
+ < *    < 
 * < * 
(  

G( * 
 ""( *
$% 
 G  &&* < "
$  $ *    
* 


"+"* < 



"

 
%  $ &&*" +  & &+ 
*
&"  &(  ) $
 & 
 &(   * < 

"
 $ &+ &
 #%& 
" 
 
#"*" 
 
%     

& $ 

  
 
( &&  
* 

"
% * 
% 
  & & 
 
* 
&+ < *

 

 %$ ""  *%"( 
&



* **  ""  
#% 
  A""  
#     
&  " "  " $" +
 
& $  $ (  


   ""  *%"&

 & $  $ ( *
( 
  
&


  
<  "$"$
 ( 

&"

 
 $        
&&  

  &% 

* * 
  ( *
#  *
 &
  ""&
* 
    ( 
    


*" * 

* 
&$"*
  "*" 

*
 *
 &
   
%%&
(  &"$  $
 " & "*" " 
 $
$ %<    ( % * 
 

&(  < *

(  &"  
 

&( +
  "&( &("" %
  &
 +   &   &"*" 
 
% <  "$" 

& $ 

  
 
  % 
( &&$ (  %$  
( (    &"*" 
 
%  $
 
 $ 
*  %
* 
& 
* 


&&  &
%$  
**     
   
  

* 
)  
*" * 

   $&
   &  
) ( + 
 ( 
 $&
  "  

* 
& "$"%
* 
 & '  & &&#%"   ( $  +  & )
$
)

& 
% 
 

 
%  $(  $   **   !  
 )$*    
* 
& %
* 
&   * 
*
" %&* 
* 
&%
* 
&

%" & 
/
"
/
"(  *"  && (   )%&$%)% 
 
 "&
   "&  " "

"*
 "
  ( *
   (  *"" : 
&  &
  
  *
F 
F =A&"!"  

  &
&""
* 
&      
 &"    &
( 
& "
   ( * 

 $ $
( + 
$   

 $
 &
* 
  ( +  &   &" " &%
*   
( &+ 
 *  !%# $%< 
&
 
% *
$% )
* 
&%"

&
 
%   &    &"
$% <  "$"!%# !
%( *
!%%* 
% 
 

 
%     &&
 $   
* 
&& "$"%
* 
&

)
  &$ ( $$
#

&&$"(
&$" ( 
*"" %"
 &" "
$ 
 * <  $   
* 
 

+ 
 * 
%$""&! $
$
   
*    &
 (  $%
 
  *&*  A%$


 %
 ? 

&    $
$(   "* "$    !%    " &+ 
%*+$%
 
  !%  


 $
 " & +  &  %
* 
&( &  $   **  
"

 
(  (    &""   & +" &"
   *&* ( % *
  "
$  %* 
 
 $   **  6 
 

 
% ( 
$%$" % 
* 
$"*
 + 
 ( &"$  <    
* ""&&%
  
 !   & "
*
+  " 

% 
 
*"  4#
7

"!
) !% %
%# 
% 4 
%:

%   
 ! )< D%

 @ !%)4%* 5% % %"!
%% 
% 4 
% 60#%
/
( ! )<D%  '>B 'ealisme dan Neorealisme dalam Tata Politik Global     7 ( 2 ?


 @A76;

 4 
&)( 
&*"* 
$%  (  "&
 
 ( &
 
 )&&        %" &   &$%

"
A  &"$   %" & ) &  



 
&    &   
%   " 
"$   A$
  
% ( 
 $ * 
$
 

&"
&&* < $   $&  & * < $&
  *"&( & "$"  
( 
  $ 
  $  $"( A%



& 
*  $
&
& "& 
  $$ "   %&
&  &% 
 

 
%  ""&
 
%  ( *
# %

%    $ 
 &$
 *
 **   $
 /
   
 ( 
 "   "&
 
""&<"+" $ &
"
    &&*"  && "
 ""&
 
% )&  $ &
&"" 
   
 I$&
  F
 
% <"+" &
  ( 
& "* (    /
"   (      &%
( *"  
! $
%  * ""& &  $
 (    "( 
  %$   
   %$"%#$%<
&  
$    "&+ $
 (  !   $ $"
 $ +" &"$  " " ( < +   &$(
%#
  &

  
&&"
&  &

/
#
 
 
 
& 
)% 
&"+" %&$% 4 
& 
&"$   
 ( %&
 *"&/%"
 "& * /
% 
$    ' B      (  
& 
&"$  $  %& 
#  #%"$  

'

  $%

 
 &   
%   "   

4 
& 
 -"!(
 

  7 
*$%

)*""   &      $%

 "!(
&  $

 '$

  " & "/( *  ( 
* 
 <    ""&+   $%

" 
 +" &  * < $%

 &&$"(
%"
)*"&$""  

*" )% $&*" $""  "  
' 
&&

 &"
 %"
D ** 


   $

$ 
  
&   
&"""!(
*" $ " (  & $  &" $
 ) $
 &("
 $   
   &
"  ( **  *- !
/
 

  7*"  $%

)&$    &  ) " 
"$$%

  *
 "&"&  !
/
&  "   !
 ,
  "* -* 

"&" &    &&


$%



(
"&   

*    "&
* < "
   &$ ( + & 
"&""  &$
 
(   &
 * <  $   c   !
/
 "*    " 
! "   $
 

%
  "& *
 

'


 ( +""  &"
 $
    * 
 %" &   & 

 !
/
&  < $    $" " ( *"&+ 
 *
  ""*"& < & "  
" 
 (  &"
G&"" ( $
* 
G&+ 
 < $
 "$'&$
/  &
   $&
&$
 (  <
    <


& "% 
&  !-%& %** 

  7

 $%

)
&  &  )   $%

)$ &
 *  
 %**&&      &
& "
* 
  
&  % & "
    **  ( * 
& "
( 
 A  
" 
*""   * "   &"   * " 

&"
&
&*" &   * "   &  
  &
*
 + 
 &(* * 
  &  * 
  
 
 ( 
*" 
&  &  ) %**+" &(*" $+ +
,""&
 
% -+"   
$" "" &<"+"  &  "
<  "$"""&
 
% 


!
$  %     (   
$ "
 & ""&

+   $
    -% " 

  7 
&
"& )"   + & )&$   "" )  &    " 
"$)*
 $"*
 % "&&  & "
* 
*
  $%

(  " &+ "   , 
&"%&
 
-   &$%

) "
*     <
 ( $
* 
 <
 ( $"*
  % "&&  
 $%

* 
" "(   ) $
*%
    & "  $! $
*
 $"*
  4 
&A%&$%  4 
& 
G%&  !
 

  7 
& 
)!  )   * 
& &*

%)%
     ) &    " 
"$)** '

   &&+   c(    "*$

!   
   
( 
& "    $" "  &

""&  &&*"  < & " ( 
 

    % 
&GA? . *   
& 
( &&     
( * 
#%") % 
&*
&

*  $  ""
 
% * "
'"
(  
 
 
  &
&
" A   
 
$&

 * /
% 
&** '

)% 
& &"  $$
#
&

 &&*""  "&
 %
""&&$

 $
 "  * 

"&   $ 
%$ 
%   
 && " 
   
( &&*  (   
& 
     
% 
 $%


&   % 
&& *
  $%%&
)"&  " %&
!$%
!(   (  &
 !  % 
  $ &&  
"$ 
" 
  &(   !"$  $ $  
& 
)% 
&+" *  $ * < 
&
 
% 
 
 %  *  % 
&
 &(
  
$
 $   
& 
  ""


 ( &&*


$

 $  
(  *   &
&
"   !%#$%<*
 *" 
" 
"
( *
$%  
&  " "  
" & ' & * 
 $
  "
   &( $
 
 !   "  @
 
 &&* 
     
& % 
&)&  $  &( 
"  +"  ** ?  "$    ( % 
&I ( F&&*  

"* 
 
 $&

  
&)$   % 
&!"&
   " " 
 ! &   "" "
'"
( @
 * 
 
& "
   +  )&  *
 + 
&""% 


( +     
&  $ 

 *"  &"* 
&     
&
" 


 &&*
$

 * 

""&&

*
+  ( 
&*
  !    &
) 
&  &(
 + < * * 

$   %*   
&  

 $    (    "*"  & "  $ $"""&! $
$
 (  A*
 $&

  
& % 
&
* 
$&

 
(    * <   
& $ &+ &
! $
( $
  
%  $  "&"
 "    * *"&"+"% 
 

 
% !  I$"F  &""  (  $ 

 < 
    *
"&" (  
&&"" $(
%#
  +  &

( % *&   "
#  "&* %)5% @ !%)4%*   %"!
%% 
% 4 
% <D%7 60#%
/
( B) Masuknya China Sebagai Anggota WTO : Jalan Bagi Transformasi 'ezim WTO     7 ( 2 ?


 @970A

* !7 
 
!/ " &
%#;
 
<% (&)$!
( # !!
%
?% 6 
. 
% !%&&!
&  
!/%$<%

!
$
 ( # &<%#%
")
!"
"!
/  (
  #%& 
%%#
& $$% !  
* %%&!%!$


*"
%%#$%< !%"
& %*+!
/%#  
! %#

&$
! 
%%#;
 I !!
%
?% 6 
. 
%*%#% 
&
# #%
   %&
 $%<


& &$
! 
%%# # &<% 
!"%&
 (  
/#%
&F#""  A(<%7!%&&!
&) #%& 
%%#
&);
 F%* $%<)!

%#  %&
 
% ?6* 
4.
&    
%    &"  &! $
$
 ( )& "
 "&$" & "
  &
     & "   !  ( 
$"  &"  $%<( 
&


"" $
 ( 
"+","%#$%<- A
 
$   
&  $%<   & "  
")&    + 
$*" $
 (   &
&*"  %&$


  ( *"  &"
$
 $
 
""&& 
&   $
 ( 

"&
   
")
$"   ( " "$ " (  & "& 
&
$ %   &&
$
 (  " 

 ( 
*" * 
.
&  4.
&
 
%    $  $

$)%& ) "  $%"$ &*
  $"" 
&  

 $   %**"   &" "
"  * 
" "& 
& $ " ).
&&&$"(
&$ ""  ( 
$" ""&!
$    " 
"(
"$

$)%& ) "  $%$ &*
 $""   
=""
  )$

$ %&      

" &   ( " ".
&)  $"*  $   $

$ %& * 
$"*  .
&!  ""     $"*   "   $%"$ &*
 $""  (   &"*  $
 .
& $ &"* 

 ".
& .
&( * "    "  
"( * ( &
*  $&" $
 
$ %"*" 
 
%      $   )%  
"&  $   +" $"&&$"(
 .
&( & "& 
&$      %"*" 
 
% )*
   & "$" %
  4.
&$   
 
% 


<"+"   *  ?% 6 
. 
%,?6-( 


  "+" ""&<"+"  $   "
( ** ) 
 *"  ?6*"* 
 
 
"   " (  
#*%$ 
+  @ " 
 * 
 #%& 
 
5 & % 
##  ,5-( 
 &&$"(
& 
&(   ?6*&   * 
5/ ) <
  * 
.
&$   
 
% )?6&&$"(
$

$'$

$  (  " 
$ "
%$  % ( (
"&%'# /%" 
%)%' 
##& ") 
%   &) $ !() N" 
 
/
!
%,N"% - %& " & (     $"   &*  $   
 &

&&"
""&<"+" $   $   ( ** ) 
 *"  + *"
 

)?6& $  
&*  '*   )" & & %$

&&
  
 , -( &"$   "  %&
   &?6  ( *
+  ?6( 
*" *   $
      '  
"

(  %

    '  %$ &"
 ! &
 $  

%/&*

);
  &
&+ 
 % ?6  *"&* *");
  &+ 
"  
"
  
"$  (   
$
" % % ' % ?6)" &   &*
  %
 %&$"
 
  ;
 
$  %
 &
  
)>$    "  &+ 
 )J>$    A%
*"
;
   $$%"
%&$""

  
=>$   B&+ 
 >$  

  ;
   $% $%"
 
 "
+" 
 
 >$   B&+ 
B>

   
  '  
  ) $ 

 * < *"&* *" .
&$   ?6) ;
  &+ 
"  
"
( *  *$%$

 $ 
$  &
*
  &"

 ;
 * *" ?6)  '  (  & $  
" && &"
  ?6
"&   ! &  *   $&*  ;
  ( & 
$    ( ( &"
&"!"    $  & "( ;
   &?6   &&* < $"*  $  $

$'$

$(  & $ 
?6 
"&&$ "
 $%

 %&
 
  
?6   &&  
$&    

)$"
&"    


"
(   &+  *"$"*  $  .
&  


"


+"   
$" %$   #%& 
.
&&""6 D%"(   &+   * 
&  "  &% $ 
$   %"  ( * "&"!"  ""  


"
)
$.
&
*"*   $
  "+"  
& 
' & 
 % ( A
 "+"  $
 

*"* &  $

$ %&    *"*  @
 $

$ %& *"* )&  .
&

+" *"*  "*   $ + 
 !  /%"
% /%"
% "*  !  /%"
%  + 
*
 $"*   + 
  &%& ( &"$    *"( " ".
&) &"

*"
%%# $%<     % 
 &  &
$"*  ( 

#
   * 
( )$"*   /%"
%+ 
   

$%<   &.
&)$ 
  $
 & $ ""  *
*    ( & $ "" *
!
  "*  &"
  %&   
/
   &.
&
" 
 ( 
"
  $&&

""& &*
* 
  & .
&  +
  $*
"""""  
.
&&    (  "
* (   

+ "*
&   ?  "$"% '% &"") &"$
 ( 
"
 

&("" !%"'
&(   & &*
 
"   "  %&
  + "  

 ( 
*"  

$%<   


"



$" %$   #%& 
.
& 6 D%"  & 
( )4
&( &
!74
 c %# 
% 4
&)&+  * <  $"*  " ".
& $ + 
  % 


 & "$"# %   A% 


 

 $ *"$ %#
(   $ 

   "*"$  $&*    " ".
& A  

*"*   $"*    &

*"
% %#$%<)&
 ( $"" $%< %%&
      $  (  
*" )&  $"
* "&* < & "(  ;
 * 
 % &
?6  &&* < $"*  ( 

#
 $  ?6 * 
.
&$   )  
"+" &&* <  &$ $"*  $    
 %$ ,-* 
 % %&
   &?6  ;
 )   
"(   " A*    " ;
 " 
  

 "     $%%% $  &   I*
 ;
  $)* *+
 ;
 * ")
  &"! "
F    ";
 * 
 % ?6)&  ;
  "&("
 *
+   %&
 " 
(  $

$ %& (  
$  
  &  &?6) " & ( %& $
   &*   
#  &$    6  
")  &+   < "

='

);
  &""  
#%&%
 $ 

  >) "" %&%
 
"

 J)>  

");
 +" &+   $

$ 
%  &  &&$&" " 

/% 
  &$  & &% (  
"
"    & 
/
 $    $%%&
;
 @
 *"&( $&

 $%$
  %$% 
&+ 
&%%$%
$&
 )&  $ ! 

)$&

 %$% 

;
  *" ""$
 <   A*"   
&  
 
$%"( 
 " ;
 &&*" $%"'$%" ;
 & 
%&$

# &&* +

$  
 
% 
 &""
$%"   
"

( $
 )@$  
) $  
 ** 
&"  ( 
 $   &
&+ 
 % ?6 ;
 & ! &

  
"
 (  & $ *"&(   ;
  &#%"$%%&
(  
% $ 
,$
& (
"(-&+ 
%
"
& "# ",!% (
"(- +   ,
(
"(-  @
 

  
 ( *
& (   ( )$   "

B;
  $ 
   * 
 "  %%&
* "   ) $  
$   "(  & "$" !  $&* (  ( 
$%;
 &! $
 J &
( % ( &"$  




 "
  

");
  &+ 
0$%
* "+" 
&$%
*  $  ""$   *  ) & "  & $%
 
&$%
* ""*
  +    $
( 
"+" % *
* < 

* < $ $  ;
  &
 &+ 
 % ?6&
 * (  ) > @ "*



* 
     & +") $  
  *&* 
(   

 ( 
$  * 
 ! & * * 
    & +"
(    *"&( )  '    G

 ( 
"  ""&(*"  & +"G

 

( &" 
$   "

  $ &(

$*
+   $"
  ( *+  
?6)$
&
 ( $"
 
%  $! *" "*

 $ 

% ( *+  !""$ %  $
   ( 
 & "& *"  

   *&* G(  
"
< 

%
'""&! *""*

 $ 
  & +"   &"!"( ;
 * 
     ( & &$"&" 
$%%&
"
) &    & +" < 
*
 $
 ( (  & 

 & $ &"
 "
    ;
 $  
 (  * < $%"
"
(   & 

&+ 
I  & F    (  &+ 
" %&$

#
 ;
  &"!"
$     "/
( 
 " A &   %$ $  

C&"+" ) * ( :=>$%&    &$  
# 
* *"( ;
   &  % ?6)
 
 
 "

B(  ( &! $
=>  * 
  ( &"+" & +" ;
 &   $ $  @$     & +"
( $
  ) 
" &*  (  

"*"&(   
 $"  %$ &&*"
 * <  + 
$"" $%<"  %&
 (  

"
 
( "  * "( & ! &

"  %&
 
"  "*  

*"
%%#$%<

)&""  


"
)!  *  $   & 
*  $"*    &.
&
")$"*  ( 
*"* 
$"*   /%"
%  ;
 ( &< 

  *&* )&""  

$"
) $%<( 
&


  &&*"!%"
& & "  *&* 
( "" &&$+"  $"*  '$"*    $*
+  ( " &"" )(   
+    &$&*    +"( ) &&$" $%

 <         &$"
 
 & &$"&&*
 $     $  ( 
*
  %     " ?6( 4   $ ";
  !  "&"&)  ** $  " ?6( 
$ (  %  *&*  &"  $
$   %  & +")$
$%"$ &*
 $""   &"  &%%"
&  $"" 
       $ $    
 ""  =  % 
 $%"

*
&"$      & +""" &  *
+  ( 
+"   *&*  A&"
$&    "*

(   &+ 
*  $"
 ( " &! $
  $  
&    & +" &&*
 "*


  "* 
$ 
&  &"&&    *&*  ""&
  "*

* 
$ 
(   & +"+" &&*
 "*

* 

# 
"
  &  %% 
  ?6  & &$ "*


" 
 $"  ( * " " %
 
%   %


 ;
  ( *"&* '* &
  
/
$&
 )&  ;
   *"   &"*  & " #


  $"*

( 
& "   &$
 &?6  " 
( ( &+ 
$ 
;
    &
 #" &
   
% 
&;
 &  $!%&$
!  $

"
"$  
%        $&
  
"( );
 +" &  $"&%"
& 
&$(
 $

 &
 
 ;
 * 
   $%<( *   & $     * ( & $       $
( +" 
 &
%   (  
*   &*
 
$ " "( 

 %?6   
&$(
$

 ( &
*  * ( $ !    &("
 

;
 )    

* &*"
" ( &&$"(




$ !    "



%  $""
$ $ !  @"& ( 
 
&* *
 
* 
  :

 $"" ( 
< 

% $ !   ? +  "?6  $% #%& 
$

")  ** $  
%( %$"

"   ""& &*  I< + F?6$ (   
%$ & ) "  $%"  & ?6  *  $%

( & 
&""   *&*   "*  


   &"* .
&?6!  #" & ) $
*
   $"    "&"" .
&
"

  &
 (  $"*  .
&

) &  ( + 
   & 
&& ( .
& 
* $"" "  %&
 )   & 

  %$ A"  ;
 ( &"!"
   & &$"& %&% 
 .
&!  ""   ;
    
&"
( 
 &&



# "" &+ 
   &.
&
"   & 

 *
&+ 
   
# 
%

    '  %$  
( ( &&$"(
& %%
 <
& F*"( & 
* < 
&     '  %%
&  & "
( *
""* + +  (  
" &&$"(

#   ""I& (%&
F &" 
"
!  %*  $  
   & 
#
(( 
# '
# 

 ( &&*"  *
&"  * (  *
( ""& %&% 
.
&( 
$   ( ) " ( 
 
&


;
  " + # %
%



+" 
""%$
    &*
+  "  
( ""(    &&*"  % ' % 
(  
*
  &+ "  " & 

 &&  .
&
"

  
%"    $"*  #" & )  "( 
*"* 
$"*  /%"
% &""  


"
)(
"$"*  $

$ %& .
&!  &  (    &"* .
&
"!  ""   &
 ( $%

 <   *&* ) &  *
 + 
$

$  ?6( *"&(    # *"* &+ 
#
    #
 )&  $% $""  
#* 
  & +"   *&*   *
 
   
%
    &"!"( ;
 * 

$%& 
!  ;
 


&&


 ! !%*
*

* 
  &    $   $
   
(  *"
$%& 
(   *
&  $  % 

)
% 
& $

 
&  "  ," & &( "&   
< - $  
 
# ;
 ( &   &" &! 
% 

 A
&$"  "*  * '*  ;
 
*
 $%%&
(  
&"
+  O
% 
&&"!" ;
 * 
"  
"
( 
 
  *"&&+ 
 % &
?6);
  & &*
$ ( *   &$   "
 ?  "$"!  %%&
;
 & "
&%%&
$  )" &   * *"( ;
 * 
 % ?6) &"!  $%

 $%"   ;
 & 
&& 

'

%

  
# %%&
( 
 $  
 $%

)& "( ;
   &&* < $"*  $  $

$'$

$?6* 
.
& $    *"
$   " $  % ;
 );
  & &$"&&*
 $ "( * $   % ?6( 
)""( &+ 
!%"
&* 
 &""   * 
"  %&
  

 ** 
#     ( 
 &$
 *"&( )
 &*  ** $   
%( & &*  $

$"
 *  .
&?6
&  $ ) &   &


( 
+" $"
  & 

*"
 4#
7 %
& :%/&*

C  "?6);
 4"
  %$ $7EE!%%&( %.% !%&E
0 $$E4  %(E

CE

E :E EB: E& "'<%' !
 '"
 '%$ E& "'<%'!
 '"
 '%$ 
$   @"


 %
& 
% "*"    "
   4
% $ &
"
     4 ?% 6 
. 
%* 
&*       &<"+"  
* 
 
   "
$  ;G?%c !*%% A ) $ J=  
% 4
& %%7;%
/
(  

.)@%$

5%* 
. 
% F
!% <D%7? ? %%K;%&$ (  c" ()"


= ""&   
% 7$""& 
?6  "7;
  
(  
   
 & 
) 
5%* 
 
 %
 : $7EE<<< %&$  !%&E%&$ ' ! E B E E%% E BJC  & 
$   @"


 @ ;%)+ &


J  
% %

! !%%&(7!" 
%( <@(7 
!%
/
( @"!  )%  4 (&%c %$
 J:  
% 
&7%#%&
"!
/  (
 <D%7;%
/
(  4 D%")6  F4
&( &
!74
 c %# 
% 4
&F
 $ A ,-  
% 4
& %%7;%
/
( P ; )*%  ,-

: ;
  ?%  (&7
< 

"& <D%7; &*

/
( '>B Pengaruh Ideologi Juche Terhadap 'egionalisme Asia Timur : Studi Tentang Hambatan Identitas dalam 'egionalisasi     7 ( 2 ?


 @9704

* !7 
 
!/ " 
#"!
/*(%A% F
%%()3+"!8
 
 
% 
. 
%)$!
(%<*%%A% "! !

 
% #%
$%
!($ ( %
 

% 
&  
!/%$%&

!
$
 (# &<%#%
")
!"!"
( %(*(  
% 

(%(*("!  
 * %%&!%!$
%!%) #
!%#
!)
  !%#
!)

(  #%
$%
!( %*+!
/%# 
!
%#

&$
! 
%%#%A% #%
 $%
!(  $ %# 

%#%
% 
. 
%!%"! &$
! 
%%# # &<% 
!"%&
 (%"
%%#""%#
%  A(<%7 

%) 
% 

()+"!)"! !

)
% !%%&() 
% 
. 
%

 ""   
(  

,;%? -&&"!" $"*  * * 
"

 
% )   
&" ( 
% 
&)$"*    %%&
%*   #%& 

&
 
%  4
% 
&*   
  
%( %4 /

*"* 
 %"
%
( &&$"(
 % &
 #


*  ( +  4
%

 &"
'
% 
 
)
"+" %$
  
  " %%&
  *  '*  % #
( + ) &+ 
" "
 ( 
*"
% 
&  4
% 
&

 +  & )$ &
)
 
( "&"&( 
*""  &   % #
 A+  & )
 
 $ &
( &"$    "!
 
 
% 
&

&"$  *" $

   
* 
( 
&*    &   
* 

"
% 

&  

"

% &"$  $ (  ""&<"+" 
 
 ( %&$
#    
* 
 


&  *
 
$  &
* <   (  & "%

&  &  &
"
  $%
% 
 
 

&"    <  ( "
 D 
& " %$"
 

&"   " "
 % #
( &
$"
  @$ );
 )%%
)A%    ,A%"-)A%    ,A%- 
<    

&" "&*7<<< %%( !%& D "



   * 
&  A%   * 
  %





%    %%&

* ( *$ $  

) &"A%"


 $ "% 
* 
 
  '    (   "&"* 
( 
&


A%"   
%%
+"!(   &"
 

&+ 
 "&" & ( & &* 
% 
 
 

&"  +"!   "!
** 
*
+  " 
A%")""( 
% 
 $    $%
# 
"
  @"!   $ " " & &%! 
!%$F4$"*
!%#A% ,4A7A%   -(  
!
$  %A
& "   ( * < $&

/%"
 $&* "      (    &
"&
( )$&
 A%"&  $
( ; +"% ,& -  & *$%

 %%


 ( &&*"
&%%&
A%" ( #
! $   ( ##!  +"!( 

)A%" (    & " $   !  *  )<  "$"*" 
  &  
) *"    
 &&$" $   (  !  '!  ( %"

 
% 
 $ * 
!  ( $%/% 
#  ?  "$"!    

 
% A%"&"$    %

( ""$) &"  &  


% )

&"* %    '  ( && %

  & *
 
"
 $     !  "* 
)

&" &&"
(  '(   &"!"( 
% 
&)(  '(  

 $ 

   &** 
$$
#    &$$
#% 
&)
&
 
% 
$  * 

&(   
) 
&       
 * " 

( &&$"(
 
% 
 

  & &&*  *
+  " 
(  A  $
  $
&*  (  ** )
$  &&"" * < #$   %"
*

 
% 
&  +  & 
% 
   ! $
<  "$"  $ & $
  6  
" 
$" &%  " *

.""&
&" 
&"!"( 

"
 +  &  
%  A*   $%<

 ( 
  %$$
#% 
&  

&"!"(  ""  * )&  "  
"  & &$"&
&$%*"( 

"
& "$"%%$ 
(  
&""   @
 *  $  $$
#(  
*" *"&( )&   "( *   @$  ;
 


&"  &&* < $  
 
 &"!" 

"
(  " )&
 "  %%&
;
  @$ (    *  
$
"   &(

   @
 

  
 ( *
& (   ( )$   "

B;
  $  
   * 
"  %%&
* "   ) $  
$   "(  &  "$" ! $&* (  ( 
$%;
 &! $
 J &
( % ( &"$   




"
  

");
  &+ 
0$%
* "+" 
&$%
 *  $ ""$   *  ) & "  & $%
 
&$%
 * ""*
 +   &

 (  @$ )$  

5@$ &! $
 =) 
(" &"$  $ $  * "  &
  
 , -  $
 $  (  ( )
 
 +  & 
% ( & $ *"&<"+"!   %)+
  "  
" ( &! "$@$ );
  A% *" 

&"!   ""   A   
 


$"* <   %
#"
% 
( &(*" * <   <  (  $ &&"

 
    
  &(   "*&*    #+  & $
%/
  
( !
$ 
 
 <    
$    ;
 '@$ 'A%( &! $
C+" % (    &&*  %%
  A%     &
 
" "

"

% ( & $  @
 

  
$&   $ $  ) "(  

&"&&$"(
&% ( !""$""$    
% 
 
  +      

&" 
#*
!
 
 <   
( )$
( 
+    & **
"   ( ( &"!" 
   ** $ $$
#
    &&+   
% 
 



&"    $  +"!( & 
 $
 "A%"       "# %( *$   &
 

"

% 


&"   & &+  $&    

)$"
*   $  %
 ! &  &  
% (  
" $ % ! & $ &    *  !%#$%<!%
&  "   *   & <  
*   &%&$

""&" 
 $' $"
  +  & $" *
  ! & ( "     #
!%#
!
&   ! &   &  *   
$&    %       & <   ! & (  
   %#

   & "   % ( &&


$%
""&&$ "
 "*"    
( &&


"*" 
  "  $%#
) ! & 


*"
  !%#
!  
$&*     &  %
) +
 +"!+"   
$" % $    $
( 
%%
 

  
%   &*
+  " 
    $   %
%%
)

/
" %&$%&$
 *"" &    $ #


& "


 %
 
 %


 ( &" * 
&   " "%*+&&$ " 

( 

 &&$ " %*+
  &"*"  "      
$%


/
(60#%)4%("! )

  
%    &" $
  
% ( &"
  &&$%"
*
+  '*
+  "  
    %


&  $"
* "&* < +"!      " $ &* &"!"( 
% 
&

&" 

@"! * 

  
% A%    &$
 
(  $
(  
*" *"&( )* < 

  
%     *$ " $  *
+  " 
" "  A%"&&*"

  
% ( * 
   %

( &" &  $&" *"" ( 


 

)+"!)&"$   & 
# 
 
  

/
"$&
&$
( )A
& ")(  "&     
/
 
&   A%  $"" @$  A  
*"&

)&  "" +  < "(  & A%"   $*

* 
  %

 
 &
& 
 
 


'


* 
 
( *"  
*  %$
  
  
  
% 

$" ( &&*" A%"&&$  

( * 
&"" 

&$

&@$ )I  *% FA%) I$
 (  "! &$"  F  @"! 
*"A
& " "+"  < ""&

 A%"(  " & &$" &&"
*"" %%&
& "$"&




 
 &&" ! &$"   
   (  
*" 
   % 
%%&
 $%
# 
"
A%" * ( * <  


  
% '+"!'


  
% 

)( %$"
 
 &*  * 
*!
A%"  $
%@$ 'A%' )  &""$$
" +  & A%" 
   *"  $   ( +  & )&" 

% 
 
  $ <"+"  @"!( 
 
 %*!
A%"  $    ( )+" *
&$
 
$   
% 
A%"  $"
"  A%"
 &&$    ( $
&    +  
  
)  "$"  "+" )"+" 
"
# (  ( <
  &     "& "
 
$%"(  )
  ( 
 *%*$
%  

 * 
(  '$ 

"  *   $

$
 
 
&   &*  G% #
& "$" 
#$   '
"$ (  ""&

&&"
  
  
% A%"* 
  %

( 
 &   ( "
 
%  ;%$% 
%,;-+"    " ( & &* 
* 
 

 <  
"    "*" / 
; &
   
*  
  ) &$ * <  
 
/ 
 (  $ 
+    *   ;)&   
/
 %%&
( 
+   A%"
 &&*" +  * 
  (  ;)(    ( $&
   $&
 
(  


   &+ 
 &   * 
*
 "*" A%" $&
 
 (    "*" (   &%
  &"( &+ 
&      )  

  
% A%"&&$     ( * 
&""@$  A%)&  $   ( 
  $   & 
% 
 
  + " 
(     &$ %
# 
"
A%"  $%%&


&"   %
(  
*"    " ( & &* 
% 
 
     (  #
!%#
! 
 
""
*  )
  $%/% 
#A%"


* *  %#
 & (  "+"* 
   A%" A%  & A%   ' :  !  
)$ 

*"&* 
  
( $  ( 
# 

 
% !  +   *"( &

 
.P%,P- A%#


 (  " & 
 *"( +"!%A
& "    *  

)&   $ 

  * < $%
# 
"
A%"&"$  * 
 
!  A%"""*%#% 
    ( )A%   
 <  )"
 %

  ) &*     ( %#
    A%'A%"( &"

"*"  +"!&

A%"( *"$ ( &%! 

 *
 

&" " &   %#
"   

&(
*  @$ ) ;
   @$   ( &&* "A%*"$ (  ""&
  "
A%")" &    ! & ( 
*
 %"
A%"
&  $  $
 " " A%" &! $
$
 @$   
( *"  
*
 
   

 
 
""%;
 ( &&$"(
$
    A%" A%#
A%"' A%)( 
   
+
 A%"*
""&&$   +"!( ) &+ 
   
'& 
"  * 

&")@$  ;
 )( *
 "   

  $**  $  &)
 
 
% 
 
 <  !  ""
   <"+"  
#
 
" A% &"$  * 
$
 

 
 <    
 

   <"+"*
  % (  $*

 
( 
 
  $
 
 $   ( &"$  $ (  &"!"( 
% 
& $ 

   & #
 *
"7  
 #

  )
 * < /%"&$     " A% & 
&
    &
$ "(    ( &
 

&"$   
 
 <  
"
 5 "(  
$*   "            & <   %"
$  * 
   <   &
% 
 
 
(  *
 $%

   &$%%&
"   
 
 "*" " A% &&     $%$   A%$   < &*

J) <  
"
5 %
""$!   $
 %$&
 A%"
  " 
*"  + +*   & <  
"   
( " * "

*
 %( +
 A%" $&&*  "
(  
$  A%* 
 ! &     "
( 
&*  A%"    & 
# 
 

%%
+"!( )&  $"
 $ &(
&$" * < 
 
  
% 
& <   $ <"+"*
 A%"&   +"!( A  +"! 
  
%#
" A% )&  %"
" & * 
"   "
%
    &
   #
!%#
!( &+ 
  * 
&" $&     
 "  A%  $ &($  
  ( %

 
 &
)&  +"!( 
$ 
A%"* 
 $%& *
 
"" ) *
 +"!


"" &  
      
$%
# 
 "
 
% 
%%&
( 
 " A%"
 
 
 <    *
&"   
 
  
&  $%
# 
"
A%"&&$"(
 &$ ( 

#
   $$%%&
 

&" $ 

  
   "

 %( (
"$    &   &
(   A
 &
 ( $"!" " A%"$  =@"


J ")  &  &
( &%+  
 
  C% $* &
$"$   

"$     &
& "A% 
 &"+" $""  + &  
$  *$ $ )  "
/%* 
 &
/ 
&  %"&& &*

 $&""  $$&* +  *+"& * )

&"
  &&$ "
 +"%%&

%  A  "




  *
  
 
*  *
 +"&&*"")  &&*
 $ "*
* * 
 $   &%
  &$ ( *


#
 
"+" %*" @$ )""( 

 %(% %)( $   



&  &
$""    &$  
&
 (   < 
 &
$&*  %

 &  
<
 ( 

&" A%" &"!" %(   & 
"+
!%* &

 
"+"  
A%$
 A%   
;
    
  '  
  ) $ 

 * < $%
# 
& "$"$"!" " A%"(   * &$ $  
 *

 %%&


&" ?  "$" &$ ( 

&*" 
 

 & &"&$" % $%%&
    ( "  * ( & *
 ) @$  ;
 ) &"+
  

"* +"&  *" 
 &"
*
  *

  %%&


&"  & 
 *
 % $%%&
   &*  * 
 
  $%/% 
#( 
 " A%"

&"$  & 
# 
 
+"!( 
$  A%" A%"

&"+" $  "
* <   ( &&


$   ( "   
 *
 

/
%$
  
)  & 

@$ )A%   

") $"!" " 

+" &"$     "!  A%"""&
"$ "   %%&
( (  !" 
* 
% 
 $&*  "
( &&  *
( (  
 

 A  +"!( &  #
!  &*
 %%&
)A%"
 *
   '  &&
 * " %%&
  "$"&&*" $   (  **   6  
" 
&&$"  "


* 
* 

$%<""& $   $ ( 
*"" (  $  "I&     F   

 ( 
& " $"
 +"!* 
$ &* 
% 
&
 
&"  +"!( 
$ A%"&&* < $  $%
# 
"
( & ! &  *
  &  & "$"%%&

%  @"!+" &""$$
"$       A%"    <  )*
  
% 
A%"& "$"  &* %(  
*
 $
 " )
 
 
( 
  $   & <  +" ( 

  &"
""<"+"  " + +
 &"+"$  %
(  
 &$
 
*"&( )
  <"+"( 
% 
&

&"*" 

>   %#
A% ) $
+"    # %%!%)(
"%&$

   @$  ;
 ""I&" 
F
 *   "
$  
+
 
""+  )&    * ( 
&" %#

%
   @$   ;
 )" & 
 $"" @$ 
;
  $*" $" " $ (   &"( &+ 
#%""
 

*
* 
&  &'&  &A%    &&$ "
   
% 
&

&"  c %
 ( 
 &$
  +"   $  A%"   
  !%#
! @"! 
  ( &&$ "
*
+  A%"" ) $
+" &&*"*
+  A%"   &
(  
# 
  A
& "
 &(
 "  ( !""$ ""$&

 $
/ 
A%"    $%$
    &

    
/
  $%%&

"!   %   &  
% 
&
 
  $  ** # %$%"
)
&  
  &( & "
) " ( *    *
+    &
A%"( 
 &&$*% <    ( *&
 
 !  **   

")+"!+" 
 &(
 $ $ &% 
( && 
$   &% 
 &
  
$

/
%  %* <  "$"&% 
*" (   &" !
$ ( 
% 
&
"

 A&

  
  ( 
 &
 (  A%", %%-+" &+ " &  


  $&

 ""&    +  &    
 A
 **  ( 
 &
 ( A%")"
 "&
 
 )+" &&*
 &$ * 
$  
  
 <  )
   & $%$   ( 
 "  
/
A%""&%% ( A%"&"
  .
&A
& " " " & $  

& 
&+  * < %#

   & 
A%"+" &"$     "$ &* 
% 
&

&"  A
&$"  
  
% A%")+"!)   # %$
( &&$ "
*
+  A%"* 
 " & "$"  & @"!


&&$  @$  A%* 
&""" & 

A%")+" &"$  * "   ""$%/% 
$%
# 
& "$"$"!" "  A%")    " & 
% 
%%&
( 
 $ A%"    %
   &*  &"!"( 
% 
&)% 
$%

A%"(  &&"
  
: "&
 $ &* 
% 
& <  )(
" #
!%#
! 
   !%#
!  "&(
 $&    

)$"
& <  ** $  
% 5 #
 !%#
!

&")  & 

%#
A%"'A%) " $ 

 "" &<"+" 
 
 <     
%$ &    "
#
 
A% ( *
  
<"+"  %$
& 
 
$ ( "  <  
"
5 %  %$
& 
 

")$"  " A% & $  & # ( *  
5 %
 &   $ & $&
 "   ""& 

$

  @
 5 % &&*
 %
*"
( 

#
   $5"   )&  $&
 +"    &&$
&*   (  & )(
"%


  "*  "
#
 
" A% @
  " A% 
 *
 * "* 
   )
 '
 ( " A%  $ 
"$ * &$
 * 
  (  &
  
%" ""&<"+" $ &
A% &

 
 <      $"  $ " 
A%    " ( 
%+% +"!   A% (  & 

 $ 
/
 @
 A%*
&" 
$%
 
  ( )*"  
 &"
%


 *  "
#
 
" A%  $ <"+"  * 
 
  )A% $ &
  $      
 <   


$  @$  ;
 * 
   $     
$"    
%
     
 $" ( +"!* 


  
% A%"  A%"*
&
& 
* 
 
 %%&
 *
& ! & &  @$  A%* 
    (   
%
 

 ( *
 * 
*
    " 
"  
%*"&(   * 

       *"
'*"
 $& $  ( 
 &$
 $"
) 
$" %%
  ** $  
%
  )&   &


$"
* < +"!&"$      "# %$ &* 
% 
&

&"*"
  # "  7 %
& F+
!%* "!" ""A 
A%   F 4 
%
<  
%  
 $   B@"


 %
& F

  &
&  QA < 
 A%

A &  

 
&"F 
*
.< B


 
$   B@"


 ;G?%c !*%% c
4
% 
&
?%%

! 60#%
/
(  c
F<4
% 
&7%%"F ,-)<4
% 
& c""%# !"
(/%$&)% = %%7 !&
  
  )
IA%"
 A%
 %$   F  
@"  
%  
 $   =&*

J 6##
!
<*$ %#&%! 
!%$F4$"*
!%#A% ,4A- $7EE<<< % ' $ !%&E
$   C@"


 4 A <
  )4 IA

"
A%"""@"  F 
/ < B


  
$   B@"




4 /
)@% 4
% 
& <<< %0#%0*%% !% "E%!E /
 E 4%
)! ,-

C A%  !"
(
 ; 
 
?$%7 5<%%"*

5%"$! R* "&)c


= %

! !%%&(%#4
% 
&7; %# %" #
! <D%7  / !&
   )( FA%    &&$%/% 
A%   F  

 & 
$  

 @ " 


  ?%  6 
. 
%#%!%%&
!;%%$ 
% /%$&,6;-

!%%# S!  S

J P ; )*%  ,-

: ;
  ?%  (&7
< 

"& <D%7; &*

/
( '>B Aksesi Iran ke dalam SCO : Potensi Geostrategis Iran Menghadapi AS     7 ( 2 ?


 @97*A

 * !7 
 
!/ "   (

<%$%

! $%<*(! !"  $%
$%<<
*(+%

  
;%%$ 
%6 
. 
%, ;6-  ;6  ; 

# & (%

! 
 F$%<$!
( # N"!%# !%%&
! !
%
/*(  
!/%$<%

!
$
 (# &<%#%
")
!"%$%

!%(%#  
4/%"
%  !
F%$%

! %( %*+!
/%# 
! %#

&$
! 
%%# I !!
%
  
 ;%%$ 
%6 
. 
%*%#%!"
(#%$$%
 
#"! #%  
% !%%&
!/%$& &$
! 
%%## &<% 
!"%&
 (  
/#% F<% 
!
!%&$% (<%  A(<%7  
;%%$ 
%6 
. 
%)%
  ) ); 
  ""  "*  % 
"
$ ! 4/%"
 &  C)$
""( 
 %/
)/ 
 &
  
 , -   &  < %%
& )  
 $ "     &+"& * 
  '     &&*"   ( ""( * &  


&   $
   ! &  &  
* 
 $
%   

 A  & 

$*""%** 
 
%%&
( 
+ "    *
  $%
# 
"
( 
&*    ** 

  (  
 $ * 

  %#% 
#$
$& %+   
*  &(
  "  $%

* 
%%'%% ( & 
 


   &" 

& $  +"" * 
 0
%#/
  
%%&


!   "& "$"
  " & ! &   %%&
     &4%"
 C:C "

B)4%"
: @"


B) %"
 C=C   = 

C&"   
&
 ""& "  $   +  +
 $ $" 
"
 &(
 *  * "* 
  4%"
' %"


+" &
$"
$&*"      $&*
* " "   A   
 * &* *

 $  $&
  6* & ) &&$$ +  
%%&
( 

$
( 
 &*  %$ 
* < 

)
&   **    "  <
 ( '<
 ( ( 
%"$ 
% $
# 
   
 
* 
&"( )     "
 *

* *  (  * 
# %
  &&*"  &
 $
( " "<  (  $ &
&$" "    '   <  ""&" 
)+
 
 *
 &
  !   "" ) 
  
<
 ( *" ?  
"
  "**"$   $   &

) $
( *
$
   * 
&  <  
" $ &( &     


 
*  
%%&
( 
* " %   ** 
    
 "

 %
&  !  %$%

)$%

% #
   &""  
 * "  )  

*   .*
+ )4"
)"&
 ).*
 )  A .  ( &&*"  
;%%$ 
%6 
. 
%, ;6-$   @"



  
  ;6


 ""&
  +  & %%&

 <  " 
 
" &
  $ " 
 <  
"  
* %   &  $

$
 (  

"*"&( ) ;6&&*
 $%

 
* 
   &+ 
  * 
%*/(   &"*  "
"&+ 
 % &
  & < "    ( ( &"
&"!"    $   
  ;6  
$  * 
 % 
( &&* <  &$ $%
( &"" * 
   & &&*"$ " ( & 
&" 
" 
  &&  

 

)$"
 &   $

( $   $ (   
 $    
(  ;6

+ "  
$&

 %$%

 !
    &$&

 %$%

 
) !
&(*"" 
* 
* 
$
$"  "
 
$ $"( &" 
    &" 
"
?
 ( '<
 ( 

) & " )&&


  "; $
   "  $

 ;6)4"
)&"$   $ 
 * "
  A .  &&$"(
!   &
(   (    " )
 :&
( *  &"$  "  
 
!   
 "    A   )$"  &
( A .  +"    $"  &
( ( * 
&  
"
* 
 &
$%"
 "
 $ 

   & *
* < 

 5 #
;    "
,  &
( &:- !  &% #
)$%<( 
&


 ;6!""$"  +"& $""%  )B &
(   &$
  
+"& $""""      $    !

  )( 
*"
  (  "&* ( (  
&



 ) 
" (  

 ( & " )J&
( *  &
(    "  %&".'! &$
( 
 "
%= >$% &
( G&  $"
*  $ * <  
   & ;6  &+ 
% 
 (  &$"  &$    
" 
 A+  &     '  
  ?  "$" ( *$%

* 
%*/) &"  &+ 
+  & (      '   %  ;6  "

B) &    
$   *



 &
( %  ;
 ""$&*  "&*&
( D  /     &+"   &

%%5;
 ""  "$ 
" "

B ;
 +"   &&*
 
/ 
( * ""$&* " 
# ""  
+
+" &+ 


$& %+     $   &

*   
"&&* "$&*   %%
&

 & "
'%'
&

)"# !'%'
&

)  
'
$$
!"
 &

 "*" " ( " * " & )" & +   ' 
&   ;
 &+ 
 %( $
  &$(
+    ;
 &+ 
  "*" (   * 
+  & <  )""( 
  !%% &&*
 "" +    $ 
   $  
<   "*"   4"
+" * "*
    "

B)$"  &
( 4"
 "%
 $"  &
(   A . A &"
 & <  +  &    
%

;%&$ (,;-""$&*  
 &
( 
 "A $
   $  '  
 ) &

*  $    '  (  &&$"(
  *" ( $
 +

  # 
   )<  "$"!   ""  
( +" &! "$.*
  &
 &

*  $   $&* " 
# ""$
$&* "  " . *(   &"*"  * 
"      
 +

  
"&(
 %
% 
;
 & "

  &"+""
  @" &&* "$&* 

%

 +

   
/ 
% C

+" %    

) +" &&* "     $
&"+"  ""&&$&"  $% 
*   
4"
);
  
 &< 
  (   & "
"
 @    $

) #N'  )
* "$  

="" &&$!$ $+    

 "
    "&
  .*
 +" "&
 
 &! $
= +" % $  

B C > $"   +" &&$"(
 %$< 
 
.*
    '  
 

&&* "$! $
"
  !   &
   +" ** $  
&+ 
 &
%  &$

   '  
   %

  
5%$%


  
A &    
$
 ;6   * 
*"##  && &* $
  "  &

 
 
  
"&"
    
    &&$  $ " ( 
 $ 

&"
 
 ;
 &+ 
+  &  
 &

 "   

( 
A((. $  

""&!  &$"
    * *"  & ;6) 
 $"&  +   *%#% 


       * 
( &"$   %  ;6$
;
  4"
+"  &&$"(
$
 "" (   

    
* < &"+" * 
&    % #
  '  I&""F &"!
   
   6 
 


&% 

  ""&+ 
%*/ &% 
 
 "" &" 
 
 &

 

   A$
 

 $ 
   * 
&
   &   ;6).*
   * 
&"
   "  
<
 ( ( A" ( &

  
.*
  &&$"(
 
(   $
* 
   $   "  A 
'A  * 
 .*
    $   "!
* 
$ "  ""& "   # 
   * ( 

   +" &"      
%   )A((. ) * 
<
 (  "'
 "   $

*  *  ""&%$ %$ 
&


 # 
    " (   
.*
 &    &" 

 *

 $%

 
<
 (  $*    
"**  (  &   "

 "&
&  +" $"


# 
   

")+  &   
 +" &! "$+  & 
*
  $&*   $  %* '%*     = 
B"" & $

& %* '%*  
  
# 
 %$ $ 
&< 
 +

  "&
 ( &"$     

   $   
$   %* 
  &+ 
   ""&* $& " * 
 <  *"    
 
%6##
!%#" ;
&) $ $   
$   %* 
    C>5 <  
"$  

   * *"  &  
;%%$ 
%6 
. 
%)  $ &%% $(""$ %*   &"+"# 
 
 +" &  
$(""$ %*      (  A
&$" 7 
 )*
  &   ;6  "$"*



)&&$"(
 
(     
* 
 )*
* 
"&*
& "$""" $    &  (  
 $  
$%

%$%

  '  
" A &  

&
$"
 &   
%
&) %* '%*    & "$" ! & 
/ 
 
 A &  ( 
 $ +" &(" $%%&
6  
") 
   & ;6&"" 
%$"
&&$"(
 $%* *

 ( 

""&+ 
#%"% 
   &


(  
+" $"
  & +


*"
 4#
7 %
& <5 5 &7(5%' (; 
 %%")
! 

C   
!%%#S "

J12 4&%)?7
!%%# ;%$% 
%  @%;%0)?

&

C ? ?
%"?
G ?
 $ <<<
#%& 
%! 
%" # 
*
)A /  $ (; 
!  <<< 
& !%&
$   @"


 %)@ 4 : %"!
%%%

! 5% $()%%74%"  A )
! 

 6
)5%$%

!) ;%&
? <
   <<< %* $%
!(
! % <<< %.% !%& <<< " 
 % <<< 
& !%& <<< $"*
 %
 !%& '>B Neoliberalisme, Solusi atau `ependensi? : Studi Tentang Kegagalan Neoliberalisme di Amerika Latin Oleh Maria Elysabet Mena     7 ( 2 ?


 @97*;

* !7 
 
!/ " %<%
* !%%&
! (<  $$

 
&
!  # !


 J )$!
(
&$
! 
%%#%
* $%
!(
 
&
! F!%%&
!  *

(  
!/%$<%

!
$
 (# &<%#%
")
!" $!(%(  0
&$$!
/  * %%&!%!$
$!() 
* 
. 
% !

 %*+!
/%# 
! %#
<%
* !%%&
!

(&
 $$%$
% $$

 
&
! &$
! 
%%## &<% 
!" %&
 (  
/#%
&F#"")$!
(#% 
% 
&!%%&
!(&  A(<%7
* 
. 
%)$!()!

) 
% 
&  ""  &
    &"$   <  ( 

 
   )
&  


  (        
&
$"

 )%
/
) .
);

)A%%&*
)" %)  " ()") "" () ."  6  
")&
    +" *


*"* 
 &
  
    '  &
  
 "&*78!%" 8
!%%#S "

J12 4&%)?7
!%%#;%$% 
%)

C *
!   &
  
)&  "&"&( ( $ &  

     <    
&$   +  (   

 

")$  & 
%
  '   
 <  

  &
&  *  

< 
 .
&%
 
(   " ) %  
"* (   $ ( &(*" * < %%
 
&
  
 (  &"$  $
"& "* 
$%
 
 
%% %
 
*
 

")
/
  $%
 
+"    
$
 " ( &
"
 
* 
 
$     $&* " 
# "")
  ( "&* ( ( 
&


  '   &
  
 ." )
   .
&"$  + "$
$  ( &"+"&
     4   
"
 
)$
&
  
 , - ;
 *%&* '%&* "" I&" 
F <  

 &"
& $  &*   
$    

   
$&* " &+ 

 %
 
 #
#  "&  
*   $&* " )  '  &
  
 A 
*
 &&* "  
"*
"

&$%( &"$  *"$ $ & 

& 
&  
/
$&
   &$  
 
% 


&"$  +  *
"" &! $
$
  
%   

&


 *   &   

( + 
 $   <  J &&*" ( 
     $$
#%
* 
&&"  A

 %&



$$  %$ &*  %%&

 
% ( &


""(  
&%?%%)   & !" $%%&
&
  
( $     C &"
$ $  ( 

 
% 
"" & "# " @
 $    " C % " " 
&
  
&! $
: ):&
( % &  $   


J )" '" 
" &! $
=: &
( %  %+  " 

&&*"  ""*" &
  
 &
&*" 
# 
(   

)*  
%
/
 &! $


>      
% % (c",c-)?%   )&
  
 &"*  
%%&
( &+ 
 
%
* 
&  "" $%%&
'$%

 (   &"
  *+    &%
%$

$'$

$%
* 
&( "    &? 
%;%")&
$"


$
#
 )$"  $ + )" 
*
+   &%)**  * 

/% 
)$&**   ""   $
/ 
 
 
 
 &" *
+  

   * 
&  +  & "
 $ 
<"+" & "
 $&**  

/
" 

$   A& 

/
"  & 

 ( *
 


+ &
& "
  &*  ( 
 
 $ "   $ &

 $
* 
)$  **  $   **    ( ( &"!"&"
    $  %
* 
&( 
 $ * 
 $ 
& 

&&"$  %"
( $ * 
&
  
"" $ "   


( & !" $%%&
) 
"&&*  $%%&
 &
  
  &"
(  $
 
   && +
$&    

)$"
 &"  %
$
( 
&*  %c % ; %%)c %)  %%
%% % %


&&* 
"
&+ 
" * 
)  !%(  &
& 
 &$ $%

# 

"

 
   $
$(( *

 
$%
 
%  !% A*   ,"/%$&-*" &"$   
 
 & (   ( %'&%) $
*   +""
&*  %$ 
  $
 
&)" &   &
 (    $
$(   $
$(&  &
 "/%$  /%$&( * "
  !% %


+" 
$"  %$   %/
% %%&
%

 
% ,-)& 0
&)( &+   * < 

&"$   ( *
 + 
  &
& $
 
  +"(    &(* * + 
( *%%& *"!(!    %
(  
 &$
 )&   $"
&&  * < %
* 
&*" %"
( $ * 
&
  
   $ %
* 
&
&
  
 %
$
&"$  

 
&%&

   4%%<( &  $* <  "//%$&&"$   
*  
" ( 
*  " "    & $   %*  @
 &"+"$  &%4%%<)&   "( 
* 
 
 $   ( 
 " &
  
)""(  .
 
 )   $  &&* <   '  

$&* " ( * +" )&  & (   (   
&

 (   & 
 &
+ $"" %%
 $%
 
 "& %
 
"& &*  * 
&    ( 
+" %&%4%%<G(  !  
  "&"+"$    %
* 
&G$"
  &"
 
&  *
+  ( 
&$"&
  
  
( 
 $    A*
+  $ &    
* 
 

&$%  "*
"

&$%)$&
 &   $&*   
&$%(     "  %&


"
 
%&$

" 
 
  $ & "  %&%
  & %&% 

 "$ *"" 
  ( &(* * 
# 
 
* 
 
)%$% 

+"   &$
 **  
 $&
 
 *
 ** & "  )
# 
&&  $ 
 
 &"*"" &  &
   "  %  &% ( 
 * $" """
   A+  ( 
  $ (  
 "
 (    +   *""& 

   A*
+  "    0! ' %// " 
%( &" 
  &  " %  ""%&%
 
&$% A%"&&& 
""   *  
&$% " 
  *
*
 $ 
$%   ( *
&"  
$  $%"%  &"  &$ (    
 
&*   ! $&* (    "$"
&$%&+ 
 &
 
 &" 
/
 A*
+  
    
* 
 
"  %&
  " 
%"  
  $  $ &
   *"  
/ 
 &"(  + 
+""* 
( 

 )
  *" &"" 
 >&+ 
 C>  &

 "$ & $ $ %
* 
&  A*
+  &$    #%& 
#
 ,&
  $ +  &&%%$"  -

""&(
&*   ! $&* (   A*
+  

&& * 
&(
&*    ! $&* (  ) &"$&* " ( 
  $ 
 *+    $&
   "& $"  )+  %
$"& 

 <"+"  c &  $&%% $%'$%( 
 $&
  $"  )& ""*

    + &
 %
 A*
+  (  
   
* 
 
 "&%  "+" (  ""& 

/%  $%%&
 
"

 
 $ * 
&* 
) &" %&*
 
 

& *
+  

&  &&
!" !" ( & 
* 
&
   
  4 &  (  
 &$
 & 0
&G$      

%
G*"
)%%&
 ( & &* 
)<  "$"

 
&$   +  )&* 
 
"! %

(  *

  


 J  
% 
  &  &
( $   )
  & &"

 &  &


( "$ $  

J 

) + "**   .
( +" 
  

$     

 &&*"
 * < %
$
+ 
$  &
  
( &"$     *&*  "&* ( (  (  &"&&



$ ( &

&  & $   
* 
 
 
$ ( &

&

)&
  
$  *%&$

    '   $
 
( & $  " + ( + 
&"
)
  &   

&&*"  
( 
 $ +" 
 
&*   A
  .
)
 )  " ( "" ($  &    
  "!
%

 ""&&*"% 
 

% ( 
 &  !%",! %;%&T "-)  $  < (    &

 

"

% (  $ &
   !%&$

/  &$   %*   
( $
  $   G   " *" $&

 %
* 
&'
  $  $ &
  +  & 
'& 
 %  &"$"
&
 * < !%"&"
&+ 
   $%
 
* " 
   !%)  & 

c)  '  
%$  ;
 )&
 * <  $   
 
%  ( &! $
 > 
% $      *
 
    * < * 
* 
 ( &"$  +  &    
  %*")" +   * 
!

 
   
(   $  
  &"+" * <  & $ %
* 
&)$%
 
(  
 &
&
  
*" ( * 
) $
&  & 


   (  $  
*"$"
* 
I$%
 
 ( * "F)(
"$%
 


"

% !%,) c)A%&"
   
* 
( -$  

"

% $
$()  & 

!%"     $&
   '  &
  
* < 

( 
 &
 <  
" &"$   
*  
   & 

&( 
 $ & "
"*
"

&$%)    $   ( 
")  * ( 

 J    $ 
 



 
% ) (
"* 
&  + " 
&%?%%&&*"  "$"  &  " &+ 
 
&&  " & &* ,#% 
0!  -) 
( &" 
&&  "   $,#
00!  - 
&&  " & &* 

&&*" &  " %&
 &+ 
 )  "  &  " 


" %$&
  $ <   $   @
 &"
"*
"

&$%  & *
 
# 
)   *"   
 *
+  "*
"


) $
$  * 
&  $&
  ""(  $"   
' & 
$
 
%
 
  &+   *
+  "*
"
( *
  A&* 
%%&
 
% 
&  ** 


 "
 ( 
!
$   $ $ %
* 
&)&  

$"
&&  * < +  " $ 
$ ""&
  
   $ $  
&%%&
 
% 
& A  $
 
 (   $
 
&)&   $&""  
$
 (  $ 
 " & "
&"" 
 $
 
&
"

) (
"%%&
 
% 
& 
&%%&
 
% 
&)  "( +" 
*"* 
 & 

&)$%
%
&)  
&)&   
/
 %%&
  &   $
  
%   
&%%&
 
% 
&)&
  
 $  && #   ( "&* ( ( 
&


)""(  
"" &
( ) $   "&  &
$%
 
  " ( 
+    &%
$

&

+" &  
"

 
  
"

$! ( &&$"(
#(  &(*   &$&* "  
% !  ""   

")*  
"
   &
 $ 

 * 
& &$" $&" *"" 

 %%%&
 $%

 $  

"
&"$    "  &

  &   
%   &"
 &%  

  &  
&

)&
  
)""(  .
  
 ) $ & +" 
"
& "# "( && &"$  %&%
  " & ( ) $  "&"
 *""  "$ *""  
 "
 "" &
  !%&$

/  

")( +" $

 " %&
  
    
% 
 
$"  ( )" & $"  &
( )""&$  

 
  "   $$
  
  A

( + 
$   <  J & "$"*   $&* " ( 
 &
% * 
*   !%" & &*     &% 
  &&<"+"  +  &
  
  

 $ + 
  &% 
( 
&*   !%%  &% 

* 
&  $&

 $
* 
  "&" 
&% % +"& !
%% (  & 
&&$$  
 &  

*"
$ $   (   
/ 
 
$  * 
* $"  
." ) .
);

) 
  *"+"$  $
  +"& $ " ( &"
&&"!" ** 
 $%  %
* " 6  
")(  "( 
 " %$&
      
% 
 
$"  ( &( " + 
"$% * ( & "
& 
& %

 
( %%
 
   &%
$
( ); %% c %+" & &*  * < !  $%

)  $
 
&  &&* <   !%
"$ ( &+"+"

&% 
  $ "  ' <    ) $
+  $%




   
      $
$(    

 (   &+& &+ 
  ( $
# % 
    "   $   $
 
 6  
") 
% 
&(    
 $ &* 

&
  
+"  "



 $+ &
 &% 
) &
  $ $ %
* 
&$"*"&&+ &
  ( &% 
  " %
* ( 
*
 %
@%c A(  &$% &
!#% %$   C $   < ( &&  $ &&* < #%& 
%%&
 %

 &
  
) &" &$  
#(  $ 

 $  

 "" ( 
&    &$
&"   &
  
+*   & "   $" " 
  
 & &$" ""&(
 $&* (  
 +  ( 
     &" &" "&* (   &(   D  "
 "    %%#
! ( " (  (  $ 
<"+"   &
&%

&)<  "$"
 &"
 &
% 


 
$ " 
 
%   @  &"+"%%&
 
% 
&&& "   *" * 
&
  
) $  
 &
 # %
%

$&
&$
  '  &
  
(  &  %
&$

& 
 5%&* "" & %
* 
&+ 


 )

%
/
) .
)" %)
%)" ."     : $


C
 "%; /.&"&"& !  ( ""!  #%& & 
 % ."   
 "
 c    *"  $   " ); /. &&* (  """ ." $  c ." +"  &" 
" ( $    "

&  "*
!$  
< "( 
+ <   ." +" &("
    * 
  '  &
  

(   &  $"  "   '  
" $  c ?% ""&$  $

% !%")&+ 
!%" ( 
$  A
&$"  & $  (  
 &$
 &"+" * 
&  &
  
 &&

 %
* 
&* 
%"


( 
  $
( ) (  %
* 
&
 * 
 &( &    '  &
  
"  


)+
 $"* 
)
# (  (  &   &  &&* < 

( *

 *
  & & $  

+"  &"+" * 
&  .
&%
* Gc ?% G" *"  "  (   &&(*  $  &%
*   '  $
$()  & 

   '  &
  
   $"( .
&

)&  
  **
 *
 $"
 &&$

 * < $%

%
* 
    &  
   
 ) $  
 &
 $%    '  *&*   $$ 
%
* 
&
"  %  

&"!"  %
$
; %% c %(   $  & &*  $%
 
 $
 
&( 
* < %%
* 
& $%
 
 

 ( 
  $
+" "
  &  & 0
&  $
* 
& $
  6  
"$"
& +" %"

* 
&
  
)(
"$ $ %%&
 
% 
&  $ &
% 


 
$%%&
%*   ** 
#     (  
 &$
 *"&( *  %
$
 $$
#& 0
&)
 &*   %%&
 
% 
&( 
+" $"
* 
%"
* 
&
  
)&    &


( 
+" $"
* < %
* 
&*" %"
( $ * 
 &
  
  & 

*"
 Konsep Hukum Fair Trade CDD"C1DDC1!+!+D 1+=C"C1DDC1!+!+DCD1='+1',$+ D   , $7D
       D+1 ' + 1  
    + 9" )550*+)550  
 /D  # " $ 2 :%
=  (   #"$               , #"$ 
  
 
  1  

  %#"$
( 
   %  (         %
     

        
 %   
  
     ;%3E 3%AE  06E   /:  
  *6E 06E    
   

       


=   

"    (  
  %      
   /,>  + :   
 
(    

   
  /   :%
   


%   
% 
  =   
 
% 
  
     
   ( 
     
   
       
#"$      
=   #"$   
      #"$ 
   
            #"$     
   1   
 ( 

   "    
  "    
         .    !"  " )550  
     . 

    

     CDD"C1DDC1!+!+D  
# " $ 2 #"$

    
   
  
 .% %
              F)G 
      

  H  H    
 %
   > !    
    %
(  
     

    %               % %  
       

  % 
 
   
 

    

 %
    
F*G 1  
.)4  
     D%  

 
    !     
   
        
       D

( 
       %      
     
    D  =       
     
     


  
              % > %

  
 F3G            % 
 

% 
  
  .  
 
 
%   
 ! %

 
 ' 2 %    
/


   
:   (   
  
%   %     F0G  '      %#"$%
  .      !"  " !"")550  .    
 
 

  F4G7 ) +.1 (    " *       +.1 (   %   !"")550%  7  ,>  + ,+  

 

 ,+    
 #"$% 
 


   #"$%%     

   
 %

   


     + " 
       %
 
.
    

     
       * ,
(( '      #"$%   !"")550%  .     7  B 1   1  !"")550 
  


  
%
  
  

  
 

  
    I   >C (      I   >C ( %  


       ( +"      
   #"$ 
          % 

  
.  
  
 %     
        
 
"( (  "  
.  
  
!"")550  
 

   
  
 !"")550  %    
       
#"$ '       #"$   
    
 . 
  
.  
.
    %       
    %               
% 
   +.1 (   C  J 

 +.1 (   C   !"")550 
% 

  #"$

    %
     

%( 

  

  


     
. 



     
  +.1 (    C   
 
  
 
 "(     (   (-( ( 
((  (    >> (( >   2      (    (  K  =  %    
(/>    :=
   ( ((  %     (  ( % %( %      ( (    %   (( F;G  "7  

 
(  % 
   
. 
    ( (  

   +.1 (    .   
 
 .
             K   (   

   /

   :%

 

     
  
  (   
 
% . 
%
      %  .   %   

  

      B =C"C1DDC1!+!+DCD1='+ 1  
CD ! #   %   
 
 
. 
>      

!    
  


 
     
.  
  

   
   !  

  

   

  
    
. 


  
  
   

     "   !"")550   "    
       
 
 %  ( 
   
   "   1  % 
   
 
 
   
  
  
  
   F9G7 )  
       

  1  
  
  
  1   %

      
   
       
       (    


%    "K   * 
 % 
  
   

  
         
  




  
   
 
   
   " 
 
   
)9     %
 
 
(
 
  
 

  3 
 %
 
 
%     
 
 
  
   
   = 
 



( 
  " 


  % 
     % (  
    

  1
%
    
      >   

    

 

  
 K     
  
(    
 
   %
    
   

   
K      
 
(     ( 

  

    FAG ,   %
   

  % 
   
  
  
(  1*9) 1)504 
 

  
      
      
 
(  F5G  
    

 


    . 
 1  
   

     30* 1)504% 
/L 

   
    
  F)6G:  1  
 
  
   
 

   
   "   
  
    MC% 
"M  (% 

      >  ( 
    
    
 
    
 
 F))G     >  (

MC     
  
 
  
  

      

    > .  >   %  
   
   
 
  

  
 
(  
  

   

 
   


 

( % 
 
  
  
F)*G       
     
    
    "  
  MC
     
 
  
 
% 
 
  
 

   
  
( %  
  

         
MC  
  %   

   
  

    
  
  

    
  

MC   % 

 
  .   !"" 1 #"$
  .
%    

%  1> B  %1> B  
 '1> B  
 =    #"$
 

.

     
     !"")550     +.1 (   %     
 

%  

   


  
  
   
MC%  

        1 !"")550   
 ( 1  " 
  
% 
     !"")550  

  

   
%
  ( 1  "  

 
   

 
      
( %   
 
 .
  

   
 
 
  
       
  
   
MC 
/  :  
  

   
  

 
( 

   
    

 


   MC    )506 
  D  = % %   !
     
 
(  %      
 1    
   
 
 

 
 
  
    
  %  

   
        

      % 
   
        


 
  
  %
 
    %

   
>   
 %   
2 ,  %

  

 >
   ( 
   
%
   

  
(  
            

    
  
(     

    
     
(  

 
  
 %   
 
( 

% 
    
% 
 
         
  
   
  %     
  
 

   
   1
   %
         
   
 %    %  %      
 
    
>      
  
   %
 

 
       
    
 >  
   
%   
   
( 

   
   


  %
 % >  
 &
 
   

    
  ( 
 
  %
  
     #"$ 
 
  
     
  %     
( 
  1        

  MC    
 
 
%   
  
    
       >  ( 
 (
  
     (   > 
   %   
   
   %  

     >  (  
         
  
    
   
  

 MC%     
   .  %MC 
   

 D  


      
    .
   
        >  ( 
M !(  
M !(    (

  
    % !(  

   %     
 
   
    >    
  !( %   
  

    
  
 
   
!(  
             
 

2 ,     
  
2 ,  F)3G   

  
 ( 1  " #"$ (   

 ( 
  
.  
  
    1 D =, '+   #"$

( 
    + 9" )550  
 /D  # " $ 2 :%       %   %    


 
  (   #"$       % 
     
      
7    (   %% (%(  >  (  >  (   + 
   #"$   
        
 

    
% 
 


 %        (      !"")550 ,>        
 


(   
  
 


   
 
% 
8   +      
 


(  
 


    
      1    ( 
   
   

       
%     
  

   N
      
  1

  %=  
 
        

 
 
%( %= %M    
   % 
 
   +  

 


 
(  

%
%   
            "  
   
 % 
(  

   

 %
  
 
 
          % 
 

   

             =  %               
   
(        
 
            
   

  
  
(           
  
          

   
 >         1
     %


    > >   
 
  %
     > >  1

 %
    
    % 
    
  
  > >       
  
  %    
 
  
  (  %  
  %      , %

   = 1      
 C >  , 
  
%, C

         ,

  
  ,
   %   
 %    
     
 %  
 %
  
     
  F)0G   


=  %
 


       % 
   (   
    
   

  %     
        

  =        
   %
     
   
    
  



 
    



 
      
 
 >  
   >       
 + 
      
 
     

 
  
     




 
 %
   
     
         1

  %

     
  
 
C+        O> % (  F)4G  (*9 3 "C=  
 %
( 
   %    
     =>  >    / 
:       >   %
  
 
  > 

      (

    
(
> C ("(=(  
(   "-%
 
  
 )*6
  )559

 >   =  
     

   =   
% 
  
>   

 
   

C ("(=( %
  ( 


 %
      = %
(  

       =  
   

C ("(    
  % 
    %
  
      =  
    1 
    %  =       ! (= ( ! OC    (         

  %      = % 1 %%,%  2 (       =     %
  %  D%C 
B
>
 ,
 
          =
 !        (*3  "C=      =
 !   %=    
     %

  
 =  % "  =
 !  
M%  
  %
 
, %"B 
 M%M>B 

 
%    
  
    
              %
     
 
   

 
  

 =   
   "C=%
   "C=  

=  F);G  
  
%    

     %"C=  



       
      
"C=
 


 
%      
  % 
  

 %
   
 (        
    
 
%
=   C2   =  "C=     
  
 
% 
  
(( 
 
 
  
  >      %    
  
= #"$% ( =         "C= 

      

 

 ( (   
 
  %"C=
  
 
 
 


 >   
 
#"$ 
   " % .   
/ :  
  
  MC      
  
  
 
% 
 
  




  
  
( %  
  

         
MC  
  %  

   
  

     
 
  

   1 
MC  

 
   
       
M !( % 
 
 
 

MC%  

 . 
  
        1 
   
%

   "    

  
    
. 
% 

   
 %  

 

    

   
 %    
 
    
      

   
   
    30* 1)504% 
/L 
 
  
    
  F)9G :  F)G,    %
1= 

  #"$% 7" B   
 %*660% *  F*G#
 .D
 % 1 
 ))1*669  F3G=  F0G,    %$ B   3  F4G   + %   + B("  1>.1   #  " $ 2 %+J
 !>7*663% *3.*0  F;G%CD ! #   %!"  B ( + = B 7 ,( =  "(%*666  F9G ' % 
%P7&&
 (&
 (
&6060&);&  &59*3;A Q 1 
 )61*669  FAG # % 

, 
%7&&
  
 

 &
 RS
TS  U
T S);4 1 
 51*669  F5G=  %     1)504%*9) F)6G= 30*  F))GMC%"M  (%> %,7>   > %)59) F)*G=  F)3G
M !( %  M " $ +,  %!# =  'C> %V 33%*66) % )6);)6;*  F)0G , C%   1 7##, !#"$$  (   '   +J
%W 
%*66; F)4GM ,   " 8"  ' T+J
%W 
% *66) F);GB%%M  = !%C(   >7 >( ( (   '  +J
%W 
%*660 F)9G 1)504%$ B  30* 

$7EE< *!%& & *%$% !%&E

CE E%$'""&'#
'  &

) = 
   "    

  
%
   
    
 
       "  (      
    
 
   

  
 


(   
 
 
      
 

 
          

      

 
            



     
      (        

  
   
   1
     
 
 
    ((
    
   (
       

 
    
%  
      

 

   



  

       (   + 

 
    )66       
   

   *6E    
 

( ;6
     ( 
  1 
   

 
    

 

 
%  "  (   
   

    
   
 % %
 
  
    1

%        
 
        
%    % 

      %  
  
  
  
  )546  
  
D%
%   
 1 =    
   (    )5A6 1
   =  (
     
    J
%,% ,% % 
 
  (
    

 

   

  
  
   

 

 
  
 

     
   "    

     
       

=  R       
R    
 =  R * „
 

: Fair Trade   " "*"%$
&
 $&

 )
 $ 
   
% ' % ( 
 *
 &$  

 
+  %* 
 
Fair Trade&"!"* 
  
# 
*"$   ** (free trade)( &""* ( %    
  
 A(  * < & &"  ( 

& 
%%&$%!
<   *"&
&  &

  "( & 
#

 %* 
* <  
(    *"
 
* 
  
 free trade( $ 
(  
 
""
  

=



B

C

J 

$&    (  $   " ' " free trade( $  $ 
(   
  
 " ' " doubel standard  "    ( 
$    '   (    &"*" $   (    '  *&*  &"*  "*" $   *"( !  #
%%#
   "*" partnership(  &"" " * $
 &+ 
"*" $%
 
#    
 "*" $         (    *&*  ( &+ 
    $  $%
 
* " !  '!  %%

 

  

$   !""$*  *      free trade&&    '  *&* "" &
* 
 
$   & )  $  

( 
  '  & +" & 
& $ *
+  $%
* 
$%"(   & "  &$   %&
 A%"
$ $     *"$

!  %United Nations &(* *   *&* &  &
"

$ "(  * 

+" %  : 

"
&$       & +"    *&* & 
* 
&   

 (  >$%$" 
"
&
& 
income ( +"& ( B  
*
*  
income % '% &

 = 
 %

$   ( & 
 & & 

  
*"   &(* * 
&$  ( & 
*       (     *&* )Fair Trade&"!"* 
*"   $     
#(  *$
 $  $%"&

& "
$ $ $

$ 
 ) $  
) %&"
 
  
    &$ ( )$

$ 

*" 
<"+"   &*" 


*"
( *
$)$"  % 
 
 $%")$
  
*   $  $&$"   &$   )   $&
"&* 
$%"( 
 
   + &+ 
*"   $   "  Bfair trade &(* ** 
   
 <  %$ )&
 ) 
 #
 
%


   fair trade&"!"$  $   " J '  C  &$&*  ( fair trade 
%
 !""$&&* "$%"'$%"&


** 
<
 (  $
D%(   )  )   &) 
) "   &*  fair trade(  !""$$%

#*"&"+" * 
( $"
*
* ( & (      $% '% 


& (  & 

*+  &(
  $" &  &"
 & $   "
$%$%
(  "( &  
&  "
 

  &+   * 
&  
'
fair trade*&* 
  %&
 

free trade  &%%
9 
&  
'

"
$+"  9  
&  $ "(   $$%%&
%
9 à
 

 * 
*"   ( *"+" &&* "
"$ $  $%"&

  & +
 
  '  "
A
 )fair trade&&*   
*+  &   "& " $    " %&"
 $%"*" % $   & ! &

$ &  

&"
%% '% &
 & "


"
Ten Thousand Villages,""( Mennonite Central Committee Self Help Service)  SERR,  SERRV International- %&"
 & (    &


  '     $   
 " = '   &"++ fair trade $
 
  

)&"!"$ &  
$   "  ' (
"
 
"Oxfam UK ( &"+"
%A%)&&$"(

""&+"  +
 ( 
*" %

$  $"
;
 %%'%%Oxfam J""$"*
 
( 
"  % World Bank  fair trade+" &"!"$ &  
$   "  '   *" Goodwill Selling.9&*  fair trade& "
  ( % 

 " & % 
 
%$&
 ,56-$ &  

$  %Oxfam Great Britain,
-)Fair Trade,&
  
 -)Transfair,@& -) % 
 

$$
c6(Fair Trade Labelling Organization)( 


 
   $  *" $
 C) "c(Internasional Federation for Alternative Trade)(  


 
%%<
+  $     
 J)? U(Network of Europian World Shops-


 

$'   " = c(Europian Fair Trade Association)


 
 
!'   "  )c


  "

( &"$   *" 
&   %
&c
&*
 
""#$ c6) c)? U c



&*  
   fair tra
%
$ &  

$  % Oxfam GB/Indonesia Fair tra      " 
$% &" &

Oxfam Indonesia ( 


 $   " C 5  Fair Trade&"!"$  $  

J ' * 
*" 
 
%

$   %
(    &"
 $%"'$%"!
( * 
""<
 ( %
   $    ' )  Fair trade %
*&* $  %&%

$ 
 ""( $ 
% 
 &*  


 
 *"&$"( ** $  56$   " B
D%(   ( 
# 

 
%60# &5E%

   +"( 


  A%%
"& (   c
 ,Ac-$  %%* C    $ & &"    
$% &Fair trade  &

 $

%%* & * 
&
""&&$  Fair trade ( 
*
  &  ,  * 
 -* 
"+"%&* Ac""& < 
& $   ( 
  
 $  $&*   +"(   fair trade  & &* %$ 
 
 :



r
   
c
 

 

: * 
   "  *&* ( 3& "8$

$free trde,%

 $   
%

< 
%
  
   $$%"%   "   .
&

$  *&* &"  $( 
 $    " *
&"" $
 $&

&%    * 
$"*
+  $"*
 " &   &%

&( " " ' " ( 
 $%"!
 $
$ 
)$*"" )"$ )

*"

 &&*
 $ ( !""$ 

#
  A$   '$   
 
% 
  &(  
 
#
 
   &$" '"  %

 
$
 
 !  (   
 %

 $
*""( 
'A!  & '& %$"  &$ ( *+ ) $(
 *"")$ &$    $ 
)&%%(   $ 
     $%"" ) &"$   (  
' 

    
  

= &*  
'
fair tra
%
( * <  
*

( Oxfam GB/Indonesia$   " C ( &"


#&("     fair trade $  $   " J ' !  $   &"$ 
&"+"  $&*  $%

#  
" $ 

  
*

( &$ '&$   "$" ' $" $( "$%"'$%"% ( 
$%"
%$  $%"(  & 

 & 
   
* 
&$   ** ( 
  
  

"% 
 
' % 
 
%$&
 $
Oxfam

 &&*" ! * ( (
"
!

 
A"$ 
&  D%(   * 
$" (  
Oxfam)YaysanSamadi Justice and Peace Institute+" &"$  56(  
#&("   
'
fair trade 
%
 
"&"+" * < 
'
fair tr  
*   <
 ( '<
 ( %
(   "
$
!
 
&! "$@ < )) "") " <
)"% =

  &"$    ( * %&(  $ 
$ 
 $  
%

'
fair tra *&* !""$*
  "
  $ 
 
  
$ " '$ "  $&
 ( +    ""
 $

$'$

$fair trade*"       Report on Fair Trade Trends in US, Canada & Pacific Rim tahun 2003  $ "+"$

$'$

$  fair trade(
"Creating opportunities for economically disadvantaged producers, Gender Equity,Transparency and accountability)Payment of a fair price, Working conditions, Environmental Sustainability. 

B "&
  $  $

$'$

$
'
fair trade !""$*&* 
 %
$

*" *"&( & 
 
 
  $   " ' " (  related  fair trade*" 
%$
%%
   " $(  $ 
  * $&      *&* $
%
     
 (  $

$fair trade    $*""  " ( & "  +  *""!  (  
"  &$   :  = = B

C 

"%
+"  & 
#
 
%/
6% JC % J(    &&*" '( ,%   "

-  * 
 % %
+"  
 !  &%   $Kovenan ECOSOC Rights( &< +
*   "" &%& 
)&
"
) &+ &
 ' *"")
   (    $+ ) "$ (  
 %

(  ( * 
*""* "  ( )%

+  (  &   )&$  (  & ""& $ $%&%
)$&*    < "+ )
*") 

    $& $  +
 
&*  ) "" *
 )&&*" * *" 
 *"") 
 *"""" &&*"# 
  "%# 
 
%  &+ 
 %   "&&*" 
 *""
 
% ) ""&%%)   + &
   " 
%
)  !"
& 
   $& $  +
  "+ &
 %
( && 
C

J   &   $ 
$&*    Fair trade $ 
  & 
 
$%  
   %' %,( 
*"-$ Fair trade(   & 

   $   decision maker. 
   decision-maker,
fair trade& $  ""  $%

# 
    
"
4

 %< 
$  < "$&
    < 
 " %"
&(   * < VV ( 
  
'free trade) $
 ( *
 "+"fair tradeVV   ( 
&"  ( ""&"" &*"   3$ $   "
<  

    
   '  *&* ) & "%
)

&$"** 
$ " *%%* 
 
 $   **     )  '  & +"( &&%$%
*

"+""*"$ (   &&$%
$%"   ( % + &
  
 )(  

 &&* " ''Bio Terrorism Act''""&(
*  '*  " ( & "    '  *"+" &&*
 "*

$  $%"'$%""" (  ""*

$   "
)
   ( &+ 
%&$

#8 J" +   &*  *"
 !""$" ""&&*"
 * < %
  &    $

$$   (  $

$'$

$fair trade  &"  '   *"&"$   &*  ( !""$* """&+  * < 
'


fair trade$    (  *&* !""$* "
%

 ( *
+   &&* "     $
( $ 
% 
)& "
*
+  "Go Organic 2010"( 
!   %&
 %
)
 
&
 
 < !  
** 
&
&  )$ &$
 $ 
%&*  <  ( ) 
' 
 @
 
""
*
+ " 
)$  . & 
 " %$"
'
fair trade  !&

  &" '" land reform (
" ' %%  
,-%  " B *"&"$     "+   &&* (  $  $ 
" & *""' 
)  "& 
&

 

 +"  $
 '$
 ( concern   
*' 
*$  $  $%"(  & +
  !""$

 " " & %   Non Govermental Organization,56-$
Oxfam Samadi Justice and Peace Institute 56' 56
( 
 'cover  &"
 

 
   $&
  "   $
"   $$  $%"% +"  
 "   
"&"+"   (   $ * < * (   $ 
 " ""&!
$  %

 $   ( * 
 
  ( ( &$" %* 
 
(  &""free trade( !  (    *
  
    &""  '"   %' %*" $ 
*  "& $  &*   
 $
 '$
 ( &  
"
  
&* "*",fair trade- %
  %%&
 "&+ 
   * < fair trade  &(* * *" ( profit * 
*

(  & 


+     $

$free trade.  A
 &  &$
 4

 %< 
&(    & $%"
 %


:( *& 3%
 
8)** 
$
 ( &   
"
    '  4

*"& " counter act´"" & &* *
+  '*
+  4

( &""* ( $
 local oriented´. "" " & %" $ 

$ & *")$ & *"&&*""    

 4$ &
( $" W:



&*
(  
  & " 
  

(    
;
 )  (
)@$ ) !
)  ) A%      " & %&!  ) "  




$"+"(   ) & "%&*% 
   
 $"  "
 "  &  & 



"
=JJ$ 
   ( %#%%)$ *
&
!$  +
$ 
* 
 %
 ;%%*
+  
( *"+" &
"
 &
  
"
  $   %&
( 
 " 4

   *
+  %   
 "  "
 " A$"" %&%B=:) $&* ")4

*"  &
   $%"" % )(  & 
&  " 


&
   
!" 
&$%(   &"    %

$ 
*" (   &""(  4

*  $)*
+  
"  &+  $ + *
 &&"
 $%

%
) ( $    ' 
 * 
$&
" "
(   
$
"   :  &")*
+  '*
+  4

*" & $     
$
 '$
  (  
 
  &  
"
  A*
+  4

*"&&*" 4

 $ &"
*"  +"& % ( 
 *
)$  $%

"
  ( )  * 
$"  4

"*"'"*"   "$    $    &
 )(  &$
  & 
 "' "  = $  
&   $%

) &*  *"&&$
  * < $ $ fair trade& 
&&*"" $+"  ( $ +   
   56"  '"   (   * ( 
 "   *" + &
 ( 
%$ 
 A(  * < 

* 
* & (   %
&&"
*"" (  
%$ 
 ""&(
 )   &$
 

%*"
 & &$"&!""$
 *"" '*""   $  $ 
 & 
 $
"$
* <  
 &

    #  * < $ 
'$ 
&


 ' 
"$ "  

"  
 W ,4$ J =

)'-$ 
:""  ( 
"  %  "
$  *" 


&(*" )* <   '  $ $  "   
 
%
$ "   * 4$ B)C+" )
&  = > 
$ $ *" *   
"   
   
"/
( 
 " 


 $%"* 
B $%$

&&$
  )* < $ $   
$ 
$ 
3 ( 8*  B>  
% $ $   4"&    

" @ < *
 " 
$ $   $ 
) ""( $ 
$ 
)
* 
  "&    

 @ < =     %

*"*" 56( * & D (  
 "&
%
 ( ** 

  ,'  -&&*
 * " $  $  $ 

  ;
!
A! &  @ *")A *"$   +  " C  " (  
*
 %'  $  $  $ 
*
  &   $   )
#


) "&
( + 
 $&   $%" 
*  
$&    *" $  $ 

 

  $ $  !
( & 
""   "*   "
( "'&"
 * 
& &"
&  $$ 
 * 
%( 
  ( ""
+ 
 "&$" 
"$ 
* ( & &"
 *&
 
% '% 
 


"( &&* < $&    * "( "  "&"&
  "
 B !  
& 
$&    ( 
  $
$ 

  '+" 
 &
%$ 
' $ 

""  *&* &( "
   $(
"  $$ $%"
)   $$%"
) $ ! $%"
 $"  '  ( 
 " % '  ""&&!  $&    *"   &&$%&%
  $ 
% 
  
% 
   $  * "*
 $ 
(  &   $  $%
$* +" (sustainability) ""$
  $%"
/
    
""$ ( &&$   * 
"&* (  $"$

$'$

$ $ 
* +" $

 
 %c6&! "$$

$&  $  !  %%
)* +" !  %%&
)$

$ 
 )$

$& "
)  $

$#
*

   $"&% &$ (( 
 " %'      $(*  *%")$ 
)$&*"   *)$!  *"
)  $ & $%" B;%%'!%%
 
"$ ( '"$ ( 56'56  && $  #
  $ 

  
"( A4D%(   &&*"+ "$% $     
#
% +
  $ ( D (   & 
 %%  & &&*  &

  !  &    fair trade& "
%$%"
 * 
  &
 %%+" &"$  *"

 "$ ( $   fair trade %56
%
C C " 
(  $ 
 " %
$  + ( &  * 
%"&"" &&*  Fair trade   & " %"&
&
  "%"&
 J  % %"&
&

 ! '! ( 
 &$ ( %56'56Fair trade
"""

%
$ %"&
&
   Oxfam  Samadi Justice and Peace Institute.    $% %"&
&
 $ 
    &"   
$%"&&&


%%
 ""&" $%"'$%" $   + (   
%"&
( A  "

  %
 *

&  +
 & 


* ( %"&( &+ 
%"&
&  $"  '$"  (  &&$%"
$%"'$%"( 
 
     $

$Fair trade  & 
  

(  J   $
 
' 
!  *"  & $  &*  * )
  (     & 
 (    & (   "
  
$
Fair trad* 
 %&$%'%&$%& 
    
"
"+"  /%"&  
 $   ( ** 
Fair trade(  ( *  W=

+" $ "( )  " ) > 
% /%"&$   %* ( &! $
 W:)B

" 

à 
 
c
 
   
  


: "
""&" #
#
  $ "  fair trade  $ $%%&
%
A"  
"  
" %

 % $ ( 
  "  ""&""( @ &"  

 %$
  +   & (   %
*   $

$%%&

* ' $
 
( 
 
  $
  $ $
 ( 

)  "$"*   /%"&  
*

(  
 
 ( )&  + * < fair trade  
 !""$#
# 
  *$ "  $$"&*" $%%&
%
 * 
*  %&$  
) &""  ( 
"  %Fair Trade Organization,c6-* < 
%$   &
  
 +"&   
$   ( ** 
fair trade

& 
 (  &! $
 W=

+" ) (  ) > 
+"&   
""global trade.30" %
  ( &&*""  /%"&  
$   
"" %

  &
&"      (  $ 
&"        

& 
%%* "(
"* "&"!"
%
$  $   "

J '  c  ( ** $ $" '$" $( "$%"'$%"( ** 
fair trade *
  &
*"  (  $ 
D%(   (
"A4) ); ) D "&)
 %%
&  D (   & 
* 
$ &$
( )
%&*%(
" %&*%%(;)
  

*"' 
: A*  $" '$" $( " *"( & 
  

   

 %( "

*  * < fair trade *"&#
# *"&&&*
 $ "( 

#
 * 
$%%&
 %
 :  &"+
 
 & "$  


 % "" & *" &"  

 %
$
fairness   & 
$   )gender mainsteraming) sustainability)$(
%

+ (    & )
&( *" * 
 $ "+ < * $"*
)&  fair trade!""$#
# &&*
 $ "   $$%%&

%
? "$" "
"
* < 
 #
#
   $ "( & 
  !
  
"&
   fair trade&"$     ( *"& & *&* 
%
 &"+
 
 &
 per-case $
 
+  *"&( &    fair trade$%
""&+ 
 " * "  &

&$   free trade( &"$   "" &  : Reasoning'(    $ & )+
 & 
* (  %*
decision maker $&
 %
& "$"56'56( concern   
*$%"%  (  & 

& 
  )&  fair trade  &&


$%
* "" &&$ "
$%%&
%
  "    
 $

  $""  & 

   $  $ 
 "  $ 
)*"") $  $%" !

%
( & 
*
)
 $% '$% $   ( * 
 

 & $  "  ( & 
*    
    & 
 * ( ( 56'56
  '  & +"( concern  &*
 Fair Trade, 
&   

&"+" * < 
  '  $ "3%%%8
& $    "" & )$"
  $$   * 
 & 
 &
  
  *"" +   * &$   $%

#* 
 $&*  fair trade
%
 ::  ") $  fair trade*
 &+ 
 "" & 
&$   
%
  "
9@ < * (      "
,""
 &   
 - * $ #   "
""
 
*  !"
 &"
(
"7  ( $
   %$% 
'%$% 

 
% Q$&*   


&$%Q&   positioning   & $+"  ! (  "*  $  *
+   
$   "" $%"'$%""
** $   & +"Q$&*" $  " %$ (  *
&$
 
$   &%
 
" 

&$%$
   )* !"
)*Q       &  ( & 
&
   

" $ #  ( 
  &&*
  * 
$%$&*  fair trade(
"&
 &*     &"+" $"&*" $  ( !""$
&$
#):  

(   &(&*"(
 $%  *  
%$ &
 ( )$"&*" $  Fair Trade ( 

#
 + 

  '  ( * " + & 
&Fair Trade. &  
"""  '  $
"
)  ) <
)@&  
) 
&  
&Fair Trade *&*  & $""  ")** $ % 
 
 $     
#&!   $&*  ( !"        &** $  "+""&"" :: := 

r



  

:B 3Fair Trade* 
 "" & 
&$   
 
% & 
 
& "" & Free Trade8   absurd.  "* (  &*  * ( "
"" 
 
+
 fair trade


"'" &     &%%
!
 '!
  & "'" &  fair trade*
"
 
)  fair trade%%* "
&   norm enterpreneurs'( & 
  
 $(*  
'
fair trade& 
   *   A%

*"
$*""  &*  ' &*  %

 $%%&
%
( *"&&"+"   '  * 
   
"   * &$ $  *
+  '*
+  $ & 
(    $&" &   *
+  ( *  $  %
 %%&
&   :C  &"* 
" "  ( $

$" & (    & "
)  fair trade "
*
  $

( 

$

*""( 

  +"
  
  (  (
"&+ 
* 
 
fair trade norm-enterpreneurs,  "$"  !  &+ 
%"&
 
  '
  *"    ( $ 
 &"
 *
& "  ""
 "   $

"
 %$   
#
   Fair trade 
  &Fair Trade Sebuah Alternatif Positif´* <  * 
&  $"&" ( $  fair trade
   &(
 &     * * * $ *  !$ $  fair trade"&*" $
   & &$"& &$"  "&!""$
 +" $%" $ 
  !
 
"
A
    Fair Trade+" 
 & &$"&
  $%

 < $%"( 
*   & $%"
  
"
& "$"$  $ 
( 
* 
$*"   *  6

  
"" " &   fair trade   & " $(   $
   
 %


"$ ( *
  
+ 
"
 $   
 
% )  & &$ ( $*
 
"$  A &$ (*" "
  $   *

'*

 "" & )""(   $%$% 
'%$% 
  
% "" &&$  $
 "( * "+ < *  &% '% $   
 
%  Fair Trade&"
 $ &+ 
*" &%( %$ 
% * 
 
&  
# 
&*%$ '$ *

( * "+ < * Fair trade *"  ( " "%$
&
 
 
 * (  &"" "*"
   (  At least)    & 
*&* (   Fair trade   3&
  8$
 '$
 $ "$    "" & * < 
& *
  
 (  & 

& +    &(* * +" & "
 &
  & 
*&* Fair trade &    & 
* "  "" &
  $  free-trader´ ( % *   & "
+"  :J "
* 
* 
* % )
 !%&    & (  
  $
* 
 (  & "
 $  + (    & &&$   %$ c
   
 "
 &   * ( %  (    & "&
(  "* "


 !%&& "   &8

6 $ "
"
 "

8/

   : 
 *"
 :B  "   **    !


   &&*
 
$
 
 * 
 "
 &
     D  
 ,c
   * 
    *&*    &


"
!%& &   * ( 
"$
"


 
 * "  A%$ " 

 
 $& "    &&+   *

  = * 
/

%
*
 $"*  %
)!%& & *
 
"$( "" &&$%&%
 
&$   %* ( &
$
 
$"*  $%

#  & 
"$  *
 $%"   %"&  %  $%$%   & 
 ) &!% &&$   *

 (   
 &""  !   %
  "   (  
"
 !  
 
%   "(  *    /

     D  
 ,c
  - $&* " %
'%%&
 =     " J &!% &

  Ô
 ,& &     

% -) (    c
 )6 
) A *% 
 !
 !%&*  "" &&* " $%"   %"& $   
  (  $ 
 #" &  (
" $ 
) **   "" & $   "$  (  < +    &&"
  *   &    $ $+    
"$ (    * 
 %"&) &&"
  &  & $   **   "" & "
   *   (  &  *
    $  &&

 $%" !   %
)  $  )  )   .       "

) *

 &!%

 * 
 &*    ( $(   &
  
  (  *%$ 
  
  c !
!%) ; 
#%
  &  &      $

  !%)  
" %"  4%   ,;66   ;6  !% &
  
 -) " (     *   * 
 *"  ""&&
 $ 
   & *

( * +" )
) */

c
  

=



=: 
 !%&)c%"" ,<<< &($"$  %- ==    "

J)!%&&"!"* 


 ;6u u


u u 
) *" %" %
#$%($
+ " * +" )/ " 
 $  *%)  
&*    *%    & &
    B  %$ 
 $    (  
 
 :   
"""
)%" %
#

 
*
 
 "
&
 ) *+   &    $ 
 "" &&*   $%('$%( %'#%( (   +"(  
+"  * 
 
  *%) &!
$   $ $    &*   * 
 & (    &$   
" && 
 $"*  

& ,%*  < &
- u  u


u  u 
   &  &



 $%%   &&


 "+"  "" &  &%  +" $%%$   
 "  = u  

       

          


     
  

 

     
  
     
 
   


   

 
     


     


    


 
          


      
        
  
 
 
      

 
   !     



   

    
"