REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES NATIONAL CAPITAL JUDICIAL REGION REGIONAL TRIAL COURT OF PASIG CITY PATEROS, METRO MANILA M ANILA BRANCH 262
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, Plaintif ,
- versus -
CRIM CASE No. 126238 For: Revival of Judge!"
ERNESTO UDANG ANDAL, A.K.A “JON-JON “JON-JON ANDAL ANDA L” an REFLE! REF LE! ANDAL AN DAL a"#a$ “LEKLEK” Accused. # -------------------------------------------- #
PETITION FOR RE%I%AL OF JUDGMENT
$riva"e $riva"e %o&lai!a!" %o&lai!a!"'' () %ou!se %ou!sel' l' re res&e s&e%"f %"full ull) ) s"a"es s"a"es "*a": 1. $riva"e $riva"e %o&lai!a!" %o&lai!a!" $E+R, $E+R, A$AS' A$AS' JR.' JR.' is Fili&i!o' of legal age' a!d residi!g a" 1138 Alle) ' $. Rosales S". rg). S"a. A!a' $a"eros' Me"ro Ma!ila. /e a) (e served 0i"* suo!s a!d o"*er legal &ro%esses of "*e /o!ora(le Cour" "*roug* "*e u!dersig!ed %ou!sel. 2. A%%us A%%used ed Er!es Er!es"o "o da!g A!dal' A!dal' is Fili&i ili&i!o' !o' of legal legal age' age' a!d forerl) residi!g a" 1138 Alle) ' $. Rosales S". rg). S"a. A!a' $a"eros' Me"ro Ma!ila' a!d !o0 &rese!"l) %o!!ed a" "*e Ne0 ili(id $riso!' Mu!"i!lu&a Ci"). /e a) (e served 0i" 0i"* su suo!s o!s a!d a!d o"*e o"*err %our" our" &ro% &ro%es esse ses s "*rou *roug* g* *is *is %ou!sel o! re%ord' A""). Je*a! . Sa&ao' $u(li% A""or!e)s ,4%e' /all of Jus"i%e' 5%o!"i!ue *ere 3. ,! 22 Se&"e( Se&"e(er er 277' 277' a%%used a%%used Er!es"o Er!es"o da!g da!g A!dal A!dal 0as fou! fou!d d guil uil") (e) (e)o!d o!d reaso! aso!a( a(le le dou( dou("" of "*e %ri %rie of frus"ra"ed urder () "*e Regio!al rial Cour" ra!%* 262 of $asig Ci") 9$a"eros' Me"ro Ma!ila' u!der Judge Isaga!i A. ;ero!io ;ero!io.. *e de%re" de%re"al al &or"io! &or"io! of "*e +e%isio! +e%isio!'' a %o&) of 0*i%* is a""a%*ed *ere"o as A!!e#
“&HEREFORE ' >udge!" is *ere() re!dered !di!g a%%used ERNESTO UDANG ANDAL ALIAS 'JON-JON( GUILTY (e)o!d reaso!a(le dou(" of "*e %rie of Frus"ra"ed Murder a!d *e is *ere() se!"e!%ed "o su?er a! i!de"eri!a"e se!"e!%e of Eig*" 98 )ears prision mayor as i!iu "o Four"ee! 91@ )ears a!d Eig*" 98 o!"*s of reclusion temporal as a#iu.
/e is also ordered "o )a* + )#/a+ 01)"a#nan+ P1 A)a$, J. 0#/#" #nn#+* #n + a13n+ 14 T#+* T13$an P$1$ 5PP 7,777.778, a0+3a" aa9$ #n + a13n+ 14 E"/n T13$an P$1$ 5PP ::,777.778. =1 @. No a&&eal or o"io! for !e0 "rial or re%o!sidera"io! 0as led () "*e a%%used 0i"*i! "*e "ie &rovided () "*e Rules of Cour". *us' "*e a(ove >udge!" *ad (e%oe !al a!d e#e%u"or) o! "*e da"e of i"s e!"r). ,! 7 Fe(ruar)' 271' "*e ClerB of Cour" of "*e RC of $asig Ci")' ra!%* 262 9$a"eros' Me"ro Ma!ila issued a Cer"i%a"io! "*a" "*e >udge!" i! favor of "*e &riva"e %o&lai!a!" (e%ae !al a!d e#e%u"or) as of 18 +e%e(er 277. A %o&) of "*e Cer"i%a"io! is a""a%*ed "o "*is $e"i"io! as A!!e# <=. ased o! "*e Rules of Cour"' a !al a!d e#e%u"or) >udge!" or order a) (e e#e%u"ed o! o"io! 0i"*i! ve 9 )ears fro "*e da"e of i"s e!"r). Af"er "*e la&se of su%* "ie' a!d (efore i" is (arred () "*e s"a"u"e of lii"a"io!s' a >udge!" a) (e e!for%ed () a%"io! 2. I! "*is %ase' "*e Mo"io! for Issua!%e of ri" of E#e%u"io! 0as led o! 1 A&ril 271' 0ell (e)o!d "*e )ear &eriod fro 18 +e%e(er 277' "*e da"e of e!"r). *us' a! i!de&e!de!" a%"io! "o e!for%e "*e 22 Se&"e(er 277 +e%isio! us" (e led (efore i" is (arred () "*e S"a"u"e of Dii"a"io!s. . *is a%"io! *as !o" )e" (ee! (arred () "*e S"a"u"e of Dii"a"io!s3' si!%e a%"io!s u&o! a >udge!" %a! (e (roug*" 0i"*i! "e! )ears fro "*e "ie "*e rig*" of a%"io! a%%rues' 0*i%* i! "*is %ase is 18 +e%e(er 277.
Emphasis and underscoring supplied. Section 6, Rule 39 of the Rules of Court 3 Article 11, Ci!il Code. 1 2
2 of 7 2 of 7
PRAYER /EREF,RE' &reises %o!sidered' "*e $riva"e Co&lai!a!" res&e%"full) &ra)s for "*e /o!ora(le Cour" "o:
9a ,rder "*e revival of "*e >udge!" of "*e +e%isio! da"ed 22 Se&"e(er 277 i! favor of &riva"e %o&lai!a!" a!d 9( Issue a 0ri" of e#e%u"io! "o i&lee!" "*e %ivil as&e%" of "*e +e%isio! da"ed 22 Se&"e(er 277 &ursua!" "o said >udge!". ,"*er reliefs >us" a!d eui"a(le u!der "*e &reises are liBe0ise &ra)ed for. GueHo! Ci")' for $a"eros' Me"ro Ma!ila' ' 271. U.P. OFFICE OF LEGAL AID Counsel or the Private Complainant ;rou!d Floor' Mal%ol /all !iversi") of "*e $*ili&&i!es +ilia!' GueHo! Ci") el. No. 26267 or 271@ lo%. 127K121
): RO&ENA E.%. DAROY-MORALES Director Roll of A""or!e)s !o. 312 MCDE No. IL-777@K1 Fe( 13K$asig I$ No. D$M-7@137KDife"ie Me(erK MaBa"i $R No. 17117K27 Ja! 1KGueHo!
JOSE ANTONIO ALILING Supervising Lawyer Roll of A""or!e)s !o. 7867 MCDE No. IL-77783@K2 ,%" 12K$asig I$ No. 2287KDife"ie Me(erKMaBa"i $R No. 221@6@K7 Ja! 1KMa!dalu)o!g
3 of 7 3 of 7
DIANE ANGELINE T. AGUSTIN Law Intern
of 7 of 7
C1)* F3n#$;
APP RONALD D. IGNACIO Assistant Provincial Prosecutor ,4%e of "*e $rose%u"or Mu!i%i&al /all 9A!!e# uildi!g $a"eros' Me"ro Ma!ila ATTY. JEHAN B. SAMPAO Counsel or the Accused $u(li% A""or!e)s ,4%e /all of Jus"i%e' +$/ Co&ou!d i%u"a!' aguig Ci")
E!PLANATION ON THE MODE OF SER%ICE
+ue "o "*e la%B of a"erial "ie a!d availa(le &erso!!el a" "*e $ ,4%e of Degal Aid "o e?e%" &erso!al servi%e' "*e foregoi!g o"io! 0*i%* is led 0i"* "*e /o!ora(le Cour" is (ei!g served o! "*e res&o!de!" () regis"ered ail. *is e#&la!a"io! is give! &ursua!" "o Rule 13' Se%"io! 11 of "*e Revised Rules of Cour". DIANE AGUSTIN
Da0 I!"er!
" of 7 " of 7
RE$DIC ,F /E $/IDI$$INES GueHo! Ci") S. S. %ERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATION AGAINST FORUM SHOPPING
I' PEDRO APAS, JR.' of legal age' Fili&i!o' 0i"* reside!%e address a" 1138 Alle) ' $. Rosales S". rg). S"a. A!a' $a"eros' Me"ro Ma!ila' af"er *avi!g (ee! dul) s0or! i! a%%orda!%e 0i"* la0' *ere() de&ose a!d s"a"e "*a": 1. I a "*e &riva"e %o&lai!a!" i! "*e i!s"a!" %ase a!d *ave %aused "*e &re&ara"io! a!d li!g of "*is $e"i"io! for Revival of Judge!" 2. I *ave read a!d u!ders"ood "*e %o!"e!"s of "*e i!s"a!" $e"i"io! a!d a""es" "*a" all "*e allega"io!s %o!"ai!ed *erei! are "rue a!d %orre%" (ased o! ) o0! &erso!al B!o0ledge a!dKor (ased o! au"*e!"i% re%ords a!d 3. I %er"if) "*a" I *ave !o" %oe!%ed a!) o"*er a%"io! or led a!) %lai i!volvi!g "*e sae issues raised i! "*e foregoi!g Co&lai!"-A4davi" (efore "*is /o!ora(le Coissio! or a!) divisio! "*ereof' or a!) o"*er %our"' "ri(u!al' or age!%) a!d "o "*e (es" of ) B!o0ledge' !o su%* a%"io! or &ro%eedi!g is &e!di!g (efore "*is /o!ora(le Coissio! or a!) divisio! "*ereof' or a!) o"*er %our"' "ri(u!al' or age!%). @. If I s*ould "*ereaf"er lear! "*a" a siilar a%"io! or &ro%eedi!g *as (ee! led or is &e!di!g (efore "*is /o!ora(le Coissio!' or a!) divisio! "*ereof' or a!) o"*er %our"' "ri(u!al' or age!%)' I u!der"aBe "o &ro&"l) i!for "*is /o!ora(le Coissio! of su%* fa%" 0i"*i! ve 9 da)s fro B!o0ledge "*ereof. IN &ITNESS THEREOF' I *ave *ereu!"o a4#ed ) sig!a"ure "*is of Ju!e 271 a" GueHo! Ci").
PEDRO APAS, JR. A4a!" SUBSCRIBED AND S&ORN "o (efore e "*is of Ju!e 271 a" ' a4a!" e#*i(i"i!g "o e *is 6 of 7 6 of 7
' 0i"* Nu(er (eari!g *is &*o"ogra&* a!d sig!a"ure' issued () . +o%. No. $age No. ooB No. Series of 271.
7 of 7 7 of 7
