logbook.pdf

ARCHITECTURE THESIS LOGBOOK

Page 1 of 78

The Pontifical and Royal

University of Santo Tomas España Blvd., Manila

COLLEGE OF ARCHITECTURE THESIS PROGRAM

ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN 1 LOG!OO"

Revised for AY 201!201"

UST College of Architecture Thei Progra! A" #$17%#$18


Page # of 78

#opyri$ht 2010 Ar. %onathan &. Manalad All Ri$hts Reserved



Page & of 78

Thesis 'o$(oo) *+ner nfor-ation /a-e Year and ection E-ail Address #ontact etails Thesis Adviser

f fond, )indly retrn to 3T #*''E4E *5 AR#6TE#T3RE 25 Beato An$elico Bildin$ 3niversity of anto To-as To-as Manila, Philippines



Page ' of 78

AD1 Contents #over Pa$e

1

#opyri$ht Pa$e

2

Thesis 'o$(oo) *+ner nfor-ation

7

#ontents

8

AY 201!201" Architectral Thesis #oncil

9

AY 201!201" Thesis Advisers

:

Thesis Adviser;s nfor-ation



Architectral esi$n 10
"

4idelines for A10

>

Reco$nition ? Ac)no+led$-ent of A10 Policies

28

A10 #onsltation heet @ee) 1

2:


2>


72

Preli-inary Endorse-ent Matri

79

#ertificate of Preli-inary Endorse-ent

7>


81


88

A10 #onsltation heet @ee) :

8

A10 #onsltation heet @ee) 

90

A10 #onsltation heet @ee) "

97

A10 #onsltation heet @ee) >

9:


9>


:2

5inal Endorse-ent Matri

:9

#ertificate of 5inal Endorse-ent

:>

Thesis 4radin$ heet Adviser

1

%ry 5inal 4radin$ heet

8



Page ( of 78

University of Santo Tomas Co##e$e of Ar%&ite%t're T&esis Co'n%i# A( )1*+)1, Ar- Car#os An$e#o D- A$'i#ar. 'a/ > and 10 #oordinator Thesis #oncil #hair Ar- Man'e# Ma0imo L- No%&e. 'a/ esi$n #lster #hair Ar- Ro$e#io D- Carin$a#. 'a/ Ar- Sy#via D- C#emente. 'a/ Ar- Lea& P- De#a Rosa. 'a/ Ar- Froi#an M- Fonte%&a. 'a/

'i)e s on 5ace(oo) Ar)iThesis#oncil and Ar)iesi$n#lster 5ollo+ s on T+itter and nsta$ra- Thesis#oncil



Page ) of 78

Avisers for t&e Ar%&ite%t're T&esis Pro$ram A( )1*+)1, Ar. #larissa '. Avendaño

9AR!1

Ar. To(ias A. Bonao(ra

9AR!2

Ar. Ma. Re(ecca M. Peñafiel

9AR!7

Ar. %anito M. Mala$a

9AR!8

Ar. Ma. &icenta . ancheC

9AR!9

Ar. @illa R. olo-on

9AR!:

Ar. RiCalito M. Mercado

9AR!

Ar. Ro$elio . #arin$al

9AR!"

Ar. Rino o-in$o A. 5ernandeC

9AR!>

Ar. 'eah P. ela Rosa

9AR!10

Ar. 5elicisi-o A. TeDco, %r.

9AR!11

Ar. ylvia . #le-ente

9AR!12

Ar. Manel Mai-o '. /oche

9AR!17

Ar. e-etrio #. AlcaraC, %r.

9AR!18

Ar. %onathan &. Manalad

9AR!19

Ar. Patric) Ro(ert A. e 'a #esta

9AR!1:



Page 7 of 78

Thesis Adviser nfor-ation Advisers /a-e #ontact nfor-ation E-ail Address *ther #ontact nfor-ation #onsltation chedle



Page 8 of 78

Ar%&ite%t'ra# Desi$n 1 Ca#enar AY 201!201" @ee)s

nclsive ates

Activities

1

1!20 %anary 201"

tart of 2 nd Ter-, AY 201!201" #orse *rientation, #onsltation Policies and chedlin$, Endorse-entsFThesis eli(erationF4radin$ yste-, etc. ndividal #onsltation ra+in$s for Preli-inary Endorse-ent

2

22!2 %anary

ndividal #onsltation ra+in$s for Preli-inary Endorse-ent

7

2> %anary G 7 5e(rary

ndividal #onsltation ra+in$s for Preli-inary Endorse-ent (-ission of ReHests for #han$e of Thesis Title, ProDect *(Dectives, andFor ProDect ite to Adviser Thesis 5or- 7 G 5e(rary 7, 201", atrday

8

9!10 5e(rary

PRELIMINAR( ENDORSEMENT 2AD3ISER4

9

12!1 5e(rary

ndividal #onsltation ra+in$s for 5inal Endorse-ent

:

1>!28 5e(rary




2: 5e(rary G 7 March


"

9!10 March


>

12!1 March

5inal ndividal #onsltation ra+in$s for 5inal Endorse-ent

10

1>!28 March

Preli-inary Ea-ination @ee)

11

2:!71 March

Easter Brea)

12

7! April

FINAL ENDORSEMENT 2AD3ISER4 + A/ri# 5+6. )1, 2Monay to Friay4 Thesis 5or- 8 Meet the %ry G April , 201", atrday

17

10!18 April

FINAL ENDORSEMENT APPRO3AL 2THESIS COUNCIL4 7 A/ri# 1. )1, Electronic ra+in$ of 'ots G April 11, 201" <@ednesday= Postin$ of Thesis efense chedle G April 12, 201"
18

1:!21 April

THESIS DEFENSE

19

27!2" April

1:

70 April G 9 May

*tstandin$ Thesis Ehi(ition %d$in$ for Thesis of the Year

1

!12 May

5inal Ea-inations for 4radatin$ tdents
1"

18!1> May

1>

21!2: May

20

2" May G 2 %ne

Baccalareate Mass


Page * of 78

St'ent G'ie#ines for t&e Deve#o/ment an Im/#ementation of t&e Ar%&ite%t're T&esis Pro$ram8 Ar%&ite%t'ra# Desi$n 1

!a%9$ro'n The Architectre Thesis Pro$ra- is co-posed of three parts, na-ely Research Methods in Architectre = and esi$n 10
•

•

Propose a relevant, feasi(le, and creative architectral desi$n soltion to an eistin$ physi! cal pro(le-I Apply the architectral desi$n process in the develop-ent of their architectral desi$n so! ltionI and Present and defend their architectral soltion to the (est of their a(ility.

Ar%&ite%t'ra# Desi$n 1 esi$n 10 is (ased on the pre-ise that the stdent has co-pleted and passed all the reHire ! -ents of esi$n > and that the Thesis Boo), +hich is its final otpt, has (een endorsed (y the A> Adviser to (e s(stantially co-plete in content and correct in style. This ter-inal Architectral esi$n corse involves the i-ple-entation of the A> otpt and preparation for Thesis oral defense. 1.0

S%o/e of :or9s- The scope of +or)s for A10 incldes the final revie+ and approval of final esi$n evelop-ent Plans, prodction of final presentation dra+in$s, and de! fense of the chosen desi$n soltion (efore the Thesis %ry.

2.0

Presentation Dra;in$ O/tions- The rationale in providin$ presentation options is to allo+ every stdent the li(erty on ho+ to visally present his desi$n soltions $iven the varyin$ epansiveness of each and every proDect. 6o+ever, le$i(ility of dra+in$s is the -ost i-portant consideration in decidin$ +hich presentation option is to (e sed. tdents are advised to discss +ith their Advisers on +hat presentation option +or)s (est for their proDects.



2.1

Page 1$ of 78

*ption A 2.1.1

#o-pter!processed dra+in$sFrenderin$s listed in Ta(le 8.1 and printed on 20J70J sheets ? -onted on 20J70J (oards. ndicate the n-erical scale on all plans, elevations, sections, and details. 2.1.2 Three <7= copies of all ite-s in ection 2.1.1 printed in A8 and rin$! (ond. 5irst copy shall (e colored +hile the second and third copies -ay (e in (lac) and +hite. ndicate the $raphical scale on all plans, elevations, sections, and details. 2.1.7 Eective --ary printed in A8 papers and inclded in 2.1.2. 2.1.8 Po+erpoint presentation
*ption B 2.2.1

canned and di$itally!enhanced -echanically drafted or freehand dra+in$sFrenderin$s listed in Ta(le 8.1 and printed on 20J70J sheets ? -onted on 20J70J (oards. ndicate the n-erical scale on all plans, elevations, sections, and details. 2.2.2 Three <7= copies of 2.2.1 printed in A8 and rin$!(ond. 5irst copy shall (e colored +hile the second and third copies -ay (e in (lac) and +hite. ndicate the $raphical scale on all plans, elevations, sections, and details. 2.2.7 Eective --ary printed in A8 papers inclded in ection 2.2.2. 2.2.8 Po+erpoint presentation
*ption # 2.7.1

#o-pter!processed dra+in$sFrenderin$s listed in Ta(le 8.1 and printed on 70J80J sheets ? -onted on 70J80J (oards. ndicate the n-erical scale on all plans, elevations, sections, and details. 2.7.2 Three <7= copies of all ite-s in ection 2.7.1 printed in A8 and rin$! (ond. 5irst copy shall (e colored +hile the second and third copies -ay (e in (lac) and +hite. ndicate the $raphical scale on all plans, elevations, sections, and details. 2.7.7 Eective --ary printed in A8 papers and inclded in 2.7.2. 2.7.8 Po+erpoint presentation
*ption  2.8.1

canned and di$itally!enhanced -echanically drafted or freehand dra+in$sFrenderin$s listed in Ta(le 8.1 and printed on on 70J80J



Page 11 of 78

sheets ? -onted on 70JK80J (oards. ndicate the n-erical scale on all plans, elevations, sections, and details. 2.8.2 Three <7= copies of 2.8.1 printed in A8 and rin$!(ond. 5irst copy shall (e colored +hile the second and third copies -ay (e in (lac) and +hite. ndicate the $raphical scale on all plans, elevations, sections, and details. 2.8.7 Eective --ary printed in A8 papers inclded in ection 2.8.2. 2.7.8 Po+erpoint presentation
*ption E 2.9.1

Mechanically drafted or freehand dra+in$sFrenderin$s listed in Ta(le 8.1 and dra+n directly on 70J80J (oards. 2.9.2 Three <7= copies
E0e%'tive S'mmary- The Eective --ary as -entioned in ections 2.1.7, 2.2.7, 2.7.7, 2.8.7, and 2.9.7 is the +ritten -anscript containin$ the follo+in$ • • • • • • •

Thesis TitleI Bac)$rond of the ProDect and tate-ent of the Pro(le-I ProDect 4oal and *(DectivesI ProDect cope and 'i-itationsI --ariCed ite escription and ite AnalysisI esi$n #oncept and PhilosophyI esi$n *(Dectives, #onsiderations, and trate$iesFApproachFoltions.

8.0

E0/e%te Dra;in$ O't/'t- 5rther to the afore-entioned visal presentation op! tions, Ta(le 8.1 presents the -ini-- otpts that have to (e prodced in esi$n 10 (efore the stdent is endorsed (y the Adviser and Thesis #oncil to have his Thesis proDect presented and defended in front of the Thesis %ry. The -ini-- dra+in$ re! Hire-ents and correspondin$ presentation specifications as prescri(ed in sections 2.1.1, 2.2.1, 2.7.1, 2.8.1, and 2.9.1 are li)e+ise sho+n on the ta(le.

9.0

C&an$e of T&esis Tit#e. Proor Pro


•

Page 1# of 78

#han$e of Thesis Title *ri$inal copies of si$ned 'etter of Proposal and #ertificate to ProceedI ReHest to #han$e Thesis TitleI and Approval to #han$e Thesis Title • • •

•

#han$e of ProDect *(Dectives *ri$inal copy of si$ned 'etter of ProposalI ReHest to Revise ProDect *(DectivesI and Approval to #han$e ProDect *(Dectives • • •

•

#han$e of ProDect ite ReHest to Revise ProDect iteI &icinity Map of Proposed iteI ite %stificationI and Approval to #han$e ProDect ite • • • •

Ta=#e ?-1 MINIMUM DRA:ING RE@UIREMENTS FOR THESIS PRESENTATION Re'irements

Minim'm S%a#e

Minim'm Content

#oncept Board

tdents, pon the reco-! -endation of their respec! tive Advisers, decide on the presentation scale of their thesis dra+! in$s.

ProDect Bac)$rond, ProDect 4oal and *(Dectives, e! si$n *(Dectives, esi$n #onsiderations, esi$n Phi! losophy and #oncept, ite Analysis

ite evelop-ent Plan

or caled Model

5loor Plans

5lly rendered and sho+in$ property line, (ildin$ shade and shado+s, north orientation, vicinity -ap, circlation flo+ of people and vehicles, site ? (ild! in$ entrances and eits
hold the stdent choose to present a scaled -odel, the site develop-ent plan is no lon$er necessary pro! vided that the scaled -odel sho+s the entire proDect t shall (e e-! develop-ent. phasiCed, Roo-s shall (e la(eled +ithin the spacesI use of ho+ever, that legends for room labels is not allowed. 5rnitre and le$i(ility of fitre layots -st (e sho+n. ho+ $rid lines and presentation section line


Page 1& of 78

ections

T+o <2= sections for sin$le strctresI one <1= section of every (ildin$ for -ltiple strctres. 'a(el visi(le roo-s and sho+ fitresFfrnitreFeHip-ent, ceilin$, doors and +indo+s. 4rid lines, /4', finish floors, ceilin$, and ape lines shall (e indicated. ections -st ct thro$h stair+ells F elevator shafts F escala! tors F ra-ps.

Elevations

5or <8= elevations for sin$le strctresI t+o <2= ele! vations of every (ildin$ for -ltiple strctres. Ren! dered and sho+in$ shade and shado+s. 4rid lines, /4', finish floor, and ape lines shall (e indicated.

Architectral Bay ection

ho+ fro- the lo+est to the top-ost architectral space andFor ele-ent. ho+ di-ensions, $rid lines, indicate levels, annotate -aterial specifications, and spot detail call!ots.

Architectral etails

trctral #oncept

dra+in$s is i-portant in a sccessfl the! sis presenta! tion, defense, and deli(era! tion.

Mini-- of five <9= niHeFspecial details derived fro- the Architectral Bay ection. etails shall (e identified in the (ay section thro$h call!ots. Anno! tated +ith di-ensions and -aterialFfinish specifica! tions. so-etric dra+in$ of all (ildin$s or of a -aDor strc! tre and sho+n +ith shade and shado+s.

Eterior Perspec! tive

treet!level vie+Fperspective of each strctreI Additional aerialF (irds eye vie+ of the +hole devel! op-ent for co-plees. Rendered.

nterior Architec! tre Perspective

At least one <1= perspective of a -aDor architectral interior. Rendered.

:.0

AD1 T&esis Aviser- The Adviser is a re$istered architect and holds a -asters de! $ree or hi$her. Advisers are -e-(ers of the faclty and are held to the sa-e respon! si(ilities and standards. Their professional and acade-ic Halifications ena(les Ad! visers to critically revie+ the thesis (ein$ proposed.

i-ilar to the previos architectral desi$n corse, the A10 Adviser shall (e re! sponsi(le for -eetin$ +ith the stdent once a +ee) and shall -aintain this schedle ntil the final endorse-ent. The Thesis Adviser is involved in helpin$ the stdent -aintain the ri$or and -ana$e the process of their thesis. n the Thesis pro$ra-, the stdent plays the role of the principal architect on a lar$e architectral co--ission, +hile the Advisers role is one of a senior collea$e offerin$ advice and $idance. t de-ands patience, co--it! -ent, and persistence.



Page 1' of 78

*ther dties and responsi(ilities of the A10 Thesis Adviser are as follo+s • •

•

•

•

• •

.0

Evalates the stdents perfor-ance after every individal consltation. Approves the stdents thesis +or) as s(stantial for preli-inary endorse-ent and certifies the readiness to proceed +ith the preparation of his thesis doc-ents for final endorse-ent. (-its to the Thesis #oncil, the list of stdents na-es reco--ended for final endorse-ent. 4ives the Advisers $rade +hich corresponds to 70L of the Thesis 5inal 4rade, s(Dect to conditions. (-its to the Thesis #oncil an electronic
Enorsements

.1

The tdent -st see) fro- hisFher Thesis Adviser a PRELIMINAR( ENDORSEMENT to proceed +ith the esi$n 10 corse. This Preli-inary Endorse-ent shall (e (ased on the s(-itted site develop-ent plan, floor plans, elevations and sections, etc of the ProDect. The Adviser shall se the A10 Preli-inary Endorse-ent 5or- and Matri for this prpose.

.2

5ro- April 7 to :, 201", the tdent -st see) a FINAL ENDORSEMENT fro- the Adviser. The (asis of this 5inal Endorse-ent shall (e the acco-! plish-ent of 9L to >0L of dra+in$s indicated in Ta(le 8.1 and in the -atri. The follo+in$ doc-ents shall (e s(-itted to the Thesis #oncil, thro$h the Thesis Adviser • • •

All dra+in$s
The Thesis #oncil shall chec) the co-pleteness of these doc-ents for the final endorse-ent approval of the stdent on Tesday, April 10, 201". All en! dorsed dra+in$s shall (e retrned to the tdent affied +ith si$natres fro- a Thesis #oncil representative. #opies of these si$ned dra+in$s shall (e in! clded in the hard (ond Thesis Boo) as C&a/ter B8 Desi$n So#'tion . ".0

Dra;in$ of Lots- The Thesis Adviser shall s(-it to the Thesis #oncil an elec! tronic copy of all endorsed stdents and their thesis titles. *n atrday, April 11, 201" an electronic lottery, to (e -oderated (y the Thesis #oordinator, shall (e held and attended (y a representative fro- each thesis class. Thesis Advisers are li)e+ise invited to +itness the dra+. UST College of Architecture Thei Progra! A" #$17%#$18


Page 1( of 78

The Thesis #oordinator shall post +ithin the #olle$e pre-ises the thesis deli(erations schedle on April 12, 201". >.0

De#i=eration G'ie#ines

>.1

essions. Thesis eli(erations shall (e fro- 1:!21 April 201". There are three daily deli(eration sessions. Mornin$ sessions start at "00AM, afternoon sessions start at 100PM and evenin$ sessions start at :00p#andidates schedled for -ornin$ sessions shall re$ister +ith the Thesis ay #hair at the 25 5aclty Roo- 'on$e on or (efore 00AM. 3pon re$istra! tion, the Thesis ay #hair shall infor- the #andidate (oth his desi$nated Dry roo- and presentation seHence. #andidates are epected to proceed to their Dry roo-, for proper introdction, and re-ain ntil his trn to present is called. #andidates schedled for afternoon sessions shall re$ister +ith the Thesis ay #hair on or (efore 1200//. #andidates schedled for evenin$ sessions shall re$ister +ith the Thesis ay #hair on or (efore 900PM.

>.2

eli(eration Attire. The #andidate shall (e in proper (siness attire drin$ the Thesis eli(eration. Proper (siness attire is •

•

>.7

5or Male #andidates corporate lon$ sleeves shirt +ith tie, or (siness sit, or Baron$ Ta$alo$ 5or 5e-ale #andidates corporate dress, (siness sit, or corporate 5ilipiniana

eli(eration ay ReHire-ents. The #andidate shall hand over to the Thesis Panel hisFher • • •

•

•

Thesis 'o$(oo)I T+o <2= copies of 'ry Fina# Grain$ S&eet detached frothis lo$(oo) Three <7= copies of the Inivi'a# 'rors Grain$ S&eet detached frothis lo$(oo)I All reHired dra+in$s and doc-ents, (ased on the #andidates presenta! tion option, as eplained in ection 2.0I and A hard!(ond copy of the Thesis Boo) +ith the copies of the si$ned en! dorsed dra+in$s in #hapter K.

The thesis (oo), as the principal otpt in esi$n >, shall (e sed as the (asis for desi$n develop-ent in esi$n 10. The Thesis %ry, drin$ the proceed! in$s, shall refer to, revie+, and verify its contents for co-pleteness and consis! tency (et+een research and desi$n soltion. A #andidates thesis proDect -ay UST College of Architecture Thei Progra! A" #$17%#$18


Page 1) of 78

lead to an nsccessfl defense shold there (e $larin$ inconsistencies (e! t+een thesis research and final desi$n soltion. >.8

Thesis %ry. The Thesis Dry or panel, all fro- the #olle$e of Architectre faclty, is co-posed of a #hair and t+o <2= -e-(ers.

>.9

Recordin$ of Proceedin$s. The #andidate shall (e per-itted to record the the! sis presentation and defense proceedin$s (y adio or video eHip-ent. 6o+! ever, the recordin$ eHip-ent shall (e s+itched off and (ro$ht ot of the %ry Roo- (efore the %ry eli(eration.

>.:

eli(eration chedle. The #andidate is $iven one hor to present and defend the proDect. The $iven ti-e shall (e (ro)en do+n as follo+s • • •

>.

20 -intes presentationI 70 -intes defense or Hestion ? ans+erI and 10 -intes %ry deli(eration and annonce-ent of Thesis $rade.

eli(eration Policies >..1

!efore t&e /resentation- 3nless reHested (y the #andidate to (e other+ise, all deli(erations shall (e open to the p(lic. Relatives and $ests -ay (e invited to +itness the proceedin$s.

The #andidates Thesis Adviser -ay (e present drin$ the presentation and defense -erely as an o(server. 6eFshe is prohi(ited fro- doin$ any of the follo+in$ (i) ans+erin$ for the #andidate, (ii) co--entin$ on %ry Hestions, and (iii) inflencin$ the otco-e of the deli(eration process. 5rther-ore, other faclty -e-(ers -ay o(serve and shall not have any official role in the proceedin$s. They shall (e prohi(ited froco--entin$ or Hestionin$ the +or) of the #andidate or conversin$ +ith any Dry -e-(er that -ay (e constred as disrptin$ the proceed! in$s. t shall (e the responsi(ility of the #andidate to ensre that di$ital files, soft+are, hard+are, and peripherals needed for his presentation are +or)in$ properly. n the event that an eHip-ent is falty, the The! sis #hair -ay decide to s)ip that portion of the presentation and (ase the deli(eration on the physical revie+ of the #andidates printed sheets or (oards. The individal %rors $radin$ sheets and Thesis %ry final $radin$ sheets shall (e co-pletely and le$i(ly filled ot (y the #andidate


>..2

Page 17 of 78

D'rin$ t&e /resentation- @hile a Thesis %ry -e-(er -ay serve as ti-e)eeper, it is epected that the #andidate is self!a+are that he does not eceed the 20 -intes allotted for his presentation.

tdents -ay assist the #andidate drin$ his presentation and defense. 6o+ever, they shall (e in their prescri(ed nifor-. The Thesis #hair reserves the ri$ht to discontine the proceedin$s shold any of the follo+in$ doc-entsF-aterials are -issin$ • •

•

•

Thesis 'o$(oo)I 5illed p %ry 5inal 4radin$ and ndividal %rors 4radin$ heetsI ReHired dra+in$s and doc-ents, (ased on the #andidates pre! sentation option, as eplained in ection 2.0I and A hard!(ond copy of the Thesis Boo) +ith the copies of the si$ned endorsed dra+in$s in #hapter K.

hold the #andidate have -issin$ or inco-plete presentation dra+! in$s, the #hair shall -a)e this )no+n to the #andidate and other %ry Me-(ers. The #hair shall, nonetheless, allo+ the #andidate to con! tine +ith the presentation. 6o+ever, this shall (e ta)en into consider! ation drin$ the co-ptation of the #andidates Thesis $rade. The si$ned final endorse-ent dra+in$s ..7

D'rin$ t&e efense- The Thesis %ry -ay as) the #andidate any Hes! tion that it dee-s relevant to the thesis proDect. The #andidate is re! sponsi(le for the correctness of ans+ers to Hestions +hich are +ithin the scope of their ProDect. The %ry -ay refer to the thesis (oo) for the validity and consistency of the #andidates ans+ers.

The %ry -ay, li)e+ise, revie+ the #andidates thesis lo$(oo) to eval! ate the #andidates dili$ence +hile +or)in$ on his thesis proDect. The #andidate shall -aintain co-posre drin$ the def ense even +hen confronted +ith difficlt Hestions or +hen challen$ed (y any -e-(er of the %ry on particlars and details of their proDect. The #andidate shall not have an anta$onistic attitde (efore, drin$ and after the de! li(eration. The #andidate shall not (e Hestioned on the financial feasi(ility of the ProDect. 6o+ever, the #andidate -ay (e as)ed Hestions on the socio! econo-ic and environ-ental i-pacts that the ProDect -ay have on the co--nity andFor i--ediate srrondin$s.



Page 18 of 78

The %ry shall not (ad$er a #andidate and press on a point that has (een conceded. A #andidate shall not (e anta$oniCed or terroriCed. A %ror shall not -onopoliCe the Hestions. The %ry #hair, actin$ as the -oderator, shall ensre that each -e-(er has an eHal opportnity to as) the #andidate. estions as)ed otsideF(eyond the scope of the #andidates +or) or difficlt Hestions +hich a #andidate sccessflly ans+er shall (e $iven additional points or -erits. >..8

D'rin$ t&e $rae e#i=eration an anno'n%ement of T&esis $rae*nce the %ry is thro$h +ith their Hestions, the #andidate, $ests, and all other spectators shall leave the Dry roo- to allo+ the %ry to deter-ine the otco-e of the deli(eration in private.

ndividal %rors 4rade. Each -e-(er of the Thesis Panel shall $rade the +or) of the #andidate (ased on the follo+in$ criteria as sho+n in Ta(le >.1 and sin$ the ndividal %rors 4radin$ heet.

Ta=#e -1 THESIS DELI!ERATION GRADING CRITERIA Criteria

:ei$&t

ccessfl evoltion of the desi$n concept and its s(stantial inte$ration to the desi$n soltionI

10.00L

ccessfl inte$ration of the proDect +ith eistin$ and ftre conditions of the site and its environsI

9.00L

ccessfl interpretation of a desi$n soltion that -eets the desired concept and thesis o(DectivesI

79.00L

nnovative (ildin$ for-s, elevations and interiors resltin$ in (ildin$ character that relates to the desi$n conceptI

19.00L

#orrect representation of lon$itdinal ? cross sections and architectral (ay section +ith sensi(le selection ? co-petent translation of architectral spot detailsI

10.00L

Appropriate choice of strctral fra-e+or)I and

9.00L

ccessfl presentation of thesis proDect and co-petent en$a$e-ent of critical dis! 20.00L corse +ith the Dry. O't/'t Grae

1-

Each %ry Me-(er shall a+ard n-erical $rades on all portionsFcate! $ories of the ProDect. The $rade scale is fro- 90 to 100, +ith 75 as the passing mark .



Page 1* of 78

Rondin$ off the individal $rade, Dry avera$e $rade, or final thesis $rade shall not (e allo+ed. A #andidate shall have sccessflly defended hisFher proDect if the Thesis proDect -erited passin$ $rades fro- t+o or three %ry Me-(ers. *nce the Thesis %ry has co-pleted their deli(eration, the #andidate shall (e called (ac) inside the %ry Roo-. tandin$ in front of the Thesis %ry, the #andidate shall affi hisFher si$natre on the Fina# 'ry Grain$ S&eet , after +hich the Thesis %ry #hair shall read the s--ary of the deli(eration and the decision of the Thesis %ry. The ori$inal copy of the 5inal %ry 4radin$ heet shall (e handed to the #andidate nless heFshe is instrcted (y the Thesis %ry to nder! ta)e so-e retochesFrevisions on the proDect. >..9

Post+e#i=eration- The #andidate shall Hic)ly collect hisFher presen! tation eHip-ent, -aterials, thesis (oo) and lo$(oo) to -a)e +ay for the net #andidate, ecept •

•

@hen the #andidate sccessflly defended hisFher thesis +ith a fi! nal $rade of 1.0
The Thesis %ry -ay as) for copies of the eective s--ary altho$h the #andidate is not reHired to do so. 10.0

S'%%essf'# T&esis Defense- The #andidate shall have sccessflly defended hisFher thesis proDect nder the follo+in$ circ-stances and as sho+n on 5i$re 10.1

10.1

@hen the thesis proDect, pon deli(eration, receives a passin$ $rade of 9 and a(ove fro- all three Thesis %rors, the Thesis final $rade shall (e derived and co-pted as follo+s 0.0L of Avera$e %ry 4rade N 70.0L of Thesis Adviser 4rade OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO 100.0L T&esis Fina# Grae The Thesis Adviser, +ho has +or)ed +ith the #andidate for a -ini-- of t+o ter-s, +ill (e allocated a thirty percent <70L= apportion-ent in the co-!



Page #$ of 78

ptation of the thesis final $rade. The (asis of this $rade +ill (e relayed to the Thesis %ry sin$ the T&esis Grain$ S&eet8 Aviser. 10.2

@hen the thesis proDect, pon deli(eration, receives a failin$ $rade of 90 to 8 fro- one Thesis %ror, the #andidate shall ato-atically receive a Thesis final $rade of 7.00
10.7

@hen the thesis proDect, pon deli(eration, receives a failin$ $rade of 90 to 8 fro- t+o or three Thesis %rors, the #andidate shall ato-atically receive a Thesis final $rade of 9.00 <5ailed=. The Thesis Advisers $rade is disre$arded.

Ta=#e 1-1 DETERMINATION OF THESIS FINAL GRADE

All %rors Passed

T+o %rors Passed F *ne %ror 5ailed

*ne %ror PassedF T+o %rors 5ailed

All %rors 5ailed

0L

7.0
9.0 <5ailed=

9.0 <5ailed=

70.0L

!

!

!

%ror 1 <#hair= %ror 2 %ror 7 Adviser

11.0

D1 Fina# Grae- The Thesis 5inal 4rade o(tained (y the #andidate drin$ the The! sis eli(eration is ato-atically eHivalent to the $rade the stdent +ill receive for the esi$n 10 corse. Ths, the Thesis Adviser shall not, in any circ-stance, chan$e the $rade of hisFher Thesis tdent +hether the stdent sccessflly or nsccessflly defended his Thesis proDect.

A stdent +ho o(tained a deli(eration $rade of 9.0 <5ailed= shall receive an encoded 10 $rade of :P 2:it&ra;a# ;it& Permission4 as reflected in the 5or- K. The Thesis #oncil shall revie+ and reserve the ri$ht to correct the $rade $iven (y the Thesis %ry if there is a co-ptation error or conversion discrepancy (et+een the Thesis 4rade and the EHivalent 4rade. This shall (e relayed to the stdent thro$h his Adviser. tdents +ho nsccessflly defended their Thesis proDects are encora$ed to )eep their copies of the %ry 5inal 4radin$ heet. The co--ents on the $radin$ sheet are sally the (asis for deli(eration shold the stdent re!enroll the A10 corse.



12.0

17.0

Page #1 of 78

T&esis Pro
12.1

The Thesis %ry #hair shall frnish the #andidateFtdent +ith the dplicateFcar(on copy of the 5inal %ry 4radin$ heet. The %rys reHired revisions and chan$es shold (e clearly indicated in this 4radin$ heet.

12.2

The stdent shold acco-plish the reHired revisions and -odifications +ithin three <7= school days fro- the deli(eration date. t is the responsi(ility of the stdent to loo) for and -eet +ith the %ry #hair and at least one %ry Me-(er for proper chec)in$ and endorse-ent of the co-pleted +or)s. Presentation and s(-ission of revisions shall (e condcted +ithin the confines of the #ol! le$e of Architectre of the 3niversity of anto To-as.

12.7

The %ry #hair and one %ry Me-(er shall affi their respective si$natres in the desi$nated (o in the dplicate copy of the 5inal %ry 4radin$ heet to in! dicate approval and endorse-ent of the presented revisions.

12.8

The student then presents this dly si$ned 4radin$ heet to the desi$nated Thesis #oordinator to officially record hisFher Thesis 5inal 4rade. The Thesis #oordinator hands over to the stdent the ori$inal copy of the 5inal %ry 4rad! in$ heet.

12.9

The stdent shall ato-atically receive a $rade of 9.00, converted to @P, if he is na(le to either present revisions +ithin the reHired period or his revisions +ere dee-ed (elo+ epectations.

Non+A//earan%e- n the event that the #andidate fails to appear on the schedled date or is -ore than 19 -intes late for his schedled presentation, he shall have for! feited his chance to defend his Thesis proDect. The #andidate shall ato-atically re! ceive a @P <@ithdra+al +ith per-ission= as final $rade for A10.

f the #andidate is sddenly indisposed or has a valid fa-ily e-er$ency, and ths can! not attend his schedled Thesis efense, he shall send, thro$h a representative, the (i) Thesis Boo), (ii) Thesis 'o$(oo), and (iii) all co-pleted Thesis @or)s as indi! cated in ection 2.0, to the assi$ned Thesis ay #hair on the day he is ori$inally schedled for deli(eration. 18.0

A//ea#s for Re%onsieration an Re'ests for Re+e#i=erations- The #andidateFtdent -ay appeal to the ean of the #olle$e of Architectre, in +ritin$, for a reconsideration of the 5inal Thesis 4rade or -ay reHest for a re!deli(eration if

18.1

There is a valid -edical reason or fa-ilyFpersonal e-er$ency for the #andi! date to -iss his schedled Thesis efense. This -st (e spported (y a hos! pital or le$al certification.



18.2

19.0

Page ## of 78

There is stron$ s(stantiated evidence of inappropriate (ehavior co-in$ froany -e-(er of the Thesis %ry (ased on the $idelines for %ry Me-(ers.

O'tstanin$ T&eses an T&esis of t&e (ear- Thesis stdents +ho o(tain a 5inal Thesis 4rade of 1.0
Their thesis proDects stand as evidence of the a(ilities and acco-plish-ents of the #olle$es otstandin$ thesis candidatesI it is a s(stantial rendition of their desi$n thin)in$ and s)ills. The *tstandin$ Thesis Ehi(it is the representation of these tal! ents to the architectral acade-ic co--nity. As sch, the ehi(it ass-es a role in for-in$ the p(lic nderstandin$ of +hat the 3T #olle$e of Architectre is. *tstandin$ Thesis Boo)s are retained (y the #olle$e for ftre reference. They are $roped in one area for easy access, and advisers of ftre RMA, A>, and A10 classes are encora$ed to refer to the- as indicators of the level of Hality for the the! sis pro$ra-. t for-s part of the cltral -e-ory of the #olle$e. rin$ the *tstandin$ Theses Ehi(it, stdents -ay a$ain (e reHired to present their proDects in front of a Dry co-posed of 3T #olle$e of Architectre Al-ni. The %ry shall $rade their +or) (ased on the sa-e deli(eration criteria presented on Ta(le >.1. The stdent +ith the -ost sccessfl thesis presentation of that years $radatin$ class shall receive the sole distinction of T&esis of t&e (ear , a+arded drin$ the ole-n nvestitres. 1:.0

D1 Re+enro##ment- 10 stdents +ho +ere not endorsed or +ho received a @P or 9.0 are eli$i(le to re!enroll dependin$ on the follo+in$ scenarios

Ta=#e 16-1 D1 RE+ENROLLMENT S%enario

Ear#iest D1 Re+enro##ment E#i$i=i#ity

tdent +as not endorsed (y the Thesis May re!enroll 10 offered in the first Adviser drin$ the 5irst Endorse-ent ter- of the scceedin$ acade-ic year tdent +as not endorsed (y the AdviserF May re!enroll 10 offered in the first Thesis #oncil in the 5inal Endorse-ent ter- of the scceedin$ acade-ic year tdentF#andidate +as a(sent drin$ May re!enroll 10 offered in the first hisFher schedled Thesis efense and ter- of the scceedin$ acade-ic year +ith no valid reason tdentF#andidate did not sccessflly May re!enroll 10 offered in the i--e! defend hisFher Thesis ProDect diate special ter-



Page #& of 78

These conditions apply to A10 stdents enrolled drin$ the econd Ter- of an Acade-ic Year. 1:.0

@'estions an In'iries- The tdent is encora$ed to conslt +ith -e-(ers of the Thesis #oncil for any Hestions and inHiries re$ardin$ esi$n > ?10. The tdent shall -aintain constant coordination and re$lar consltation +ith hisFher Thesis Ad! viser.



Page #' of 78

# 3 T

Re%o$nition  A%9no;#e$ment of Ar%&ite%t'ra# Desi$n 1 Po#i%ies

6 E R E

*ri$inal F tdent #opy

, OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO here(y ac)no+led$e that  have careflly read and nderstood all the provisions of the Architectral esi$n 10
 frther ac)no+led$e that  a- no+ tas)ed to finaliCe -y research +or) in accordance +ith the eistin$ $idelines and policies of the 3niversity of anto To-as #olle$e of Ar! chitectre.  a- li)e+ise reHired to s(-it the said research +or) on the ti-e and date desi$nated (y the Thesis Adviser this Ter-.

t is nderstood that -y co-pliance to all of the provisions specified herein shall (e the (asis of -y Advisers assess-ent of -y perfor-ance in accordance to all eistin$ $radin$ and evalation policies of the #olle$e and of the 3niversity.

#onfor-e

ate

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

tdents /a-e and i$natre



Page #( of 78

# 3 T

Re%o$nition  A%9no;#e$ment of Ar%&ite%t'ra# Desi$n 1 Po#i%ies

6 E R E

plicate F Adviser 5ile #opy

, OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO here(y ac)no+led$e that  have careflly read and nderstood all the provisions of the Architectral esi$n 10
 frther ac)no+led$e that  a- no+ tas)ed to finaliCe -y research +or) in accordance +ith the eistin$ $idelines and policies of the 3niversity of anto To-as #olle$e of Ar! chitectre.  a- li)e+ise reHired to s(-it the said research +or) on the ti-e and date desi$nated (y the Thesis Adviser this Ter-.

t is nderstood that -y co-pliance to all of the provisions specified herein shall (e the (asis of -y Advisers assess-ent of -y perfor-ance in accordance to all eistin$ $radin$ and evalation policies of the #olle$e and of the 3niversity.

#onfor-e

ate

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

tdents /a-e and i$natre

/ote to the tdent Qindly detach this dplicate copy and s(-it to yor Adviser on yor first consltation -eetin$. /ote to the Adviser Qindly collect and co-pile in a short (ro+n envelope. Than) yo.



Page #) of 78

PRE!#*/3'TAT*/ /*TE

:ee9 1. 1*+) an'ary )1, 5ill this section (efore -eetin$ yor Adviser /a-e

ection

Proposed Thesis Title

Proposed ite @hat are the isses and concerns that  shall as) -y Thesis Adviser



Page #7 of 78

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY

:ee9 1. 1*+) an'ary )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today

2. @hat shold  acco-plish in ti-e for the net schedled thesis consltation

7. @hen is -y net schedled consltation

Post consltation evalation
Belo+ E! pectation

 ati sf acto ry

A(o ve E ! pectation

Ecellent

tdent actively contri(ted to the discssion +ith personal insi$hts and via(le alternatives tdent ca-e for consltation prepared +ith discssion points and ac! co-plishin$ last -eetin$s to!do list. tdent arrived for consltation, and on ti-e. tdent ehi(ited interest and dili$ence (y ta)in$ notes of the consl! tation proceedin$s

i$ned

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO Advisers si$natre over printed na-e



Page #8 of 78

+a!e

,ate

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY # 3 T

:ee9 1. 1*+) an'ary )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today

6 E R E




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned


/ote to the Adviser Qindly collect ? co-pile in a short (ro+n envelope to (e sed as ftre reference for the stdents A10 final assess-ent.



Page #* of 78

PRE!#*/3'TAT*/ /*TE

:ee9 ). ))+)* an'ary )1, 5ill this section (efore -eetin$ yor Adviser /a-e

ection





Page &$ of 78

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY

:ee9 ). ))+)* an'ary )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned




Page &1 of 78

+a!e

,ate

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY # 3 T

:ee9 ). ))+)* an'ary )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today

6 E R E




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned





Page &# of 78

PRE!#*/3'TAT*/ /*TE

:ee9 5. ) an'ary + 5 Fe=r'ary )1, 5ill this section (efore -eetin$ yor Adviser /a-e

ection





Page && of 78

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY

:ee9 5. ) an'ary + 5 Fe=r'ary )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned




Page &' of 78

+a!e

,ate

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY # 3 T

:ee9 5. ) an'ary + 5 Fe=r'ary )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today

6 E R E




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned





Page &( of 78

AD1 PRELIMINAR( ENDORSEMENT MATRIB *ri$inal F tdent #opy To (e revie+ed and -ar)ed (y the Thesis Adviser tdent -st (e a(le to present hisFher otpt to the Thesis Adviser as descri(ed in any of the hi$hli$htedFitaliciCedFshaded (o to -erit a preli-inary endorse-ent.

Re'ire O't/'t

A

B

#



E

0 ! 2>L
70L ! 8>L <E&E'*P/4 *3T! P3T=

90L ! 8L <6A'5@AY #*M! P'ETE=

9L ! ">L <3BTA/TA''Y #*MP'ETE=

>0L ! 100L <#*MP'ETE=

Site Deve#o/+ ment P#an
*nly the (ildin$ line, contor lines and prop! erty line are sho+n

Everythin$ stated in A N Access and circlation
Everythin$ stated in B N 'andscapin$
Everythin$ stated in Everythin$ stated in  # N N Renderin$ of (ildin$
F#oor P#ans
'ess than half of all floors of all (ildin$s are dra+n sche-ati! cally

More than half of all floors of all (ildin$s are dra+n sche-ati! cally

All floors of all (ild! in$s +ith +all thic)! nessI door and +indo+ openin$s are indicatedI all spaces are le$i(ly la(elled

Everythin$ stated in # N All doors and +indo+s are dra+nI frnitreFfitreFeHip! -ent <55E= are dra+n on all -aDor spaces, ad! -inistrative spaces, and toilets

Everythin$ stated in ;; N 55E sho+n on the rest of the spacesI all floor plans are la(elledI n-erical or $raphical scale are sho+nI $ridlines and section lines are dra+nI dra+in$s are rendered

E#evations
'ess than half of all re! Hired elevations

More than half of all reHired elevations

All reHired elevations

Everythin$ stated in ;#; N ra+in$ la(els, $rid! lines, finish floor lines

Everythin$ stated in ; N hade and shado+sI dra+! in$s are renderedI n-eri! cal or $raphical scale



Page &) of 78

+a!e

,ate

AD1 PRELIMINAR( ENDORSEMENT MATRIB Thesis Adviser #opy To (e revie+ed and -ar)ed (y the Thesis Adviser tdent -st (e a(le to present hisFher otpt to the Thesis Adviser as descri(ed in any of the hi$hli$htedFitaliciCedFshaded (o to -erit a preli-inary endorse-ent.

Re'ire O't/'t

A

B

#



E

0 ! 2>L
70L ! 8>L <E&E'*P/4 *3T! P3T=

90L ! 8L <6A'5@AY #*M! P'ETE=

9L ! ">L <3BTA/TA''Y #*MP'ETE=

>0L ! 100L <#*MP'ETE=

Site Deve#o/ment P#an

Everythin$ stated in # N ra+in$ la(el, /orth orientation, $raphical or n-erical scaleI la! (els <(ildin$s, otdoor spaces, and par)in$=I la(els for site and (ildin$ in$ress and e$ress
Everythin$ stated in  N Renderin$ of (ildin$
F#oor P#ans





E#evations







Page &7 of 78

A

B

#



E

0 ! 2>L
70L ! 8>L <E&E'*P/4 *3T! P3T=

90L ! 8L <6A'5@AY #*M! P'ETE=

9L ! ">L <3BTA/TA''Y #*MP'ETE=

>0L ! 100L <#*MP'ETE=

Se%tions
'ess than half of all reHired sections

More than half of all reHired sections

All reHired sections are dra+n co-pletely

Everythin$ stated in ;#; N ra+in$ la(els, $rid! lines, different levels are sho+nI all roo-s are la(elled

Everythin$ stated in ;; N 5rnitreFfitreFeHip! -ent, ceilin$ are dra+nI dra+in$s are renderedI n! -erical or $raphical scale

Ar%&ite%t'+ ra# !ay Se%+ tion 2A!S4 an S/ot De+ tai#s
'ess than half of all architectral details

More than half of all architectral details

All five architectral detailsI AB sho+in$ the lo+! est to the hi$hest archi! tectral featre

Everythin$ stated in ;#; N #allots, di-ensions, floorFceilin$Fape line, -aterial specs, frni! treFfitreFeHip-ent, $ridlines, dra+in$ and roo- la(els, scale of the AB

Everythin$ stated in  N 5ive architectral spot details +ith di-ensions, specifications, scale and dra+in$ la(els

Str'%t'ra# Con%e/t
'ess than half of strctral concept

More than half of strc! tral concept

trctral concept is dra+n +ith di-ensions, specifications, and dra+in$ la(els

Everythin$ stated in ;#; N trctral #oncept
Everythin$ stated in  N hade and shado+s and renderin$ for the trct. #oncept

Pers/e%tives
More than half of the reHired eterior and architectral interior perspectives are -od! eled

More than half of the reHired eterior and architectral interior perspectives are -od! eled +ith co-ponents

More than half of the reHired eterior and architectral interior perspectives are ren! dered +ith -aterials

More than half of the reHired eterior and architectral interior perspectives are ren! dered +ith shado+s and li$ht

All reHired eterior and architectral interior per! spectives are post pro! cessed +ith entora$e, and (ac)$rond.

Con%e/t !oar
ProDect Title, ProDect Bac)$rond, ProDect 4oal and *(! Dectives

Everythin$ stated in ;A; N esi$n *(Dectives, e! si$n #onsiderations, Philosophy and #on! cept

Everythin$ stated in B; N #onceptal evelop! -ent, 5or- or hape 5indin$

Everythin$ stated in # N ite Analysis

Everythin$ stated in ; N All icono$raphy, i-a$es, illstrations to spport A, SB, #, and I Renderin$

T&esis !oo9
3pdated F corrected less than 70L of the (oo)


3pdated F corrected -ore than 90L of the (oo)

3pdated F corrected -ore than 9L of the (oo)

3pdated F corrected F co-! pleted all reHire-ents for the Thesis Boo)

Re'ire O't/'t



Page &8 of 78

+a!e

A

B

#



E

0 ! 2>L
70L ! 8>L <E&E'*P/4 *3T! P3T=

90L ! 8L <6A'5@AY #*M! P'ETE=

9L ! ">L <3BTA/TA''Y #*MP'ETE=

>0L ! 100L <#*MP'ETE=

Se%tions









Everythin$ stated in  N 5ive architectral spot de! tails +ith di-ensions, specifications, scale and dra+in$ la(els

Str'%t'ra# Con%e/t an Detai#s




Pers/e%tives





Con%e/t !oar





T&esis !oo9


3pdated F corrected -ore than 90L of the (oo)

3pdated F corrected -ore than 9L of the (oo)

3pdated F corrected F co-! pleted all reHire-ents for the Thesis Boo)

Re'ire O't/'t

# 3 T

,ate

6 E R E



Page &* of 78

The Pontifical and Royal 3niversity of anto To-as Espana, Manila

#*''E4E *5 AR#6TE#T3RE T6E PR*4RAM

Certifi%ate of Pre#iminary Enorsement *ri$inal F tdent #opy

This #ertificate is here(y $iven to OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO +hose thesis entitled OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO has (een careflly evalated and endorsed (y the ndersi$ned Thesis Adviser.

This frther certifies that the stdent has sccessflly co-pleted all the preli-inary re! Hire-ents of the Architectral esi$n 10 corse and is no+ eli$i(le to proceed to final phase of the Architectral Thesis Pro$ra-.

This #ertificate of Preli-inary Endorse-ent is issed on OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO Thesis Adviser



Page '$ of 78



# 3 T 6 E R E

Certifi%ate of Pre#iminary Enorsement plicate F Adviser 5ile #opy

This #ertificate is here(y $iven to OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO +hose thesis entitled OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO has (een careflly evalated and endorsed (y the ndersi$ned Thesis Adviser.

This frther certifies that the stdent has sccessflly co-pleted all the preli-inary re! Hire-ents of the Architectral esi$n 10 corse and is no+ eli$i(le to proceed to final phase of the Architectral Thesis Pro$ra-.

This #ertificate of Preli-inary Endorse-ent is issed on OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO Thesis Adviser



Page '1 of 78

PRE!#*/3'TAT*/ /*TE

:ee9 ?. +1 Fe=r'ary )1, 5ill this section (efore -eetin$ yor Adviser /a-e

ection





Page '# of 78

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY

:ee9 ?. +1 Fe=r'ary )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned




Page '& of 78

+a!e

,ate

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY # 3 T

:ee9 ?. +1 Fe=r'ary )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today

6 E R E




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned





Page '' of 78

PRE!#*/3'TAT*/ /*TE

:ee9 . 1)+1* Fe=r'ary )1, 5ill this section (efore -eetin$ yor Adviser /a-e

ection





Page '( of 78

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY

:ee9 . 1)+1* Fe=r'ary )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned




Page ') of 78

+a!e

,ate

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY # 3 T

:ee9 . 1)+1* Fe=r'ary )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today

6 E R E




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned





Page '7 of 78

PRE!#*/3'TAT*/ /*TE

:ee9 6. 1+)? Fe=r'ary )1, 5ill this section (efore -eetin$ yor Adviser /a-e

ection





Page '8 of 78

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY

:ee9 6. 1+)? Fe=r'ary )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned




Page '* of 78

+a!e

,ate

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY # 3 T

:ee9 6. 1+)? Fe=r'ary )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today

6 E R E




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned





Page ($ of 78

PRE!#*/3'TAT*/ /*TE

:ee9 *. )6 Fe=r'ary + 5 Mar%& )1, 5ill this section (efore -eetin$ yor Adviser /a-e

ection





Page (1 of 78

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY

:ee9 *. )6 Fe=r'ary + 5 Mar%& )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned




Page (# of 78

+a!e

,ate

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY # 3 T

:ee9 *. )6 Fe=r'ary + 5 Mar%& )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today

6 E R E




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned





Page (& of 78

PRE!#*/3'TAT*/ /*TE

:ee9 ,. +1 Mar%& )1, 5ill this section (efore -eetin$ yor Adviser /a-e

ection





Page (' of 78

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY

:ee9 ,. +1 Mar%& )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned




Page (( of 78

+a!e

,ate

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY # 3 T

:ee9 ,. +1 Mar%& )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today

6 E R E




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned





Page () of 78

PRE!#*/3'TAT*/ /*TE

:ee9 . 1)+1* Mar%& )1, 5ill this section (efore -eetin$ yor Adviser /a-e

ection





Page (7 of 78

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY

:ee9 . 1)+1* Mar%& )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned




Page (8 of 78

+a!e

,ate

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY # 3 T

:ee9 . 1)+1* Mar%& )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today

6 E R E




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned


/ote to the Adviser Qindly collect ? co-pile in a short (ro+n envelope to (e sed as ftre reference for the stdents A10 final assess-ent



Page (* of 78

PRE!#*/3'TAT*/ /*TE

:ee9 1. 1+)? Mar%& )1, 5ill this section (efore -eetin$ yor Adviser /a-e

ection





Page )$ of 78

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY

:ee9 1. 1+)? Mar%& )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned




Page )1 of 78

+a!e

,ate

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY # 3 T

:ee9 1. 1+)? Mar%& )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today

6 E R E




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned





Page )# of 78

PRE!#*/3'TAT*/ /*TE

:ee9 11. )6+51 Mar%& )1, 5ill this section (efore -eetin$ yor Adviser /a-e

ection





Page )& of 78

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY

:ee9 11. )6+51 Mar%& )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned




Page )' of 78

+a!e

,ate

A10 /&3A' #*/3'TAT*/ 3MMARY # 3 T

:ee9 11. )6+51 Mar%& )1, This section shall (e filled ot (y the Thesis stdent drin$ consltation. 1. @hat are -y Advisers co--ents on -y otpt today

6 E R E




 ati sf acto ry


Ecellent


i$ned





Page )( of 78

+a!e

Sectio-

Title

AD1 FINAL ENDORSEMENT MATRIB *ri$inal F tdent #opy To (e revie+ed and -ar)ed (y the Thesis Adviser tdent -st (e a(le to present hisFher otpt to the Thesis Adviser as descri(ed in any of the hi$hli$htedFitaliciCedFshaded (o to -erit a preli-inary endorse-ent.

Re'ire O't/'t

A

B

#



E

0 ! 2>L
70L ! 8>L <E&E'*P/4 *3T! P3T=

90L ! 8L <6A'5@AY #*M! P'ETE=

9L ! ">L <3BTA/TA''Y #*MP'ETE=

>0L ! 100L <#*MP'ETE=


F#oor P#ans 0L=






E#evations 0L=






Site Deve#o/+ ment P#an 0L=



Page )) of 78

+a!e

Sectio-

Title

# 3 T

AD1 FINAL ENDORSEMENT MATRIB plicate F Adviser 5ile #opy To (e revie+ed and -ar)ed (y the Thesis Adviser

6 E R E

tdent -st (e a(le to present hisFher otpt to the Thesis Adviser as descri(ed in any of the hi$hli$htedFitaliciCedFshaded (o to -erit a preli-inary endorse-ent.

Re'ire O't/'t

A

B

#



E

0 ! 2>L
70L ! 8>L <E&E'*P/4 *3T! P3T=

90L ! 8L <6A'5@AY #*M! P'ETE=

9L ! ">L <3BTA/TA''Y #*MP'ETE=

>0L ! 100L <#*MP'ETE=


F#oor P#ans 0L=






E#evations 0L=






Site Deve#o/+ ment P#an 0L=



Page )7 of 78

+a!e

SectioA

B

#



E

0 ! 2>L
70L ! 8>L <E&E'*P/4 *3T! P3T=

90L ! 8L <6A'5@AY #*M! P'ETE=

9L ! ">L <3BTA/TA''Y #*MP'ETE=

>0L ! 100L <#*MP'ETE=

Se%tions














Pers/e%tives





Con%e/t !oar





Re'ire O't/'t

5/A' E &A'3AT*/

DID NOT MEET ENDORSEMENT CRITERIA

SATISFACTORIL( MET ENDORSEMENT CRITERIA

Evalated (y F ate



Page )8 of 78

+a!e

Sectio-

# 3 T 6 E R E

A

B

#



E

0 ! 2>L
70L ! 8>L <E&E'*P/4 *3T! P3T=

90L ! 8L <6A'5@AY #*M! P'ETE=

9L ! ">L <3BTA/TA''Y #*MP'ETE=

>0L ! 100L <#*MP'ETE=

Se%tions














Pers/e%tives





Con%e/t !oar





Re'ire O't/'t

5/A' E &A'3AT*/

DID NOT MEET ENDORSEMENT CRITERIA

SATISFACTORIL( MET ENDORSEMENT CRITERIA

Evalated (y F ate



Page )* of 78



Certifi%ate of Fina# Enorsement *ri$inal F tdent #opy

This #ertificate is here(y $iven to OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO +hose thesis entitled OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO has (een careflly evalated and endorsed (y the Thesis Adviser.

This frther certifies that the stdent has sccessflly co-pleted prodction of at least >0L of the Architectral esi$n 10 corse reHire-ents and is no+ eli$i(le to defend hisFher thesis proDect on the desi$nated date and session to (e deter-ined drin$ the electronic dra+in$ of lots for all candidates that -erited this 5inal Endorse-ent.

n the -eanti-e, the stdent is advised to discss +ith hisFher Adviser the (est presentation option for the thesis proDect.

This #ertificate of 5inal Endorse-ent is issed on OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO Thesis Adviser



Page 7$ of 78



# 3 T 6 E R E

Certifi%ate of Fina# Enorsement plicate F Adviser 5ile #opy

This #ertificate is here(y $iven to OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO +hose thesis entitled OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO has (een careflly evalated and endorsed (y the Thesis Adviser.

This frther certifies that the stdent has sccessflly co-pleted prodction of at least >0L of the Architectral esi$n 10 corse reHire-ents and is no+ eli$i(le to defend hisFher thesis proDect on the desi$nated date and session to (e deter-ined drin$ the electronic dra+in$ of lots for all candidates that -erited this 5inal Endorse-ent.

n the -eanti-e, the stdent is advised to discss +ith hisFher Adviser the (est presentation option for the thesis proDect.

This #ertificate of 5inal Endorse-ent is issed on OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO Thesis Adviser



Page 71 of 78

THESIS GRADING SHEET8 AD3ISER
# 3 T 6 E R E

To the Thesis Adviser Qindly fill p the necessary infor-ation (elo+ to serve as a thoro$h assess-ent of the stdents per! for-ance for the A10 corse. Than) yo.

A.

Please chec) the (o if the stdent has the follo+in$ in hisFher final otpt. This +ill constitte 79L of the stdents $rade. Content

Ma0im'm 

#oncept Board

7.90

ite evelop-ent Plan

7.90

All 5loor Plans

:.00

All Elevations

8.00

All ections

8.00

Architectral Bay ection ? Architectral etails

7.90

trctral #oncept

7.90

nterior Architectre Perspective
7.90

Eterior Perspective
7.90

Grae

SU!TOTAL FOR AJ OUT OF 5

B. s the +or) of $ood Hality Please evalate the overall otpt of the stdent sin$ the follo+in$ evalation -atri. This +ill constitte 79L of the stdents $rade. 5ail

Pass

5air

4ood

&ery 4ood

Ecellent

18.

1:.1

1.0

1".8

1>.9

21.0

Presentation of ne+ ideas
8.>

9.8

9.

:.2

:.9

.0

Accracy and le$i(ility of dra+in$s <20L=

8.>

9.8

9.

:.2

:.9

.0

4radin$ #riteria #ontri(tion to solvin$ the Thesis 4oal and *(Dectives <:0L=

SU!TOTAL FOR !J OUT OF 5



# 3 T 6 E R E

Page 7# of 78

THESIS GRADING SHEET8 AD3ISER
5ail

Pass

5air

4ood

&ery 4ood

Ecellent

"."

>.:

10.1

10.>

11.:

12.9

#ontri(tes to the discssion (y providin$ per! sonal desi$n F research insi$hts <70L=

9.2

9.

:.1

:.:

.0

.9

Attends consltation re$larly and pnctally <20L=

7.9

7."

8.0

8.8

8.:

9.0

#o-es to consltation prepared <90L=

SU!TOTAL FOR CJ OUT OF )

. oes the stdent display -atrity and the ri$ht deport-ent drin$ this ter- Please evalate the overall otpt of the st! dent sin$ the follo+in$ evalation -atri. This +ill constitte 9L of the stdents $rade. 4radin$ #riteria 'evel of Matrity and eport-ent <100L=

5ail

Pass

5air

4ood

&ery 4ood

Ecellent

7.9

7."

8.0

8.8

8.:

9.0

SU!TOTAL FOR DJ OUT OF 

5rther co--ents

SUMMAR( #riteria

A

B

#



*tpt 4rade

#o-pleteness of @or)

79L

ality of @or)

79L

#onsltation ties

29L

Matrity and Attitde

9L

FINAL AD GRADE AK!KCKD

E@UI3ALENT 5 APPORTIONMENT OF THE FINAL THESIS GRADE



Page 7& of 78

%ry 5inal 4radin$ heet Origi-al  Stu/e-t Co6

# 3 T 6 E R E

+a!e

Sectio-

Title

A/0ier

ProFect Site

,ate

Thesis Grade Computation

Poi-t to Gra/e Co-0erio-  E2ui0ale-t

A. 3uror 1 Chair Gra/e

4i-al Gra/e

Re!ar5

E2ui0ale-t

B. 3uror # Gra/e

+o- A66eara-ce

P

P

C. 3uror & Gra/e

($.$$ % 7'.**

4ail

(.$$

,. A0erage 3ur Gra/e 9A:B:C;  &

7(.$$ % 78.**

Pa

&.$$

7*.$$ % 81.**

4air

#.7(

8#.$$ % 8&.**

4air

#.($

8'.$$ % 8).**

Goo/

#.#(

4. 7$< 3ur Gra/e 9, = .7$;

87.$$ % 88.**

Goo/

#.$$

G. &$< A/0ier Gra/e 9E = .&$;

8*.$$ % *1.**

Goo/

1.7(

H. Thei 4i-al Gra/e 94 : G;

*#.$$ % *&.**

>er Goo/

1.($

I. E?UI>ALE+T TO@ +ote@ H i -ot to e rou-/e/ off

*'.$$ % *(.**

>er Goo/

1.#(

*).$$ % 1$$.$$

EDcelle-t

1.$$

E. A/0ier Gra/e

Su!!ar@ 9Ki-/l ue ac5 6age for a//itio-al co!!e-t;

4raded (y

ate

OOOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOO

OOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOO O

Advisers /a-e and i$natre

Ca-/i/ate Sig-ature

Thei 3ur

3ur 1 Chair

3ur #

3ur &

Re0iio- ,ue ,ate@

Ae!e-t 9Pleae e-circle; Sati Satisf sfa actor ctory y

Origi-al Gra/i-g Sheet Releae/ B@

Unsa nsatis tisfact factor ory y

,ate@



Page 7' of 78

%ry 5inal 4radin$ heet ,u6licate  Office 4ile Co6

# 3 T 6 E R E

+a!e

Sectio-

Title

A/0ier

ProFect Site

,ate

Thesis Grade Computation

Poi-t to Gra/e Co-0erio-  E2ui0ale-t

A. 3uror 1 Chair Gra/e

4i-al Gra/e

Re!ar5

E2ui0ale-t

B. 3uror # Gra/e

+o- A66eara-ce

P

P

C. 3uror & Gra/e

($.$$ % 7'.**

4ail

(.$$

,. A0erage 3ur Gra/e 9A:B:C;  &

7(.$$ % 78.**

Pa

&.$$

7*.$$ % 81.**

4air

#.7(

8#.$$ % 8&.**

4air

#.($

8'.$$ % 8).**

Goo/

#.#(

4. 7$< 3ur Gra/e 9, = .7$;

87.$$ % 88.**

Goo/

#.$$

G. &$< A/0ier Gra/e 9E = .&$;

8*.$$ % *1.**

Goo/

1.7(

H. Thei 4i-al Gra/e 94 : G;

*#.$$ % *&.**

>er Goo/

1.($

I. E?UI>ALE+T TO@ +ote@ H i -ot to e rou-/e/ off

*'.$$ % *(.**

>er Goo/

1.#(

*).$$ % 1$$.$$

EDcelle-t

1.$$

E. A/0ier Gra/e

Su!!ar@ 9Ki-/l ue ac5 6age for a//itio-al co!!e-t;

Ca-/i/ate Sig-ature

Thei 3ur

3ur 1 Chair

3ur #

Re0iio- ,ue ,ate@

3ur & Ae!e-t 9Pleae e-circle; Satisfactory

Chec Chec5e 5e/ /   ,ate@ ate@

Che Chec5e/ c5e/   ,ate ,ate@@

Unsatisfactory

To the Stu Stu/e/e-t@ Ki-/ Ki-/l l u! u!it it thi thi for! or! to the the The Thei i Cou-cil Coor/i-ator afterar/. UST College of Architecture Thei Progra! A" #$17%#$18


Page 7( of 78

Grain$ S&eet8 T&esis 'ror 1 2C&air4 # 3 T

+a!e

Sectio-

Title

Pree-tatio- O6tio- 9E-circle;

ProFect Site

A

C

,

E

Comment Box

Grading Criteria

6 E R E

B

FAIL

PASS

FAIR

GOOD

VG

EXC

50 - 74

75 - 78

79 - 83

84 - 91

92 - 95

96 - 100

Given Grade

Succeful e0olutio- of the /eig- co-ce6t a-/ it uta-tial i-tegratio- to the /eig- olutio- 91$.$<; (.$ % 7.'

7.( % 7.8

7.* % 8.&

8.' % *.1

*.# % *.(

*.) % 1$

Succeful i-tegratio- of the 6roFect ith eDiti-g a-/ future co-/itio- of the ite a-/ it e-0iro- 9(.$<; #.( % &.7

&.8 % &.*

'.$ % '.1

'.# % '.(

'.) % '.7

'.8 % (.$

Succeful i-ter6retatio- of a /eig- olutio- that !eet the /eire/ co-ce6t a-/ thei oFecti0e 9&(<; 17.( % #(.*

#).&  #7.&

#7.7  #*.1

#*.'  &1.*

&#.#  &&.&

&&.)  &(.$

I--o0ati0e uil/i-g for! ele0atio- a-/ i-terior reulti-g iuil/i-g character that relate to the /eig- co-ce6t 91(<; 7.(  11.1

11.&  11.7

11.*  1#.(

1#.)  1&.7

1&.8  1'.&

1'.'  1(.$

Correct re6ree-tatio- of lo-gitu/i-al J cro ectio- a-/ ar% chitectur chitectural al a ectio- ith e-ile e-ile electioelectio- J co!6ete-t co!6ete-t tra-latio- of architectural 6ot /etail 91$<; (.$ % 7.'

7.( % 7.8

7.* % 8.&

8.' % *.1

*.# % *.(

*.) % 1$

A66ro6riate choice of tructural tructural fra!eor5 9(<; 9(<; #.( % &.7

&.8 % &.*

'.$ % '.1

'.# % '.(

'.) % '.7

'.8 % (.$

Succeful 6ree-tatio- of thei 6roFect a-/ co!6ete-t e-% gage!e-t of critical /icoure ith the Fur. 9#$<; 1$.$  1'.8

1(.$  1(.)

1(.8  1).)

1).8  18.#

3ur 1 Chair Sig-ature O0er Pri-te/ +a!e

18.'  1*.$

1*.#  #$.$

Gra/e

Thei ,elieratio- Reult

Passed

Failed



Page 7) of 78

Grain$ S&eet8 T&esis 'ror ) # 3 T

+a!e

Sectio-

Title


ProFect Site

A

C

,

E

Comment Box

Grading Criteria

6 E R E

B

FAIL

PASS

FAIR

GOOD

VG

EXC

50 - 74

75 - 78

79 - 83

84 - 91

92 - 95

96 - 100

Given Grade


7.( % 7.8

7.* % 8.&

8.' % *.1

*.# % *.(

*.) % 1$


&.8 % &.*

'.$ % '.1

'.# % '.(

'.) % '.7

'.8 % (.$


#).&  #7.&

#7.7  #*.1

#*.'  &1.*

&#.#  &&.&

&&.)  &(.$


11.&  11.7

11.*  1#.(

1#.)  1&.7

1&.8  1'.&

1'.'  1(.$

Correct re6ree-tatio- of lo-gitu/i-al J cro ectio- a-/ ar% chitectural a ectio- ith e-ile electio- J co!6ete-t tra-latio- of architectural 6ot /etail 91$<; (.$ % 7.'

7.( % 7.8

7.* % 8.&

8.' % *.1

*.# % *.(

*.) % 1$

A66ro6riate choice of tructural fra!eor5 9(<; #.( % &.7

&.8 % &.*

'.$ % '.1

'.# % '.(

'.) % '.7

'.8 % (.$


1(.$  1(.)

1(.8  1).)

3uror # Sig-ature O0er Pri-te/ +a!e

1).8  18.#

18.'  1*.$

1*.#  #$.$

Gra/e


Passed

Failed



Page 77 of 78

Grain$ S&eet8 T&esis 'ror 5 # 3 T

+a!e

Sectio-

Title


ProFect Site

A

C

,

E

Comment Box

Grading Criteria

6 E R E

B

FAIL

PASS

FAIR

GOOD

VG

EXC

50 - 74

75 - 78

79 - 83

84 - 91

92 - 95

96 - 100

Given Grade


7.( % 7.8

7.* % 8.&

8.' % *.1

*.# % *.(

*.) % 1$


&.8 % &.*

'.$ % '.1

'.# % '.(

'.) % '.7

'.8 % (.$


#).&  #7.&

#7.7  #*.1

#*.'  &1.*

&#.#  &&.&

&&.)  &(.$


11.&  11.7

11.*  1#.(

1#.)  1&.7

1&.8  1'.&

1'.'  1(.$

Correct re6ree-tatio- of lo-gitu/i-al J cro ectio- a-/ ar% chitectural a ectio- ith e-ile electio- J co!6ete-t tra-latio- of architectural 6ot /etail 91$<; (.$ % 7.'

7.( % 7.8

7.* % 8.&

8.' % *.1

*.# % *.(

*.) % 1$

A66ro6riate choice of tructural fra!eor5 9(<; #.( % &.7

&.8 % &.*

'.$ % '.1

'.# % '.(

'.) % '.7

'.8 % (.$


1(.$  1(.)

1(.8  1).)

3uror & Sig-ature O0er Pri-te/ +a!e

1).8  18.#

18.'  1*.$

1*.#  #$.$

Gra/e


Passed

Failed


logbook.pdf

Recommend Documents