Media Power: The Double Bnd by Stuart Hall
An English scholars anays of the boaaster eationship t t pwe stctue sciet gests tat bae ithin tht stctue eees it nitn o th pita de. British broadcastng sttutons ave a reat eal o orma atonomy om te sta an ovent, u er auo to roaat erves sate, an ltaty, i s o the ae at e ae esponsb. What are usua unstoo as "exera nuene o oadastn ae n fa t ve wokng otex for roadasng e sud o suh i iuenes tereore s a naqat o or exang t mdation etwen raasing a ower t s eiat on a oe roaasi wh taes at ae vau t oa an eta autono; extna nuenes ae see as oahg uon ts area of redom I o not mean to deny spi intane o pressur ien an censorshi to i oaastr ae een ujet Nor do ea t en th reative autoom o roadasing roadasin g in it da-o-a rat eveess e rea aos been radatn owr, an ido is oro mst u a o O t s tt av e as of udersann o poer d uen ow how rate isiuona nteratio is aopsed soieties wh ae o e fora deora Isi are coeie o a either staeontroe ad oiated in ase e e wihn te oex o sae power o as ree and autonoous e cannt from an exera uenes ode pre or coreed e sei areas of coere an dsuure wich aise eee deent instiuos n sce Thus w ou i posse o acou or the act tat on oe se ocasos roadcaer ass er edtora nepn Stuart Ha is D reo o Cee for Conmporay Culral des th Uvers Brmgha. Ega Ths a x rm s r to he Fo os Pc at es o M 2
Journal of Comunicatin, Autu
dce agast cea ial rs u d a te am e count for t mutual aust ts t it of terests d dtos. cu ig m y t ay btwe rcstrs te is titutis of power. T overage f ret evets i Nrtr l as b assie ta tulss a extenal trait Silly ti a eate wit eet to te bro castrs' rigt t iti ere seative oesme o IRA. Here cearly, raasts a sbjec h o xal c a p ssr " n t itrl t onal sel-cenors. B v ad o cc presetatios ssue bee mae o broadcater, ca e vae a i w systematclly, te roadcaer r o accor v ec her crrent aas ege o Nrt I sto prpoed IRA a mpazrs? Tre o ony o a js cocal, coigcy w sc a rac cod eer becm ideprad h br dcast r zat: o n were cry s llz powr y agait grmet plies a e brdcsrs ould rr a xral autty lteative o e s e blc p O wtr sa r enes rectl o cr oacas cora Ulsr or r v a lg edec gazas s be to t temsel d eon o iuo rocaters' ec t o ntervew IR pok " e d c te ymblc cote o or e as di o RA as a llal gzon s a mrr rc a amia te cis t c o tcal arte subscrib a te IA do ot ctitt a e e polca c n he l s a Smper b mor e mslead, mds ar rque aad b ot e pocal r a plcal O r sp ry o o or ca a tae or agt-pr op e meia e see s c pple o are d or wok oca Mc a rooio s s adaned b e o . Teevson era er fro a x mely arro cal , n os wo ok a poerull caz o o morale e oaca os B I o l a o - a ca acco or trms of ovr ot cl aoo or rho a r cor W ar o ca a q r a c
0
Media POet: Th Doble B
indvds re systemtcl constrined t hnde the vet new nd ccunt hich tey rcess ay thin the fek a lmted se f nterr etat ns . Nr d beeve tht the dcstes ae system· aticall y ensed an pssured fm extrnsc srces except n ited n largey exceptina ces. Jut s t s mssie t "net the inuene dvetising in the pres n te of the nue f tmes adertsers ha eplcitly thetened edit ith the wthdrawa f the utm, s it is impsle to net the re structue f interests n teevisin rd in ter diect repreenttin y gernment cals t ra cst institutins. Crtnl thee re ssue n es hee te sstem scutny is very precse-n it is iprtnt to ien f y where nd wht these re But the retve utnm te broadc tng sttuto s o a mee cv: t is I eeve centra to te pe nd ideg are meated n soeti ke rs. B rocast ng accmmates tself t the werdelg exus b w of a nmber ui intevening cnceps hese cncets meate the relatinhip the cstes t er Te ovde he srucure o etimtins whch ermit te bracasters o exrcise a subsanal measre of doral nd day-tay cnrol wout crav he oeral egemon At te me me, t esseta o recogze that t orentan f b roacasting withn he hegemonc de logy s o a fctly regulted fuly ntegrate ne·densn stem The centr ncept hch mate b radcstng ' s ratons th owereolgy cmpe re blance martaty jecit prfeson sm nd consensu BToadcing ititutio aTe TquiTed to erat a stem of bal btween contin itTt and vwpoint. Untl r ece ntl u cer s were exec e t vi balance wn snle rgrams and wheneer a oc s cvsa s gunr me strct ppied Elsehee it hs come to me nte ree: nce ve resnbe ero f tie." Te broacasers are thu quTd o Tcoz that cncs inteest nd pinin eist Indeed use cntves tca a makes goo lely braca cntrversal rograms d the ceen Thu bradcstin ppers e very rvers f mnithc un cal-as recsey n, demtc n c n rovrsl . Yet balance s crucay eercse wthi an veral rameor assumptins abou srbton f poltica wer: he coni ere s scuuously regu late. A ebae between Laor nd Cosrvae ary esm na ara subject t th executve an nfoal sancns- tlf famed by aement, e ewere bu reoued in e ui on tev s r e e n ao devces an ts ry scous e Poical baace eraes essenaly btween he gtmae ma arie
21
J Cu uu
te pariamentar sstem Baane omes rier e gros ose the onsenss partiiate, sine e ros o n e e tei o ia egita tsea isse o Lab a Conse tve sokes ta ogeer agais oes I is a eso does not avo o pit e b i des avoan reroeoe deitio oitis an exes esses etrazes oer eo B eatig balae within a given trucu, eeiso at aiais te prevaling eitio o te poia er oe a e sae met t eesses an oi oi eoe ig suture o stittioaize ass onis o i te se es It teeb eitmes te prevaiing srre ieres ile s us bsrv "baae eee te aries also ideta s a avrabe me te sstm as a sste as p o o a o atenatv ts o ie t is ts as tist ee te sre exbe d edibe Imparialiy denes w brocters goiae iuaio o con rom wihn.
roadastes are nt spose o express ersoal oinos o o tvesa ssues: the are ommttd to a goos marta beten th c pates In aie ose a broaasrs ae vies e wrk orose is t isst ha te boaser ust be te ast peson i at a to epress a e u as al go proers o ee s m ta oe a uttg a ga Prouers ave beoe x temey sked a ng aaed std io teams; the ite ala t f hw ma Beadette Devis ake a Ia Pase is one those edtoa ats hh a prurs are sie at initin Yet te at o ipartiat as several esaale sequees t eads aastg o he asse o a ase smet isse A cotovesa qestions mt ae t sies ad e t side are su v a og eal n weigt Resnsbi i are beteen e pats a se eves a mase o raise or ens s sme ositos is a fml baane: t a it o no ea o e ute a eatv egs o te se or ea sde t ea ord I om assets tha e s being osoe b the eee ro a os lat t caa st e heee to sa that all possibe eus ae t s smetal ament of arguts a sr the oadaster's martalit but t hard avaes te tt. Imaat as at gves the boaaster resete a bi teest mose ot esuto It omits o the amat vi o ts Hs o a o intevenng ave a o tovers s to act n te tuo te saoro o t omomser e an s o etate itvets an e t savae m s c omnat rom the ep he bt oos positos . A s ths beo tasaed nt th uge f
Media Pow: The Dble B
oos al faus o oroms a ss of ans, ts, or falus n comuao. Th oh way of nutralng ont s o asst so orrng ntrst whh soats h otg as hus boadass a sa n ass hat ans pous co poston ods all ustal cct, n f th skrs ha a oo as. hs sak of th boadas n onct sout hs h functon of lgtag thos lmnts a con whch a "astwhh ca b absac from a al as nd ut a aka Th as whc s tnsl nt amabl o ths procss s "als a unrasoabl Boadastn s thus ras abo h cncs whc t tats. ss o sad outsd th ral a of nss whch pts ad omns. Th ad won who du poras a ral socal uals n h st of th cocs hy t. u hs suct mns s ss h ctty f th am. h oms hy oc a ousd ths ocs hy c on nd jd thm bu thy o atat h. hs cy of boacastn to sta ao ot s say damag h wr who s cua t dtf wh h snt ad wh us coms s hsf a a nal ad sassoa pay to a pasa a mpassd sul th dsod saor f h scac f coc If b qu b m b , j b
bjv b " Ojcy, aa, s a paoa c. ad dtg s h manuat f raw datasy cd d sgn ls o cau h w ay h da ha t ors a u ascpn a ra, a uay o h ara fo th facts, s a lus a utpa A md accs f aty a slc. dtd o manulat so aty s mnad wh vlus w pons, mt s, msns asmns. Th chc lm h as of an rath than h s sjc cra ohr tha hos md n h atal sf h asc ah tha h s s cant, shws shng sca ofhoda, d, ca. Each f ths ns s a aas a takfad s f d stann and y has ma wthn tha c. a dsn t ths c of wth hat, a a dscous o of h spaat fams of dtd maal as sns y wh a g . Th datn f sal actos h os h w s cmsh aas h ang shms f pat whch w aly ut tacy f h n ad dcd sca scs atas o h stc f sa nowld a ad wch y t mak ss wd ad ts t. Such a s kd s t
J
Ja of Communicaion, Autmn 1974
a neutral stuctre; it is ho hogh wi pevoy edmend oca ais. Te usio of "eaty deend on such conx o anin, sch backroun ches of rconion and inaon, o i concon Ho objt is a ci o a mne's ickt lin used n a new urt aairs ocumtay roa? he imae we e a a noh no one oub tha he caaman ad eo w hee, saw han, r tyi to sho i s it is Ye te e etct f ti noe oun et is an noly cossed o inmaio ch in onoatos It on has an o wn s m cnx: icke (fo t eoint of e skes) as an nde h uon r to o t in while te tk connes th c fom h eo of he Ca Bad a a ndx of h ng and ctvn of ak-an sance h ic wn o e ment) as an men hich mht cntu a nt's ae oc; the icke om h oca ioin) an f ecalati ass conict h ice m h won f olic) as a oblm in he oicn of cas nic ad o on_ W e ie i amanid by ommnay o no wheth ovides th actuaity bass fo a stuio dscson nt, ts ann i t inexcal sinnc wihin he eevant conx f anng w eoe s siniait ano ial ead o h do ma th ss trs o thes oes of aaeness, in m he connotv r of h mesae he ocs o ntatio whin hch s sed m aks sen in a ubic iscoue a o uta nerk of eann, and o adcas o can oe such an itout suat ithin o o aoh of hose oics Al pofes geneate their dttve eologies a outes.
Pssiais boadcasti ss o v a a deen aier hich suts the boadcastr rom h cnnn ocs hch lay rss ny ro rm mak i a aa It is oftn a ce of pfessonal eesm, qu e o nezon. By o erng sses o susta o a ical iom, a an hmf soi prar y f t echia omten with hch e am s ecutd, e rdu ases sf abo h omac conen of h ssue h pesens hat oncens him entiy h mnts o ood ee vson": cun nd edng w o fssona ns; smo mne men o rnson wn e suio o between e am es ood ful of i and ama Te mos ai of s itchna strucus i t f nws ts e e med jonls, ke s ouar i s, o a oo s sory n h ss on ut an d ha crtia ae need ih th oo Ns au , hw a mama -
4
Media
Poe:
The Dbl Bind
value-loaed sysem f vais S a sysem as gat patal use, since t nables t edt to get s dne under he cndiin f avly pssue scus wtot c ack rs pcipes But the dea tat such sedimentd scial noledge is eutrala se f tcal ptls nly-is an ilusin .
Consensus be dened the "lowes comm deniO' in h v bf hh r y hred amongs e populaion of a ciey.
Cnsensus pvdes e basis f c uiy ad undamena ageemen in comm sal le. "T cnsensus" is he srucure f cmmonsns idegy ad beiefs t puic at ag n rmal dmcacs a gat al f a ods t sia de tgeher consiss ose aci shared agemnts aut fudamnta issue embedded a the ve f "cmmn s ie lgy," ath ta at s fomaly rten dn in cnsiunal potcls ad mts e cnsensus" any s cic ss i hever, xtremy uid and dicut t dne pnis o very individuals ccide eactly ih it. Ye t wt t noion that me shaed barain r compmise as rac n undameals" i wuld be dicu eiher en bradas i omal democaic scieis. mde cmple bueaucac class socies consensus plays he le hic " ublic pinn" was cast r i ideal demcaic hery n pracice, sice t e majiy pepe have ite rea, dayday access decisins and infmain, cmmnsense idelis ar usualy a cm psite eecin f he dominan idelgis, praig a a passie and diused lee in socey Tug e csesus" is exemely dicul lcae is exisence als undeies ad garantes the broadcasr in his dayday unons His sese he sae f play" in ubic opin prvds a sor o waan r his manc ers a roughandady way eern ha · pele n genral ae hikig ad eeig au an ssue" is my impssin ha in heir eeyday poessoal pacice, badcases ae me tet reguaed y thei snse o heir audiece han by any sile her suce_ Bu, as we have ned, e csensus s i ac a ermy uid and amivale sucur, a bes. In pracice he aencis o ovrmen and coro hile espsible n sme al se o he pepe elc oa/ubic opinin/he auiece, are or ha y reaso, driv ra h area csesus as a aea i whic e wn coset o ass o hei acis ad pices hr deio a ouloks s ar a pwul s o w asse: (a) aus ey a ma oe i crsalizi ssues ) bcaus h rovde h ia a rao whch sup r rd rpraios ,
5
Jourl of Communication, Autumn 174
(c) because hey ca rey e dsrgz t f g eling t prve by ierta, srt f act geee t h xsg sae rs contie. W re ths t igy rdc st whereb the ees f pr csn k, s gt fr r cis a conen whch te themses e prfly rsructr Thus proces o opinio rman ad attitude crstaaon is, ie o ma o te other rcsses we he bee iscssg, process "strc ture n dmce W can uerstad y radcsg sef stds sc a and ambiguu stn. Fr h meda d he dmian sttts communcn a cscsessfrmt re tmsele he prir SOUT of atitdes d kdg it c pc n crysizs, nd te rmary h betee he dmn lasses d he aic At th sme time, as te rit i the r-ptcl csnsus h ociet wdes, the csss cess t rvide the brdcster it buili ioogca cmpss The rig es hs hve drec trs n moooiin te chas for cnsess-frmti fr their referre account n terpretaion, hereb exending her hegon: hy lso av veed ineres i insuring , h le ther dvces mea wll emseves reprce, on heir ehl, t etve strc e o ageement wic teir egm. In sch mmts, th mia emels ecome the or te aratin o egmc nd oneregemonc ideogies ad e rr sciea cass coict the delogicl leel Both of televis's unctis ar ocd t tis rcss: ths oc cions when t elborates interretats accots of he wrld n s ow beal se many occso when, a te sked strcres cces i blie o reroduce and valdate the sts f ccredited wee w vew oblge to aen ad deer o, ad whse teens n or places n arlmnt, n conrences n brrooms n e c s reqied to trnmt Te meda canot g retin e redbl wih he pbic wthot givig sme cce t wiesss an accounts wch ie otsde the cnensus. Rut he omnt it des s, mede edaers tse wh its citcs who tck brodcstin o unwtingl n he blance o pblc eg gant e politicl ordr oens itse to the stregs o h ses whch ar strgging o wn earin or er inerpreons in oder o redne the stuios n wc he e cn n a moe orble wa s boadcasins oube bind
26
