GRAND LAW DEBATE 2016 SPEECH AFFIRMAT AFFIRMATIVE: IVE: BENEFICIA BENEFICIALITY LITY Since the ei!tence "# #"$n%&in'! i! ( #(ct) *h+ (,e thei, ,i'ht! !h,"$%e% *ith c"n-ect$,e! (n% !$.."!iti"n!/ Re!.ecte% "(,% "# -$%'e!) %i!t i!tin' in'$i!h i!he% '$e!t e!t!) &(% &(%ie! ie! (n% 'ent&ee 'ent&een) n) ( .&e(!(n .&e(!(ntt eenin eenin' ' t" +"$ (&&3 C"nt C"nt,( ,(,+ ,+ t" *h(t h(t the the ne'( ne'(ti ti e !i%e i%e *i!he! *i!he! t" i.,e!! i.,e!! $."n ee,+" ee,+"ne ne thi! eenin') thi! %e(te i! n"t "n&+ ("$t $! n(t$ n(t$,( ,(&4 &4" ",n ,n citi citi5e 5en! n! ", ("$ ("$tt "$, "e,5e(&"$!ne!! t" .,"tect (n% $.h"&% the (n (n%(te (n% inte',it+ "# "$, c"n!tit$ti"n) $t ,(the, thi! i! (&!" ("$t the the #"$n% #"$n%&in &in'! '! *h"!e *h"!e !t(t$ !t(t$! ! *e h(e h(e i!e,( i!e,(&+ &+ #(i&e% #(i&e% t" c&e(,&+ c&e(,&+ %e#ine3 %e#ine3 An% An% *e !h"$&% t(,,+ n" ",e) #", in%ee%) ( ,i'ht %e&(+e% i! ( ,i'ht %enie%3 A! the ene#ici(&it+ ene#ici(&it+ !.e(e, #", the (##i,(tie) I h(e n" %"$t in in% th(t %ec&(,in' #"$n%&in'! (! n"n4n(t$,(& ",n citi5en! *i&& e ene#ici(& n"t "n&+ #", "$, !+!te "# '"e,nent $t (&!" #", the #"$n% #"$n%&in &in'! '! the! the!e& e&e! e! *h"!e *h"!e ,i'ht! ,i'ht!)) (n% (n% !t(t$ !t(t$! ! *e h(e h(e ne'& ne'&ect ecte% e% #", !" &"n') &ie 7(n e&e.h(nt in the ,""83 The The #(ct #(ct "# the the (tt (tte, e, i!) i!) neit neithe he,, the the c"n! c"n!ti tit$ t$ti ti"n "n n", n", ei! ei!ti tin' n' &e'i &e'i!& !&(t (ti ie e en(ct en(cten ent! t! .,"i .,"i%e %e #", ( (nne, (nne, + *hich ( #"$n%&in' (+ e c"n!i%e,e% ( Phi&i..ine Citi5en Thi!) %e!.ite "$, c&e(, "&i' "&i'(t (ti"n i"n $n%e, $n%e, inte,n inte,n(t (ti"n i"n(& (& &(* t" en(&e the t" %" !"3 A! the+ (,e e!!enti(&&+ e!!enti(&&+ "# $nn"*n $nn"*n .(,ent('e) #"$n%&in'! c(nn"t #(&& $n%e, th"!e *h" (c9$i,e Phi&i..ine citi5en!hi. + the e,e #(ct "# i,th t" ( Fi&i.in"
"the, ", #(the,3 The+ c(nn"t (&!" !"$,ce thei, Fi&i.in" citi5en!hi. #," n(t$,(&i5(ti"n in (cc",%(nce *ith the ei!tin' &(* (! the,e i! +et n" &(* th(t h(! een .(!!e% (&&"*in' ( .,"ce!! #", the t" (c9$i,e citi5en!hi.3 Re.$&ic Act 1;) *hich (en%e% the Rei!e% N(t$,(&i5(ti"n Act) .,e!c,ie! th(t the (..&ic(nt $!t (t &e(!t e ("e 1< +e(,! "# ('e3 A! ( ,e!$&t) $nti& !$ch tie the #"$n%&in' ".t! (n% i! 9$(&i#ie% t" $n%e,'" the .,"ce!!) he=!he i! te.",(,i&+ ( !t(te&e!! .e,!"n in the e+e! "# "$, C"n!tit$ti"n3 The 1>? C"nenti"n ,e&(tin' t" the St(t$! "# St(te&e!! Pe,!"n! %e#ine! ( !t(te&e!! .e,!"n (! "ne *h" i! n"t c"n!i%e,e% (! ( n(ti"n(& + (n+ St(te $n%e, the ".e,(ti"n "# it! &(*3 A! !$ch) he=!he c(nn"t ee,ci!e ce,t(in cii& (n% ."&itic(& ,i'ht! *hich (,e e!.eci(&&+ ,e!e,e% #", citi5en! "# ( St(te3 Th,"$'h the (##i,(tie !i%e "# the .,"."!iti"n) *e *i&& e (&e t" c&(,i#+ (n% #i,&+ e!t(&i!h the !t(t$! "# #"$n%&in'! in ( (nne, th(t i! c"n!i!tent *ith the c"n!tit$ti"n3 It i! #$n%(ent(& in "$, &e'(& !+!te th(t the ,i'ht! (n% e!t inte,e!t "# the chi&% i! .(,("$nt) (n% it i! t" the e!t inte,e!t "# the #"$n%&in' t" e %ec&(,e% ( Fi&i.in"3 Whethe, it e (chiee% th,"$'h (n (en%ent t" the n(t$,(&i5(ti"n &(*) ", th,"$'h (n enti,e&+ %i##e,ent &(* t" en(&e #"$n%&in' in",! t" e n(t$,(&i5e%) the .,"&e "# thei, !t(te&e!!ne!! i! ,e!"&e%3 A! ( c"n!e9$ence) the+ ec"e citi5en! "# the Phi&i..ine!) *ith (&& the ,i'ht! (n% .,ii&e'e! "# ( n(t$,(&i5e% Fi&i.in"3 @n the "the, h(n%) it (&!" ene#it! the St(te in th(t n"t "n&+ *i&& the .,"."!iti"n e!t $."n #"$n%&in'! the ,i'ht! "# ( n(t$,(&i5e% Fi&i.in") the St(te in t$,n
ec"e! c".&i(nt *ith it! "&i'(ti"n! $n%e, inte,n(ti"n(& &(*3 n%e, the Inte,n(ti"n(& C"en(nt "n Cii& (n% P"&itic(& Ri'ht! (n% the N C"nenti"n "n the Ri'ht! "# ( Chi&%) St(te! P(,tie! (,e ,e9$i,e% t" en(&e ee,+ chi&% t" (c9$i,e ( n(ti"n(&it+3 It (&!" (cc".&i!he! the St(te inte,e!t in th(t it c&(,i#ie! *he,e #"$n%&in'! e&"n' in the c(te'",+ "# Fi&i.in" citi5en!) th$! .,e!e,in' the ,e!e,(ti"n "# ce,t(in e+ '"e,nent ."!iti"n! t" n(t$,(&4",n Fi&i.in"! (! ,e9$i,e% + the C"n!tit$ti"n3
Th,"$'h the .,"."!iti"n) t*" inte,e!t! (,e the,e#",e ene#ite%: the inte,e!t "# the #"$n%&in' (n% the inte,e!t "# the St(te3 A (&(nce i! the,e#",e c,e(te%3 The en% "# the &(*) "hn L"ce ,ein%! $!) i! n"t t" ("&i!h (n% ,e!t,(in) $t t" .,e!e,e (n% en&(,'e #,ee%"3 F", in (&& the !t(te! "# c,e(te% ein'! c(.(&e "# &(*) *he,e the,e i! n" &(*) the,e i! n" #,ee%"3 Mi!te,=M(%( M"%e,(t",) I ( n"* ,e(%+ #", + inte,.e&&(ti"n3
