Tugas Kelompok ke-1 Minggu 3
Pelaja Pelajari ri case case study study “Philip “Philip Anderso Anderson” n” pada buk buku u Mercha Merchant nt halama halaman n 196-197, 196-197, dan jaabl jaablah ah pertanyaan berikut ini!
0942F – Sistem Pengendalian Pengendalian Manajemen
Asumsikan salah satu klien Philip Anderson adalah seoran" pria dan sudah menikah, berusia #6 tahun dan memiliki dua oran" anak yan" masih kecil dan ia in"in memindahkan sejumlah besar dana pensiunnya yan" saat ini diin$estasikan dalam bentuk deposito% Philip merekomendasikan growth investment dan terdapat ti"a alternati& di baah ini%
0942F – Sistem Pengendalian Manajemen
1% Alternati& in$estasi mana yan" palin" men"untun"kan ba"i' (a) klien, (b) *tuart + o% .% /ika jaaban (b) anda berbeda den"an (a) dan Philip merekomendasikan pilihan yan" memberikan keuntun"an tertin""i, apakah Philip bertindak etis atau tidak etis /elaskanlah! #% Alternati& yan" mana yan" diharapkan oleh manajemen puncak *tuart + o% direkomendasikan Philip kepada klien 0% Apakah sistem pen"endalian perusahaan dirancan" untuk memastikan pilihan di atas
n this case, e ha$e really to di&&erent points o& $ie' in one side, there is Philip Anderson, the Phoeni2 branch mana"er o& *tuart + o%, ho mana"es a team ith his ays, his idea, his e2perience but the results do not reach the tar"ets &i2ed by the &irm% n the other side, there is the direction o& *tuart + o%, hich has opposite ideas to Philip Anderson% ill try to analy3e the challen"es Philip Anderson &aces &rom the point o& $ie o& costs o& control and considerin" ethical concerns%
4eadin" this te2t, e could easily &eel that Philip Anderson5s ork ay is totally opposite to the &irm ay% he sentence “ho &ar he Philip Anderson8 could bend ithout breakin"” shos the challen"e o& the alone man is important &or him% e could &eel Philip5s desire to sho ethical concerns are at least as important as costs control% :espite the demand o& the branch mana"ers to push speci&ic products to be sold in the aim to impro$e cost control, Philip Anderson tries to resist mana"in" his team ith his ay% he results o& the man are ethically "ood but don5t in term o& achie$in" bud"et tar"ets% he cost control o& the &irm causes ne"ati$e attitude, resistance
0942F – Sistem Pengendalian Manajemen
and &rustration o& Philip Anderson because he does not a"ree ith this control system' by mana"in" cost, some ethical dilemmas created by Philip could be lost that is hy he shos such a resistance%
hen, e can not say that Philip Anderson is a bad mana"er% ndeed, by readin" the te2t, despite the ne &ailure o& his team hich has not reach the tar"ets &i2ed &or them, this man seems to ha$e a stron" character, he used to mana"e a team% n my opinion, his is just not to the ri"ht place% he description o& this mana"er su""ests that the man could ha$e built and mana"ed his on enterprise% ndeed, e can read that Philip is “indi$idual”, “enjoys bein" a mana"er” and he has a lot o& e2perience%
hree n$estment Alternati$es' Alternati$e A ;roth &und &rom a lar"e in$estment company years (net o& mana"ement &ees)' 1?%7#@ 4isk' Moderate Mana"ement &ees' ?%0@
Alternati$e ;roth &und &rom *tuart+ o% @ &ront-end A$era"e annual total returns o$er last > years (net o& mana"ement &ees)' 1?%6.@ 4isk' Moderate Mana"ement &ees' 1%.@
Alternati$e B2chan"e-traded &und
0942F – Sistem Pengendalian Manajemen
years (net o& mana"ement &ees)' 11%?1@ 4isk' Moderate Mana"ement &ees' =one
1% hich o& the in$estment alternati$e' Alternati$e A, Pro$ides the hi"hest returns to the client% ;i$en the same risk le$el, the more return &or the same amount o& in$estment the hi"her returns to the client% Dor instance, your client ants to in$est E1??% Dor alternati$e A, the client ill recei$e E1?%69 in return% (he in$estment o& E1?? turns to E99%6 a&ter the mana"ement &ee, and recei$es E99%6F1?%7#@GE1?%69 in return)% Dor alternati$e , the client ill recei$e E9%96 in return% (he in$estment o& E1?? turns to E9#%H a&ter the mana"ement &ee and &ront-end load, and recei$es E9#%HF1?%6.@GE9%96 in return)% Dor alternati$e , the client ill recei$e E1?%#> in return% (he in$estment o& E1?? turns to E90 a&ter the purchase and sell commissions, and recei$es E90F11%?1@GE1?%#> in return)
Alternati$e , Pro$ides the hi"hest pro&its to *tuart + o% Isin" the same scenario as the abo$e e2ample, Alternati$e ill "enerate E6%. pro&it to *tuart + o% hile Alternati$e A and "enerate E?%0 and E6%
.% hich alternati$e should the top mana"ement o& *tuart + o% ant Philip to recommend to his client s the company5s control system desi"ned to ensure that choice (he case mentions se$eral measures used to reard the branch man"ers)% Alternati$e is most likely to be encoura"ed to%%% SISANYA DI BLUR
0942F – Sistem Pengendalian Manajemen
