Contracts.obliCON

SAN BEDA COLLEGE OF LAW Manila OBLIGATIONS AND CONTRACTS MEMORANDUM FOR

:

SECTIONS I-F and I-K  

FROM

:

ATTY. MANUEL P. CASINO

DATE : 17 F!"#a"$ %&1' (----------------------------------------------------------------( 1. MEMORI)E : ARTICLES 1*&+-1'%% %. READ T,E FOLLOWING CASES: A. Ral and Cnn#al Cn/"a0/ Cn/"a0/ a. Ga"0ia . T2i3 +14 SCRA '** 5%&&76 B. alidi/$ 8 Cn/"a0/#al Cn/"a0/#al S/i9#la/in A"/i0l A"/i0l 1*&;< a. BF Uni/d Uni/d ,=>n" ,=>n"? ? A0ia/i A0ia/in3 n3 In0. In0. . T2 Ci/$ Ci/$ Ma$"3 Ma$"3 +1+ SCRA SCRA 1 5%&&76 !. Ti# . Pla/in#= Plan/ P2il.3 In0. 3 +17 SCRA 1&1 0. D#n0an . Gla(3 '*4 SCRA *'* 5%&&'6 d. S/a" S/a" Pa9" Pa9" . Si= Si=!l !l33 '47 SCRA SCRA %%4 5%&& 5%&&;6 ;6 . P"=i" Dl9=n/ Dl9=n/ Ban@ . CA3 '%7 '%7 SCRA ;4; 5%&&'6 5%&&'6 B.1 E0ala/in Cla#: a. Pl/a Pl/an n . CA3 CA3 %; SCRA SCRA %'7 %'7 514 51466 !. N> Sa=9a Sa=9a#i/a #i/a B#ild" B#ild" . . PNB3 PNB3 '*+ SCRA +;+ 5%&&' 5%&&'66 B.% Cn/"a0/ 8 Ad2in a. Ti/an Cn/" Cn/"#0/in #0/in C"9. . . Uni-Fil Uni-Fild d En/"9"i En/"9"i3 3 In0. In0. +17 SCRA SCRA 14& !. Tln/ Tln/in in . . CA3 +17 SCRA SCRA 7*% 0. Pl/ Pl/n n . . BPI BPI33 +17 +17 SCRA SCRA '*& '*& B.*. alidi/$ 8 0n/"a0/ a. A"iaa A"iaa da. da. D D G#""a G#""a . . S#9li0 S#9li033 '44 SCRA SCRA **% **% !. R9#!l R9#!li0 i0 . . La? La?33 '4 '4 SCRA SCRA '%' B.'. On Nn-I=9ai"=n/ 8 O!lia/in 8 Cn/"a0/ a. S""an S""an . . Gallan/ Gallan/ Ma"i/i Ma"i/i= = S"i0 S"i0 In0.3 In0.3 +4% SCRA %+' !. Gld Gldn>a n>a$ $ M"02a M"02andi ndii in n C"9" C"9"a/i a/in n . E# E#i/a i/a!l !l PCI Ban@3 Ban@3 G.R. G.R. N. 1++'&3 Ma"02 1*3 %&1* C. Bindin E880/ 8 8 Cn/"a0/ A"/i0l 1*&4< a. !. 0.

,i" 8 Will ,i" Willia= ia= Sill Silla a . . Sill Silla3 a3 '&% '&% SCR SCRA A +&1 +&1 Da"i Da"i Na0a" Na0a" . Gall"$ Gall"$ F"a=3 F"a=3 / / al.3 al.3 G.R. G.R. N. 144713 144713 A##/ A##/ 1*3 %&1*. %&1*. Plan/ Plan/" " Dl Dl9= 9=n/ n/ Ban@ Ban@ . S9# S9#  E"n E"n/ / L9 L9 And Fl Fl"n "n/in /ina a L93 L93 G.R. N. 14;**%3 O0/!" %*3 %&1*

D. Rla/ii/$ 8 Cn/"a0/ A"/i0l 1*11< 1*11< a. Ball Ball/" /"  . A!in3 A!in3 '4% SCRA SCRA %*

1

!. Fili9ina S$/=3 In0. . MRT Dl9=n/ C"9"a/in3 +*7 SCRA ;& D.1. S/i9#la/in P#" A#/"#i a. A"/( Dl9=n/ C.3 In0.3 .Wllin/n In#"an0 C.3 In0.3 G.R. N. L%+&4 #n %73 17* !. Mi#l Fl"n/in3 E/ al.3 . Salad" En0a"na0in3 S".3 / al.3 3 G.R. N. L%7;; S9/=!" *&3 177 0. R!00a C. Y#n . Ca3 G.R. N. 7+14 an#a"$ 1*3 14 d. A0ia/d Ban@ . C#"/ O8 A99al And L"n Sa"=in/ ".3 G.R. N. 1%*7* #n %3 14 . S#/2 Pa02= Dl9=n/3 In0. . ,n"a!l C#"/ O8 A99al3 E/ Al.3 G.R. N. 1%;%;&3 D0=!" 1;3 %&&' E. P"80/in 8 Cn/"a0/ a. !. 0. d.

. 8. . 2. i.  H. @. l.

Mal!a"a . CA3 '&% SCRA %;; P9l? ,=i/  ,#in C"9. . CA3 G.R. N. ;1;%*3 D0. %&3 14'. Din . C#"/ 8 A99al3 1+4 SCRA *7+ Sa"a Cn/"#0/in  Dl9=n/ C"9"a/inPi0@  S2l3 In0.3A/lan/i0 E"0/"3 In0. in/ n/#"< . P2ili99in P"/ A#/2"i/$3 G.R. NO. 17&+*&3 #l$ +3 %&1& Mi"al . Y#a$3 11 SCRA '1& Pa0#ld . Ralad3 *'+ SCRA 1*' a"din Dai3 I0. . CA3 *** SCRA ;4' La8"/a . Ma02#0a3 *** SCRA '7% R=an . G"i=al/ ;P2il. ;< T$/a S2a>3 In0. . C#"/ 8 A99al and Sa G.R. L-11;;+& Ma$ %*3 1+<. i"inia Pa0 . C#"/ 8 A99al G.R. N. L-1&%*;3 Ma"02 143 1'< Ca" Ra/3 E/ Al. . C#"/ O8 A99al3 E/ Al. G.R. N.. 1%4&1;3 S9/=!" 173 14< E.1. O9/in Cn/"a0/O9/in Mn$ / A"/. 1*%'in "la/in / A"/. 1'7< a. !. 0. d. .

Ba#=n/ . P"i/ '1 P2il. ;7&< C"ni0 . .M. T#an  C. 74 SCRA **1< Na/in . IAC 17 SCRA **%< A/@in K"ll  C. . C#a ,ian T@ 1&% P2il '4< S#/2>/"n S#a" and Mla C. . A/lan/i0 G#l8  Pa0i8i0 C. +1 O.G. *''7< 8. San02 . Ri3 '+ SCRA *;4< . R#"al Ban@ 8 Pa"ana# . CA G.R. N. ;%&+13 14 Ma"02 14+< E.%. Ri2/ 8 Fi"/ R8#al a. D8ini/in !. En8"0a!ili/$ 0. Nd 8" di/in0/ 0nid"a/in a. E#a/"ial Ral/$ . Ca"=l  Ba#"=ann3 %;' SCRA '4* 51;6 !. Pa"ana# Kin . CA3 %;4 SCRA 7%7 5176 0. Li/nH#a . L  C"93 *%& SCRA '&+ 516 d. PUP . CA3 *;4 SCRA ;1 5%&&16 F. En/ial R#ii/ 8 Cn/"a0/ F.1. Cnn/ A"/i0l 1*1-1*';< 1. Mn/inla . i0/"ia Millin C.3 +' P2il 74% %. En"i# . S#n Li8 In#"an03 +1 P2il %; *. La#di0 . A"ia3 '* P2il. %7&

2

F.1.a. Mi/a@ a. G= Ma"in . Lin/n3 '+ P2il. ;+* !. S$lia Li02a#0 D Ln .T2 ,n. C#"/ O8 A99al3 Ma0a"ia D Ln And  i0n/ D Ln3 G.R. N. 4&;+3 #n ;3 1& 0. D=in Ral/$ . CA3 +1* SCRA '& 5%&&76 F.1.!. iln03 In/i=ida/in and Und# In8l#n0 a. 0l$n M. Tld . Ma"il# M. ,$dn G.R. N. 17%1*3 D0=!" 43 %&1& !. F"an0i L . C#"/ O8 A99al3 P9l O8 T2 P2ili99in And Plaia Panlin D C2in3 G.R. N. &'%* S9/=!" ;3 11 0. Man#l T. D G#ia3 E/ Al.3 . ,n. P"idin #d3 Rinal T"ial C#"/3 B"an02 1%3 Mall3 B#la0an3 E/ Al.3 G.R. N. 1;1&7'3 Ma"02 %%3 %&1& d. Dl9=n/ Ban@ O8 T2 P2ili99in1 And P"ia/ia/in And Mana=n/ O88i0 F"="l$ A/ P"ia/ia/in T"#/< . ,n. C#"/ O8 A99al3 P2ili99in Uni/d F#nd"$ And Ma02in"$ C"9. And P2ili99in I"n Man#8a0/#"in C.3 In0.3 G.R. N. 1*47&*3 #n *&3 %&&; F.1.!. F"a#d a. AlHand" . Tan@2 . Dl9=n/ Ban@ O8 T2 P2ili99in3 S/"lin S2i99in Lin3 In0.3 R#9"/ . Tan@23 i0n/ A"na3 And A/ P"ia/ia/in T"#/3 G.R. N. 171'%43 N=!" 113 %&1* !. I=idi A!and And Cnla0in A!and . F"an0i0 Lada3 Mila" Lada And T2 ,n"a!l C#"/ O8 A99al3 G.R. N. L-4%+;' O0/!" 1*3 14 F.%. O!H0/ 8 Cn/"a0/ a. D=in Ral/$ . CA3 +1* SCRA '& 5%&&76 !. Wil8"d T. ailidad And Lli/a A. ailidad .Ga!in ailidad3 ". And D"/2$ ailidad3 G.R. N. 1;11*;3 N=!" 1;3 %&&; 0. A#""a F B. Ca=a02 . C#"/ O8 A99al And Anlin Bann3 G.R. N. 1%7+%&3 F!"#a"$ 3 %&&7 F.* Ca# " Cnid"a/in A"/i0l 1*+&-1*++< a. Elia L. Pna0 . )il ,. R#a$a And Fli0i/a E. R#a$a3 G.R. N. L-%41&%3 D0=!" 1'3 141 !. Anl  Wa"2#in C.3 In0.3 . C2lda En/"9"i And Daid S$H#03 G.R. N. L-%+7&'3 A9"il %'3 1;4 0. R9#!li0 O8 T2 P2ili99in3 AndO" Na/inal Ma"@/in C"9"a/in . ,n. Ga#dn0i Cl"i!l3 A #d O8 T2 C#"/ O8 Fi"/ In/an0 O8 Manila3 B"an02 I3  San A#/in3 A E(-O88i0i S2"i88 O8 T2 Ci/$ O8 Manila3 And Binnid Y. A#ila"3 G.R. N. L-%7&+3 D0=!" %43 17& F.*.a. Si=#la/d Cn/"a0/ a.

Ga#dn0i al"i3 E/ Al.3 . i0n/a R8"0a3 E/ Al.3 G.R. N. 1;*;473 Ma"02 %43 %&&; !. R#!n L$la .T2 ,n"a!l C#"/ O8 A99al3 / al.3 G.R. N. 11+7*'3 F!"#a"$ %*3 %&&& 0. Mni0 Cn090in . Pa0in0ia S/a. Ana3 G.R. N. L-%%77 D0=!" %3 1+& G. F"= 8 Cn/"a0/ A"/i0l 1*+; 1*+4< a. Uni"i/$ 8 /2 P2ili99in . P2ila! Ind#/"i3 In03. G.R. N. 1+%'113 S9/=!" %3 %&&'

3

!. L#n Bn . P. . O!"in3 a= A O/"and And G. R. ,a"$3 G.R. N. L-1*;&%3 A9"il ;3 114 0.

Ma"ln Da#dn-,"na . ,n. Wal8"id D L Anl3 #d O8 T2 C#"/ O8 Fi"/ In/an0 O8 J#n Ci/$3 ,ll$>d Fa" Ea/ P"d#0/in3 In0.3 And Ra=n aln#la3 G.R. N. L-%7&1&3 A9"il *&3 1;

d. Ma"@/ Dl9"3 In0. MADE< . ,n. In/"=dia/ A99lla/ C#"/ And Ga#di U$3 G.R. N. 7'743 S9/=!" 43 14 .

ai= L. Yana . T2 ,n"a!l C#"/ O8 A99al3 Man#l A. D # And Wil2l=ina M. Manan3 G.R. N. 1'*%%3 N=!" %43 %&&4

8.

Binnid C. T0 And #an C. T03 ".3 . M/"9li/an Ban@ And T"#/ C=9an$3 G.R. N. 1;%***3 D0=!" %*3 %&&4

,. R8"=a/in 8 In/"#=n/ a. C!# Cn/"a0/" Cn"/i#= C. . CA3 '&7 SCRA 1+' !. Ylanda Rll-Bn/i"3 / al. . ,n. Ma/ Landa3 G.R. N. 1%413 1% A9"il %&&& 0. P"0 J#i" And Lna"da illa . Ma"0l A"Hna3 T"i/a Bala"!a"3 92in A"Hna3 And Cn02i/a A"Hna3 G.R. N. 1+4&13 Ma"02 3 %&&' I. In/"9"/a/in 8 Cn/"a0/ A"/i0l 1*7&-1*7< a. Wd T02nl$ C"9"a/in . E#i/a!l Ban@in C"9"a/in3 '+1 SCRA 7%' !. T"#a/" . B"na!3 '+ SCRA '* 0. ,""ian . T"i@a C=="0ial3 In0.3 '7; SCRA '%1 d. ,#i!n2a . CA3 *%& SCRA ;%+ . R$nald P. Fli"nd3 " . M/"9li/an Ban@ And T"#/ C=9an$3 G.R. N. 1'4*%+3 S9/=!" *3 %&&7  . Cn/"a0/#al O!lia/in a. P"8inal A0ad=i0 Plan3 In0. . C"i/=3 '+* SCRA *'% !. GF E#i/$3 In0. . alnna3 ';% SCRA ';; 0. LL La>"n0 F/>a"3 In0. . PCI Lain and Finan0 C"9.3 ';4 SCRA **. K. ida!l Cn/"a0/ 1. Miail2 . CA3 *+' SCRA ;7+ %. L$la . CA3 *%; SCRA %4+ *. M/"9li/an Wa/">"@ And S>"a S$/= M><3 . C#"/ O8 A99al3 / al.3 3 G.R. N. 1%;&&& O0/!" 73 14 '. #lian F"an0i03 E/ Al. . Pa/" ,"""a3 G.R. N. 1*43 N. %13 %&&% +. Fi"/ P2ili99in ,ldin C"9"a/in . T"an Middl Ea/ P2il.< E#i/i In0.3 G.R. N. 17+&+3 D0=!" '3 %&& L. R0ii!l Cn/"a0/ a. C2ina Ban@in C"9"a/in . CA3 *%7 SCRA *74 !. # Ca=9 And R=a"i Ca=9-Ba#/i/a . Nni/a B#nnida Pa/"ana3 E/ Al.3 G.R. N. 17+'3 D0=!" 43 %&&

4

0.

Rn0" Dl9=n/ C"9"a/in And Rn a#in . Pa/"n In#in3 I"n G#ill"=3 Fd"i0 Ban/#an3 F"nand Ma!an#a And Lia Tian03 G.R. N. 1'&'73 Ma"02 43 %&&1 d. I"n OdHa"3 E/ Al. . Iid" P. G#i03 E==an#l G#i0 And L#"d G. A="an/3 G.R. N. L-;7+'43 D0=!" %&3 14 . ,i" O8 S8ia J#i"n . Dl9=n/ Ban@ O8 T2 P2ili99in3 G.R. N. 17*''13 D0=!" *3 %&& 8. K,E ,ONG C,ENG3 / al. . COURT OF APPEALS3 ,ON. TEOFILO GUADI)3 G.R. N. 1''1; Ma"02 %43 %&&  n 9"0"i9/in 8 a0/in / "0ind. M. Unn8"0a!l Cn/"a0/ a. P#a . CA3 *'+ SCRA %** M.1. S/a/#/ 8 F"a#d a. T"#a/" . B"na!3 '+ SCRA '* !. C"dial . Mi"anda3 *'4 SCRA %+4 0. T2 M#ni0i9ali/$ O8 ,an$3 B#la0an . ,n. Si=n P. D#=d#=3 ". / Al.3 G.R. N. 1;4%43 Ma"02 %%3 %&1& d. K"  C. . Linad3 *4 SCRA +%' . S>di2 Ma/023 AB3 E/ Al. .C#"/ O8 A99al3 Al Mana=n/  Dl9=n/ C"9"a/in And An/ni K. Li/nH#a3 G.R. N. 1%41%&3 O0/!" %&3 %&&' M.%. REPUBLIC ACT NO. 47% E-C=="0 A0/< N. id Cn/"a0/ 1. illa . R#"al Ban@ 8 TanHa$3 +44 SCRA '*; a. Bl/"an . illa"a3 +4+ SCRA %4* !. U$ S#i Pin . Can/lla 7& P2il ++< 0. Ma2a"li@a P#!. C. . Tal G.R. N. ;++'3 & #l$ 14;< d. Ba#/i/a . Mn/illa L-;+;3 &* A9"il 1+;< . R#!ia . Ba/ill" +1 SCRA 1%&< 8. K"in@ . R. 8 Dd3 /0. 7 P2il. ';1< N.1.  In Pari Delicto Rule a.

P/n0ian Ra=i" . Ma. C0ilia Ra=i"3 G.R. N. 1;+&443 Ma"02 173 %&&; !.  Mn02a3 E/ Al. . Fl"n/in T ".3 G.R. N. 1+*%&13 an#a"$ %;3 %&&7 0.

Al8n Anl3 E/ Al. . T2 C#"/ O8 A99al3 G""i S/a. In And Ana/a0ia Diin3 G.R. N. L-11&%'3 an#a"$ *13 1+4

d.

A!a0# S0#"i/i C"9"a/in . R#!n U. A=9il3 G.R. N. 1;&&1;3 F!"#a"$ %73 %&&;

.

Anl  Wa"2#in C.3 In0. . C2lda En/"9"i And Daid S$H#03 G.R. N. L-%+7&'3 A9"il %'3 1;4

5