MANAGEMENT CONSULTANCY - Solutions Manual
CHAPTER 19 SOURCES OF INTERMEDIATE AND LONG-TERM FINANCING: DEBT AND EQUITY I.
Questions 1. The bond bond agree agreeme ment nt speci specifi fies es such such basic items items as the the par valu value, e, the coupon rate, and the maturity date. 2. The priorit priority y of claims claims can can be determ determine ined d as follo follows: ws: senior secured debt, junior junior secured debt, debt, senior debenture, subordinated debenture, preference preference shares, ordinary shares. 3. Bond Bond conv conver ersi sion on.. 4. The advantages of debt are: a. Interes Interestt paymen payments ts are tax deducti deductible ble.. b. The financial financial obligation obligation is clearly specified specified and of of a fixed nature. nature. c. In an infla inflati tion onary ary econo economy my,, debt debt may be paid back with with cheape cheaper r pesos. d. The use use of debt, debt, up to a prudent prudent poin point, t, may low lower er the the cost cost of capital capital to the firm. The disadvantages are: a.
Intere Interest st and princi principal pal payme payment nt oblig obligat atio ions ns are set by contrac contractt and must be paid regardless of economic circumstances. b. Bond indenture indenture agreements agreements may place burdensome restrictions restrictions on the firm. c. Debt, Debt, utili utilize zed d beyon beyond d a give given n point point,, may serve serve as a depr depress essant ant on outstanding ordinary shares. II. Multiple Choice
19-1
Chapter 19
1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
D D D B A
6. 7. 8. 9. 10.
C C E D B
11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
C D D A D
Sources of Intermediate and Long-term Financing: Debt and Equity
16. 17. 18. 19. 20.
D C B A C 21. 22. 23. 24. 25.
26. 27. 28. 29. 30.
A C B B B
A A C C B
31. 32. 33. 34. 35.
A C D A C
36. 37. 38. 39. 40.
C A A D C
41. 42. 43. 44. 45.
C A D B C
Supporting computations:
16. Px
=
where Px Po N S
= = = =
value of a share ex-rights market value of share rights-on (Po x ofN)rights + 5required to purchase one share number subscription N + 1price per share
Hence, Px
=
=
18. The following schedule applies for the term loan: (P75 x 4) + P60 360 5 5 Beginning Interest Principal Year Balance x (1 – T c ) Payment 1 P5000 P195 P1000 2 4000 156 1000 3 3000 117 1000
19-2
=
P72
Ending Balance P4000 3000 2000
Sources of Intermediate and Long-term Financing: Debt and Equity
4 5
2000 1000
78 39
1000 1000
Chapter 19
1000 -0-
The present value of interest after taxes at 12% is calculated to be P453.49. 19. After the tax benefit, the annual cost of leasing is P1,400 (1 – .35) = P910. The present value annuity factor for four years at 12% is 3.0373. The present value cost of the lease is the cost of the first payment plus the present value of the four future payments, or P910 + P910 (3.0373) = P3,673.94. 20. The present value annuity factor for five years at 12% is 3.6048. Therefore, the present value of principal payments is P1,000 (3.6048) = P3,604.80. The present value cost of the purchase option is the present value of principal payments or P3,604.80 plus P453.49 which equals P4,058.29.
III. Problems PROBLEM 1 (CAM FURNITURE COMPANY)
a. Proposal 1: 10 year 12 percent bonds CAM FURNITURE COMPANY Income Statement For the Year Ended December 31, 2005 Estimated sales levels
19-3
Chapter 19
Sources of Intermediate and Long-term Financing: Debt and Equity
Sales........................................ P30,000 Operating costs........................ 3* Operating income..................... Interest charges........................ Net income before taxes........... Income taxes............................ Net income...............................
P400,000 360,000 40,000 14,000 26,000 13,000 P 13,000
Outstanding shares =
=
P600,000 540,000 60,000 14,000 46,000 23,000 P 23,000
P800,000 720,000 80,000 14,000 66,000 33,000 P 33,000
10,000
* EPS (P36 market value – price earnings ratio of 12) Earnings per share Price-earnings ratio Estimated market value
P1.30 10 times P13
P2.30 10 times P23
P3.30 10 times P33
Proposal 2: Ordinary share issue to yield P33-1/3 CAM FURNITURE COMPANY P100,000 Income Statement - 1/3 For the 33 Year Ended December 31, 2005 Sales........................................ Operating costs........................ Operating income..................... Interest charges........................ Net income before taxes........... Income taxes............................ Net income...............................
Estimated sales levels P400,000 P600,000 P800,000 360,000 540,000 720,000 40,000 60,000 80,000 2,000 2,000 2,000 38,000 58,000 78,000 19,000 29,000 39,000 P 19,000 P 29,000 P 39,000
Outstanding shares =
+ 10,000 = 13,000 shares
Earnings per share Price-earnings ratio Estimated market value
P1.46 12 times P17.52
P2.23 12 times P26.76
P3.00 12 times P36.00
b. Within the constraints of this problem, two possible objectives emerge: profit maximization as measured by earnings per share and wealth maximization as measured by the price of the ordinary shares. If profit maximization is used, the firm should choose to finance the new product by selling bonds, since earnings per share is higher for each of the three
19-4
Sources of Intermediate and Long-term Financing: Debt and Equity
Chapter 19
levels of sales. On the other hand, wealth maximization would require the sale of new ordinary shares because share price is higher at each sales level. Wealth maximization is the preferred criterion for financial decision making. Unlike profit maximization, it represents a measure of the total benefits stream to be enjoyed by the shareholders, adjusted for both the timing of benefits and the risk associated with the receipt thereof. A criterion that ignores these two important determinants of value cannot be expected to provide a proper guide to decision making. Because wealth maximization is the preferred objective, the sale of ordinary shares is the recommended financing technique. c.
Proposal 2 would still be the choice, because the market value remains above that of Proposal 1. The difference is getting smaller, however, which means that Proposal 1 would become attractive if sales reached a higher level (approximately P1.6 million).
d. The investment banker would suggest that lower price-earnings ratio with debt financing is a reflection of the greater returns demanded by shareholders in compensation for the variability in earnings and higher risk of bankruptcy created by the fixed commitment to pay debt interest and principal.
PROBLEM 2 (FAYE INDUSTRIES, INC.) Faye Industries Inc. Pro Forma Consolidated Income Statement Including Earnings per Common Share and Return on Average Common Shareholders’ Equity For the Year Ending November 30, 2006 (P000 omitted except per share amounts) (1) Issuing Long-term Bonds P12,978
Earnings before interest and taxes Interest on Current debt (P13,395 x 9.5%) Alternative 1 (P15,300 x 10%) Total interest Income before income tax Income taxes (40%) Net income
1,273 1,530 2,083 10,175 4,070 6,105
19-5
(2) Selling Preference Shares P12,978
(3) Selling Ordinary Shares P12,978
1,273
1,273
1,273 11,705 4,682 7,023
1,273 11,705 4,682 7,023
Chapter 19
Sources of Intermediate and Long-term Financing: Debt and Equity
Preference share dividends (P15,300,000 ÷ P120) x 13% Earnings available to common shareholders Add: Common shareholders’ equity December 1, 1999 Equity financing Common shareholders’ equity November 30, 2000 Average common shares outstanding (in thousands) December 1, 1999 balance Additional issued December 1 Total (and average) shares outstanding Pro forma earnings per share (P6,105 − P0) ÷ 26,330 (P7,023 − P1,658) ÷ 26,330 (P7.023 − P0) ÷ 33,980
= = =
1,658 6,105 55,028
5,365 55,028
P61,133
P60,393
26,330
26,330
26,330
26,330
7,023 55,028 15,300 P77,351
26,330 7,650 33,980
P0.2319 P0.2038 P0.2067
Estimated return on average common shareholders’ equity P6,105 ÷ [(P55,028 ÷ P61,133) ÷ 2] = P5,365 ÷ [(P55,028 ÷ P60,393) ÷ 2] = P7,023 ÷ [(P70,328 ÷ P77,351) ÷ 2] =
19-6
10.51% 9.30% 9.511%
