Ledonio v Capitol Development Corp. Digest for Oblicon
Labor 2Full description
Full description
Digest
PNB v. San Miguel Corporation G.R. No. 186063, January 15, 2014Full description
digestFull description
Corporation Law case digest, Corporate Dissolution - Rehabilitation (Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act of 2010, R.A. No. 10142)Full description
DigestFull description
Full description
BungeCor por at i onvCame menf or t e( 29August1952) Baut i s t aAngel o,J . FACTS: •
•
•
• •
•
Pl ai nt i ffs cl ai m t hata cont r actwas ent er ed i nt o bet ween t he Vi sayan Pr oduct s Comp mpany ( r epr esent ed by Ca me me nf o r t ea ndc o mp mp an y )a ndBu ng eCo r p .f o rt h es a l eo f5 00l o ngt o nsofc o pr ai nb ul kat$ 18 8. 8 0p ert o n. I twa ss t i p ul a t edt h atVi s a y anPr o duc t swo ul ds hi pt h ec o pr ao nNo v emb ero rDe ce mb mb er1 94 7t ot h epl a i n t i ffi nSF , CAf ordel i v er y . Vi s ay anPr oduc t sf ai l edt omak et hed el i v er y .Bel i e vi ngi ngo odf ai t ht hatt hec opr awoul dbedel i v er edont i me, pl ai nt i ffsol dt oEl Dor adoOi l Wor k st hequant i t yofc opr ai tpur c has ed. Bec aus eoft hef ai l ur et os hi pan ddel i v ert hec opr ao nt i me,pl ai nt i ffc l ai msi ts uff er eddamageswor t hP1 80, 00 0. De f e nd an tVi c e nt eKh oa dmi t t e dt h ati twa sVi s a y anPr o du ct s T ac l ob ant h ate nt e r e di nt ot h et r a ns ac t i o na ndn ot Vi s a y a nPr o du c t s Ce bu . Hewa st h eman age ra ndco nt r o l l i n gs t o ck ho l d ero fVi s a y anPr o du ct s T ac l o ba n. o Kh oc l ai mst h ath e“ d i dh i sb es t ”t oc omp l ywi t ht h ec o nt r a ctb utf a i l e dt od os obe c au s eo ff or c ema j e ur e.He s t at edt hath ear r ange df oras hi pt omak et h edel i v er y ,butb ef or et hes hi par r i v ed,as t or mo cc ur r edc aus i ngt h e d es t r u ct i o no ft h eb od eg awh er et h ec o pr awa ss t o r e d.
I SSUES+RULI NG:
WoNt hec i v i l l i abi l i t yoft hedef endant ssubs i s t sdes pi t eoft hef or t ui t ousev ent . YES. Thes ubj ec toft hec ont r ac ti s500t onsofc opr a;i tdoesnotr ef ert oan ypar t i c ul arors pec i fi cc opr a,nordoesi t me nt i ont h ep l a cewh er et h ec opr ai st ob ea cq ui r ed . Thesubj ec tmat t eroft hesal ei st her ef or egener i candnots pec i fi c. o I ta ppe ar i ng t hatt he o bl i gat i on ofa ppel l anti st o del i v erc opr ai n a ge ner i cs ens e,t he obl i g at i on c an no tbe d ee me me de x t i n gu i s he db yt h ed es t r u c t i o no rd i s a pp ea r a nc eoft h ec o pr a . Thei robl i gat i ons ubs i s t sasl ongast hatc ommodi t yi sav ai l abl e.A gener i cobl i gat i oni snote xt i ngui s hedbyt he g .Genusnunquanper i t l os sofat hi ngbel ongi ngt oapar t i c ul a r enus . Ac c o r d i n gt oMa Ma nr e s a: ac onc r e t e,par t i c ul ar i z edobj ec t ,i ndi c at edbyi t sowni ndi v i dual i t y Speci fict hi ng: o newhos ed et er mi nat i oni sco nfi nedt ot hatofi t sna t ur e,t ot h egen us( gener o)t owhi c hi t Ge ne r i ct hi ng: o per t ai ns •
•
•
•
YES. Wo Nd ef e nd an t sar el i a bl ef o rd a ma ma ge s . Ac cor di ngt ot hepl ai nt i ff ,i ts uff er eddamageswor t h$84, 630. 86asi tf ai l edt odel i v ert hec opr at oEl Dor ado. Th el o we rc o ur tr u l edt h att h es al et oElDo r a dowasc on cl u de db ef o r et h es al eb et we enp l ai n t i ffa ndd ef en dan t c or p or a t i o n.Ass uc h ,t h ec opr as ol dt oEl Do r a doc ou l dno th av ebe ent h eo nepu r c h as edf r o md ef e nd ant . Ho we v er ,t hel o werc our ts t i l l f ou ndi tpr opert oa war ddamag es . t hel owerc o ur ti ni t sr ul i ng;t h e di ff er enc ei nt hed at esi smer el ynomi nalbec aus eo ft het i medi ff er e nc e SC: bet weenNYandCebu. • •
• •
Affir me d.Co s t sa ga i n s td ef e nd an t . DI SPOSI TI ON:
