Affect in Language Learning Edited by JANE ARNOLD
• Cambridge Language Teaching Library
4
Anxiety and the language learner: new insights Rebecca L. Oxford
Introduction True story number 1 Ressa was enrolled in a graduate program in Russian at a famous university. She did not have a strong background in speaking Russian or in understanding spoken Russian, although her reading and writing were passable in the language. Ressa had expected that her graduate program would give her the strength that she lacked in speaking and listening. However, she discovered that the Russian graduate program was taught completely in English with an emphasis on literary analysis, except for the linguistics classes on Old Church Slavonic, which had very little to do with the modern Russian language. Ressa learned that at the end of the first two years of the graduate program, without once having used the Russian language in the classroom, each graduate student was required to stand up in front of a large group of professors and peers and present in flawless Russian a one-hour lecture on some aspect of Russian literature or linguistics. If a student failed in this task, he or she would be thrown out of the program. Ressa's worry began when she found out about that requirement. She did not want to make a fool of herself in front of a mass of professors, nor did she want to face the greatest humiliation: being involuntarily released from the program. Her anxiety turned to terror; she started having nightmares about the lecture she was required to give. She gained weight and started feeling depressed as well as anxious. What she called her 'terror quotient' became so high that she quit the Russian program. She never told the professors why, and they never asked. By dropping out, she gave up possibilities of using Russian for a career.
ss
4 Anxiety and the language learner
True story number 2
Maurice studied French in high school and made a botch of it, earning failing grades in French although he was an honors student in all his other classes. He believed he was a total language failure. He did not know at the time that he had auditory processing problems. Later, Maurice needed to learn a foreign language to graduate from college. Because of his very painful experiences · earlier in high school French and a new understanding of his auditory difficulties, he knew he could not learn through conventional means in the usual language classroom. His only hope, he thought, was some kind of nontraditional immersion program. Therefore, he went to Guatemala to study Spanish at a well-reputed language institute. His main goal was to learn to speak Spanish well enough to pass a proficiency test at the university back home. The stakes were high: If he did not pass ordinary classes or the language test, he could not graduate. He was already anxious when he arrived. As a visually-oriented learner who needed to see things written down, Maurice became increasingly fearful when he was placed in a mostly-auditory class in Guatemala. Halfway through the class he panicl
4 Anxiety and the language learner The importance of anxiety in language learning has led to significant research and discussion on the topic (Horwitz and Young 1991; Young in press; H. D. Brown 1994a; Gardner 1985; Oxford 1990a, 199ob; Reid 199 5 ). The purpose of the current chapter is twofold: to present an updated review of the research on language anxiety and to offer classroom implications based on research findings.
Research review This section reviews research concerning whether language anxiety is a short-term state or a lasting trait, whether it is harmful or helpful, which factors correlate with language anxiety, and how anxiety can be identified in the language classroom. State or trait Anxiety sometimes arises in response to a particular situation or event (situational or state anxiety), but it can be a major character trait. Language anxiety can start as transitory episodes of fear in a situation in which the student has to perform in the language; at this time, anxiety is simply a passing state. Ideally, language anxiety diminishes over time, as shown in studies of students learning French (e.g., Desrochers and Gardner 1981). However, language anxiety does not decrease over time for all students. If repeated occurrences cause students to associate anxiety with language performance, anxiety becomes a trait rather than a state (Gardner and Macintyre 1993). Once language anxiety has evolved into a lasting trait, it can have pervasive effects on language learning and language performance. Harmful anxiety Though some language ,researchers assert that a posltlve mode of anxiety exists, most language research shows a negative relationship between anxiety and performance. The negative kind of anxiety is sometimes called 'debilitating anxiety', because it harms learners' performance in many ways, both indirectly through worry and selfdoubt and directly by reducing participation and creating overt avoidance of the language. Harmful anxiety can be related to plummeting motivation, negative attitudes and beliefs, and language performance difficulties. Gardner and Macintyre stated that the strongest (negative) correlate 6o
4 Anxiety and the language learner
of language achievement is anxiety (1993). Studies show the negative correlation of anxiety with the following: - grades in language courses (Aida 1994; Horwitz 1986; Trylong 1987); - proficiency test performance (Ganschow, Sparks, Anderson, Javorsky, Skinner and Patton 1994; Gardner, Lalonde, Moorcroft and Evers 1987); - performance in speaking and writing tasks (Trylong 1987; Young 1986); - self-confidence in language learning (Macintyre and Gardner 1991; Gardner and Macintyre 1993); - self-esteem, i.e., the judgment of one's own worth (Horwitz, Horwitz and Cope 1986; Price 1991; Scarcella and Oxford 1992). The relationship between language anxiety and language performance is not simple. Young (1991) explained that sometimes language anxiety is negatively related to one skill and not another. Ganschow, Sparks, Anderson, Javorsky, Skiller and Patton (1994) suggested that high anxiety might be a result of language learning problems rather than the cause. Helpful anxiety
Some research suggested that language anxiety was actually 'helpful' or 'facilitating' in some ways, such as keeping students alert (Scovel 1978). Helpful anxiety has been shown in a few studies to be related to: - high language proficiency and self-confidence among a hand-picked group of excellent language learners (Ehrman and Oxford 1995); - oral production of difficult English structures among native Arabicspeakers and Spanish-speakers (Kleinmann 1977); - good grades in language classes for students in regular French, German, and Spanish classes but not for students in audiolingual classes (Chastain 197 5 ). Language researchers hold different views about the existence or significance of helpful anxiety. Horwitz (1990) stated that anxiety is only helpful for very simple learning tasks, but not with more complicated learning such as language learning. Young (I 99 2) interviewed language learning experts Rardin, Omaggio Hadley, Terrell and Krashen about their views on the helpfulness of language anxiety. Rardin responded that a positive aspect of anxiety operates all the time, but we only notice when a negative imbalance occurs. Omaggio Hadley suggested that a certain amount of tension might be useful for language 61
4 Anxiety and the language learner
of language achievement is anxiety (1993). Studies show the negative correlation of anxiety with the following: - grades in language courses (Aida 1994; Horwitz 1986; Trylong I987); - proficiency test performance (Ganschow, Sparks, Anderson, Javorsky, Skinner and Patton 1994; Gardner, Lalonde, Moorcroft and Evers 1987); - performance in speaking and writing tasks (Trylong 1987; Young 1986); - self-confidence in language learning (Macintyre and Gardner 1991; Gardner and Macintyre 1993); - self-esteem, i.e., the judgment of one's own worth (Horwitz, Horwitz and Cope 1986; Price 1991; Scarcella and Oxford 1992). The relationship between language anxiety and language performance is not simple. Young (1991) explained that sometimes language anxiety is negatively related to one skill and not another. Ganschow, Sparks, Anderson, Javorsky, Skiller and Patton (1994) suggested that high anxiety might be a result of language learning problems rather than the cause. Helpful anxiety
Some research suggested that language anxiety was actually 'helpful' or 'facilitating' in some ways, such as keeping students alert (Scovel 1978). Helpful anxiety has been shown in a few studies to be related to: - high language proficiency and self-confidence among a hand-picked group of excellent language learners (Ehrman and Oxford 1995); - oral production of difficult English structures among native Arabicspeakers and Spanish-speakers (Kleinmann 1977); - good grades in language classes for students in regular French, German, and Spanish classes but not for students in audiolingual classes (Chastain 197 5 ). Language researchers hold different views about the existence or significance of helpful anxiety. Horwitz (1990) stated that anxiety is only helpful for very simple learning tasks, but not with more complicated learning such as language learning. Young (I 99 2) interviewed language learning experts Rardin, Omaggio Hadley, Terrell and Krashen about their views on the helpfulness of language anxiety. Rardin responded that a positive aspect of anxiety operates all the time, but we only notice when a negative imbalance occurs. Omaggio Hadley suggested that a certain amount of tension might be useful for language 61
4 Anxiety and the language learner
learning, but she refused to term this tension 'anxiety'. Likewise, Terrell preferred to call such tension 'attention' rather than 'anxiety'. Krashen contended that there is no helpful aspect to anxiety in language acquisition, which almost by definition requires that anxiety be zero, but that helpful anxiety might exist for language tasks in formal language learning situations. Clearly, the jury is still out concerning the existence of helpful anxiety. Correlates of language anxiety
Correlates of language anxiety range from highly personal (such as self-esteem) to procedural (such as classroom activities and methods). Self-esteem
Self-esteem is a self-judgment of worth or value, based on feelings of efficacy, a sense of interacting effectively with one's own environment. Efficacy implies that some degree of control exists within oneself. Unsuccessful language learners often have lower self-esteem than successful language learners (Price 1991). Whether this affects their overall self-esteem or only their situational self-esteem partly depends on how important language learning is to the individuals involved. Self-esteem is vulnerable when the learner perceives himself or herself as very competent in the native language and totally inadequate or limited in the target language (Price 1991). Horwitz, Horwitz and Cope (r986) noted that foreign language learning can cause a threat to self-esteem by depriving learners of their normal means of communication, their freedom to make errors, and their ability to behave like normal people. Among highly anxious language students, those with high self-esteem might handle their anxiety better than those with low self-esteem, resulting in better performance. Like anxiety, self-esteem can be a trait (an inherent personality characteristic) or a state (related to a particular situation). A person can feel good about himself or herself globally or generally, yet at the same time experience low self-esteem in a particular situation or environment (Scarcella and Oxford 1992). Tolerance of ambiguity
Tolerance of ambiguity is the acceptance of confusing situations. Second language learning has a great deal of ambiguity about meanings, referents and pronunciation, and this can often raise language anxiety. Therefore, a degree of ambiguity-tolerance is essential for language learners. Students who are able to tolerate moderate levels of confusion
4 Anxiety and the language learner are likely to persist longer in language learning than students who are overly frightened by the ambiguities inherent in learning a new language (Chapelle and Roberts I986). Risk-taking
Students who are highly anxious about the frequent ambiguities of language learning often suffer reduced risk-taking ability. It is more useful for language learners to take moderate but intelligent risks, such as guessing meanings based on background knowledge and speaking up despite the possibility of making occasional mistakes, rather than taking no risks at all or taking extreme, uninformed risks (Oxford I 990a, I99ob; H. D. Brown I994a). Language students who fear ambiguity or whose self-esteem is low, frequently 'freeze up', allowing their inhibitions to take over completeJy (Beebe I983). Decreases in risk-taking frequently occur when students feel extreme discomfort in the language classroom (Ely I986). Students who avoid risks are stalled by actual or anticipated criticism from others or by self-criticism that they themselves supply. When they do not have enough practice, their language development becomes seriously stunted. Competitiveness
Using diary studies of language learners, Bailey (I 9 8 3) asserted that competitiveness can lead to language anxiety. This happens when language learners compare themselves to others or to an idealized selfimage, which they can rarely attain. Scarcella and Oxford (I992) agreed that competitiveness can relate to language anxiety but suggested that this link does not occur in all students. Some students, particularly those in competitive cultures, thrive on competition. The emotional import of competitiveness for a given individual depends on the learning style preferences of the student, the precise nature of the competition, and the demands and rewards of the environment. Social anxiety
Social anxiety can include speech anxiety, shyness, stage fright, embarrassment, social-evaluative anxiety and communication apprehension (Leary I 9 8 3). Social anxiety occurs along with the prospect or actual presence of interpersonal evaluation. People who are highly concerned about others' evaluations of them- and we might assume these to be people with shaky self-esteem and/or strong external locus of control (the learner's belief that his or own performance is controlled by 63
4 Anxiety and the language learner external factors) - tend to act in ways that minimize the likelihood of negative assessments. These people are more likely to avoid or withdraw from social situations in which others might view them negatively. When they relate to others, they often fail to take the initiative or participate only minimally in conversations (Aida 1994). In the language classroom, this is observable in behaviors such as keeping silent, responding only when necessary, being passive, and avoiding class entirely. Communication apprehension is defined as a person's level of anxiety associated with either real or anticipated communication with another person or persons (McCroskey 1984). People who suffer from communication apprehension are more reluctant to converse or interact with others; therefore, they tend to avoid communication or withdraw from it as soon as possible. McCroskey, Payer and Richmond (1985) and Foss and Reitzel (1988) observed communication apprehension in ESLIEFL classrooms. Test anxiety Test anxiety can be part of social anxiety, particularly in an evaluative situation where the student is asked to communicate in the target language. However, test anxiety can occur in noncommunicative situations, too. Test anxiety is 'the tendency to become alarmed about the consequences of inadequate performance on a test or other evaluation' (Sarason 1984), regardless of whether the fears are realistic. Students with test anxiety frequently experience cognitive interference (Sarason 1984) and have a difficult time focusing on the task at hand (Aida 1994). Identity and culture shock Identification with a language group or target culture implies that the learner is an insider, a member of the 'club' of French, Spanish, German or Chinese speakers. Young (1992) suggested that anxiety is lower (that is, the affective filter is reduced) if a student feels such identification, and anxiety is higher if the student does not identify with the language group. Paradoxically, for other learners anxiety can arise because of over-identification with the language group and the concurrent feeling of loss of personal identity. This idea is similar to Guiora's (1972) theory of language ego and Clarke's (1976) theory of clash of consciousness. Anxiety about losing one's own identity can be part of culture shock. Culture shock is defined as 'a form of anxiety that results from the loss of commonly perceived and understood signs and symbols of social intercourse' (Adler 1987:25). Culture shock can involve some or all of
4 Anxiety and the language learner these symptoms: emotional regression, physical illness, panic, anger, hopelessness, self-pity, lack of confidence, indecision, sadness, alienation, a sense of deception, a perception of 'reduced personality', and glorification of one's own native culture. However, if handled effectively, culture shock can become a cross-cultural learning opportunity involving increased cultural awareness, increased self-awareness and reintegration of personality (Adler 1987). Beliefs
Research suggests that the beliefs of both learners and instructors are linked to language anxiety (and possibly to learner performance through instructors' classroom procedures and students' responses to those procedures, discussed later). Foreign language learners in Horwitz's (1988) study believed that they should be able to speak with great accuracy and an excellent accent, language learning consists mainly of translation from English, two years is long enough to become fluent, and some people could learn languages more easily than others. Some of these beliefs were extremely unrealistic and led to language anxiety. Many language teachers maintain the belief that they should be directive, authoritarian and even intimidating and that they must correct every error. However, these behaviors can lead to language anxiety (Young 1991). Classroom activities and methods
Koch and Terrell (1991) found that more than half of their subjects reported oral skits and oral presentations in front of the class as the most anxiety-producing activities and that oral quizzes and being called on to respond orally were also anxiety-producing. Similar results were found by Horwitz and Young (1991) and Young (in press). Yet speaking tasks are not the only anxiety triggers. For some language students, writing, reading or listening can also create fear, depending on the student (see Horwitz and Young 1991; Scarcella and Oxford 1992). Some teaching methods, such as Community Language Learning, can reduce language anxiety for many learners (Samimy and Rardin 1994). Instructor-learner interactions
Many researchers relate language anxiety to instructor-learner interactions (Horwitz, Horwitz and Cope 1986; Koch and Terrell 1991; Price 1991; Scarcella and Oxford 1992; Young 1990). Harsh error correction, ridicule and the uncomfortable handling of mistakes in front 6s
4 Anxiety and the language learner
of a class are among the most important instructor-learner interaction issues related to language anxiety. An important aspect of instructorlearner interaction has frequently been overlooked: style conflicts between teachers and students. Teacher-student learning style conflicts have been shown to relate to lower grades for students and to contribute to stress in the classroom (Oxford, Ehrman, and Lavine 1991). Ways to identify language anxiety
Teachers and researchers might sometimes be able to infer language anxiety through tests of general anxiety. However, this practice is not recommended (Gardner and Macintyre 1993) because researchers view language anxiety as a specific phenomenon that is better assessed directly. A number of instruments exist, the best known of which is the 'Foreign Language Classroom Anxiety Scale' or FLCAS, by Horwitz (r986). The FLCAS was developed to capture the specific anxiety reaction of a student to a foreign language situation. This instrument integrates three related anxieties - communication apprehension, test anxiety, and fear of negative evaluation - but is more than the sum of these parts (Aida 1994; Horwitz, Horwitz, and Cope 1986). Language anxiety is often readily observable even without an instrument like the FLCAS. However, behaviors vary across cultures, and what might seem like anxious behavior in one culture might be normal behavior m another culture. The following are likely signs of language anxiety. - General avoidance: 'Forgetting' the answer, showing carelessness, cutting class, coming late, arriving unprepared, low levels of verbal production, lack of volunteering in class, seeming inability to answer even the simplest questions. - Physical actions: Squirming, fidgeting, playing with hair or clothing, nervously touching objects, stuttering or stammering, displaying jittery behavior, being unable to reproduce the sounds or intonation of the target language even after repeated practice. Physical symptoms: Complaining about a headache, experiencing tight muscles, feeling unexplained pain or tension in any part of the body. Other signs which might reflect language anxiety, depending on the culture: overstudying, perfectionism, social avoidance, conversational withdrawal, lack of eye contact, hostility, monosyllabic or noncommittal responses, image protection or masking behaviors (exaggerated smiling, laughing, nodding, joking), failing to interrupt when it would be natural to do so, excessive competitiveness, excessive selfeffacement and self-criticism ('I am so stupid'). 66
4 Anxiety and the language learner Classroom implications After diagnosing anxious behavior, language teachers can act to reduce anxiety, depending on students' needs and cultural background. Teachers can use any •or all of the following suggestions for diminishing language anxiety. - Help students understand that language anxiety episodes can be transient and do not inevitably develop into a lasting problem. - Boost the self-esteem and self-confidence of students for whom language anxiety has already become a long-term trait by providing multiple opportunities for classroom success in the language. - Encourage moderate risk-taking and tolerance of ambiguity in a comfortable, non-threatening environment. - Reduce the competition present in the classroom. - Be very clear about classroom goals and help students develop strategies to meet those goals. - Give students permission to use the language with less than perfect performance. - Encourage students to relax through music, laughter or games. - Use fair tests with unambiguous, familiar item types. - Help students realistically assess their performance. - Give rewards that are meaningful to students and that help support language use. - Provide activities that address varied learning styles and strategies in the classroom. - Enable students to recognize symptoms of anxiety and identify anxiety-maintaining beliefs. - Help students practice positive self-talk (self-encouragement) and cognitive 'reframing' of negative or irrational ideas. Using suggestions such as these, teachers can enable students to deal more effectively with language anxiety. When teachers help their students reduce language anxiety, situations such as Ressa's and Maurice's can be halted before becoming full-blown disasters. Students like Ressa and Maurice- and many others- can be spared the pain of severe language anxiety and can experience what it means to succeed in the language classroom.
67
