4_Chapter 4 Classic Methods of Slope Stability Analysis

!"#$%&' ()*'

!"#$$%& '()*+,$ +- $"+.( $)#/%"%)0 #1#"0$%$

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

.%/0+# 123#3 4$- 3+)0# %* 32*5 Y-/-&&"1; $% Z";< [
2<

Y-#"#$"1; /%&'Z '%# ! $(1 " " $(1 " " ! ! V"#$4&."1; /%&'Z #"1 ! $(1 !

!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6.

β

W

023? [?I \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 5%& * ,&8 4)%(' 2$ 4*$, :,-1'-+ /%& )"3"$"1; -\4")".&"43+ !3(M ! " "

?@++- 3@A/#$,#5 3+)0# %* 32*5 Y-/-&&"1; $% Z";< [<]+ '%1#"2-& ( #)"'- %/ :"2$, * (12 2-0$, ,< =,- .4%*(1$ :-";,$ %/ $,- #)"'- "#^ Z " ! *,# "

## " ! # $ #: %

=,- -//-'$"8- #$&-## 1%&3() $% $,- .(#- %/ $,- #)"'- "#^ $"1 ! *,# " '%# !

'%# ! *

=,- #,-(& #$&-## ()%1; $,- #)%0"1; .(#- %/ $,- #)"'- "#^ % ! *,# " #"1 !

'%# ! *

=,- /('$%& %/ #(/-$* (;("1#$ #)"2"1; 3(* .- 2-&"8-2 (# 0!

,# " '%#] ! $(1 " " & ,# #"1 ! '%# !

0!

$(1 " " $(1 !

:,-1'-

R%$- $,($ $,- -M0&-##"%1 /%& /('$%& %/ #(/-$* /%& $,- /4))* #4.3-&;-2 #)%0"# "2-1$"'() $% $,($ /%& ( 2&* #)%0-<

γ

β

a W′

d

023? [?] \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 5%& * 5"))8 4"!.'&3', 4)%(' 2$ 4*$,

2@

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69> a

γ = bulk unit weight

z

β

023? [?X \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 5%& * 4'.2<2$=$2#' 4)%('; " ! Y *$*)8424

.#/%G%*H*%I# 3+)0#J ! K L 2*2+-3%3 Y-/-&&"1; $% Z";< [<_+ '%1#"2-& ( #)"'- %/ :"2$, ! (12 2-0$, W< =,- 2"#$4&.N "1; /%&'- "# #W! #"1 !< =,- &-#$%&"1; /%&'- "# * 44 '%# ! =,- /('$%& %/ #(/-$* (;("1#$ #)"2"1; "# $,-&-/%&0!

44 #W '%# ! #"1 !

M!:;=4 =N8B<7= K%1#"2-& ( 1($4&() #)%0- "1 %8-&N'%1#%)"2($-2 P%12%1 ')(* 1-(& )"3"$"1; -\4")".&"43< =(9- W ! F 3+ 44 ! AJJ 9>(+ # ! ]J 9RU3_ + ! ! AJ! :,"', (&- $*0"'() 8()4-#< =,-1 44 0! #W '%# ! #"1 ! !

AJJ ]J & F & '%# AJ! #"1 AJ!

! [']

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


!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6. H tan α

H α

023? [?[ \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 5%& * >'+*) !*$E; " ! Y *$*)8424; $% #'$42%$ +&*+E

! K L 2*2+-3%3 O)$ "#$I%12+ 1@IJ *) I#*3%)* 1$21P X1 Z";< [<[+ $,- 2"#$4&."1; /%&'- "# A(]#_] #"1 )( $(1 )< =,- &-#$%&"1; /%&'- "# 44 _(#"1 )< =(9"1; $,- '&"$"'() (1;)- %/ #)"2"1; (# )'&"$ ! [C!+ $,-1 _' ! [44 (#< `)$-&1($"8-)*+ (##43"1; ( #)"0 '"&')-+ $,- '%&&-#0%12"1; &-#4)$ :%4)2 ._' ! _'QC44 (#< =,-#- 0&-2"'$"%1# :%4)2 .- 41#(/- "1 0&('$"'- .-'(4#&-() ')(* #%")# (&- :-(9 "1 $-1#"%1< ! K L 2*2+-3%3 O)$ "#$I%12+ 1@IJ &%I( I#*3%)* 1$21P Y-/-& $% Z";< [
_' A & #"1 [C! ]

`$ /(")4&- :,-1 0 ! A+ $,- '&"$"'() ,-";,$ "# _' ! ]'IF44 (#< =,"# ;"8-# ( 3%&- &-()"#$"' 0&-2"'$"%1 /%& $,- ,-";,$ %/ ( $-30%&(&* 8-&$"'() '4$ "1 ')(*<

D = Hc/2 Hc γ = bulk unit weight su = undrained shear strength 45˚

023? [?K \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 5%& * >'+*) !*$E; " ! Y *$*)8424; 12#- #'$42%$ +&*+E


34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69>

M!:;=4 =N8B<7= K%1#"2-& $,- 2"//-&-1$ (00&%(',-# $% (1()*#"1; $,- #,%&$ $-&3 #$(.")"$* %/ ( 8-&$"'() .(19 "))4#$&($-2 "1 Z";< [
IJ!^ V"#$4&."1; Y-#$%&"1; 0 [C!^ V"#$4&."1; Y-#$%&"1; 0 _J!^ V"#$4&."1; Y-#$%&"1; 0 Z%& '(#- @.D :- ,(8-^ Z%& ( 2&* #)%0-^ V"#$4&."1; Y-#$%&"1; 02&*

! C & F'C & ]J & #"1 [C! ! F'JF & IJ ! [][UC_J 60˚

45˚

10 m

! C_J 9R ! [<][ 9R ! J
30˚ γ = 20 kN/m3

su = 60 kN/m2 (a)

Qw

10 m

5m

5m

45˚ (b) 10 m

4·24 m 10 m

(c)

023? [?T \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+-'4 5%& 1%&E', 'V*.()' D*H *44".2$3 ,255'&'$# *$3)'4 %5 4)2( ()*$'4; D!H #*E2$3 * [K! 4)2( ()*$' *$, * 1*#'&<=))', #'$42%$ +&*+E; D+H *44".2$3 4)2( ()*$' 24 #-' L"*,&*$# %5 * +2&+)'


!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6.

Z%& ( :-$ #)%0- @$-1#"%1 '&('9 G))-2 :"$, :($-&D O($-& /%&'! A] & C & C & AJ TM$&( 2"#$4&."1; ! A]C & #"1 [C! 0:-$ ! [][(C_J ' QQ'[

! A]C 9R ! QQ<[ 9R ! J
X$ '(1 .- #--1 $,($ $,- G))"1; %/ $,- $-1#"%1 '&('9 :"$, :($-& ,(# ( #";1"G'(1$ -//-'$ %1 #$(.")"$*< Z%& '(#- @'D :- ,(8- @1%$"1; $,- '-1$&%"2 %/ ( \4(2&(1$ %/ ( '"&')&(2"4# ` "# )%'($-2 [`(_* /&%3 $,- '-1$&- %/ $,- '"&')-D^ `&-( >-&"3-$-&

! * & AJ] ([ ! * & AJ(]

! FQ
! FQ'C & ]J & ['][ ! AC'FA & IJ & AJ ! B[][UIICI
! IICI
=(9"1; 3%3-1$# ;"8-#^ V"#$4&."1; Y-#$%&"1; 0 X1 #433(&* :- ,(8-^

'(#- @(D 0 ! A<_B @IJ!D+ A<]J @[C!D+ A<_B @_J!D< '(#- @.D 0 ! J'QJ @2&*D+ J
.#/%G%*H*%I# 3+)0#J #Q#1I%"# 3I$#33 2*2+-3%3 Y-/-& $% Z";< [%&- :($-& 0&-##4&- ! " ! .W#: '%# ! '%# ! ! .W#: '%#] ! =,- 1%&3() -//-'$"8- #$&-## %1 $,- .(#- %/ $,- #)"'- "#^ $" ! ## $ .#1 %W '%#] ! O,-1'- $,- /('$%& %/ #(/-$* (;("1#$ #)"2"1; "# 0!

+" ' ## $ .#1 %W '%#] ! $(1 " " #W #"1 ! '%# !


34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69>

1

β

Seepage parallel to slope

Z mZ

U γw

γz

γz cos β

γz sin β

1 cos β

023? [?U \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 5%& * 4'.2<2$=$2#' 4)%(' 12#- 4''(*3' (*&*))') #% #-' 4)%('; '55'+#2>' 4#&'44 *$*)8424 X/ +" ! J+ $,- '&"$"'() #)%0- "# ;"8-1 .* $(1 !' !

## $ .#1 % $(1 " " #

X/ "1 (22"$"%1 . ! A+ "<-< $,- :($-& $(.)- "# ($ $,- ;&%412 #4&/('-+ $,-1 $(1 !' !

#" $(1 " " #

X/ c%: "# ,%&"a%1$()+ ,%:-8-&+ $,-1 " ! #: W (12 ! " #: $(1 " " 0! A$ ] # '%# ! $(1 ! '%30(&-2 :"$, ! " #: $(1 " " 0! A$ # $(1 ! /%& 0(&())-) c%: (12 +" ! J<
!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6.

M!:;=4 =N8B<7= Y-/-&&"1; $% Z";< [(< `##43- $,- #)%0"# %1 $,- 0%"1$ %/ #)"2"1;+ "<-< 0 ! A< O,($ "# $,- 8()4- %/ $,- (1;)- %/ #,-(&"1; &-#"#$(1'- :"$, &-#0-'$ $% -//-'$"8- #$&-##+ " " d R%: $,- /('$%& %/ #(/-$* (;("1#$ #)"2"1; "#^ 0!

+" ' ## $ .#1 %W '%#] ! $(1 " " & #W #"1 ! '%# !

:,-1'-

]F'J[C $ ] IB'Q_Q ! J'_CQI

$(1 " " !

" " ! AB'F!

X/ +" ! J+ " " ! ]A']! (12 "/ W "# "1G1"$-+ " " ! ][']!<

1m

u = γw × 6 × cos2 12˚

6m

12˚

023? [?P \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 5%& * 4'.2<2$=$2#' 4)%(' 12#- 4''(*3' (*&*))') #% #-' 4)%('; 1%&E', 'V*.()'

8*%3)I$)0- )O 0#$/#2A%+%I=,- -//-'$ %/ (1"#%$&%0* :"$, &-#0-'$ $% 0-&3-(.")"$* %1 $,- #$(.")"$* %/ ( )%1; #)%0- "1 ( /&"'$"%1() #%") @"<-< +" ! JD+ /%& ( '%12"$"%1 %/ #--0(;- 0(&())-) $% $,- #)%0- #4&/('- (12 $,- :($-& $(.)- ($ $,- ;&%412 #4&/('- 3(* .(##-##-2 4#"1; $,- -\4($"%1 %/ =-))"1; @ABQQD^ 0 ! (A $ ##: (#%! #-'] 2) $(1 " " ( $(1 2
34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69> $############## :,-&-"1 ! ! A(#A ' E] $(1] 2%e E ! E! (Ef + :,-&- E! "# $,- ,%&"a%1$() 0-&3-(.")"$*+ (12 Ef "# $,- 8-&$"'() 0-&3-(.")"$*e 2 "# $,- #)%0- (1;)- (12 #: + # (12 " " (&- (# 4#4())* 2-G1-2< ?* :(* %/ "))4#$&($"%1+ $,- 8(&"($"%1 %/ 0 :"$, E "# (# /%))%:# /%& 2 ! A[! (12 " " ! ]F!^ E!A

0 ! A'J]

E ! AJ

0 ! A'CI

E ! ]J

0 ! A'F_

.+%0 1%$1+# 2*2+-3%3J ! ! L /#I()5

R%$- $,($ $,- " ! J (1()*#"# "# (00&%0&"($- %1)* $% $-30%&(&* #,%&$ $-&3 -M'(8($"%1# :,-&- $,- 412&("1-2 %& #,%&$ $-&3 #$&-1;$, "# (##43-2 $% .- '%1$&%))"1; #$(.")"$*< =,- #)"0 '"&')- " ! J 3-$,%2 "# %4$)"1-2 "1 Z";< [
x

a

H DH

W = Aγ i

l

su F

α

023? [?J C'8 4E'#+- 5%& #%#*) 4#&'44 *$*)8424 %5 * 4)%(' *44".2$3 * +2&+")*& 4)2( 4"&5*+'; .'#-%, %5 4)2+'4
!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6. R%$"1; $,($ V ! ` #"1 )+ ) ! * #-' ) (12 Z ! (* ;"8-# % 4 #-' ) 0! % 4 ( #"1 ) /%& -\4() #)"'- :"2$,#+ :,"', "# ( '%18-1"-1$ /%&3 /%& ,(12 '()'4)($"%1< S%)4$"%1# (&- (8(")(.)- /%& #"30)- ;-%3-$&* (12 /%&^ "

'%1#$(1$ 412&("1-2 #,-(& #$&-1;$, @=(*)%&+ AB_FD 0·19

i = 53˚ 0·18

45˚

0·17

30

˚ ·5 ˚ 22

n=

3

15

˚

0·16

1

0·14

7· 5˚

Stability number N = su/FγH

2

0·15

0·13

nH i

H

DH

0

0·12

0·11

0·10

0·09

1

2

3

4

Depth factor D

023? [?IY @*8)%&74 +"&>'4 5%& 4#*!2)2#8 $".!'&4 <2

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69> "

#,-(& #$&-1;$, "1'&-(#"1; )"1-(&)* :"$, 2-0$, /&%3 a-&% ($ ;&%412 #4&/('- @g".#%1 (12 H%&;-1#$-&1+ ABI]D<

C2-+)$R3 3)+@I%)* =,"# "# /%& #"30)- #)%0-# :"$, 1% #--0(;- (12 1% $-1#"%1 '&('9#< X$ "# 2-&"8-2 /&%3 #)"0 '"&')- (1()*#"# :"$, 44 '%1#$(1$ :"$, 2-0$,< Y-/-&&"1; $% Z";< [
44 #_

0!

44 a#_

/%& 0 ! A :,-1'- "1 0&('$"'/%& #)%0- (1;)-# )-## $,(1 C[!

X$ "# (28"#(.)- $% 4#- $,"# 3-$,%2 (# ( G&#$ (00&%M"3($"%1 /%& $%$() #$&-## @" ! JD '(#-< S$(.")"$* 143.-&# /%& #)%0- (1;)-# ;&-($-& $,(1 C[! (&;"8-1 "1 =(.)- [<]<

;+)($ +1 7#0"+GH$ &*#G)$ -+G " ! A &#$( @AD /%& ! + C[!+ '&"$"'() '"&')-# (&- $%- '"&')-# (12 _+ ! 5#!% @]D /%& ! , C[!+ '&"$"'() '"&')-# (&- %/ ;&-($ 2-0$, (12 _' "# "12-0-12-1$ %/ ! @_D /%& ! , C[! (12 \ *! ++ _' ! 5#!%<

M!:;=4 =N8B<7=. @AD =(9- - ! AJ 3+ 44 ! CJ 9>(+ , ! ++ # ! ]J 9RU3_ < Z%& ! , C[!+ 44 (#_ ! J'AQ 0!

CJ ! A'_Q J'AQ & ]J & AJ

Z%& ! ! BJ!+ 44 (#_ ! J']I 0!

CJ ! A'BI J']I & ]J & AJ

@]D =(9- 44 ! _J 9>(+ # ! AQ 9RU3_ + 0 ! A'_< V-$-&3"1- _3(M /%& ! ! [C! (12 BJ! (12 /%& \ ! A (12 +< =,#%)4$"%1 "# #-$ %4$ "1 =(.)- [
<<

44 #a0

!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6.

@*!)' [?I b*)"'4 %5 #" (#! ! R ! ! [C! _3(M ! ! BJ! _3(M

\!A

\!+

J
J
R%$-^ 4#"1; ( 0)(1- /(")4&- #4&/('- /%& ! ! BJ! ;"8-# _3(M ! [

44 44 ! # J']C#

"<-< _3(M !

_J ! C'A] 3 J']C & AQ & A'_

S$(.")"$* 143.-&# /%& ( " ! J (1()*#"# (&- 0&-#-1$-2 "1 =(.)- [<]< R%$-^ a ! 44 (#_ ! ! #)%0- (1;)`##430$"%1# (&-^ " " "

'%1#$(1$ 44 1% $-1#"%1 '&('9# #)"0 '"&')- (1()*#"#<

@*!)' [?] A#*!2)2#8 $".!'&4 5%& " ! J *$*)8424 !

>)(1-

K"&')-

BJ! FC! IJ! [C! _J! AC!

J<]CJ J
J<]IA J<]AB J
,

$%- '"&')-#+

,,

&

$%- '"&')-# (&- '&"$"'() '"&')-#

$%- '"&')-# (12 \ ! A

>%A3)* 2*5 B)$,#*3I#$* STUVWX =,- (##430$"%1# "1 Z";< [
$%$() #$&-## (1()*#"# #)"0 '"&')1% $-1#"%1 '&('9 <@

!"#$% &#'$!( )* ,"-+ (.& #"/$ ,+"*% %.0-.%%#-.0

"*+, -,.. /*0!$# 1#2 3$4+5#!%54#6! 78495! :$4 !%10*;*%< #8=054!

! !

!! "#$%&'("#) *"#&'%*+ ,"-. /&0-. 1%23 4&%2 '- )%2!#/ (!%1'$& '00%256 "3'-"#) -2 ' #2%3'**+ $2#(2*"/'-&/ $*'+ " /&0&#/( #$% 2# &7 8!- 2# (*20& '#)*&7 !! !'! 7 '#/ 2# "7 -.& !#",&").-9 " "( )":&# 8+ ! " !! !! ", ""( "( ! ;# ") ' "

!"#$%& %'()*+% <1 !! !'! " =#>7 " " ;? @AB3> 7 ,.'- (*20& ,2!*/ 8& %&C!"%&/ -2 )":& " " ;#> 12% '# &5$':'-&/ $!--"#)D E!8(-"-!-"#) "# -.& &C!'-"2# '82:& )":&( ( " ?#;FGH '#/ .&#$& -.& %&C!"%&/ (*20& "( ;I"9

+,

!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6.

=Q#1I%"# 3I$#33 3+%0 1%$1+# 2*2+-3%3J E%3()0 STUYYX =,- #)"0 '"&')- /(")4&- 3-',(1"#3 "# #,%:1 "1 Z";< [
=,- /('$%& %/ #(/-$* 0!

(8(")(.)- #$&-1;$, #$&-1;$, &-\4"&-2 /%& -\4")".&"43

(12 $,4# $,- 3%.")"a-2 #$&-1;$, "# ;"8-1 .* 4! O

+" $(1 " " ' #$1 $ "% ' 0 0

x A

n+1 n

R

D

B

C

α positive

α negative (a)

P′

b

c′ l F

′ nφ

ta F

n+1 n

En u γw

Xn

P′

En + 1

W

tan θ = tan φ′ B T= s f

C α (b)

W

θ

Xn + 1

F

ul

Xn – Xn +1 En – En +1

P

P = P ′ + ul (c)

023? [?I] \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+-'4 5%& '55'+#2>' 4#&'44 *$*)8424 %5 * 4)%('; .'#-%, %5 4)2+'4; D*H 4)2( +2&+)' 5*2)"&' .'+-*$24.; D!H 5%&+'4 *+#2$3 %$ *$ 2$,2>2,"*) 4)2+'; D+H 5%&+' (%)83%$

@B

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69> " "

` ;-1-&()"a-2 (1()*$"'() #%)4$"%1 "# 1%$ 0%##".)- (12 ( 143-&"'() #%)4N $"%1 "# &-\4"&-2 @?"#,%0 (12 H%&;-1#$-&1+ ABIJD< =% -#$"3($- 8()4-# %/ $1 ($ -(', 0%"1$ %1 /(")4&- #4&/('- :- 4#- $,#)"'-# 3-$,%2 %/ Z-))-1"4# @AB_ID+ G&#$ 04.)"#,-2 ($ $,- P(&;- V(3# K%1;&-##<

Y-/-&&"1; $% Z";< [
+" $(1 " " ' #$1 $ "% 0 0

#['A%

=,- $%$() 1%&3() #$&-## ($ $,- .(#- %/ ( #)"'- "# $1 ! N() :,-1'- 4 !

"

+ $(1 " ' (#N()% $ ") 0 0

"

#[']% #['_%

=,- #,-(& /%&'-+ 4+ ('$"1; %1 .(#- %/ #)"'- "# 4)< =(9"1; 3%3-1$# (.%4$ L ;"8-#+ /%& )"3"$"1; -\4")".&"43 ' ' ' ZV ! A` ! 4)` #['[% /&%3 -\4($"%1 @[<_D ' ' +" ) $(1 " " ' #N $ ")% ZV ! ` 0 0 ) ` '( " + ) ' #N $ ")% $(1 " " "<-< 0 ! % ZV

#['C%

$% %.$("1 N &-#%)8- 1%&3() $% #)"0 #4&/('N ! #Z ' c$ $ c$ ' A % '%# ) $ #M$ $ M$'A % #"1 ) X1#-&$"1; -\4($"%1 @[
' $(1 " " (#c$ ! c$'A % '%# ) $ #M$ $ M$'A % #"1 )).

#['I%

#['F%

S"1'- $,-&- (&- 1% -M$-&1() /%&'-# %1 $,- #)%0-+ "$ /%))%:# $,($ $,- #43 %/ $,- "1$-&1() /%&'-# 34#$ .- a-&%+ "<-< ' #['Q(% #c$ $ c$ ' A % ! J ' #M$ $ M$ ' A % ! J #['Q.%

.4$ $,- $-&3# "1 c$ ! ! ! (12 M$ ! ! ! 2% 1%$ 2"#(00-(&e $,-* %1)* 2% #% "/ " " ! '%1#$(1$ (12 ) ! '%1#$(1$+ "<-< :- ,(8- #)"2"1; %1 ( 0)(1-< L1- 0&%0%#()+ $,- i1"$-2 S$($-# ?4&-(4 %/ Y-')(3($"%1 @iS?YD #%)4$"%1+ "# $% (##43- $,($ ' $(1 " " (#c$ $ c$ ' A % '%# ) $ #M$ $ M$ ' A % #"1 )) ! J @C

!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6. =,-1+ 04$$"1; V ! ` #"1 ) ;"8-# ' " A (+ ) ' $(1 " " #Z '%# ) $ ")%) 0!% Z #"1 )

#['B%

=,"# /%&3 %/ #%)4$"%1 ;"8-# &-#4)$# %1 $,- '%1#-&8($"8- #"2-+ 0(&$"'4)(&)* /%& 2--0 '"&')-#< X1 #"30)- $-&3#+ :- ,(8- &-#%)8-2 $,- $%$() :-";,$ Z 1%&3() $% $,- #)"'(12 $,-1 #4.$&('$-2 $,- /%&'- 24- $% 0%&- :($-& 0&-##4&- ")+ #-- -\4($"%1 @[
) #-' )

! Z '%# ) $ ") '%#] ) (12 %.$("1 0!%

' " A (+ ) ' $(1 " " #Z '%# ) $ ") '%#] )%) Z #"1 )

#['AJ%

=% (8%"2 $,-#- -&&%&#+ :- &-$4&1 $% -\4($"%1 @[4$ #N $ ")% ! N" + (12 &-#%)8- 8-&$"'())* $% -)"3"1($- $,- M$ $-&3# (# /%))%:#^ Z ' c$ $ c$ ' A ! ") '%# ) ' N" '%# ) ' N"

$(1 " " +" #"1 ) ' ) #"1 ) 0 0

$,-1 N" !

Z ' c$ $ c$ ' A $ )(" '%# ) ' #+" #"1 )(0%) ('%# ) ' #$(1 " " #"1 )%(0 )

#['AA%

S4.#$"$4$"1; $,"# "1 -\4($"%1 @[
! " $(1 ) $(1 " " .) ! '%# ) A ' 0

#['A[%

@D

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69> 1·5

tan φ′ F

1·4 1·3

1·0

0·8

1·2 0·6 mα

1·1 0·4

1·0 0·9

0·2

0·8 0·7

0·0

0·2

0·6

0·8

0·5 –50

–40

0·0

0·4 0·6

–30

tan φ′ F 1·0

–20

–10

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

α: degree

023? [?IX B*$!"74 +"&>'4 %5 3) ! +%4 )(I ' ##*$ ) #*$ " " (Z%) (12 ( "# $,- $%$() 8-&$"'() #$&-## ($ .(#- %/ #)"'-< f()4-# %/ .) (&- ;"8-1 "1 Z";< [
'%$1@+2$ 2*2+-3#3 1)/02$#5 O,"$3(1 (12 ?(")-* @ABIFD '%1#"2-&-2 /%4& '(#-#< =,- &-#4)$# (&- ;"8-1 "1 =(.)- [<[<

@?

!"#$%&' ( ,+(--., )%/0"&- "1 -+"*% -/(2.+./3 (4(+3-.-

!"#$%& %'()*+%

!"#$ %$&% '()*+, +-./01+ (2 +22+34"5+ 64)+66 .7.186"6 (2 . 61(0+ .669/"7# . 3")391.) 6:+.) 69)2.3+

)*

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69> @*!)' [?X 0*+#%&4 %5 4*5'#8 5%"$, !8 #-' dA6`; 42.()2=', *$, &23%&%"4 .'#-%,4 5%& #1% +*4'4; *5#'& 624-%( DIJKKH TM(30)A ]

iS?Y A<_Q A
?"#,%0N#"30)"G-2

?"#,%0N&";%&%4#

A
A
@*!)' [?[ 0*+#%&4 %5 4*5'#8 5%"$, !8 #-' dA6`; 42.()2=', *$, &23%&%"4 .'#-%,4 5%& 5%"& +*4'4; *5#'& Z-2#.*$ *$, 6*2)'8 DIJTUH TM(30)A ] _ [

iS?Y

?"#,%0N#"30)"G-2

?"#,%0N&";%&%4#

A<[B A
A
A
.+%0 1%$1+# 2*2+-3%3J B)$,#*3I#$* 2*5 <$%1# STUVYX `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

/(")4&- #4&/('- %/ ;-1-&() #,(0$:%N2"3-1#"%1()"$* /%&'- (12 3%3-1$ -\4")".&"43 '%304$-& (1()*#"# .(#-2 %1 (##430$"%1# "1$-&&-)($"1; $,- #)"'- #"2- /%&'-# c (12 M<

X$ '(1 .- #--1 $,($ )(&;- -&&%&# '(1 (&"#- :"$, $,- iS?Y 3-$,%2 (12 :&-'%33-12 $,-&-/%&- $,($ 4#- %/ $,- iS?Y 3-$,%2 #,%4)2 .- (.(12%1-2< ` 2"/G'4)$* :"$, $,- ?"#,%0N#"30)"G-2 3-$,%2 '(1 (&"#- "/ ! " $(1 " " A ' $(1 ) 0

@F

!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6. .-'%3-# 1-;($"8- %& J< =,"# '(1 %''4& "/ ) "# 1-;($"8- (12 $(1 " " (0 "# )(&;-< X/ ! " $(1 " " A ' $(1 ) 0 "# )-## $,(1 J<] $,- 4#- %/ %$,-& 3-$,%2# "# &-'%33-12-2<

.I2A%+%I- 1)#Z1%#*I3 O)$ #2$I( 3+)0#3 ?"#,%0 (12 H%&;-1#$-&1 @ABIJD+ 4#"1; $,- ?"#,%0N#"30)"G-2 3-$,%2+ ,(80&%24'-2 ',(&$# %/ #$(.")"$* '%-/G'"-1$# /&%3 :,"', ( /('$%& %/ #(/-$* /%& (1 -//-'$"8- #$&-## (1()*#"# '(1 .- &(0"2)* %.$("1-2< =,-#- ',(&$# (&- ;"8-1 "1 `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
φ′ = 30˚

c′ = 0·05 γIH D = 1·0 cotβ = 3

F

2·00

1·00

0·0 0·0

0·2

0·4

0·6

0·8

1·0

ru

023? [?IK O2$'*& &')*#2%$4-2( !'#1''$ 5*+#%& %5 4*5'#8 Z *$, (%&' (&'44"&' &*#2% &" ; *5#'& 624-%( *$, S%&3'$4#'&$ DIJTYH @2

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69>

DH

H u γw

h β

023? [?IT A('+2=+*#2%$ %5 (*&*.'#'&4; *5#'& 624-%( *$, S%&3'$4#'&$ DIJTYH 0-&3"$# $,- &-#4)$# %/ #$(.")"$* (1()*#"# $% .- 0&-#-1$-2 "1 2"3-1#"%1)-## /%&3< =,-&- (&- #-8-1 8(&"(.)-# @#-- Z";< [
$,- ,-";,$ %/ $,- #)%0- _ $,- 2-0$, $% ( ,(&2 #$&($43 \_ $,- 0%&- 0&-##4&- &($"% &4 ! "(#$,- #)%0- (1;)- ! $,- '%,-#"%1 "1$-&'-0$ :"$, &-#0-'$ $% -//-'$"8- #$&-## +" $,- (1;)- %/ #,-(&"1; &-#"#$(1'- :"$, &-#0-'$ $% -//-'$"8- #$&-## " " $,- .4)9 41"$ :-";,$ #< /%& ( ;"8-1 8()4- %/ +" (#_+ 0 2-0-12# %1 '%$ !+ \+ &4 (12 " " < =,&-8()4-# %/ +" (#_ ,(8- .--1 4#-2^ J+ J
=,- 8()4-# %/ $,- #$(.")"$* '%-/G'"-1$# ,(8- .--1 0)%$$-2 (;("1#$ $,'%$(1;-1$ %/ $,- #)%0- (1;)- @#-- `00-12"M A+ Z";#< `A
!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6. 4·0

Linear extrapolation

F

3·0

2·0

Actual

1·0

0·0 0·0

0·02

0·04

0·06

0·08

0·10

c ′ / γH

023? [?IU 0*+#%& %5 4*5'#8 e 4#*!2)2#8 $".!'& &')*#2%$4-2( 4-%12$3 'V#&*(%)*#2%$ 2$ #-' &*$3' %5 '" (#! Y?YK #% Y?IY #(3- (# $,- /('$%& %/ #(/-$* :,-1 \ -\4()# A<]C< X/ $,- 2-#";1 8()4- %/ $,0%&- 0&-##4&- &($"% "# ,";,-& $,(1 &4- /%& $,- ;"8-1 #-'$"%1 (12 #$&-1;$, 0(&(3-$-&#+ $,-1 $,- /('$%& %/ #(/-$* :"$, ( 2-0$, /('$%& \ ! A']C ,(# ( )%:-& 8()4- $,(1 :"$, \ -\4() $% A
M!:;=4 =N8B<7=. @AD i#- #$(.")"$* '%-/G'"-1$# $% "18-#$";($- $,- #)%0- #,%:1 "1 Z";< [(+ " " ! ]_!+ _ ! A] 3+ # ! AB'C7 ]J
_F I] II [B ][ & & & & A]F A_Q A]Q BI [F

! J& J']B& J'[C& J'C]& J'CA& J'CA /%& -(', #)"'-+ &-#0-'$"8-)*+ :,-1'- $,- (8-&(;- &4 @)"1-(& "1$-&N 0%)($"%1D ! J<_Q+ %& ()$-&1($"8-)*+ $,- (8-&(;- &4 @4#"1; (&-(#D ! J<_B< +" A'Q ! J'JFI ! #_ AB'Q & A] =,-&-/%&- 2% '()'4)($"%1# /%& +" (#_ ! J'J]C (12 J
@@

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69>

Z%& , ! A'JJ+ +" (#_ ! J'JC . ! A'FB&

$ ! A'[]&

&4- ! J'[C

=,-&-/%&- 2--0-& '"&')-# (&- 1%$ '&"$"'() #"1'- &4 ! J'_B , J'[C 0 ! A'FB $ J'_B & A'[] ! A'][ Z%& \ ! A'JJ+ +" (#_ ! J'J]C . ! A'C]&

$ ! A'_C&

&4- ! J'Q

=,-&-/%&- 2--0-& '"&')-# (&- 1%$ '&"$"'() 0 ! A'C] $ J'_B & A'_C ! J'BB /%& +" (#_ ! J'JFI 0 ! A'][ '

J'JFI $ J'JCJ & #A'][ $ J'BB% J'JCJ $ J'J]C

! A'][ ' J']I ! A'CJ

=,"# '(1 .- '%30(&-2 :"$, 0 ! A'[_ .* #)"0 '"&')- (1()*#"# @#-Z";< [(+ " " ! ]C!+ _ ! _C 3+ &4 ! J'C+ #"2- #)%0-# [ ,%&"a%1$() $% A 8-&$"'() %1 ( &%'9 /%412($"%1< R%: +" (#_ ! ]_(]J & _C ! J'J__ +" (#_

.

$

J
]<[J ]
]
Z%& " " ! ]C!+ #)%0- [ ^ A /%& +" (#_ ! J'J]C+ 0 ! ]'[J $ J'C & ]'AC ! A'_]C /%& +" (#_ ! J'JCJ+ 0 ! ]'FC $ J'C & ]']J ! A'IC /%& +" (#_ ! J'J__+ 0 ! A'_]C ' #A'IC $ A'_]C% & Q(]C ! A'[_ 4#"1; )"1-(& "1$-&0%)($"%1< @_D K,-'9 P%2()-1 @#-- Z";< C
BAA

!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6.

_ ! AQ 3+ #(*< +" (#_ ! B'Q(AQ'F & AQ ! J'J]B &4 ! J'[ /%& +" (#_ ! J'J]C& \ ! A'J . ! A'[C& $ ! A'[J

"

0 ! A'[C $ J'[ & A'[J ! J'QB

/%& + (#_ ! J'JC& \ ! A'J

. ! A'FC& $ ! A'CJ

"

0 ! A'FC $ J'[ & A'CJ ! A'AC

/%& + (#_ ! J'J]B

0 ! A'QB ' [(]C#A'AC $ J'QB% ! J'B_

S-8()2#%1 @ABCID /%412 0 ! A'JC<

9)*G()/),#*#)@3 0)$# 0$#33@$# $2I%) 5%3I$%A@I%)* X/ $,- &4 8()4- 8(&"-# /&%3 0%"1$ $% 0%"1$ "1 ( #)%0-+ "$ "# 1-'-##(&* $% 4##%3- (8-&(;- 8()4- %/ &4 :,-1 4#"1; #$(.")"$* '%-/G'"-1$#< L1- :(* %/ 2%"1; $,"# "# "))4#$&($-2 "1 Z";< [
:,-&- f$ "# $,- (&-( %/ (1* #)"'-<

ru1 h 1 ru2 h 2 ru3 h3 A2

A3

A4

023? [?IP \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 5%& *>'&*32$3 $%$<-%.%3'$'%"4 (%&' (&'44"&' &*#2% ,24#&2!"#2%$; *5#'& 624-%( *$, S%&3'$4#'&$ DIJTYH

BAB

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69>

D)#P 2*5 E$2- 5#3%,* 1(2$I3 !%-9 (12 ?&(* @ABQ]D 0&-#-1$-2 ( #-&"-# %/ 2-#";1 ',(&$#< =,-* '%1#"2-&-2 G8- 2"//-&-1$ ;&%412 :($-& c%: '%12"$"%1# (# #,%:1 "1 `00-12"M ]+ Z";< `]
[3# )O D)#P 2*5 E$2- 1(2$I3 =,- 3-$,%2 4#-# $,- /%))%:"1; #$-0#^ " " " "

2-'"2- %1 ;&%412:($-& '%12"$"%1# '()'4)($- +" (#_ $(1 " " G12 $,"# 8()4- %1 %4$-& '"&'4)(& #'()- (12 /%))%: &(2"() )"1- $% "1$-&N #-'$"%1 :"$, '4&8- '%&&-#0%12"1; $% #)%0- (1;)&-(2 %// $(1 " " (0 %& +" (#_0 (12 '()'4)($- 0 @#-- ()#% Z";# AJ<]] (12 AJ<]_D<

M!:;=4 =N8B<7= @AD K,-'9 $,- -M(30)- ;"8-1 "1 Z";< [
+" ! J'J]Q #_0

# 0 ! A'J] # 0 ! A'J[

#(* 0 ! A'J_+ :,"', '(1 '%30(&-2 :"$, 0 ! A'JC (# %.$("1-2 /%& P%2()-1 .* S-8()2#%1 @ABCID<

BAC

!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6.

<2$I%2++- 3@A/#$,#5 3+)0#3 Y-/-& $% Z";< [
C

E

γ γ

G γw

B A

F

023? [?IJ \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 5%& * (**))8 4"!.'&3', 4)%('? @-' $'# ,24#"&!2$3 .%.'$# 24 #-' .%.'$# ,"' #% #-' .*44 %5 4%2) D"42$3 4*#"&*#', "$2# 1'23-# #H )'44 #-' &'4#%&2$3 .%.'$# ,"' #% #-' 1*#'& D"$2# 1'23-# #1 H

G

E

γw

B γw

A

F

023? [?]Y \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 4-%12$3 * +8)2$,&2+*) 4"&5*+' !'$'*#- * 5&'' 1*#'& )'>') +%&&'4(%$,2$3 #% #-' 3'%.'#&8 %5 #-' (**))8 4"!.'&3', 4)%(' 4-%1$ 2$ 023? [?IJ

BAD

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69>

γ γ

γw

(a)

No water pressure acting here

γ γ′

(b)

023? [?]I @-' (**))8 4"!.'&3', 4)%(' 4-%1$ 2$ D*H 24 4#*#2+*))8 'L"2>*)'$# #% #-' 4)%(' 4-%1$ 2$ D!H "42$3 4"!.'&3', "$2# 1'23-#; # " ; !')%1 #-' )'>') )2$' %5 4"!.'&3'$+'; *$, *)4% .'*4"&2$3 (%&' 1*#'& (&'44"&'4 5&%. #-24 )'>') )2$' %5 4"!.'&3'$+' *4 ,*#". "<-< $,- 0%&- 0&-##4&- "# 3-(#4&-2 /&%3 $,- -M$-&1() )-8-) :($-& #4&/('- (# 2($43< =,- .4)9 41"$ :-";,$ "# 4#-2 (.%8- $,- -M$-&1() :($-& )-8-) (12 $,#4.3-&;-2 41"$ :-";,$ "# 4#-2 .-)%: $,- -M$-&1() :($-& )-8-)< g('&*#2$3 2$ #-24 1*8; 1' *"#%.*#2+*))8 *$, +%&&'+#)8 #*E' 2$#% *++%"$# #-' '55'+# %$ 4#*!2)2#8 %5 #-' 'V#'&$*) 1*#'& (&'44"&'< P

P q

q

∆W

Hw

Z

(γ)

Hw

∆W

Hw

Z2

(γ)

∆W

Z

(γ ′)

(γ ′)

Z1

∆x

∆x

∆x

(a)

(b)

(c)

∆W = (γz + q) ∆x + P p = γz + q + p / ∆x u = γw Hw

∆W = (γ ′z1+ γ ′z2 + q )b + P p = γ ′z1 + γ ′z2 +q + p / ∆x u = γw Hw γ ′ = γ – γw

∆W = γ ′z ∆x p = γ ′z u = γw Hw γ ′ = γ – γw

023? [?]] A"..*&8 4E'#+- 4-%12$3 -%1 >'+*) #%#*) 4#&'44 0 *$, (%&' 1*#'& (&'44"&' 4 24 +*)+")*#', 5%& '*+- 4)2+' %5 * 4)%(' #-*# 24 D*H ,&8; D!H (**))8 4"!.'&3', *$, D+H +%.()'#')8 4"!.'&3',

BA?

!"#$%&' ( -+(,,.- )%/0"&, "1 ,+"*% ,/(2.+./3 (4(+3,.,

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

#$%& '&() *+,-$.$/- 01+.23 4/5 6/51+7 +89:!;+

)*+

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69>

γ = 19 kN/m3

u=0 1·5 m

u = 30 kPa

3m 1m

2m

2m

1m A

1m

u = 35 kPa

B

1m C

30 kPa

023? [?][ \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 5%& 1%&E', 'V*.()' 12#- &*(2, ,&*1<,%1$ @]D X1 Z";< [<][ :- '%1#"2-& $,- #$&-##-# .-/%&- (12 (/$-& &(0"2 2&(:N 2%:1 ($ $,- $,&-- 0%"1$# `+ ? (12 K #,%:1< `$ 0%"1$ ` $,-&- "# 1% ',(1;- "1 $,- :($-& )%(2 2"&-'$)* (.%8- $,- 0%"1$ 24- $% &(0"2 2&(:N 2%:1< `$ 0%"1$ ?+ $,- ',(1;- "1 :($-& )%(2 "# A 3 %/ :($-&< `$ 0%"1$ K $,- ',(1;- "1 :($-& )%(2 "# ] 3 %/ :($-&< f# (%2$# f^ .-/%&- &(0"2 2&(:N2%:1 (- ! _ & AB ' ] & B ! FC 9>( "- ! AC 9>( (- $ "- ! IJ 9>( (/$-& &(0"2 2&(:N2%:1 (- ! C & AB ! BC 9>( "- ! _C 9>( (- $ "- ! IJ 9>( "<-< 1% ',(1;- "1 -//-'$"8- #$&-##< f# (%2$# 6^ .-/%&- &(0"2 2&(:N2%:1 (- ! ] & AB ! AQ 9>(

"- ! J 9>(

(- $ "- ! AQ 9>(

(/$-& &(0"2 2&(:N2%:1 (- ! A & AB ' A & B ! ]Q 9>(

"- ! ]J $ AJ ! AJ 9>( @&-3%8() %/ A 3 %/ :($-&D (- $ "- ! AQ 9>(

BAF

!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6.

f# (%2$# G^ .-/%&- &(0"2 2&(:N2%:1 (- ! A & B ! B 9>( "- ! J 9>( (- $ "- ! B 9>( (/$-& &(0"2 2&(:N2%:1 (- ! A & B ! B 9>( "- ! AJ $ AJ ! J 9>( @&-3%8() %/ ] 3 %/ :($-&D (- $ "- ! B 9>( @_D K%1#"2-& $,- -M(30)- ;"8-1 "1 Z";< [<]C< h-* 0(&(3-$-&# (&- (# /%)N )%:#^ + " ! J (12 C 9>(+ " " ! ]J!+ # ! AB'C 9RU3_ < =,- $&"() #)"0 '"&')- "# 2"8"2-2 "1$% #"M #)"'-# %/ -\4() :"2$,#< ?* #'()"1; ,-";,$# /&%3 $,2&(:"1;+ :- ,(8- 3(;1"$42-# %/ #$&-##-# ;"8-1 .-)%:< ?-/%&- &(0"2 2&(:N2%:1 $,- #$&-##-# (&- (# #,%:1 "1 =(.)- [
&(0"2 2&(:N2%:1 #";1"G'(1$)* &-24'-# $,- /('$%& %/ #(/-$*+ (12

0

10 m Scale

1

u=0 10 20 kPa

30

2

h1

3 4

h2

40

hw 5 6

50 60

023? [?]K \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 5%& 1%&E', 'V*.()'

BA2

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69>

@*!)' [?K? ML"2>*)'$# 4#&'44'4 5%& #-' 4"!.'&3', +*4' (- ^ 9>(

"- ^ 9>(

(- $ "- ^ 9>(

] & AB'C ' A & B'C ! [Q'C A'C & AB'C ' [ & B'C ! IF'_ J'C & AB'C ' C'[ & B'C ! IA'A C'_ & B'C ! CJ'[ _'B & B'C ! _F'A A'I & B'C ! AC']

AJ I ] A ] _

_Q
(- ^ 9>(

"- ^ 9>(

(- $ "- ^ 9>(

_ & AB'C ! CQ'C _'C & AB'C ' ] & B'C ! QF'_ ]'C & AB'C ' _'[ & B'C ! QA'A A'C & AB'C ' _'Q & B'C ! IC'[ J'C & AB'C ' _'[ & B'C ! []'A A'I & B'C ! AC']

]J ]I ]] AI F _

_Q
S)"'A ] _ [ C I

@*!)' [?T ML"2>*)'$# 4#&'44'4 5%& &*(2, ,&*1<,%1$ S)"'A ] _ [ C I

R%$- $,-&- "# 1% ',(1;- "1 $,- 8-&$"'() -//-'$"8- #$&-##+ ( $ "+ /%& -(', #)"'-W

@*!)' [?U A#*!2)2#8 *$*)84'4 5%& 4"!.'&3', +*4' +" ! C 9>( S)"'-

A ] _ [ C I

)^ 2-;&--

( #"1 )^ 9>(

f +" ' (" $(1 ""

6 .) 0 ! A'CB

CF _[ AI J $AC $_]

[J
AB
J
"

BA<

+" ! J f(6

]C
f (" $(1 " A[
6 .) 0 ! A']J

f(6

J
AF
$,- /('$%& %/ #(/-$* "# #-1#"$"8- $% $,- 8()4- %/ + " 4#-2 "1 $,- (1()*#"# 7 2# 24 #-'&'5%&' 'V#&'.')8 2.(%&#*$# 2$ (&*+#2+' #% +-%%4' #-' >*)"' %5 + " #% !' "4', 2$ #-' 4)%(' 4#*!2)2#8 *$*)8424 12#- 3&'*# +*&'< Y-3-3.-& $,- %)2 #(*"1; 51% '-- $%% )%:+ 1% 0," $%% ,";,6W

!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6.

@*!)' [?P A#*!2)2#8 *$*)8424 5%& &*(2, ,&*1<,%1$ +" ! C 9>( S)"'-

A ] _ [ C I

)^ ( #"1 )^ 2-;&-9>( CF _[ AI J $AC $_]

[B
+" ! J

f +" ' (" $(1 ""

6 .) 0 ! A']A

AB
J
f(6

f (" $(1 "

]_
6 .) 0 ! J'B]

f(6

J
AC
@*!)' [?J A"..*&8 %5 &'4")#4 5%& 1%&E', 'V*.()' ,'(2+#', 2$ 023? [?]K +" ^ 9>(

?-/%&- &(0"2 2&(:N2%:1

`/$-& &(0"2 2&(:N2%:1

A
A<_A J
C J

@[D K%1#"2-& $,- #)%0- ;"8-1 "1 Z";< [<]I &-0&-#-1$"1; ( '4$ /%&3-2 (# 0(&$ %/ ( &"8-& '%1$&%) :%&9#< =,- #$-(2* #$($- :($-& )-8-) "# ;"8-1 (# $,- )"1- `?K< V4- $% ( #422-1 %0-1"1; %/ ( #)4"'- ;($-+ $,:($-& )-8-) "1 $,- :($-&:(* "# #4.j-'$-2 $% ( &(0"2 2&(:N2%:1 ($ $,-12 %/ :,"', $,- :($-& #4&/('- "# &-0&-#-1$-2 .* `?V+ "<-< ($ &(0"2

0

5

10 m

Scale

1 γ = 19 kN/m3 A

3·4

2 3·1 3·1

γ = 20 kN/m3 c ′ = 18 kPa, φ′ = 23˚

1·0

3

C

B 4 5

6·2 6·5

4·6

6 1·7

D

023? [?]T \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 5%& 1%&E', 'V*.()'

BA@

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69>

@*!)' [?IY A#*!2)2#8 *$*)8424 5%& 4"!.'&3', +*4' K%)431 R%< S)"'- R%< A ] _ [ C I SiH

A

]

_

[

C

)^ (- ^ 9>( "- ^ 9>( ( #"1 ) +" ' #( $ "% $(1 " " 2-;&-[I _[ ]] ]J $A $AA

II<_ BA<[ QA
J J J J J J

[F
[I
I

F

.) @0A ! A'BD

CUI

J
C[<_ CB<] C]
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
BBA

!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6.

@*!)' [?II A#*!2)2#8 *$*)8424 5%& &*(2, ,&*1<,%1$ K%)431 R%< S)"'- R%< A ] _ [ C I SiH

A

]

_

[

C

)^ (- ^ 9>( "- ^ 9>( ( #"1 ) +" ' #( $ "% $(1 " " 2-;&-[I _[ ]] ]J $A $AA

II<_ A]]<[ A[_
J _A I] IC [I AF

[F
[I
I

F

.) @0A ! A'[D

CUI

J
CJ
$,- 8()4- %/ .) '%&&-#0%12"1; $% -(', 8()4- %/ )< T(', 8()4- %/ +" ' #( $ "% $(1 " " "1 '%)431 C "# $,-1 2"8"2-2 .* $,- '%&&-#0%12"1; .) 8()4- (12 $,- &-#4)$ 04$ "1 '%)431 F< ` 3%&- (''4&($- 8()4- %/ $,- /('$%& %/ #(/-$* "# $,-1 %.$("1-2 (# 0] ! ]F['F(A_I'I ! ]'JA< Z4&$,-& "$-&($"%1# 3(9- )"$$)- "30&%8-3-1$< =,- 2($( (12 '%304$($"%1# /%& $,- &(0"2 2&(:N2%:1 '(#- (&- ;"8-1 "1 =(.)- [
.@//2$- )O I(# 3I#03 $#\@%$#5 I) 2*2+-3# I(# 3I2A%+%I- )O 2 3+)0# A(2*5 @(D A#'( IR A+*)' ,&*12$3< >&-0(&- ( #'()- 2&(:"1; %/ ( '&%##N#-'$"%1 $,&%4;, $,- #)%0-< V&(: "1 ( &-()"#$"' 0&%0%#-2 /(")4&- #4&/('-< @.D A#'( ]R A)2+' (*&*.'#'&4< V"8"2- $,- #)"2"1; 3(## "1$% #)"'-#+ 0&-/-&N (.)* %/ -\4() :"2$,< =,- #)"'- :"2$, #,%4)2 .- #-)-'$-2 $% $(9(''%41$ %/ ',(1;-# "1 #%") 0&%0-&$"-#+ #)%0- ;-%3-$&* (12 0%&0&-##4&- 2"#$&".4$"%1< L.$("1 $,- "1')"1($"%1 :"$, &-#0-'$ $% $,,%&"a%1$()+ )+ %/ $,- $(1;-1$ $% $,- '-1$&- %/ $,- .(#- %/ -(', #)"'@1%$- $,($ ) "# ()#% $,- "1')"1($"%1 $% $,- 8-&$"'() %/ $,- &(2"() )"1j%"1"1; $,- '-1$&- %/ $,- #)"0 '"&')- $% $,- '-1$&- %/ $,- .(#- %/ -(', #)"'-D< @'D A#'( XR Z'23-# (*&*.'#'&4< Z"12 $,- $%$() 8-&$"'() #$&-## ('$"1; ($ $,- '-1$&- %/ $,- .(#- %/ -(', #)"'-< =,"# :")) .- $,- #)"'- ,-";,$ $"3-# $,- 41"$ :-";,$ /%& ( 41"/%&3 #%")< Z%& $,- 0(&$)* #4.3-&;-2 '(#-+ #4.3-&;-2 41"$ :-";,$ :")) .- 4#-2 .-)%: $,- :($-& )-8-) $% '%30-1#($- /%& $,- &-#$&("1"1; -//-'$ %/ :($-& 0&-##4&- %1 $,- #4.N 3-&;-2 /('- %/ $,- #)%0-< BBB

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69> @2D

@-D

A#'( [R N%&' 1*#'& (&'44"&'< X1 ( $%$() #$&-## (1()*#"#+ $,- 0%&0&-##4&-# (&- 1%$ 91%:1 (12 1%$ 4#-2< X1 (1 -//-'$"8- #$&-## (1()*#"#+ $,- 0%&- 0&-##4&-# :")) .- /%412 /&%3 #'()"1; %// $,- 2&(:"1;< Z%& $,'(#- %/ #$-(2* #--0(;-+ ( c%: 1-$ :")) .- 4#-2< Z%& $,- '(#- %/ ( #4.3-&;-2 #)%0-+ 0%&- 0&-##4&-# :")) .- 3-(#4&-2 /&%3 $,- )-8-) )"1- %/ #4.3-&;-1'- (# 2($43< Z%& &(0"2 2&(:N2%:1+ "$ "# (##43-2 $,($ 2&("1(;- @#--0(;-D 24&"1; &(0"2 2&(:N2%:1 ,(# 1%$ %''4&&-2 (12 $,($ ( c%: 1-$ ,(# 1%$ .--1 -#$(.)"#,-2 (12 ,-1'- 0%&0&-##4&-# (&- 2-G1-2 .* $,- ;-%3-$&* %/ $,- #)%0-< A#'( KR \'#*2)', +*)+")*#2%$4< K()'4)($- ( #"1 ) /%& -(', #)"'- (12 #43 $,-3 "1 ( $(.)-< Z%& $%$() #$&-## (1()*#"#+ '%304$- /('$%& %/ #(/-$* 0 ! % % # 44 ( '%# )%( ( #"1 )< Z%& -//-'$"8- #$&-## (1()*#"#+ -8()4($- 0%&0&-##4&-# " %& "- + (12 -8()4($- $,- #$&-1;$, $-&3 /%& -(', #)"'-+ + " ' #( $ "% $(1 " " + (12 #43 "1 ( $(.)-< Z"12 $,- G&#$ $&"() % " + ' #( $ "% $(1 " " % 0A ! ( #"1 )

R%: 4#- $,"# G&#$ $&"() 0A $% -8()4($- $,- 0(&(3-$-& $(1 " " (0A "1 %&2-& $% -1$-& E(1.46# '4&8-# @Z";< [
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

BBC

!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6. a

W s l

023? [?]U \'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 5%& $%$<+2&+")*& #%#*) 4#&'44 *$*)8424 !8 .'#-%, %5 4)2+'4; $'3)'+#2$3 42,' 5%&+'4 =% $(9- (''%41$ %/ "1$-&#)"'- /%&'-# 4#- $,- E(1.46# \4(#"N-30"&"'() '%&N &-'$"%1 /('$%& 5J :,-1'% 4)( '%# ) 0 ! 5J % Z $(1 )

:,-&- 5J "# +A (12 8(&"-# .-$:--1 A (12 A
#['AI%

:,-&- $) ! '%#] )#A ' $(1 ) $(1 " " (0%<

')/0@I#$ 0$),$2/3 C(# >#)I#1(*%12+ 2*5 >#)G#*"%$)*/#*I2+ .)OI&2$# 4%$#1I)$- S>>.4X =,"# :-. #"$- @:::<;;#2<'%3D '($()%;4-# 0&%;&(3# "1 $,- G-)2# %/ ;-%$-',1"'() -1;"1--&"1;+ #%") 3-',(1"'#+ &%'9 3-',(1"'#+ -1;"1--&"1; ;-%)%;*+ /%412($"%1 -1;"1--&"1;+ ,*2&%;-%)%;*+ ;-%N-18"&%13-1$() -1;"1--&"1;+ -18"&%13-1$() -1;"1--&"1;+ 2($( (1()*#"# (12 2($( 8"#4()"N a($"%1 (12 )"#$# :%&)2:"2- #400)"-&# (12 04.)"#,-&# %/ $,-#- 0&%;&(3#< >&%;&(3# (&- "12-M-2 .* 0&%;&(3 1(3-+ 0&%;&(3 '($-;%&*+ %0-&($"1; #*#$-3 (12 0&%;&(3 #$($4#+ (12 $,- V"&-'$%&* -1$&"-# (&- )"#$-2 .* '($-;%&*< >&%;&(3 04.)"#,-&# (12 #400)"-&# (&- "12-M-2 .* %&;(1"a($"%1 1(3- (12 .* '%41$&*+ (12 $,- V"&-'$%&* -1$&"-# (&- )"#$-2 "1 ()0,(.-$"'() %&2-&< =,- V"&-'$%&"-# %/ 0&%;&(3#+ 04.)"#,-&# (12 #400)"-&# (&- '&%##N &-/-&-1'-2< =,- V"&-'$%&* ()#% ;"8-# )"19# $% %$,-& :-. #"$-# /-($4&"1; ;-%$-',1"'()+ ;-%N-18"&%13-1$() %& &-)($-2 #%/$:(&-< =,-&- "# ( /&-ggSV R-:#)-$$-&< =,- ggSV :-. #"$- /%& #)%0- #$(.")"$* 0&%;&(3# )"#$# $,- /%))%:"1; 2-#'&"0$"%1# %/ 0&%;&(3#+ ')(##"G-2 .* 0&%;&(3 1(3-+ $*0- @'%33-&'"()+ /&--:(&- %& #,(&-:(&-D+ (12 %0-&($"1; #*#$-3 @VLS+ BBD

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69>

–1·0

–0·5

tan α

0

0·5

1·0

2·0 3·0

1·4

1·0

1· 0

0

0· 6

4 0·

0· 0· 2 4 0

2 0·

0·6 40

30

6 0·

tan φ′ 20

tan φ′

F

0

0·8

1·

nα

1·2

10

F 0

10

20

30

40

0· 8

50

60

70

α: degree (a) ∆n

p q

Q

∆W

L

d ∆l

α positive

s F

(b)

f0

1·20

1·10

φ′ = 0

c ′ > 0, φ > 0 c′ = 0 1·00

0

0·1

0·2 d /L

0·3

0·4

(c)

023? [?]P D*H B*$!"74 +"&>'4 5%& 1) ! +%4] )#I ' #*$ ) #*$ " " (Z%; D!H ,'=$2#2%$ 4E'#+- 5%& $%$<+2&+")*& '55'+#2>' 4#&'44 *$*)8424; D+H B*$!"74 4'.2<'.(2&2+*) +%&&'+#2%$ 5*+#%& 5%& 2$h"'$+' %5 42,' 5%&+'4?

BB?

!4=>796 ? '78..6' B=CD!4. !? .7!<= .C8E676CF 8987F.6. O"12%:#+ H('D< V-$(")-2 40N$%N2($- 2-#'&"0$"%1# %/ -(', 0&%;&(3 (12 :%&)2:"2- #400)"-&# (&- ;"8-1 "1 $,- g-%$-',1"'() (12 g-%-18"&%13-1$() S%/$:(&- V"&-'$%&* ($ :::<;;#2<'%3< ?* 3"2N]JJJ+ $,"# :-. #"$- ,(2 &-'-"8-2 %8-& %1- 3"))"%1 ,"$# (12 :(# ($ $,($ $"3- ;-$$"1; A[J JJJ ,"$# 0-& 3%1$,<

3"+.( $)#/%"%)0 K$+%"L $+-)M#G( %1,(N " K!`SH 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1_M+ O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R=+ iRXl " VPXS` 7 Z&--:(&- 7 VLS " TS`i 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS+ iRXl+ !> " TS=`fTP 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " g()-1( 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " g?SPL>T 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1_M+ O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " g-%N=-' ? 7 K%33-&'"() 7 H('+ >%:-&H(' " gTLSPL>T 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " g-%S$(& 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " gZ`]V 7 Z&--:(&- 7 VLS+ O"1_M+ O"1BCUBQ " ggiNSPXKT 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R=+ O"1]JJJ " ggiNSPL>T 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R=+ O"1]JJJ " g>SN>K 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " gS)%0- 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " gS=`?PF 8< AYLS=`? 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " HS=`? 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " >KS=`?P C H 7 >4.)"' 2%3("1 7 VLS " >-1$( 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " YT`HT 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " S(&3( 7 S,(&-:(&- 7 VLS " S?NSPL>T 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " S)"2- 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS+ O"1_M+ O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " SPX> 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " SPL>?g 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " S)%0- @g-%#%)8-D 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " S)%0- @L(#*#D 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS+ O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " SPL>T QY 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " S)%0-NO 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " SPL>RK 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " S$(.) /%& O"12%:# 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R=+ O"1]JJJ " S=`?PT 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS+ O"1_M+ O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " S=`?PT>YL /%& O"12%:# 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1_M+ O"1BCUBQ " S=TV:"1 ]<] 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1_M+ O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= BBE

34567 !58639 :; .!67 894 :!'; .7!<= =9>69==:69> " " " " " " "

SO`ST 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS =SPL>T 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O-.UE(8(+ E(8( ')"-1$+ #-&8-& '()'4)($"%1< =SPL>T_ 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS+ iRXl =S=`? 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS+ iRXl i=Tl`S_ 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS O"1S$(.) 7 S,(&-:(&- 7 O"1_M+ O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= lS=`?P 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS

3"+.( $)#/%"%)0 KG+&OL $+-)M#G( %1,(N " `KKTK`PK 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " KPimS=`Y 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " TaS)"2- 7 Z&--:(&- 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " >)(1- Z(")4&- `1()*#"# 7 Z&--:(&- 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " Y%'Z()) 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " YLKh_V 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " YLKh>Z 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " YLZTl 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1_M+ O"1BCUBQ " YL=LH`> 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " S)%0- h-*.)%'9 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " SPL>T>`Kh 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " SO`YS 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " S:-2;- 7 K%33-&'"() 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= " OTVgT 7 K%33-&'"() 7 VLS " O-2;- Z(")4&- `1()*#"# 7 Z&--:(&- 7 O"1BCUBQ+ O"1R= .7!<=]M .I@5#*I =5%I%)* '4 =,- SPL>TUO S$42-1$ T2"$"%1 KV "# 0&%24'-2 .* gTLNSPL>T X1$-&N 1($"%1() P$2 (12 "# 0&%8"2-2 :"$, $,"# .%%9< =,- .-#$ :(* $% ;-$ ;%"1; "# $% "1#$()) $,- #%/$:(&- (12 $,-1 /%))%: $,- $4$%&"() "1 K,(0$-& _ "1 $,i#-&6# g4"2-< L1'- *%4 ,(8- ;%1- $,&%4;, $,"# #"30)- $4$%&"() *%4 :")) ,(8- ( 0&-$$* ;%%2 "2-( %/ ,%: $% %0-&($- $,- #%/$:(&-< n%4 #,%4)2 $,-1 .- (.)- $% ;% $,&%4;, $,- S$42-1$ T2"$"%1 )-##%1#< =,- '%30)-$- i#-&6# g4"2- "# ()#% "1 $,- %1N)"1- ,-)0< n%4 '(1 ;-$ ($ $,- %1N)"1- ,-)0 .* 0&-##N "1; $,- ZA 9-* :,-1 ( '%33(12 "# ,";,)";,$-2+ .* )%%9"1; ($ $,- $(.)- %/ '%1$-1$# %& .* #-(&',"1; "12-M-2 :%&2# @"$ :%&9# 34', )"9- (1* O"12%:# (00)"'($"%1 %1N)"1- ,-)0 #*#$-3D< `1%$,-& :(* %/ ;-$$"1; (1 "1$&%24'$"%1 $% $,- #%/$:(&- "# $% %0-1 $,- G)-# "1')42-2 :"$, $,- S$42-1$ T2"$"%1< ?* %0-1"1; $,-#- G)-# "1 VTZXRT (12 KLR=LiY *%4 '(1 \4"'9)* #-- $,2-G1"$"%1 -18"&%13-1$ (12 ,%: *%4 '(1 8"-: $,- &-#4)$#< =,- $-',1"'() %8-&8"-: %/ SPL>TUO '(1 .- 2%:1)%(2-2 /&%3 $,- gTLN SPL>T X1$-&1($"%1() P$2 :-. #"$- "1 '%)%4& @:::<;-%N#)%0-<'%3D< =,SPL>TUO 0('9(;- "1$-&/('-# :"$, $,- %$,-& gTLNSPL>T X1$-&1($"%1() P$2 3%24)-# /%& #--0(;- @STT>UOD (12 /%& #$&-## 2"#$&".4$"%1 @SXgH`UOD< BBF