4 Salgado vs CA, March 26, 1984 (128 SCRA 395)

SALGADO VS. COURT OF APPEALS

March 26, 1984 (128 SCRA 395)

MEDIALDEA,  J.: FACTS:

PCIB filed acti! t rec"er ! a #r$i%%r& !te 'ith #ra&er fr 'rit f attach$e!t CI Ri*al lifted the 'rit f attach$e!t it #re"i+%l& #re"i+%l& i%%+ed after #etiti!er #etiti!er $"ed $"ed t +a%h +a%h it Ba!#%t #%ted ed .!d .!d /he /he C+r C+rtt f A##e A##eal al% % rec rec!% !%id ider ered ed a!d a!d a+thri*ed the i%%+a!ce f the 'rit f attach$e!t ISSUE:

Ca! a 'rit f attach$e!t i%%+e if !te %+ed +#! i% f+ll& %ec+red0 HELD:

Petiti! i% i$#re%%ed 'ith $erit /he chief #+r#%e f attach$e!t i% t %ec+re a c!ti!e!t lie! lie! ! defe defe!d !da! a!t t% % #r# #r#er ert& t& +!ti +!till #lai #lai!t !tif ifff ca ca! ! .ta .tai! i! a  +d$e!t a!d ha"e %+ch #r#ert& a##lied t it% %ati%facti! r t $a-e $a-e % %$e $e #r" #r"i% i%i i! ! t +!%e +!%ec+ c+re red d de.t de.t% % i! ca ca%e %e% % 'her 'here e the the $ea! $ea!% % f %a %ati ti%f %fac acti ti! ! ther there eff are are lia. lia.le le t .e re$"ed .e&!d the +ri%dicti!, r i$#r#erl& di%#%ed f  r c c!c !cea eale led, d, r t the her' r'i% i%e e #lac #laced ed .e& .e&!d !d the the reac reach h f  creditr% Sec 1, R+le 5 %tate% the r+!d% ! 'hich attach$e!t $a& i%%+e

Sec 3, R+le 5 A! rder f attach$e!t %hall .e ra!ted !l& 'he! it a##ear% .& the affida"it f the a##lica!t, r f  %$e ther #er%! 'h #er%!all& -!'% the fact% that  there i% ! ther %+fficie!t %ec+rit& fr the clai$ %+ht t .e e!frced .& the acti! /he rea%! fr the r+le #rhi.iti! attach$e!t 'here i!de.ted!e%% 'a% alread& %ec+red i% t #re"e!t the %ec+red creditr% fr$ attachi! additi!al #r#ert& a!d th+% t&i! +# $re f the de.tr% #r#ert& tha! 'a% !ece%%ar& t %ec+re the i!de.ted!e%% / %+%tai! a! rder f attach$e!t, it i% i!c+$.e!t +#! the #lai!tiff t e%ta.li%h either f the%e 2 fact%: a) that the .liati! had !t .ee! %ec+red rii!all& .) that, if %ec+red at it% .ei!!i!, the %ec+rit& later .eca$e "al+ele%% Sec 13, R+le 5 a+thri*e% the di%chare f a! attach$e!t 'here the %a$e had .ee! i$#r#erl& r irre+larl& i%%+ed R+le a+thri*i! i%%+a!ce f 'rit f attach$e!t $+%t .e %trictl& c!%tr+ed i! fa"r f defe!da!t