001 - Nltdra v Csc

NLTDRA v. CSC GR No. 84301 | April 7, 1993 Campos, Jr., J. Nati tion onal al Land Land Title itle  and and Petitioner/s: Na Deed Re!itration Ad"initration #NLTDRA$

S*&/ S*&/ &rea &reati tion on led led to t/e t/e i*an&e o ne) appoint"ent.

%iole %ioleta ta Gar&ia Gar&ia'' Civil Civil Respondents: Servi&e Co""iion #CSC$

Issues: ( oN t/e t/e ne) ne) re5 re5*ir *ire"en "ent /o* /o*lld 6e applied to LRC e"plo+ee at t/e ti"e o t/e reor!aniation' reor!aniation' ( oN t/e t/e reo reor! r!an ani iat atio ion n )a )a &ar &arri ried ed o*t in !ood ait/' ( oN >veted ri!/t t/eor+? i appli&a6le in t/i &ae'

Facts: ( Repondent %ioleta Gar&ia )a appo appoiinted nted Dep*t ep*t+ + Re!i e!iter ter o  Deed %-- --- )it/ t/e Land Re!itration Co""iion #LRC$ ( ollo ollo)i )in! n! t/e t/e reor reor!a !ani nia ati tion on o t/e t/e LRC LRC into into t/e Nation National al Land Land Title Title  and Deed Re!itration Ad"initration #NLTDRA$ *nder 2 49, /e )a appointed a Dep*t+ Re!iter o Deed --.  T/e 2 introd*&ed a o re5*ire"ent t/at peron in DRD -- /o*ld 6e a "e"6er o t/e /ilippine ar Gar&ia Gar&ia  appoin appoint"e t"ent nt )a o te"p te"por orar ar+, +, 6e&a 6e&a* *e e /e /e )a )a not not a "e"6 "e"6er er o t/e t/e /ilippine ar. ( S/e S/e )a ter ter"ina "inate ted d or all alle!ed e!edl+ l+ re&eivin! 6ri6e "one+. :er appeal to t/e t/e ;eri ;eritt S+t S+te" e"  rote rote&t &tio ion n oard )a later dropped, t/e latter &lai"in! t/at /er ter"ination )a d*e d*e to t/e t/e e%ete >%eted d Ri!/t T/eor+?' t/e o ne) ne) re5* e5*ire" ire"en entt o ar "e"6 "e"6er er /ip /ip /o*l /o*ld d not appl+ to /er Re5*ire"ent i onl+ or t/e o @llin! *p o va&ant poition ater ater t/e re5*i re5*ire re"en "entt )a introd*&ed. ( :en&e, t/i petition. LRTDRA ar!*e= 2 49 49 a6ol a6oli i/e /ed d all all LRC LRC o poition poition,, and &reated &reated ne) one one *nde *nderr t/e t/e NLTD NLTDR RA.

Held:  B2S. T:2 R2-R2;2NT AL-2S T ALL. ( 2 49 49 a6ol a6olii/ed /ed al all t/e t/e po poitio ition n in t/e t/e LRC, LRC, and re5*i e5*irred ne) appoin appoint"e t"ent nt to 6e i*ed i*ed to all t/e e"plo+ee o t/e NLTDRA ( A6ol A6olit itio ion, n, /o) /o)ev ever er,, doe doe not not "ea "ean n re"oval' in *&/ &ae t/ere i no "ore ten*re to peaE o. pon t/e diol*tion o t/e oF&e, no i"pair i"pair"en "entt o e&*r e&*rit+ it+ o ten*r ten*re e o&&*r. ( pon t/e reor!aniation, ne) poiti poition on )ere )ere &reat &reated ed *nder *nder t/e NLTDRA )/i&/ re5*ired t/e addi additi tion onal al 5*al 5*ali@ i@&a &ati tion on o ar ar "e"6 "e"6er er/ /ip ip.. -t )a )a a &rit &riter erio ion n i"poed &on&o"itant )it/ a valid reor!aniation "ea*re. ( All All o&& o&&*p *pan ant t o o *& *&/ / po poit itio ion n,, LRC LRC e"plo+ee or ot/er)ie, "*t /ave *&/ 5*ali@&ation.

 B2S. T:2 R2RGAN-AT-N R2RGAN-AT-N AS CARR-2D T -N GD A-T:. ( Dario v. ;ion= reor!ani aniation on /all 6e re!arded a valid i t/e+ are p*r*ed in !ood ait/. ( A i i t/e t/e &ae &ae /er /ere, e, reo reor! r!an ani iat atio ion n i &arried o*t in !ood ait/ i it i or t/e p*rpoe o e&ono"+ or to "aEe t/e 6*rea*&ra&+ "ore eF&ient. N. %2ST N. %2ST2D 2D R-G: R-G:T T T:2 T:2R RB D2S D2S NT 2H-ST ( T/er T/ere e i no no *&/ *&/ t/i t/in! n! a a a ve veted ted interet in an oF&e. 2<&ept

&ontit*tional oF&e )/i&/ provide or pe&ial i""*nit+ a re!ard alar+ and ten*re, no one &an 6e aid to /ave an+ veted ri!/t in an oF&e.

(

Neit/er i t/ere a veted propert+ ri!/t to 6e ree"plo+ed in a reor!anied oF&e.